Ugly Pitch-Framing for the Chicago Cubs This Year May Have Cost Them Several Wins

Coming into the season, we were on alert about Welington Castillo’s questionable pitch-framing ability thanks to a variety of third party sources on the subject. That tends to lead to bias when using our eyes to evaluate how he actually did this year, so I don’t necessarily trust that it felt like Castillo wasn’t much better this year than in the past (though still quite good at the other catching stuff).

According to one set of data, however, Castillo was indeed pretty bad at framing. Moreover, he wasn’t alone on the Cubs:

John Baker figures prominently there, right with Castillo in terms of strikes the team lost (arguably) because of poor framing. In other words, the Cubs got far fewer strikes than they should have gotten this year, based on where the pitches actually were. Sure, it could just be an umpire-related fluke, but the data – and the theory behind it – strongly suggests the Cubs lost these strikes because of the way their catchers received the ball. And we’re not talking about the Cubs not getting a framing advantage. We’re talking about the Cubs affirmatively losing strikes. This is a serious issue.

Baseball Prospectus generally agrees with Mark Simon’s calculations, placing the Cubs third worst in baseball, having lost about 228 strikes this year, and somewhere between 27 and 34 runs due to framing (though BP has Castillo as bad as Simon does, BP has Baker just about framing-neutral). StatCorner has Baker as slightly below average, and Castillo the second worst in baseball, ahead of only Jarrod Saltalamacchia. Rafael Lopez and Eli Whiteside, in small samples, come up negative as well. In total, StatCorner has the Cubs giving up about 30 runs thanks to poor framing, which is right in step with BP’s calculation.

A win is usually worth about 10 runs, so we’re talking about three *entire* wins the Cubs may have lost this year due to poor framing. Let that wash over you like a tartar sauce shower.

An important caveat: the last couple years we’ve really still only started to understand and analyze pitch-framing in a granular way that attempts to say “this is how many strikes you lost, thus this is how many outs you lost, thus this is how many runs you lost, thus this is how many games you lost.” I don’t think it’s unfair to say that this is not an exact science just yet, and many folks – me included – were really shocked to learn in the last 12 to 18 months just how valuable pitch-framing could be.

But … yeah. However you slice it, the Cubs were likely really bad at framing this year, and it cost them dearly. As we look ahead to a competitive window, this kind of thing is where seemingly middling teams can take a leap forward – or where seemingly strong teams can fail to get over the hump.

Since it was both of the Cubs’ primary catchers (and Lopez/Whiteside, too), I can’t help but wonder: is there a pitching component here? Something where certain kinds of pitchers tend not to get framing calls as consistently as others? I don’t think we can argue that the catcher is the main guy in the framing equation, but the pitcher’s movement and locating ability has to play a part, right?

BP lets you sort by battery, so you could dig into this more if you’d like. I don’t really see anything obvious. The only pitchers that show up in the bottom 100 for both Castillo and Baker are Jake Arrieta (damn, dude: how awesome could he have been if he hadn’t lost 44(!) strikes this year, or even better, had gotten some extra ones?) and Travis Wood. Those guys are totally different pitchers, with completely different sets of tools.

If you’re looking for the top framing catchers this year:

Russell Martin is obviously available as a free agent, and Miguel Montero is an obviously-available trade candidate. Just pointing it out.

However the Cubs do it, you’d like to see them address this issue going into next season. I love me some John Baker, but if the Cubs are going to have a light-hitting veteran back-up taking 1/3 of the starts, they’re probably going to need it to be someone who is superlative defensively, calls a good game, works well with pitchers and young players, and is a great framer.

As for the starter … I’m torn. There’s so much to like about Castillo’s game, and there remains some uncertainty about these framing calculations. But there’s a significant chance that Castillo is one of the worst framers in baseball, and it tangibly harms the Cubs to the tune of several extra losses per season. I don’t know that his bat and other defensive skills will ever make up for that.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Wrigley Field is Gonna Be Lit This Year (As in New Colored Lights!)

Last year, the Cubs started using their new LED outfield lights to do a little dancing display during 'Go Cubs Go,' lighting along with the song and throwing in a W. It was very fun and I liked it. This...

The 2024 Chicago Cubs for Dummies

Boom. We made it. The offseason is over, and the Cubs regular season - and those elevated expectations - begins tomorrow. But in case you slept through the winter, I'm here to catch you up on everything you need to...

Why Craig Counsell Wanted Miles Mastrobuoni on the Cubs’ Bench

I don't know why Miles Mastrobuoni bugs some folks, but it's probably heavily-weighted toward his small-sample, bad-batted-ball-luck start last year, and that time he didn't dive while playing in right field. It can be hard to shake initial impressions, I...

