While it has been assumed by most that, since he was acquired last year in the Ted Lilly trade, Blake DeWitt was *the* Chicago Cubs’ second baseman until further notice, I suspected that he could find himself in a bit of a battle this Spring with infielder Jeff Baker and possibly an up-and-comer like Darwin Barney.

The first and most obvious clue? Mike Quade suggested repeatedly that Baker would leadoff against lefties – meaning that Baker, and not DeWitt, would play regularly at second base against lefties, even though DeWitt actually hit better against lefties last year than he did against righties.

Losing the job is just one step removed from a platoon, and at times, Baker has looked like he could be a productive full-timer at second base. Thus, I see things this way: DeWitt is the presumptive favorite to start at second against righties, but Baker could win the full-time gig with a much better Spring than DeWitt.

And it sounds like DeWitt is going to have to work very hard to keep that from happening.

“There are plenty of guys in the mdidle of the diamond who are playing well,” Quade said. “They are doing what they do. [DeWitt] is a left-handed bat in the midst of those guys. He’s a guy we would like to be able to count on. But we are going to look at everybody.”

That list includes DeWitt, Jeff Baker, Darwin Barney and Augie Ojeda. DeWitt has struggled defensively early in spring training. Quade and his staff are concerned not only by DeWitt’s errors [he has committed two in Cactus League play] but also by some of the missed opportunities when he could have turned double plays.

“[DeWitt has] got some work to do,” Quade said. “Nobody works harder than him. He’s going from third base to second base. We backed off third base completely. And I think to me the main point would be consistency around the bag turning the double play.”

DeWitt, who was out early taking extra ground balls with Castro on Wednesday, said he is working everyday to improve on the double play.

“It’s something I want to improve upon,” said DeWitt, 25, who was acquired from the Los Angeles Dodgers in a trade that sent Ryan Theriot and Ted Lilly to Los Angeles on July 31. “I feel comfortable turning the double play. I’ve made a few strides this spring understanding some things mechanically that I didn’t get before. That’s why [Starlin] Castro and I have been working early on things, and it’s all looking good.” ESPN Chicago.

DeWitt’s bat is never going to carry him if he can’t play adequate defense, even at second base. Most feel like he’s got the potential to be an above average defensive second baseman (he has always been an excellent third baseman), but so far, he hasn’t shown it.

But DeWitt has plenty of room to grow, both in the field and at the plate. He’s just 25, after all. For comparison’s sake, it’s worth pointing out that “youngster” Darwin Barney is also 25 – just two and a half months younger than DeWitt.

  • Art

    Quade is always making excuses for every guy on this team. defensively Colvin is having problems. Quade says maybe cause he’s playing 2 positions. DeWitt is having D problems. Quade says maybe cause he’s playing 2 positions.

    Colvin hasn’t played 1B since college, ok, he’s rusty at 1B. that’s no reason he’s been bad in the OF. DeWitt has played 3B & 2B in the ML’s, no excuse. all Quade has to say is, best man wins, and not for 3-4 games, for 3-4 weeks.

    • miggy80

      As a leader you have to pick and choose your words very carefully. How do you think the guys would react if he started to show he doesn’t have faith in them? Or better yet, what would you think of him then? What this shows me is that Q should be able to handle the media in Chicago.

  • jstraw

    That picture of DeWitt is hilarious. “I found the ball coach…now what?!”

    • jim

      “Hey Mommy, look what I found!!”

  • philoe beddoe

    The Dodgers wanted Theriot because they said he was a “true” middle infielder..nice speak for saying DeWitt couldn’t play there..he is a 3B who is trying to be made into a 2B because his offense, which would be ‘suspect’ for a 2B, is unacceptable for a 3B..

    long story short, he is not a major league 2b defensively

Bleacher Nation Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. Bleacher Nation is a private media site, and it is not affiliated in any way with Major League Baseball or the Chicago Cubs. Neither MLB nor the Chicago Cubs have endorsed, supported, directed, or participated in the creation of the content at this site, or in the creation of the site itself. It's just a media site that happens to cover the Chicago Cubs.

Bleacher Nation is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.