Penalver and Zych. I like the sound of those two names side by side. It sounds like a powerful law firm or a prestigious investment agency. If I were to be audited, I would want a firm with a name like Penalver and Zych handing my business with the IRS. Toss in a black silk suit and a handlebar mustache and I would have the most intimidating representation in town.

Welcome to another audit-free edition of Prospects’ Progress, the series in which we take a look at two prospects in the farm system and see how they progressed (or didn’t) over the course of the past year. As you have probably guessed by now, today the spotlight falls on infielder Carlos Penalver and reliever Tony Zych.

If case you’ve forgotten since Tuesday, Prospects’ Progress is not a top prospects list or player ranking system. All of that will be coming later in the winter.

Carlos Penalver, INF

Pre-Season Evaluation 

Penalver made his professional debut in the Dominican Summer League in 2011. He did not have a great campaign, but he did walk 35 times against just 42 strikeouts, stole 21 bases in 29 attempts, and put together a very respectable OBP of .364. The young Venezuelan spent the vast majority of his time at shortstop, and at the end of the season was ranked third within the Cubs’ organization at that position by Baseball America. Only Marco Hernandez and Wes Darvill came in higher (Baez and Lake were listed at third).

Coming into the 2012 season all I really wanted to see was more of the same. If Penalver could keep playing shortstop, keep getting on base, stay active on the basebaths, and hold the strikeouts to a minimum, I would be content.

Post-Season Verdict

Well, three out of four isn’t bad.

Penalver, at the age of 18, went to the Arizona Rookie League and hit .273/.341/.322. His walk rate was a quality 9.3%, and his strikeout rate was a very acceptable 15.1%. On defense he made 42 appearances at shortstop (second base was his second most frequent position at 5) and committed 14 errors. That error total looks high, but for a young shortstop that number is pretty meaningless. The important thing is that he was continuing to get steady work at the position. So, in three of the four areas I was watching, Penalver showed me exactly what I wanted to see.

And then we get to the fourth area. For some reason, Penalver attempted only eleven stolen bases all season. He was successful in 7 of those chances, but when a guy has a higher OBP than SLG, you don’t expect him to have the same number of steals as he has doubles. Players who do not have a lot of power need to make up for that in other areas, and base running is typically one of those areas. So far in his career Penalver has not shown much power at all. His career totals over 121 games and 516 trips to the plate are 1 HR, 3 3B, and 18 2B. He is listed at 6’0″ and 170 lbs; there is plenty of room for power to show up as he adds muscle over the next two or three seasons, but unless and until it does, his abilities on the base paths are likely to be a significant part of his offensive game.

Future Prognosis

Barring an injury, trade, or something else unforeseen, there is no room in Kane County for Penalver next season. He will likely open the year in extended spring training and move to Boise for the start of the Short-Season leagues in June. I expect he will be the regular shortstop for the Hawks, will continue to post quality numbers in the OBP, BB%, and K% categories, and will show more power than what he has demonstrated so far. I hope he rediscovers his baserunning game and turns in another 20+ steal season.

Long term, Penalver is blocked at shortstop for the Cubs by Starlin Castro, but it remains to be seen if he has enough of a bat to reach the majors anyway. If he can raise his SLG enough to become a .270/.340/.380 hitter then he probably has a career on the middle infield somewhere. We are years away from knowing that will be the case, though. Right now he is an interesting prospect that we will be keeping an eye on for the foreseeable future.

Tony Zych

Pre-Season Evaluation

The Cubs took Zych in the 2011 draft, and was he immediately tagged by analysts as being very close to the majors. Zych is a right handed reliever with late inning potential. His fastball can flirt with triple digits, has some life to it, and is delivered via a somewhat jerky pitching motion that adds deception. From the day he signed he has been a fairly safe bet to reach the major leagues. In the 2012 season I was looking to see just how fast he could reach the majors, and if we could imagine him as a closer one day.

Post-Season Verdict

Fast, and yes.

Zych could compete for a bullpen job in spring training, and I would not be at all surprised if he wins one. Should that happen, I would not be surprised if he is given a chance to close when/if Marmol is dealt during the year (or suffers another melt down). Zych is as legitimate a late inning arm as the Cubs have in the system today.

