287 replies to this topic

[hansman1982]

This is bullcrap. We have arms appearing out of nowhere!!!!!!!!

[TWC]

Waitaminnit.... did the OG cut off everyone else's arms? He was the only one w/ 2 hands and thus the only one able to amputate the others?

[Cubbie Blues]

Noooooooo. No. No no no.

Wait 9 people ate an arm?
did 10 people eat an arm?
All the shipwrecked partook of the arms

So someone didn't eat an arm?
Everyone on the island ate

There were only 10 people on the entirety of the island.
Yes

[Cubbie Blues]

This is bullcrap. We have arms appearing out of nowhere!!!!!!!!

No

[Cubbie Blues]

Waitaminnit.... did the OG cut off everyone else's arms? He was the only one w/ 2 hands and thus the only one able to amputate the others?

Everyone helped with the cutting

[Cubbie Blues]

Just when I thought I could leave you sucked me back in.

[hansman1982]

And everyone ate arms?

So 10 arms were ate from 9 people yet 9 people have 1 arm 1 guy has 2 and arms weren't provided by anyone or anything other than the 9 people?

Was he a Siamese twin?

Did everyone eat an entire arm?

[hansman1982]

Noooooooo. No. No no no.

Wait 9 people ate an arm?
did 10 people eat an arm?
All the shipwrecked partook of the arms

So someone didn't eat an arm?
Everyone on the island ate

There were only 10 people on the entirety of the island.
Yes

Ah ha...you didn't answer my question. Based on 10 people surviving the shipwreck answer the question.

[Cubbie Blues]

And everyone ate arms?
Yes

So 10 arms were ate
No

from 9 people yet 9 people have 1 arm 1 guy has 2 and arms weren't provided by anyone or anything other than the 9 people?
Yes

Was he a Siamese twin?
No Stinky already covered that one

Did everyone eat an entire arm?
A least not at once

[Cubbie Blues]

Noooooooo. No. No no no.

Wait 9 people ate an arm?
did 10 people eat an arm?
All the shipwrecked partook of the arms

So someone didn't eat an arm?
Everyone on the island ate

There were only 10 people on the entirety of the island.
Yes

Ah ha...you didn't answer my question. Based on 10 people surviving the shipwreck answer the question.

Let's just call it 10 people from here

Yes all 10 ate

[hansman1982]

And everyone ate arms?
Yes

So 10 arms were ate
No

from 9 people yet 9 people have 1 arm 1 guy has 2 and arms weren't provided by anyone or anything other than the 9 people?
Yes

Was he a Siamese twin?
No Stinky already covered that one

Did everyone eat an entire arm?
A least not at once

Did someone regurgitate an arm?


I give up - I have no clue how 10 people all ate a full arm when there were only 9 arms.

[Cubbie Blues]

Did someone regurgitate an arm?
No

I give up - I have no clue how
No

10 people all ate a full arm
No

when there were only 9 arms.
Yes

[SirCub]

Ok, so 9 people cut off their arms and those 9 arms were used to feed 10 people? The OG presented his "spare arm" but it wasn't eaten? Then when the OAM saw him years later, he was outraged that the OG still had both arms, and shot him?

I feel like I'm missing something. Didn't everybody on the island already know that the OG was keeping both his arms? Did they expect him to chop one off after they were rescued?

[Cubbie Blues]

Ok, so 9 people cut off their arms and those 9 arms were used to feed 10 people?
Yes

The OG presented his "spare arm" but it wasn't eaten?
No

Then when the OAM saw him years later, he was outraged that the OG still had both arms, and shot him?
Yes

I feel like I'm missing something.
Yes

Didn't everybody on the island already know that the OG was keeping both his arms?
Yes/No

Did they expect him to chop one off after they were rescued?
YES

[Spencer]

Did OG make a promise to cut his arm off after leaving the island so everyone would be on level footing rather than participate in cannibalism?