A Tale of Two Quarterbacks: What Can We Expect From Cutler and Rodgers?

CutlerRodgers

The Packers concluded their Obsessive Aaron Rodgers Watch yesterday, and as Brett was kind enough to post, he will return this weekend, playing the role of white knight in shining green/gold/cheesehead armor. Plenty of people reacted as though that sealed things up for Green Bay. I might be a bit biased; I do write a Bears blog, after all. And if this was the 2010 Green Bay Packers, I might feel that way. But that team had a legitimately good defense, as did last year’s Packer squad. Both were top-10 by Football Outsiders Defensive Efficiency metric. This year? Not the same story. And that defense just lost Clay Matthews.

Beyond their regression on defense, expecting Aaron Rodgers to step in and play up to his full potential (on the road in potentially difficult conditions) is a lot to ask, even for a player of his caliber. He might get Randall Cobb back, which could be another boost for the Packers. But if you’re asking me to pick which offense I’d expect to perform better on Sunday, I’d take the Bears. Rodgers has essentially missed eight weeks, and though he’s “practiced” for two weeks now (according to Mike McCarthy) that is still a very long lay-off to overcome. A fractured clavicle also seems like a difficult injury to deal with as a quarterback; it was his non-throwing shoulder, but it’s more of a core injury than anything, and throwing a football requires movement in the off-arm as well. (I just pantomimed a throwing motion, in case you were wondering.)

It’s also a tough injury to protect. You can’t exactly put a cast on it, or add extra padding. Nor can he protect himself from re-injury should he be sacked, hit, or otherwise knocked to the ground. (I’m not going to advocate anything overly dirty, but I think we might see Rodgers on the receiving end of the slightly late, two-handed shoves to the chest that Cutler takes every week.) I’m assuming that the first hits he takes in the game will be the first contact he’s experienced since he was originally injured. If the Bears can rattle him physically, is there any guarantee he’ll play at a higher level than Matt Flynn would have?

Aaron Rodgers is a great player. Before he was injured against the Bears, the Packers moved the ball 71 yards on 6 plays. Chicago’s defense is quite poor; I don’t think they’ll be as bad as they were against Philadelphia, but that’s only because of how extraordinarily poor they were against the Eagles. It was so bad I have a hard time envisioning a repeat performance. But that doesn’t mean I think they’ll play well.

The silver lining for the Bears? I don’t think Green Bay’s defense will play well, either. They’ve allowed 74 points ovr their last 2 games. The Bears picked them apart for 442 yards the first time around, with Josh McCown under center and Clay Matthews out; 171 of those came on the ground. Green Bay ran for 199, of course. Eddie Lacy is expected to play despite missing practice, and he very well might have another big game. I think this weekend will likely be another high-scoring affair. The over/under is currently 53; I’d take the over, assuming the weather isn’t catastrophically bad.

Why do I have such faith in the offense, despite Jay Cutler’s well-chronicled struggles against Green Bay? Well, it’s pretty simple, and Jay Cutler feels the same way: they weren’t as good on offense in those years. As Adam Hoge notes in that story, Cutler’s been sacked 30 times against the Packers, including 11 times over two losses last season. (Remember his confrontation with J’Marcus Webb last year, as the offensive line gave up seven sacks? Remember how J’Marcus Webb was the starting left tackle last year? Or have you successfully blocked those painful memories?) McCown was only sacked once in November’s victory. This Bears offense is built to handle the sort of pressure that has troubled Cutler against Green Bay; this post from ESPN Chicago’s Michael C. Wright (using numbers provided by ESPN Stats & Info) notes that “the Packers have sent five or more 43 percent of the time on first down on Cutler, while the rest of the league tried that tactic just 29 percent of the time.”

How have the Bears handled that pressure? From the same post: “Cutler has completed 49 percent of his throws for one TD and eight interceptions when Green Bay sends five or more pass-rushers over the past five years.” That’s not good, and there were many factors at play, Cutler’s performance included. But lack of anything resembling competent offensive line play jumps out, of course. How about the receiving talent? Devin Hester, Roy Williams, Johnny Knox, Dane Sanzenbacher, Kellen Davis…who exactly was Cutler supposed to use as a safety valve? Not to mention the people calling plays, from Mike Martz’s “no audibles allowed” approach (seriously) to Mike Tice’s “(unintelligible grunting)” efforts, there was very little support on the sideline. Until this season, Jay Cutler was asked to lead an offense that was the polar opposite of quarterback friendly, and he suffered for it.

