Quantcast

The Chicago Cubs offense sucks.

And yet, several players are hitting very well. Ryan Theriot, Kosuke Fukudome, Marlon Byrd, Geovany Soto, Alfonso Soriano and Starlin Castro are all hitting very well. That’s six of your eight regulars. So how is it possible that the offense is not scoring runs? You know the answer. Aramis Ramirez and Derrek Lee.

Manager Lou Piniella is aware of the problem, but for weeks, he’s addressed it with minor “tweaks” of the lineup, as he calls it. Enough is enough. It’s time for something more drastic, and Gordon Wittenmyer nailes it:

”I don’t know exactly what our choices are,” Piniella, who also flip-flopped his 1-2 hitters Tuesday, said before the game. ”[Alfonso] Soriano’s been swinging the bat well [at No. 6] and we don’t want to disturb that situation. [Geovany] Soto’s doing is job nice in the seventh hole. We’ve got our leadoff people that are getting on base.”

But after yet another night of not enough hitting, running and scoring, Piniella would be more than justified in getting more drastic with his moves in fixing the hitting problems.

As drastic as bringing up raw, touted young shortstop Starlin Castro the first week of May when middle infield and table-setter hitting weren’t the problems?

As drastic as fixing the eighth-inning setup problems by sending Carlos Zambrano to the bullpen?

What are the choices again?

How about dropping Ramirez to seventh or eighth until he starts hitting? If Lee’s late hitting is a sign his slump is over — about the time he came on strong last year — then put him back in his usual spot. Otherwise, use him somewhere between fourth and sixth.

Don’t disturb Soriano? Why not?

Move him into one of the marquee spots when he’s hot and back down to sixth when he’s not. Keep Marlon Byrd somewhere in the 3-4 mix at least until Lee and Ramirez are back to top form.

Move up Soto, who has become one of the best hitters on the team.

Maybe none of it works. Maybe it gets some people mad.

But isn’t that what Ted Lilly suggested the Cubs needed to do to get out of their funk? And is it going to be any worse.

I can’t really say it better myself. Why not drop Ramirez dramatically? Why not move Soriano and Soto up? Are they really going to so change their approach in a slightly different spot in the lineup that they’ll “stop” hitting?

You have to put guys in the order most likely to score runs, and generally that means just two things: (1) your best hitters should come early so they get the most at bats, and (2) your best hitters should be grouped together so that pitchers don’t get a chance to breathe and rallies don’t have a chance to die.

Lou Piniella is violating both of those rules right now, presumably, so as not to bruise any egos. It’s time for dynamite, Lou, and if some egos catch flying debris, so be it.

  • pygreg

    I like Lou, but maybe it’s time for him to go soon. It’s obvious the order needs to be changed drastically until/if D-Lee and A-ram get hot. We need to stop trying to recreate the 08 team and work with what the players we currently have are currently doing.

  • wax_eagle

    Ummm Bruce Miles just posted today’s lineup..Boom!

    http://blogs.dailyherald.com/node/4040

    • Ace

      I win at the Internet.

  • Bric

    I agree. Watching the last couple of games against the Marlins really shows how unimaginitive he’s become. Before Castro trying it today, I can’t remember the last time I’ve seen someone bunt for a hit. Silva got his bunt down with three guys right up in his face. What’s wrong with pulling the bat back and trying to slap it past them? Lou’s got no fire, no creativity, no balls anymore. If he had a pair Aram would be sitting until Baker lost the job back to him.

    • jstraw

      Silva’s bunt was beautiful.

      • Bric

        True, but we didn’t get a run out of it so it was a wasted out. The point is Lou’s afraid to try anything risky. In his own words “It’s entertainment.” What!? I’d be thinking differently if the Cubs were playing good, disciplined baseball, but right now (even with tofay’s win) they’re not not.

  • Jeff

    It’s becoming really difficult to watch Aramis at the plate lately. It seems that every game for the last couple of weeks he’s either striking out or hitting a week pop up with runners in scoring position when the Cubs are trying to rally. It doesn’t seem like he’s getting any better as the season goes on, his hard hit outs and fouls are even becoming few and far between. Lee seems to be coming out of his annual early season slump lately, but how long can the Cubs and Piniella afford to wait on Ramirez to hit, it’s going to cost a a team with 6 regulars batting over .300 a chance at the post season and possibly cost Lou his job.

    • Ace

      No answers in this situation are good answers, Jeff. And you’ve hit on all the right questions. The Cubs can’t wait on Aramis – not in the middle of the lineup. But on the other hand, the Cubs can’t win without a productive Aramis.

      • Rylan

        Remember that Jake Fox kid that we didn’t have room for, because he would never get enough at-bats?

        • Ace

          .566 OPS this year in Oakland. Just throwing it out there.

          • Rylan

            He was good in Chicago :~)

Bleacher Nation Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. Bleacher Nation is a private media site, and it is not affiliated in any way with Major League Baseball or the Chicago Cubs. Neither MLB nor the Chicago Cubs have endorsed, supported, directed, or participated in the creation of the content at this site, or in the creation of the site itself. It's just a media site that happens to cover the Chicago Cubs.

Bleacher Nation is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

Google+