Chicago Cubs Manager Lou Piniella is unlikely to come back to manage the Cubs after this season, his last under contract. Though speculation about his successor has been limited to a stray comment about Bob Brenly here, and about the Cubs grooming AAA manager Ryne Sandberg there.

Surely the team will have learned its lesson with Dusty Baker and Lou Piniella that it doesn’t necessarily pay to go out and overpay for an aging, previously-successful manager. Right? Right?

Enter Joe Torre, who is also a free agent after this year.

“It’s going to be me and how I feel toward the end of the year,” Torre said. “Do I want to do this again? The thing I don’t want to do is just shut it down. I don’t think that would be fair to my wife. But it is going to have more to do with me than anything else.”

The one-year extension Torre discussed with general manager Ned Colletti last winter also would have included a front-office role for Torre starting in 2012.

The report also speculated that Torre could manage either the Chicago Cubs, New York Mets or Atlanta Braves next season, something Torre all but ruled out.

“I refuse to say absolutes, but I think it is very, very remote that it will ever happen,” Torre said. “I hate to say it would never happen because I don’t know what is going to happen. But I certainly don’t anticipate that at 70 years of age, I am going to be searching around for another place.” ESPN Los Angeles.

The Chicago Cubs are tossed out as a possible destination for Torre likely simply because they are a high profile team with an opening next year. That Torre says he’s unlikely to be looking for another job does not really end the discussion – Lou Piniella famously repeated that he was done managing before taking the Cubs job.

With apologies to the older among us, Torre’s age (like Piniella’s) is a concern. Although the manager doesn’t have to pinch run, some physicality in the form of the proverbial “fire in the belly” is nice. Further, an older guy is unlikely to provide much continuity.

  • Pingback: / archive » Torre to Manage the Cubs in 2011?, Red Sox’ Beckett Hurts Back Taking Batting Practice, Twins’ Hardy May Be Headed to DL, lots more()

  • jstraw

    That’s as close to Torre saying “NFW” as you’re likely to get.

  • KB

    We should put up a poll: Brenley or Ryno for 2011 manager.
    I’d actually vote for Brenley.

    • Ace

      I think I might, too.

    • jstraw


    • ed

      definitely brenly

      • Allan

        Brenly…Torre is old…Joe Girardi maybe

  • Rowan Campbell

    I think joe Girardi should manage the cubs in 2011 if the New york yankees don’t resign him.
    He knows the cubs orginazation he has been a cubs fan his whole life.
    He wanted the job after Dusty Baker was not resigned after 2006.
    I know LOu piniella got the job he has done a solid job.
    i think joe Girardi would be the best manager to take the cubs job in 2011.
    He is still young and has many years ahead of him.
    He has done a very good job job as Yankees manager.
    102 years is a long time to wait for a Championship.
    The cubs need to build a contender for 2011 and beyond.
    Iam optimistic for 2011.
    Us cubs fans deserve a winning team next year.
    So Tom Ricketts must sign Joe Giradi and give him a good offer.

    • jstraw

      Umm. OK.

  • Pingback: Join the Cub(s): Let’s Find a Manager | Baseball Bloggers Alliance()