It Actually Happened in One Inning: Three Triples, One Double, Two Singles, and ZERO Runs

I tried my absolute hardest (and failed) to crack this baseball riddle before clicking on the source material to find the answer, but I hope you’ll try all the same: How do you think it’s possible for one team to hit THREE triples, ONE double, and TWO singles in one inning without scoring a single run? Because believe it or not, it happened for real in 1890, when Joshua Mercer Goar was pitching in the Indiana State League against the Anderson Tigers.

It’s not necessarily a trick question, mind you, but it certainly helps to be familiar with a few quirks about the sport/rules/game-scoring. Note, the answer has nothing to do with “unearned” runs or anything like that. So what was the order of events? How did it go down? Do you have a guess?

I’ll give you some time (and space) to think it through.







The Answer (via

The first batter, Benjamin Ireland, hit a triple. Next up was Ed Wiswell. There was a wild pitch, Ireland tried to score and was tagged out at home.

1 triple. 1 out.

Wiswell then hit a triple and was tagged out trying to stretch it into an inside-the-park homer.

2 triples. 2 outs.

A third batter and a third triple. This time it was Rush Shumway (I swear these names are real).

3 triples.

Next up, Gene Derby. Derby laid a bunt down the third-base line and the third baseman followed it, hoping it would roll foul. It didn’t. Derby got to second for the always exciting bunt double and Shumway remained at third on the play.

1 double.

Next, another bunt. This time just a single. Gene Fatz beat it out to first and neither runner advanced.

1 single.

And then, with the bases loaded, Frank Fear hit a “vicious” liner — as only someone named Frank Fear could — to right. It hit Fatz in the arm while he was off the bag. Fatz was out, but, according to MLB Rule 5.05, Fear is still awarded a single.

1 single, 3 outs, inning over.


You can head over to for a little more detail on Goar and the baseball environment at the time. What an incredible story.

Read More

written by

Michael Cerami covers the Chicago Cubs, Bears, and Bulls at Bleacher Nation. You can find him on Twitter @Michael_Cerami

more baseballisfun news

Pablo Sandoval Just Hit a Six-Run Home Run, and I Mean That Literally

You know how you joke about a batter trying to hit a six-run home run when he swings out of his shoes? Or how you joke, macabrely, that all your team needs is a six-run homer when they're down to...

Ichiro Suzuki Continues His Delightful Tour of Terror by Shutting Out a High School Girls Team and Notching a Couple Hits

I hope Ichiro Suzuki keeps doing baseball things until he's 100. Because it's always great. Earlier this month, Ichiro broke a window while taking batting practice at a high school, and he has continued his tour of TERRORIZING high schoolers...

Ichiro Suzuki, Now 50, Broke a High School Window Taking Batting Practice

I love everything Ichiro Suzuki does. I could watch his throwing videos for hours, and the things he's done past age 40 are all the more impressive. Ichiro is now 50, but he's still swinging the bat. And since he...

Hands Down, the Best Baseball Halloween Prank I’ve Ever Seen

I probably shouldn't even title this thing the best "baseball" Halloween prank, because this is just one of the best Halloween-type pranks I've ever seen. Just good old fashioned terrifying fun. Missouri State baseball pulled off an all-timer. Just watch...

So You Want To Bet It All On the Cubs, Eh? …

I was browsing the depths of the Bleacher Nation media folder when stumbled on this old and terrible, but also excellent and awesome, photoshop of Kyle Hendricks on Babe Ruth's body. I have absolutely no idea why I made it,...

Arizona State Baseball Played a Scrimmage in Full Halloween Costumes

When you think of the fall and baseball in Arizona, you probably think of instructional ball for prospects at their various camps, and of course the Arizona Fall League. And, in years like this one where the Diamondbacks are in...

The Best Way to End the Little League World Series? With a Walk-Off Home Run!

Today, the team from El Segundo, California, representing the United States in the Little League World Series, beat the team from Curaçao 6-5 to win the championship. That'd be cool enough, but HOW they won it makes it all the...

