1800's is not baseball. I'm out on that one. But if Cap Anson is EVER the right answer in one of these, that will be the day CB does not guess him. So my only guess is that it is NOT Anson.
Whoa whoa whoa. We can just guess "NOT Anson"? I'm going to guess that it's someone who has never been in my kitchen and less than 400 innings.
I'd say someone that hasn't been in my kitchen but then the answer could be my wife.
I really hope that isn't an euphemism.