Now, this is one spicy take from Chicago Bears legend Dan Hampton:
"If my team had Jay Cutler at QB we would have won 4 Super Bowls" – @ChicagoBears Dan Hampton on the '85 team pic.twitter.com/dA94We8CL6
— Pro Football HOF (@ProFootballHOF) July 8, 2017
Armed with an all-time great defense, an elite running back, and Hall of Fame players scattered throughout the roster, the Chicago Bears had a chance to be the team of the 1980s. The Super Bowl winning 1985 Chicago Bears make one of the most compelling arguments for being the greatest single-season team in NFL history, but the team’s inability to parlay all that was going well into multiple championships still lingers. Perhaps some stability at quarterback would have helped?
Here is the list of the 12 quarterbacks who started games for the Bears during Hampton’s career, which spanned from 1979-1990:
And if we narrow our search to focus on the post-Super Bowl XX stretch of Hampton’s career, the Bears started seven different quarterbacks, with Tomczak’s 31 starts leading the way. If we tighten our focus even more, more games were started by McMahon’s backups (26) than McMahon himself (21).
No wonder Hampton said: “If my team had Jay Cutler at QB we would have won four Super Bowls.”
First, it’s nice to hear someone put some respect on Cutler’s name. After all, he is atop the charts of many franchise passing categories. But also, maybe Hampton is onto something here, even if we’ll never be able to prove it. From 1986-89, McMahon made only 21 starts in 47 possible games in what were his age 27-29 seasons. And during his career with the Bears, McMahon never played more than 14 games. During Cutler’s age 27-29 seasons, he played in missed only eight games by comparison and played in at least 15 games five times in eight seasons. McMahon owned an 80.4 quarterback rating, a 4.4 TD% and 3.7 INT% during his Bears career, while Cutler posted an 85.2 rating, 4.7 TD% and 3.1 INT%.
It’s fair to point out that McMahon and Cutler were statistically similar players. Because of that, it would be hard to sway me to go against Hampton. Simply put, a healthy McMahon (or in Hampton’s eyes, a suitable replacement such as Cutler) would have likely led the Bears to championship glory at least one more time.
Whether it has been because of injury or poor performance, instability at quarterback has long plagued the Bears – even during its greatest era.
You’re up next, Mitch Trubisky – but after Mike Glennon has “his year” first.
Jordan Howard did it all as a rookie pic.twitter.com/abu0S1c6zw
— Pro Football Focus (@PFF) July 8, 2017