Kinda Sounds Like Craig Counsell May Have a Set Top Three in the Batting Order

New Chicago Cubs manager Craig Counsell has said, generally, his batting order philosophy is the very simplistic (and very correct): just get your best hitters the most at bats. Sure, there's some play in that to set up good match-ups,...

Los Angeles Dodgers Signing Will Smith to a TEN-YEAR Extension

The Los Angeles Dodgers have done it again. And by it, I mean they have signed a funkily-structured contract that is going to leave some folks annoyed. The Dodgers are extending catcher Will Smith on a DECADE-long deal with a...

The Stretch: 2024 MLB Season Preview

On Monday, during a team-building conversation with some of the Bleacher Nation and Betsperts Media Group folks, we discussed sports—shocking, I know—and Brian Twining asked the group what their favorite sport was. For me, it's baseball. There's no debate. I...

We Have to Talk About Some of the “Deals” the Cubs Sat Out in Free Agency

This week, in a conversation with Jon Greenberg at The Athletic, Cubs President Jed Hoyer made an honest and sober (but also moderately disappointing) admission about the 2024 Chicago Cubs: "We need to perform probably at or a little bit...

The Chicago Cubs Are Reportedly Now Worth Over $5 Billion

Given all the tumult in the baseball broadcasting world, and the uncertain future for that portion of revenues, you'd be forgiven for expecting that MLB franchise valuations would slow their recent surge. But, according to Sportico at least, you'd be...

Reds Second Baseman Matt McLain Had Shoulder Surgery

The injury to Matt McLain's shoulder issue obviously wound up being worse than he and the Cincinnati Reds had been hoping. The damage to his left (non-throwing) labrum ultimately required surgery: https://twitter.com/m_sheldon/status/1772993402604339478 When the hope is that a guy can...

Cubs Actually Getting a Whole Lot of Votes to Win the NL Central

ESPN dropped its big season preview, and included were a set of divisional predictions by way of their writers, editors, and analysts voting. There's nothing in the way of proof or certainty there, but with 26 voters, I do like...

Latest News

Pac-12 Basketball Predictions, Computer Picks and Best Bets | March 28

There is one game featuring a Pac-12 teams on the Thursday postseason college basketball schedule, the Clemson Tigers versus the Arizona Wildcats. Make sure you check out below for today's best bets!How to Bet on Pac-12 Games[lasso rel="draftkings-promo-1" id="299003"]Best Pac-12...

Rays vs. Blue Jays Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Tampa Bay Rays look to start their season with a win as home favorites (-135) in a season-opening matchup with the Toronto Blue Jays. First pitch is on Thursday at 4:10 PM ET on MLB Network, live from Tropicana...

Astros vs. Yankees Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Houston Astros look to start their season with a win as home favorites (-156) in a season-opening matchup with the New York Yankees. First pitch is on Thursday at 4:10 PM ET on YES, live from Minute Maid Park.Houston's...

Tigers vs. White Sox Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Detroit Tigers begin their season as -181 favorites in a road tilt against the Chicago White Sox on Thursday at 4:10 PM ET, live on BSDET.Tarik Skubal starts for Detroit while Garrett Crochet is Chicago's starter for the contest.Tigers...

Reds vs. Nationals Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Cincinnati Reds begin their season as -154 favorites in a home tilt against the Washington Nationals on Thursday at 4:10 PM ET, live on MASN2.Cincinnati's Frankie Montas gets the start, and he'll go against Washington's Josiah Gray.Reds vs. Nationals...

Dodgers vs. Cardinals Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Los Angeles Dodgers (1-1) will look to Will Smith, red hot after a four-hit game, to lead them in a matchup with the St. Louis Cardinals (0-0) on Thursday at 4:10 PM ET on BSMW. The Dodgers are -232...

Marlins vs. Pirates Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Miami Marlins look to start their season with a win as home favorites (-133) in a season-opening matchup with the Pittsburgh Pirates. First pitch is on Thursday at 4:10 PM ET on Sportsnet PT, live from LoanDepot park.Miami's Jesus...

Padres vs. Giants Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The San Francisco Giants (0-0) are the underdogs on the moneyline (-106) in Thursday's contest against the San Diego Padres (1-1). Game time is set for 4:10 PM ET on NBCS-BA. The Giants are favored against the spread in this...

Twins vs. Royals Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Minnesota Twins look to start their season with a win as road favorites (-122) in a season-opening matchup with the Kansas City Royals. First pitch is on Thursday at 4:10 PM ET on BSN, live from Kauffman Stadium.Pablo Lopez...

Orioles vs. Angels Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Baltimore Orioles are moneyline favorites (-192) to begin their season with a home win over the Los Angeles Angels on Thursday at 3:05 PM ET, live on BSW.Baltimore's Corbin Burnes and Los Angeles' Patrick Sandoval have been named the...

more cubs news