Things are different now. This is a terrific offense, and not just by Chicago standards. An improving offensive line (that rates far better in terms of pass protection than run blocking), a sparkling collection of skill players, and a coaching staff that gets it. It’s no surprise that Cutler has played much better this year. He’s 8th in ESPN’s Total QBR, which is not adjusted for opponent. (Josh McCown is 1st, despite playing a softer schedule; his numbers still speak to the offense’s improvement.) That is not a metric that has been kind to Cutler in the past. His ranking over his Chicago career, going backwards to 2009: 21st, 16th, 22nd, 20th. He was 4th with Denver in 2008, the last time he played on a competent offense. This season, he ranks ahead of names like Brady, Luck, Wilson, Romo, Newton, and Stafford. We’ve seen quite an offensive improvement this season, and let’s remember that it’s just the first year. It stands to reason that things could get even better, and that’s one big reason why I’ve advocated for Cutler’s return.

This Sunday’s game is a big one, obviously. It’s essentially the first round of the playoffs, but it’s going to be treated as so much more than if the Bears simply had to beat the Vikings. This is your stereotypical “BIG GAME”: biggest rival coming to town, national television, a returning Aaron Rodgers, the potential for snow, an expiring contract for the home team’s quarterback. The praise or criticism for Cutler (and to a lesser extent, Rodgers) is going to be massively amplified, and some are going to use it as a referendum on whether he should be re-signed this offseason. I’m certainly not going to go that far, and I highly doubt anyone in the Bears front office will either.

It will, however, be a very important part of an overall evaluation. With the Lions imploding yet again, it’s obvious that the Packers are the true benchmark in the NFC North, and how the Bears stack up relative to the Packers, both now and going forward, will have a large impact on Chicago’s success. The two teams have had mirroring seasons, in many ways: starting quarterbacks missing significant amounts of time, rosters ravaged by injuries, quality offenses being counterbalanced by struggling defenses. It’s poetic that they’d meet with the division on the line. And whoever wins will have certainly earned their title, having overcome fairly significant obstacles en route to the playoffs.

I really do think Jay Cutler will play well.

I don’t know if that will be enough for the Bears to win.

But I hope they do.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more bears news

D-Line Thoughts, Caleb, GM Seth Rollins, Pack Votes No, and Other Bears Bullets

Cubs and White Sox opening day is today today. March Madness resumes with the Fighting Illini playing in the Sweet 16 later tonight. SIU, my alma mater, is reportedly hiring a "Coach Nagy" to lead its basketball team. And what...

Dan Campbell is Happy To See Justin Fields Leave the NFC North

There was no escaping the mixed emotions from Chicago Bears fans when the Justin Fields trade went down earlier this month. But there were none of that from Detroit Lions Head Coach Dan Campbell. Heck, I'd argue there was just...

Another Pass Rusher Signs Elsewhere: Jadeveon Clowney Lands With the Panthers

Another day. Another pass rusher signing. And another defensive lineman going to a team that isn't the Chicago Bears. NFL Network insider Ian Rapoport was the first with the news of Jadeveon Clowney signing with the Carolina Panthers. Meanwhile, ESPN's...

Malik Nabers Might’ve Run His Way Out of the Chicago Bears Draft Spot

Today was LSU's Pro Day and Chicago Bears GM Ryan Poles was scheduled to be in attendance, per The Athletic's Adam Jahns. Assuming Poles made his flight, he got a good look at the likes of quarterback Jayden Daniels, as...

Goodell on Bears Stadium Deal, No to Hard Knocks? More Old Friends Go to Steelers, and Other Bears Bullets

I keep forgetting that I have a Starbucks gift card from Christmas that has gone unused to this point. Maybe I'll remember it next time I go out for coffee. A big shout out to PFF Brad, who made the...

Ryan Poles Was Pissed Off By RGIII’s Comments About Caleb Williams Situation

When I saw them pop up, RGIII's comments suggesting Caleb Williams pull an Eli Manning and refuse to play for the Chicago Bears were met with an eye-roll, audible groan, and immediate dismissal before moving onto more pertinent topics. But...

Bears Stadium Update: Kevin Warren Reiterates Plans to Build in Downtown Chicago

It sure is starting to sound like Arlington Heights fumbled the bag when it comes to locking in Arlington Park as the future home of a Chicago Bears stadium. While meeting with the media at the NFL owners meetings in...

