Meet the Cubs’ GM Candidates Cheat Sheet: Theo Epstein

[This series intends to introduce you to each of the legitimate Chicago Cubs GM candidates, and give you a quick, clean rund0wn of the most important information to know about that candidate as the Cubs' search process continues. Previously: Brian Cashman.]

Name and Age: Theo Epstein, 37.

Current Role and Contract Status: Boston Red Sox General Manager since November 2002, signed through 2012. He currently makes something north of $1.5 million per year.

Previously on BN: Epstein’s Name Keeps Popping UpEpstein for HOF?, Epstein for President?Theo Epstein Speaks, Epstein May Be a Possibility, Bullets, More BulletsStill More Bullets

Record in Current Role: The Red Sox have made the playoffs every year under Epstein except for last year and 2006. They won the World Series twice (2004 and 2007). Even in the two non-playoff years, the Red Sox were 10 and 16 games over .500.

Notable Prior Experience: Epstein cut his teeth in the San Diego Padres’ organization, first doing public relations, and then taking over baseball operations. He picked up his law degree at the University of San Diego while he was working for the Padres.

Reason(s) for Including as Candidate: Big market GM, very successful, and, having ended the Red Sox’s “curse,” is inextricably tied to the fate of the Chicago Cubs in the minds of many. Also, Tom Ricketts wants to emulate the “Boston Red Sox model,” which is another way of saying, “I want to do it like Theo Epstein has done it.”

Tom Ricketts’ Criteria: Track record of success in a winning organization? Check. Demonstrated commitment to player development? Check. Strong analytical background? Check.

Pros/Hype: This is the guy who FINALLY won it all for the Boston Red Sox. And, make no mistake, that 2004 squad was his team, which he started building when he took the reigns after the 2002 season. Since then, the Sawx have done nothing but win and make money hand-over-fist. He has changed the culture in Boston, and, after doing so, has ably dealt with the dangerously high expectations his own success engendered. At the close of the last decade, Epstein was honored with a slew of “best executive of the decade” type awards.

Cons/Cynical Criticism: Like his counterpart in New York, Epstein has been giving a huge freaking checkbook with which to work. It’s easy to cover mistakes when you’ve got all that green backing you up – mistakes like John Lackey, Daisuke Matsuzaka, Carl Crawford, etc. Also, Epstein is under contract for 2012, and Boston ownership has not given any indication that they will allow him to step out for interviews. The Cubs would have to, at a minimum, wait out the Red Sox season before being able to talk to him, at which time he could easily tell them, “not interested.”

Desirability: Very high. Just like with Cashman, I get the cynicism. But – once again like Cashman – Epstein faces unbelievable pressure from the owners, the media, and the fans in Boston. And, unlike Cashman, that pressure is almost exclusively the product of Epstein’s own efforts. So successful has he been that his progeny are littered through MLB front offices, and most are themselves considered desirable GM targets. The Red Sox roster is made up not only of expensive free agents, but also brilliantly-developed Boston talent, as well as players acquired by way of other Boston talent.

Likelihood/Probable Outcome: With the Red Sox’s current swoon, the chances that Epstein would consider taking an interview with the Cubs (if he was even permitted to do so) have crept up slightly from “highly unlikely” to “maybe.” I still don’t think he would ultimately take a job with the Cubs, even if he were offered a president-level position (which Tom Ricketts has suggested isn’t going to happen for any candidate). I do, however, believe Epstein is one of a handful of candidates at the top of Ricketts’ list, for whom Tom is ready and willing to wait the season out. Ricketts will get in Epstein’s ear if he really wants to – but it remains dubious that the outcome would be anything more than a better title and more money from the Red Sox for Epstein.

Brett Taylor is the editor and lead writer at Bleacher Nation, and can also be found as Bleacher Nation on Twitter and on Facebook.

29 responses to “Meet the Cubs’ GM Candidates Cheat Sheet: Theo Epstein”

  1. CubFan Paul

    nice piece ..it gets me wondering what an Epstein led Chicago front office would look like and how successful he could be here *if* he can do it his way

  2. Fishin Phil

    As much as I would love to see Epstein come here, I agree that it is still highly doubtful.

  3. Toosh

    Hughes just resigned. Rather than being fired?

    1. Fishin Phil

      Dang Toosh, you are fast!  Nice find.

      1. Toosh

        Thank you! I (Sorry, Brett) read other websites.

  4. Dan Ballard

    My only concern with Epstein or Cashman is mentioned in the article. They both have always been one and two in payroll. Could either one of them do it with our payroll?

    1. Toosh

      With one of the highest revenue streams and payrolls in the NL, the Cubs should have one of the best farm systems and Major League rosters in the NL as well.

    2. hansman1982

      Here is Boston’s payroll:
      2011: $163,822,475
      2010: $168,109,833
      2009: $121,745,999
      2008: $133,390,035
      2007: $143,026,214
      2006: $120,099,824
      2005: $123,505,125
      2004: $127,298,500

      Here is Chicago’s:
      2011: $134,004,000
      2010: $144,359,000
      2009: $134,809,000
      2008: $118,345,833
      2007: $ 99,670,332
      2006: $ 94,424,499
      2005: $ 87,032,933
      2004: $ 90,560,000

      Basically he would be walking into what he had for the first 4 years he was in Boston…on ya, the years he won 2 WS rings. I think he can handle it.

  5. baseballet

    I’m charmed by Ricketts’s love affair with Theo Epstein. Let’s hope their courtship takes place in Chicago, like “When Harry Met Sally.” Theo is the Meg Ryan of GM candidates. He’s America’s sweetheart.

  6. Alex

    If Ricketts doesn’t get Epstein, I wouldn’t mind seeing Cherington as a candidate.

  7. Meet the GM Candidates Cheat Sheet: Andrew Friedman | Bleacher Nation | Chicago Cubs News, Rumors, and Commentary

    [...] [This series intends to introduce you to each of the legitimate Chicago Cubs GM candidates, and give you a quick, clean rundown of the most important information to know about that candidate as the Cubs' search process continues. Previously: Brian Cashman, Theo Epstein.] [...]

  8. Meet the GM Candidates Cheat Sheet: Billy Beane | Bleacher Nation | Chicago Cubs News, Rumors, and Commentary

    [...] to know about that candidate as the Cubs' search process continues. Previously: Brian Cashman, Theo Epstein, Andrew [...]

  9. Meet the Cubs’ GM Candidates Cheat Sheet: Ned Colletti | Bleacher Nation | Chicago Cubs News, Rumors, and Commentary

    [...] to know about that candidate as the Cubs' search process continues. Previously: Brian Cashman, Theo Epstein, Andrew Friedman, Billy [...]

  10. Meet the GM Candidates Cheat Sheet: Jed Hoyer | Bleacher Nation | Chicago Cubs News, Rumors, and Commentary

    [...] at least not without a bunch of cursing and ruing another Cubs disaster. Previously: Brian Cashman, Theo Epstein, Andrew Friedman, Billy Beane, Ned [...]