I had something else planned for this introduction, but my wife just brought me a freshly baked chocolate chip cookie and all other thoughts floated right out of my head. You are allowed to be insanely jealous. I don’t mind.

While I enjoy this warm, tasty, and slightly melty piece of delectableness, let’s review the basics of Prospects’ Progress. This series takes a look at many of the prospects in the Cubs farm system and considers the improvements (or lack of improvements) made over the course of the past season. I’ll get to player rankings and top prospect lists in a few weeks (my how time flies), but those will be a separate series entirely. All prospects, from the top of the heap to players you have barely heard of, are eligible to be considered in this space.

Lately we’ve been on a run of the more elite prospects, so for today I think we’ll dig a little deeper in the system for a couple of guys who are high on potential but have yet to emerge as potential impact players. Matt Loosen is a fairly anonymous pitching prospect today, but that may not last another season. Likewise, shortstop Marco Hernandez may be a breakout season waiting to happen.

Of course delectableness is a word. Now put that dictionary down, we’ve got some prospects to discuss.

Matt Loosen, RHP

Pre-Season Evaluation

The Cubs took Loosen out of Jacksonville University in the 23rd round in 2010. He signed early enough to pitch in 14 games (seven starts) for Arizona and Boise that year. In 2011 the still-Hendry-led Cubs started the righthander in Peoria and let him pitch his way rapidly up the system. He made it to Tennessee for two starts, but spent most of his time in Peoria and Daytona. Across those three stops he struck out 8.5 batters per nine innings and walked 3.2 (a rate that is somewhat inflated by a 6.5 BB/9 in Tennessee).

Those are solid numbers. Despite his rapid rise and relative success in 2011, though, he did not appear on Baseball America’s list of Cubs right handed starting pitching prospects prior to the 2012 season. Were there just too many names to list them all, or is Loosen a non-prospect who just happened to have a good year?

Post-Season Verdict

It was probably a numbers issue. Loosen certainly has flaws in his game, but his 2012 season demonstrated that there is potential here worth monitoring. The new Cubs front office decided to slow Loosen’s rise up the farm system down a bit and sent him to Daytona for a full season. Loosen responded with a 1.145 WHIP, 8.8 K/9, 0.6 HR/9, and a very respectable 6.6 H/9. Those quality numbers are only slightly tarnished by his age; at 23, he was slightly on the old side for High A. His walk rate (3.7 BB/9) was higher than I like to see as well.

Neither the age nor the walks are my largest concern with Loosen, though. That honor goes to his season GO/AO of 0.58. That figure trickled upwards as the season wore on, but at this point I think we can safely classify Loosen as a fly ball pitcher. As he heads for the tougher competition of the Southern League and, eventually, the small ballparks and high elevation of the Pacific Coast League, more and more of those fly balls are likely to find a way over the wall.

On the other hand, 2012 he gave up home runs at the rate of just 0.6 HR/9. Combine that with reports of a nasty slider and his career high total of 12 hit by pitch and a picture starts to emerge. I suspect Loosen spent much of 2012 learning to attack hitters and jam them with his fastball. His relatively moderate line drive percentages and relatively high infield fly ball percentages lend credence to that theory. We’ll find out when he hits Double A.

Future Prognosis

As a fly ball pitcher who was slightly old for his league and who beat up on younger competition, Loosen’s season was only good. If, though, he is type of hurler who can consistently jam hitters with his fastball and get the swing-and-miss strikeout with his slider, things look quite a bit different. That latter description is that of a potential number three starter, and that is how I am classifying Loosen for now. If he has success in Double A, we could be talking about him as a rotation candidate in Chicago as soon as July of 2014.

He should open 2013 in Tennessee, and Tennessee will tell the story. If he can repeat his formula from Daytona, he could become one of the most talked about break through stories in the Cubs farm system this year. If he can’t, there is an army of pitchers with similar potential waiting in the wings to steal that spotlight.

Marco Hernandez, SS

Pre-Season Evaluation

The Cubs have a lot of shortstop prospects, but many of them I list as Infielders or SS/3B because there is some debate regarding that player’s ability to stick at shortstop. Shortstop is the most defensively demanding position on the diamond (not including catcher, which is an entirely different kettle of fish) and players who can play here at a major league level are somewhat rare.

Marco Hernandez is one of those players. He is also a switch hitter. It isn’t hard to see why he attracts attention from the national prospecting publications.

Post-Season Verdict

In a bit of a surprising move, the Cubs opted to let Hernandez open the season as the everyday shortstop in Peoria. He struggled for a time, and just when it seemed he was adjusting to the league and having some success the Cubs demoted him back to extended spring training in order to clear the position for Javier Baez. He was eventually reassigned to Boise where he was the regular shortstop and finished the year with a line of .286/.310/.416. He capped off his time in Boise with a very strong August, hitting .324/.360/.472 over 27 games. Those numbers are not great, but for a 19 year old true shortstop, they are not bad at all.

Future Prognosis

I like the defensive potential and I love that he is a switch hitter (even though his splits are problematic), but I have serious concerns with Hernandez’s viability long term. Take a look at his Boise numbers again, and focus on the OBP. .310 for the season is not good for a guy with little power, and even that .360 in August does not look quite as shiny beside a batting average of .324.

On the other hand, Hernandez weighed in this year at 6’0″ and just 170 lbs. There is plenty of room there to pack on enough muscle to raise his power totals considerably. He is likely to always be more of an Alex Gonzalez than an Alex Rodriguez, but his career SLG of .373 is not the final word. Nor is it quite fair to say that a 19 year old player is not going to learn to control the strike zone more effectively. There is clearly some up[side here.

