With far more options to join the Chicago Cubs bench this year than there are spots, the team will have to make many difficult choices in filling out its 25-man roster. Manager Lou Piniella is hoping that Mike Fontenot can back up shortstop, making some of those choices just a little bit easier.

“Either you’re going to want a little more defense, or you’re going to want some offense,” Piniella said. “If Fontenot can play some shortstop, we can look to carry a bat. If he can’t, well then basically, we’ll be able to carry one less bat on the bench.”

In other words, the Cubs may be looking for a way to keep a player such as Kevin Millar, Chad Tracy, Bryan LaHair or Micah Hoffpauir. The odd-man out in that situation could be slick-fielding infielder Andres Blanco.

“We know that Blanco can do a nice job as a utility infielder and backup shortstop,” Piniella said. “Depending on what we do in the outfield, and we’re just supposing, if we carry a defensive center fielder to help (Marlon) Byrd out, a defensive infielder, (Koyie) Hill catching, now all of a sudden, you start getting a little thin offensively coming off the bench. If we can get a few of these other guys to be able to fill in for a day or two, we might be able to carry another bat.

“No determination has been made, but we’ve got to look at those things.” Daily Herald.

Or, the team could not carry 12 pitchers, but whateves.

With a five-man bench, there is only so much flexibility that the Cubs can have, even if Fontenot can backup shortstop. We know that Koyie Hill and Xavier Nady get a spot. The non-starting second baseman – Fontenot or Jeff Baker – gets another spot. That leaves just two spots. The good news is that, with those three guys, the Cubs can pretty much have a backup at every spot, assuming Fontenot can backup shortstop. The only tricky one is center field, but worst case scenario, Kosuke Fukudome can back it up, and the Cubs can insert Nady into right field.

That means that, at least in theory, the Cubs will be able to choose the two best players to keep on the roster. They’ll probably grab an outfielder who can play solid defense (Sam Fuld?), and an infielder who’s got a big bat off the bench (Chad Tracy?). Those are just my super-early thoughts, so it will be interesting to watch as things play out.

  • N

    I really liked Andres Blanco’s defense last season and wouldn’t mind him actually being on the team, so I’m disappointed for him that this might cost him a spot, but I think it’s the better move for the team. Theriot’s going to play just about every game and is not so bad that Lou would want to pull him for defense, so the only way Blanco gets in a game is if Lou makes three double switches at 2nd (always a possibility) or if they need a bunt or if Theriot gets hurt.

    Based on what Lou has said this week, they’d go with Castro full time if Ryan ever went to the DL, so the only way Fontenot’s seeing extended innings at SS is if Theriot was hurt but not hurt enough to go to the DL (Bradley-rific) and he doesn’t really have a history of it. Tracy (or another lefty hitter) would give someone on the bench to be a big hitter against righties – they really don’t have that when Fontenot and Fukudome are in the lineup.

    • Ace

      Yup. I think Lou is banking on the fact that even if Fontenot is his designated “backup” shortstop, he’ll rarely if ever actually have to go out there.

  • Hawkboy64

    so just because fontenot bats left handed he’s the back up at short if were nt so worried about hving leftys in the line-up then blanco should be the back up fr both short and 2nd

Bleacher Nation Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. Bleacher Nation is a private media site, and it is not affiliated in any way with Major League Baseball or the Chicago Cubs. Neither MLB nor the Chicago Cubs have endorsed, supported, directed, or participated in the creation of the content at this site, or in the creation of the site itself. It's just a media site that happens to cover the Chicago Cubs.

Bleacher Nation is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.