Cubs Sign Dominican Pitcher Juan Carlos Paniagua for $1.5 Million

Busy news night.

Today, the Chicago Cubs made a *huge* international signing, inking 22-year-old righty Juan Carlos Paniagua to a $1.5 million deal. The 22-year-old righty has a fastball that can touch 98 mph, but is typically in the mid-90s. He’s got a quality slider, and a good changeup.

That the Cubs gave him $1.5 million – more than half of their $2.9 million bonus pool for the 2012-13 international signing period, speaks to how highly they think of him (and how desperate they are for young pitching).

But there is a little more to the Paniagua story. From Ben Badler:

Like any international signing, Paniagua will still require a background investigation and the contract approval of Major League Baseball, which in Paniagua’s case has been a problem before.

Paniagua, 22, originally signed with Arizona as Juan Carlos Collado for $17,000 on May 8, 2009. He pitched in Arizona’s Dominican Summer League program for parts of two seasons with a pending contract (an option that is no longer allowed) but had his deal terminated due to fraudeulent paperwork and was declared ineligible to sign for one year.

During his time off, his fastball rose from peaking at 92 mph to touching 98 mph, and in 2011 he signed with the Yankees for $1.1 million as Juan Carlos Paniagua. MLB also terminated that contract due to what the league called “falsified documents” and declared him ineligible to sign for one year, a penalty that ended today.

Now, before you say those are red flags, you have to remember: it might not have been his fault. As a young kid coming out the DR, this stuff often happens TO you, rather than BY you. I’m not saying it’s not something to make you a little squeamish, but if the Cubs were willing to drop such a huge chunk of their international budget on him, I’d say they’ve vetted him fully.

Paniagua probably immediately slots in as one of the more interesting Cubs pitching prospects, and will probably see some action later this year in the lower minors. Next year will probably be the real year to watch him (hopefully) progress.

Together with the signing of Dominican shortstop Frandy De La Rosa for $700K, the Cubs have now spent at least $2.2 million of their $2.9 million international signing budget (on which they can go over by a bit, subject to certain restrictions). I’d guess the remaining $700K will be spread out over a number of signings, from which many of tomorrow’s superstars emerge.

Starlin Castro only cost the Cubs $45,000.

Brett Taylor is the editor and lead writer at Bleacher Nation, and can also be found as Bleacher Nation on Twitter and on Facebook.

48 responses to “Cubs Sign Dominican Pitcher Juan Carlos Paniagua for $1.5 Million”

  1. Crockett

    I like this approach. Sign two well known, high-end guys and then just suck up about 10-15 16 year old’s who will all become little Starlins.

    1. Luke

      Imagine what they might be able to do with a much larger pool of IFA funds next season. Depending on where they finish, the Cubs could wind up with over $5 million to spend.

      1. Jimmy james

        What happens with this money if the contract is voided…do they get it back next year, like draft picks that aren’t signed?

    2. Richard Nose

      Sweet little baby Starlins.

    3. Kyle


      If you are going to drop this much money, an intriguing 22-year-old like this is much more palatable to me than a 16-year-old. Way too much happens between 16 and the big leagues to make these guys any sort of predictable. Castro being an excellent example.

  2. Luke

    I’m glad this one got done.

    1. Scotti

      I’d like to take this opportunity to point out that JCP (TM) starts his career as a “old for every league he will play in” guy and that it doesn’t matter one bit. Some cats get started late (injury, missions work, strange dealings with other countries, etc.) and that has no real impact on what REALLY matters–experience for your league.

      Discount, or upgrade, a guy if he has too much or very little past baseball experience, not his age. Far too often there are reasonable reasons behind those circumstances.

  3. mudge

    Great work, Brett. Sure beats the rumors!

  4. Martin

    Almora, Baez, Soler, Paniagua…

    How much of the Cubs top 10 prospects from this time last year won’t be in their top 10 at the end of this season?

  5. Serious Cubs Fan

    If hes 22 years old then why didnt they just sign him before the July 2nd start of the new international free agent signing period? Then they could have just saved themselves $1.5 mil of the $2.9 mill they had right?

    1. Bric

      Because the suspension from his prior contract with the Yankees expired today.

  6. Serious Cubs Fan

    nvm sorry just read all the way through. Brett anyway we could bring the edit button back?

  7. Master Gonzo

    If this guy works out, it will add a nice splash to the mantie-wetting party in 2015/6.

  8. Wester

    Boy I wish I could edit this useless post…

  9. Njriv

    What’s his ceiling?

    1. Luke

      I don’t want to go there until I have a better idea how much movement he has on his fastball and how reliably he can throw his slider and changeup for strikes.

      But Baseball America’s Ben Badler has already Tweeted that he’d be in the Cubs’ Top 30 somewhere. That probably means his ceiling is no lower than a No 3/4 starter.

      1. Assman22

        Should have a better idea in a few weeks once he gets going in Zona. Paniagua could be a big timer for the Cubs and at a fraction of what a couple others cost earlier this season. Glad that source was right too, I was going to start questioning his input if he had missed this one :)

  10. cubchymyst

    After reading the Ben Bradley article about when he signed with the Yankees. I am excited about this pick up.

    Yanks thought he had above-average potential on both curve and change-up

  11. babe ruth

    hey brett!! i was thinking that it would be nice if you could do a live video chat somtime on or, or whatever site you would prefer. i think it would be great if you did this while doing your 30 hour marathon, at the trade deadline

  12. Tommy

    Dodgers have made an offer to the Cubs for Dempster. It is unknown whether Zach Lee was in the offer.

  13. Serious Cubs Fan

    I really hope its Zach Lee but idk, sweetening the pot could mean Allen Webster offer or Chris Reed or Angel Sanchez who is a kid is quite projectable but having a bad year though. If the cubs got zach lee i would jump for joy

  14. Cubs’ Minor League Daily: Dawn of Soler | Bleacher Nation | Chicago Cubs News, Rumors, and Commentary

    [...] to the Ryan Dempster trade chatter and the signing of Juan Carlos Paniagua, the professional debut of the Cubs’ $30 million dollar outfield prospect Jorge Soler was [...]

  15. Leroy K.

    45,000???? wow….That’s amazing…