Hernandez should return to Low-A in 2013 as a member of the incredibly loaded Kane County team, and I expect he will fare much better his second time in the league. OBP related warning signs aside, this is a guy with a potentially bright future ahead of him. If he can improve his pitch selection, I would not be surprised to see him break out in a big way in a year or two.

I would not be surprised to see him traded, either. The Cubs are set at shortstop well into the future, and true shortstop prospects are not that common. When the Cubs think Hernandez’s value is at its highest, I suspect he’ll be dealt. That is likely two or three years down the road, but you never know. If a team falls in love with him tomorrow, there is no reason the Cubs could not pull the trigger.

  • http://windycitysportswonk.blogspot.com/ Myles

    It’s nice that Loosen had a good season, it’s still really hard for me to get too jazzed about a 23-year old in high-A who still walks more than his share of hitters.

  • The Dude Abides

    Luke – who would you rate are our top two or three catchers in the minors, Don’t recall seeing any in various list of our top prospects? Thanks

    • http://www.bleachernation.com Luke

      If I can’t count Clevenger or Castillo, there is no clear leader.

      Marra might have the best bat of the remainder, but Gibbs is probably the best defensively. Brenly is probably the closest to the majors, but also has one of the lowest ceilings (and that ceiling may not extend above Triple A).

      • Carew

        What about Chadd Krist?

        • http://www.bleachernation.com Luke

          Another potentially good one.

      • Cedlandrum

        Don’t forget Wilson Contreras, he would be my number 1 and that is pathetic.
        The rest is a crap shoot. The young guys like Marra and Rosario can hit but need a lot of work behind the plate. Rosario will only be 19 and was hurt most of last year. So there is promise, but it is a long way off.

        • Spriggs

          From what I saw of Rosario over the last couple years, he has a decent enough arm, but his catching skills are extremely poor. Like you said, he is only 19 next year… so though he has a ton of work to do in that department, there is plenty of time. Something happened to his bat last year too, and maybe it was the injury you mentioned, but he was not the same at the plate as he looked as a 17 year old.

          • Cedlandrum

            Yeah that is interesting and I never really heard what the injury was, so I will be interested in what you see this spring.

      • Spriggs

        Is Lopez considered a legit catcher in the system or is just organization filler?

        I liked what I saw in Marra in the AZL this year. Kid was always on base. Looks like a decent LH bat.

        • http://thecubcontrarian.blogspot.com/ Kyle

          It’s always kind of hard to tell with catchers because that line is so blurry. It feels like the worst 2nd catchers and most 3rd catchers in the majors are just organizational filler.

        • Cedlandrum

          Lopez is most likely filler. He was a drafted senior out of college which you know isn’t that great because he is older. Age 25 season this year. But he does have a decent bat. He hasn’t been a catcher that long, so he could improve.

  • Cedlandrum

    The 2010 draft was certainly an interesting one. There are some pitchers in that draft that you look at and say, “what do we have here?” Guys like Loosen, Beeler, Zeeler(knuckleballer), Austin Reed, Jochish all could be back of rotation or middle relievers or they could all wash out. I wouldn’t be surprised if none of them ever made it or if they all had at least a cup of coffee. Too many of those guys in those drafts.

  • http://thecubcontrarian.blogspot.com/ Kyle

    This is where rookie-ball slash lines shouldn’t be taken too seriously. 19’s an age where they are still learning to play professionally, and Hernandez has scouts drooling over him.

    We’ll know a lot more about him this year, where his focus is going to have to be more on production and he’s at an age where he should be starting to put it together. He could fly up the rankings list or settle into mediocrity pretty easily.

    He’s a big part of something that I know you’re aware of, Luke, but I think many fans overlook. We had a wonderful set of drafts in 2011-12, and we spent a ton of money on Soler, and we traded for a lot of prospects. But we also had two straight years of very nice DSL teenage prospects graduating to the states. That’s sort of the fourth front.

    • http://www.bleachernation.com Luke

      I love the DSL crop lately.

      Amaya, Hernandez, Penalver, Candelario, the other Baez, etc. etc. etc., and that’s just the hitters.

      There is so much potential coming out of that pipeline right now.

      • MightyBear


        Do you think that DSL pipeline was because of Oneri Fleita and do you think because he left it might slow down? Or do you think because of the new facilities, it might get even stronger? Thanks.

        • http://www.bleachernation.com Luke

          Fleita gets a lot of credit for building the system up, but I don’t think letting him go will harm things any. The Cubs have a very good, large, and well funded organization down there right now. And that is not likely to change any time soon.

          • ETS

            doesn’t it shock you we let him go though?

      • ssckelley

        Find us some more pitching coming out of that pipeline. I know Arias did not look to bad in Boise, will the Cubs be looking to bring up others? Daury Torrez perhaps?

        • Cedlandrum

          I’m very interested in how Torrez looks in the states, because his numbers certainly pop.

    • Noah

      I think a good player to look at for this is former Cubs’ prospect Hak-Ju Lee. In Low A in 2010, his first year of full season ball and last season with the Cubs, Lee made 34 errors. He was down to 24 this past season.

      There are just a lot of errors in the lower minors. Less polished players, just flat out less talented players, and fields that aren’t as well maintained all contribute.

  • #1cubsfan2013

    did we sign ss Frandy De La Rosa this year

    • http://www.bleachernation.com Luke


  • Rizzo44

    That is a fuc.king stupid idea… Just sign some good players like we did for Schierholtz…

    • Cedlandrum

      What are you talking about?