Luke Raley Just Hit One of the Weirdest Inside-the-Park Home Runs You’ll See

Pretty much every inside-the-park home run that happens at the big league level is necessarily going to involve some wonkiness. Sometimes, it's a "little league" home run, with the defense throwing the ball around. Sometimes it's just a guy with...


Sometimes a headline says the whole thing. There is no real reason for this play to exist, other than the fact that it is awesome. And that's kinda what the Savannah Bananas are all about. Just enjoy this unreal feat...

This Has Got to Be One of the Best Little League Catches I’ve Ever Seen

Listen, I'm no expert on Little League Baseball, so I can't say I've got every amazing play loaded up there in my brain. But I have seen my fair-share of highlights over the years, and it's hard to recall a...

Latest News

Steelers vs. Patriots Injury Report, Inactives – Week 14

The Pittsburgh Steelers (7-5) have five players on their injury report as they prep to meet the New England Patriots (2-10) on Thursday, December 7 at Acrisure Stadium, with the opening kickoff slated for 8:15 PM ET. As for the...

Jed Hoyer Speaks: Where Things Stand, Winning the Offseason, a Window of Moments, and More

At the close of the Winter Meetings, Chicago Cubs President Jed Hoyer spoke about the things that did and did not happen this week, and how the Cubs proceed with their offseason - and longer-term future - from here. I...

Robbie’s Goodbye, 2024 Pro Bowl Vote, Sweat’s Stock is Up, and Other Bears Bullets

My apologies if this week's Bears Bullets are coming out a little later than you'd like. Getting back into the swing of things after the Bears bye hasn't been easy. Much like the players, yours truly can use a little...

The Zach LaVine News, Three Wins in a Row, Playing Team Basketball, and Other Bulls Bullets

Despite not suiting up on Wednesday night, Zach LaVine stole the show. The Chicago Bulls announced that the two-time All-Star will stay in street clothes for an extra 3-4 weeks due to his right foot injury. We gave our instant...

Robbie Gould Announces His Retirement

Robbie Gould, long held as the gold-standard of Chicago Bears kickers, announced his retirement from the NFL in social media posts via Instagram and The Players' Tribune. Gould dives deep in his retirement post at The Players' Tribune. And,...

NFL Notes: Former Jaguars Employee Accused of Stealing More than $22 Million, Robbie Gould Retires, More

According to a report by The Athletic's Katie Strang and Kalyn Kahler, a former Jacksonville Jaguars employee is accused of stealing more than $22 million from the franchise from 2019 to 2023 by exploiting the team's virtual credit card program....

NBA In-Season Tournament Update, Luka’s Big Night, LaVine Out 3-4 Weeks, More

It's time for the NBA-In Season Tournament semifinals! The Lakers, Pelicans, Pacers, and Bucks are in Las Vegas for the In-Season Tournament semifinals tonight. The winners will then move on to the finals on Saturday night. In addition to the...

Panthers’ Hayden Hurst Dealing With Post Traumatic Amnesia

It was almost a month ago that Carolina Panthers' tight end Hayden Hurts entered the league's concussion protocol. Hurst took a big hit against the Chicago Bears on Thursday Night Football in Week 10, and he has been sidelined since....

DeVante Parker Player Props Week 14: Anytime TD Props and Odds vs. the Steelers

[lasso ref="draftkings-promo-1" id="299003" link_id="897543"]With the New England Patriots squaring off against the Pittsburgh Steelers in Week 14 (Thursday at 8:15 PM ET), is DeVante Parker a good bet to score a touchdown? Below, we break down the odds and numbers...

Brook Lopez Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Pacers – Thursday, December 7, 2023

Will Brook Lopez make two 3-pointers when the Milwaukee Bucks play the Indiana Pacers on Thursday at 5:00 PM ET? If so, he'll beat his prop for the game.Brook Lopez's Three-Pointer Prop Odds vs. the PacersBrook Lopez's over/under for three-pointers...

more baseballisfun news