Is Mike Trout Already Worthy of the Hall-of-Fame? I Think So

Exactly one week from today – January 18, 2017 – the Baseball Writers Association of America will announce the newest inductees to the Hall of Fame.

Among the 34 eligible players – including Jeff Bagwell, Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Trevor Hoffman, Edgar Martinez, and many others – you will not find, any active Major Leaguers.

Well, Manny Ramirez is eligible for Cooperstown and has just signed a deal with the the Kochi Fighting Dogs out of Japan …

… but that’s not exactly what I meant.

And with all of the attention surrounding the draft, I’ve noticed an unusual question posed more than one time: Is Mike Trout already worthy?

[adinserter block=”1″]

Now, of course, Mike Trout isn’t anywhere close to being Hall of Fame eligible (among many requirements, a player needs to have been an active MLBer for ten years and a non-active one for another five), but that’s not really the question, is it? What we want to find out is something closer to “If he met all of the requirements, but stopped playing right now, would Mike Trout get elected into the Hall of Fame?”

Well, at Angels.com, Richard Justice (who’s apparently not a judge), suggests that Trout already has the clout (because he’s apparently a poet) to be in the Hall of Fame. Let’s take a look at the root of his argument.

“Trout’s 48.5 career Wins Above Replacement is already higher than a handful of Hall of Famers … and with anything resembling his performance thus far in the 2017 season” Trout will launch make it into the top 100 of all time. Okay, that’s a pretty convincing start. With 48.5 WAR, Trout has already passed two prominent Hall of Famers (well, more than just these two, but we’ll start here):

  • Jim Rice (47.4 WAR)
  • Lou Brock (45.2 WAR), and
  • In addition, Trout’s slash line, which adds up to a career .409 wOBA, completely obliterates each of Rice (.375 wOBA) and Brock (.336 wOBA). Of course, WAR isn’t everything and Trout has only played five full seasons, but if his next five seasons are like his last five, Trout will find himself with the 22nd most WAR of all-time … at just 30 years old.

    Plus, Trout already has more MVP wins (3) and Silver Slugger awards (5) than Brock and Rice combined (1 MVP, 2 Silver Sluggers) – and that’s not counting the three second-place finishes for Trout in the MVP race. But that’s not all.

    [adinserter block=”2″]

    In Craig Edwards’ search for active Hall of Famers (FanGraphs), he found that Albert Pujols, Adrian Beltre, Miguel Cabrera, and Ichiro Suzuki all figure to be something just short of “mortal locks” for enshrinement at Cooperstown. From there, another 10 or so active players stand a chance. And then, there’s Mike Trout, as usual, in a category all on his own.

    According to Edwards, Trout “doesn’t need his 30s” to prove that he’s a deserving Hall of Famer. In fact, with just one more good (not even “great,” by Trout’s standards) season, Trout should be a virtual lock for the Hall of Fame.

    After all, as Nicholas Stellini points out, Trout has already left his stamp in the history books:

    Think about that, seriously. Mike Trout has essentially already become one of the best center fielders in the history of the game, and he hasn’t even played his age 25 season yet. That’s not a guy on pace for a trip to Cooperstown; that’s a guy who’s already booked a ticket.

    Eventually, Mike Trout will become an official Hall-of-Famer, but by most standards, he already is.

    written by

    Michael Cerami began covering the Chicago Cubs for Bleacher Nation as a part-time contributor in 2015. One year later, he joined Bleacher Nation full-time, covering the Chicago Cubs and Major League Baseball. Today, Michael runs Bleacher Nation, contributing as a writer (Cubs, MLB) and an editor for all sections of the site, including the Chicago Bears, Bulls, and Blackhawks, as well as MLB, NBA, NHL, and NFL. In 2019, Michael was the co-host of NBC Sports Chicago's Cubs Post-Game Show Outside the Ivy. You can find him on Twitter/X @Michael_Cerami

    more cubs news

    Now We Know Why Ian Happ Was Removed Mid-game

    In the top of the seventh inning of today's 8-3 win over the Miami Marlins, Alexander Canario trotted out to left field in place of Ian Happ. At first, we thought (or maybe just hoped) that Craig Counsell was giving...

    Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 8, Marlins 3 – April 19, 2024

    And just like that the Chicago Cubs are the first team in the NL Central to reach 12 wins! They're not technically in first place yet because the Brewers (11-6) have played fewer games, but we're talking about a matter...

    Nico Hoerner and Dansby Swanson with Back-to-Back Slick Defensive Plays

    With a lefty Marlins starter on the mound this afternoon, Nico Hoerner lead off today's game for the Chicago Cubs. And he did it in style, ripping a leadoff double to the left-center field wall, before coming into score a...

    Pre-Gamin’: Marlins at Cubs – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

    *The Cubs were rained out yesterday, but today? Today, we've got a Friday 1:20 start at Wrigley Field, and that means all is right in the world. Before you take a look at the Cubs lineup against Miami, check out...