There are three things I really like to see in a closer: high K/9, low BB/9, and very low HR/9. A high K/9 tells me that this pitcher has the stuff to strike his way out of jams on a consistent basis. In 24+ innings at Double A Tennessee, Zych turned in a K/9 of 10.2. His season number, including his 36+ innings in Daytona, was 9.4. His BB/9 jumped to 4.4 with the Smokies, but the season number was an excellent 1.7. He gave up one home run all year. One. That’s a HR/9 of 0.1 on the season (0.4 in Tennessee) if you’re interested.

That’s not say Zych’s season was all great. He finished the year with a Double A WHIP of 1.541 thanks in no small part to his elevated walk totals. That is not such a good thing. Naturally, walks will be one of the things we are watching closely in the spring.

Future Prognosis

If Zych can keep the walks down, the velocity up, and the long balls non-existent, he could be an excellent closer. Thanks to its movement and his slightly unorthodox delivery, his fastball should continue to be an effective strikeout weapon as he climbs up the ladder. When he does arrive in Chicago I think the Cubs would prefer to start him out as a seventh inning guy and ease him into the late inning roles, but with a team this young and this much in flux, you never know what can happen. Regardless of where he begins 2013 (Tennessee, Iowa, or Chicago are the options), I think there is no doubt that he will finish the year in the Chicago bullpen. Should Rafael Dolis not claim the closer’s job in the post-Marmol era, Zych is more than capable of handling it himself.

  • daveyrosello

    Agree on Zych. I think he, Blake Parker and Dolis are the three guys currently in the system with the best chance to become big league bullpen arms. And of course, Vizcaino if he doesn’t have the stamina to be a starter.

  • terencemann

    I don’t know if Zych will be an instant success but I’d love to see him get enough innings in spring training to see if he’s ready for the 2013 bullpen. If the Cubs bullpen next season includes Dolis, Zych, Russell and Bowden, there could be a learning curve but that could be a good group to build off of.

    • Big Daddy

      I wasn’t impressed with Bowden. His ball just seems to lack movment. He looks like a BP pitcher to me.

      • Big Daddy

        “Movement”. Sorry.

    • Kyle

      There’s definitely some potential there for it to be adequate. Even adequacy would represent a huge advantage over last year.

      Still hate the idea of losing Cabrera off that list. I was really excited to see what he could do in a second-time around the majors.

  • Kyle

    Zych is one of my favorite prospects. If the offspeed tightens up just a little bit, he’s a legit major league reliever pretty quickly. I don’t know if I see him as a closer or shut-down setup man, but it’s within his range of possible outcomes for sure.

  • Fastball

    Sounds like this kid has potential. It would be nice if we could produce a lefty with an upper 90’s fastball and a great curve ball. I personally don’t like Russell and his batting practice fastball. I doubt he can break a window with his fastball. Anyway this Zych kid seems like he has some promise. Having been a long time pitcher I don’t see much in these other guys to be honest. Can’t stand watching Camp pitch. His advantage is he does throw so damned slow it takes hitters a minute to get used to the slowness of his pitches. If Dolis could learn how to pitch with just an ounce of balance in his delivery he could be good. His mechanics are damned near as poor as Marmol’s. I personally don’t see us trading Marmol this off season. I think the smarter play is to keep him in our pen and get him out of the gate next spring just like he finished up this past season. 3 months of continued success will get us a much better return at the deadline than he will bring this winter.

    • When the Music’s Over

      ….or Marmols regresses back to 2011 / first-half 2012, and he nets the Cubs very little. That’s the game the Cubs front office needs to decide if they want to play.

  • Pingback: Was Rick Hahn Almost the Cubs’ GM? No, and Other Bullets | Bleacher Nation | Chicago Cubs News, Rumors, and Commentary()


    Hoping they take their time with Zych. They rushed Dolis, Beliveau and Cabrera before they were ready last year, while they DFA’d more MLB ready guys like Gaub and Maine.

    Zych has looked pretty good, but doesn’t have the truly dominant numbers that you’d expect from a future closer, IMHO. I’d expect him to be more of a set up guy. For how impressive his fastball *looks*, it still gets hit quite a bit early in the count (just like Cabrera).

    Out of Zych, Cabrera and Dolis, Dolis’ FB is the toughest to do anything with, but Dolis’ secondaries aren’t as good as those other guys. I would really like them to try Dolis again as a starter at Iowa this year: his starting/relieving splits are not that wide in the low minors, and his sinker is so good that he’s the kind of guy who could pitch to contact and go deep into games with little else other than the sinker.