The NFL is Playing a Christmas Day Doubleheader in 2024

Christmastime is generally full of cheer. And in 2024, it will be full of cheering. In fact, we're talking double the cheer. ESPN NFL insider Adam Schefter reports the league will play not one, but *TWO* Christmas Day games. It's...

2024 NFL Mock Draft: How High Can J.J. McCarthy’s Stock Rise?

Hard to believe we're less than a month away from the 1st Round of the 2024 NFL Draft! With just weeks remaining until the NFL's most noteworthy offseason event, there are plenty of rumors floating. As we work through all...

NFL Rules Shakeup, Tomlin on Fields, Trubisky’s Linsanity Run, and Other Bears Bullets

The Bachelor's season-finale had a couple of jaw-dropping moments. Once the group chat catches up, it is going to be lit. What better way to start Bears Bullets than with breakfast anecdotes? I think I'm going to enjoy D'Andre Swift's...

Latest News

Guardians vs. Athletics Probable Starting Pitchers – March 28

The Cleveland Guardians (0-0) and the Oakland Athletics (0-0) square off on Thursday at Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum for Opening Day. First pitch is at 10:07 PM ET.The Guardians will call on Shane Bieber versus the Athletics and Alex Wood.Guardians vs....

Mariners vs. Red Sox Probable Starting Pitchers – March 28

The Seattle Mariners (0-0) open their 2024 season with a home contest against the Boston Red Sox (0-0) on Thursday, with first pitch at 10:10 PM ET.The Mariners will look to Luis Castillo against the Red Sox and Brayan Bello.Mariners...

Diamondbacks vs. Rockies Probable Starting Pitchers – March 28

The Arizona Diamondbacks (0-0) begin their 2024 season with a home matchup against the Colorado Rockies (0-0) on Thursday, with first pitch at 10:10 PM ET.The Diamondbacks will give the nod to Zac Gallen against the Rockies and Kyle Freeland.Diamondbacks...

Buffalo Bills 1st Round Mock Draft: Wild Crossroads at 28 – Offense or Defense?

The Buffalo Bills stand at a crossroads. The 2024 NFL Draft looms, and the 28th pick presents a fascinating dilemma. This Buffalo Bills 1st Round Mock Draft analyzes 10 different options that could be available to them at their current...

How to Watch Celtics vs. Hawks: Live Stream or on TV

The Atlanta Hawks (33-39) hope to continue a three-game home winning stretch when hosting the Boston Celtics (57-15) on Thursday, March 28, 2024 at 7:30 PM ET.In their last time out, the Celtics lost 120-118 to the Hawks on Monday....

Rangers vs. Cubs Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Texas Rangers look to start their season with a win as home favorites (-120) in a season-opening matchup with the Chicago Cubs. First pitch is on Thursday at 7:35 PM ET on ESPN, live from Globe Life Field.Texas' Nathan...

Dejounte Murray Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Celtics – Thursday, March 28, 2024

Will Dejounte Murray make four 3-pointers when the Atlanta Hawks face the Boston Celtics on Thursday at 7:30 PM ET? If so, he'll beat his prop for the game.Dejounte Murray's Three-Pointer Prop Odds vs. the CelticsDejounte Murray's over/under for three-pointers...

Bogdan Bogdanovic Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Celtics – Thursday, March 28, 2024

To beat his 3-point over/under, Bogdan Bogdanovic needs to make three from beyond the arc on Thursday, when his Atlanta Hawks meet the Boston Celtics on Thursday at 7:30 PM ET.Bogdan Bogdanovic's Three-Pointer Prop Odds vs. the CelticsBogdan Bogdanovic's over/under...

Jayson Tatum Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Hawks – Thursday, March 28, 2024

At 7:30 PM ET on Thursday, it'll be the Boston Celtics versus the Atlanta Hawks, with Jayson Tatum needing three treys to beat his 3-pointer prop.Jayson Tatum's Three-Pointer Prop Odds vs. the HawksJayson Tatum's over/under for three-pointers in this game:...

Jaylen Brown Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Hawks – Thursday, March 28, 2024

To beat his 3-point prop, Jaylen Brown must make three from beyond the arc on Thursday, when his Boston Celtics play the Atlanta Hawks on Thursday at 7:30 PM ET.Jaylen Brown's Three-Pointer Prop Odds vs. the HawksJaylen Brown's over/under for...

more bears news