    MLBits: The White Sox Might be the Worst Team Ever, What Games I’m Watching this Weekend, More

    Happy Friday! Well, for everyone except for the pilots who were supposed to be manning the Colorado Rockies flight last week but instead allowed a member of the Rockies coaching staff to hop in the pilot's seat for a fun...

    Can I Interest You in a Positive Injury-Update on Justin Steele?

    Justin Steele, arguably the single most irreplaceable player on the Chicago Cubs 2024 roster, went down with a hamstring injury just 4.2 innings into his Opening Day start against the Rangers on March 28. In his place, the Cubs sixth...

    FAA Reportedly Investigating How a Passenger on Colorado Rockies Team Flight Was Seen Accessing the Cockpit

    If you do this job long enough, it's really wild to see the range of topics that can somehow become attached to sports. That is to say, I did not envision myself at some point writing about flight safety, cockpit...

    Cubs Farm Report | April 19, 2024: Kevin Alcántara is Heating Up!

    The Iowa Cubs were rained out, but the rest of the farm was in action, and so was Kevin Alcántara, who picked up four hits and now has seven in his last three games as he breaks out of an...

    It’s Not Kyle Hendricks Last Chance (But…), Ben Brown, Jameson Taillon, and Other Cubs Bullets

    Well, the rain stole one from us yesterday, which is a blessing and a curse. On the bright side, the bullpen gets an extra day of rest (on top of the day Hayden Wesneski bought them). But on the flip...

    The Chicago Cubs Are Not Stealing Bases So Far This Year

    The Chicago Cubs are against theft. Of bases: https://twitter.com/codifybaseball/status/1781046629103231339 The Chicago Cubs this year have stolen just three bases, the fewest in all of baseball. Dansby Swanson has stolen two bases, Nick Madrigal has stolen one. That's it. I don't...

    Latest News

    Reds vs. Angels Probable Starting Pitchers – April 20

    The Cincinnati Reds (10-9) host the Los Angeles Angels (9-11) for a home game at Great American Ball Park on Saturday. First pitch is at 6:40 PM ET.The probable starters are Graham Ashcraft (2-1) for the Reds and Patrick Sandoval...

    Braves vs. Rangers Probable Starting Pitchers – April 20

    After winning their past five games, the Atlanta Braves (13-5) host the Texas Rangers (11-10) at Truist Park on Saturday at 7:20 PM ET.The probable pitchers are Charlie Morton (1-0) for the Braves and Nathan Eovaldi (1-1) for the Rangers.Braves...

    Orioles vs. Royals Probable Starting Pitchers – April 20

    The Kansas City Royals (13-7) and the Baltimore Orioles (12-7) square off at Kauffman Stadium on Saturday at 7:10 PM ET.The probable starters are Corbin Burnes (2-0) for the Orioles and Cole Ragans (0-1) for the Royals.Orioles vs. Royals Pitcher...

    Guardians vs. Athletics Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, April 20, 2024

    The Cleveland Guardians (14-6) are set to take on the Oakland Athletics (8-12) Saturday at 6:10 PM ET, airing on NBCS-CA. The Guardians are listed as -170 favorites by oddsmakers, while the underdog Athletics have +141 odds for the contest.Cleveland's...

    Phillies vs. White Sox Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, April 20, 2024

    Following a two-homer game last time out, Alec Bohm leads the Philadelphia Phillies (12-8) into action as -320 favorites against the Chicago White Sox (3-16). First pitch from Citizens Bank Park at 6:05 PM ET on Saturday, live on NBCS-PH.Zack...

    Phillies vs. White Sox Probable Starting Pitchers – April 20

    The Philadelphia Phillies (12-8) look to add to a four-game winning streak as they host the Chicago White Sox (3-16) at 6:05 PM ET on Saturday.The probable starters are Zack Wheeler (0-3) for the Phillies and Mike Soroka (0-2) for...

    Guardians vs. Athletics Probable Starting Pitchers – April 20

    The Oakland Athletics (8-12) visit the Cleveland Guardians (14-6) for a road game in Cleveland on Saturday. The contest begins at 6:10 PM ET.The probable pitchers are Logan Allen (2-0) for the Guardians and Alex Wood (0-1) for the Athletics.Guardians...

    FanDuel Promo Code for $150 Bonus, NBA Playoff Odds, and More for Saturday

    It's that time of the year again – playoff season in the NBA kicks off TODAY, promising months filled with relentless excitement! New users are in for a treat with an amazing FanDuel promo code offer. By signing up today,...

    Knicks vs. 76ers: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

    In Game 1 of the opening round of the NBA Playoffs, the New York Knicks will go up against the Philadelphia 76ers.In their last time out, the Knicks won on Sunday 120-119 against the Bulls in overtime. The 76ers' last...

    Dodgers vs. Mets Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, April 20, 2024

    The New York Mets (11-8) and Harrison Bader, coming off a four-hit game, are underdogs (+156) on the moneyline and will look to upset the Los Angeles Dodgers (12-10) on Saturday at 4:05 PM ET on WPIX.Los Angeles' Gavin Stone...

    more cubs news