The MMQB’s 2018 Re-Draft Sends Roquan Smith to the Worst Possible Destination

Re-drafts are fun, in theory. Because there is nothing like going back in time and righting the wrongs of what happened before by getting the right player with the right pick. But there are times when things go right in the draft, such as in 2018 when the Chicago Bears selected Roquan Smith with the No. 8 pick in the 2018 NFL Draft.

Conor Orr of SI.com’s The MMQB doesn’t dislike what he saw from Smith during his rookie season, but believes the Bears would have been better off going in a different direction if a re-draft was to occur. Orr shared his re-draft, which has the Bears taking Notre Dame guard Quenton Nelson with the eighth pick despite Smith being on the board and available to be picked. Huh? Orr’s explanation: “The Bears are doing backflips in their facility with this pick. The most pro-ready offensive lineman in five years tumbles to them, giving them a decade of Pro Bowls to pair with Kyle Long.”

Snagging Nelson as a first-rounder would have had its perks, to be sure. He earned a Pro Bowl selection, first-team All-Pro honors, and was Pro Football Focus’ third highest-graded guard. Adding Nelson to the core on the line of scrimmage with Charles Leno Jr., Cody Whitehair, Kyle Long, and Bobby Massie would have made a good bunch even better.

Nelson falling to the Bears in this re-draft means Smith tumbles down the draft board. Indeed, Smith drops all the way down to pick No. 14 which is owned by – UGH! – the Packers.

“Again, this isn’t a reflection of Smith having a bad rookie season – he was great,” Orr writes about Smith going to Green Bay. “While it’s not precisely the haunting edge defender Mike Pettine’s defense needed, Smith can play in any system and cover almost anyone. He’s valuable almost anywhere.”

YUCK! The Bears passing on a guy who can “play in any system” and “cover almost anyone” is one thing, but watching him fall to the Packers is one step too far. Simply thinking about Smith suiting up in the relish and mustard colored jerseys makes me feel gross inside.

The wildest thing in Orr’s re-draft might not be who the Bears picked or how Smith landed in Green Bay, but instead, the have history-altering implications with changing picks can be mind-blowing if you think about them for an extended period of time. Especially with the Bears passing on drafting a player who would have filled their biggest need in pass-rusher Bradley Chubb, who goes to the Raiders with pick No. 10. And suddenly, the Raiders edge defense looks a lot stronger with Chubb opposite of Khalil Mack and — you know what, we’ll stop there. No need to think about the Bears living in a world where Mack isn’t in Chicago.

In the end, we’re cool with how things went when the draft happened in real-time. After all, it was a highly-acclaimed effort by GM Ryan Pace and his crew. The Bears ending up with Smith (a studly inside linebacker with a ton of upside) and a quality interior offensive lineman (James Daniels) who was showered with love from PFF (and elsewhere) for his rookie year performance turned out to be good for the short term and could very well be great for the team over the long haul. So, back off and keep your re-drafts outta my sight.

written by

Luis C. Medina, who you can find on Twitter at lcm1986, has been covering the Chicago Bears at Bleacher Nation since 2017. Since then, he has written about 3 head coaches, 5 play-callers, and 11 starting quarterbacks. Previously, Luis wrote about the Cubs and MLB at BN (2015-16) and worked in the Chicago Tribune sports department (2011-16). He also co-hosted a Cubs postgame show, Outside the Ivy, in 2019.

more bears news

Checkdowns, Hard Knocks, Fields, QB1’s Other Tasks, and Other Bears Bullets

I'm back. Did you miss me? The following is an abbreviated version of Bears Bullets as I get back into the swing of things. DaWindyCity Production does tremendous work. And it doesn't get much better than a mock Hard Knocks...

Interesting Bears Predictions, Context on OTAs, Trust Your Gut, and Other Bears Bullets

We're probably a little early on schedule predictions like the one that Windy City Gridiron's Bill Zimmerman put together. Still, I appreciate his efforts and found the write-up entertaining nonetheless. Bill broke down every regular-season game and two playoff games...

The Bears Won’t Have Much of an Advantage (or Disadvantage) When it Comes to Travel This Season

The Bears schedule has been released for about a week now, and I've had this one in the bookmark folder on Twitter since then, and I've got a few minutes to get into it now. Bill Speros has calculated the...

Inside the Bears War Room on Draft Night, D.J. on Caleb, Byard on the Culture, and Other Bears Bullets

I'll admit, I expected the outrage over Caleb Williams's and the Bears' offense's tough day to be much less than I thought it would be. It's nice that people can understand the difference between a rookie in shorts and a...

VIDEO: Dan Orlovsky Explains the Challenges That Await Rookie QBs (Like Bears Caleb Williams)

Dan Orlovsky is best known by most football fans as the guy who scrambled out the back of the end zone and took a safety. Others might know Dan from his quirky taste in foods. To each their own in...

Around the NFL: Dak’s Not About the Dollar, Rookie Sleepers, Leaner Lamar, More

NFL Notes — Despite not having a contract extension in place (or even in sight), Dak Prescott doesn't plan on skipping any Cowboys offseason activities. Dak Prescott on Extension Talks: "I don't play for money" Despite entering the final year...

Bears OTAs: Tough Day for Caleb Williams and the Offense

Are you ready for the premature panic on social media because Caleb Williams and the Chicago Bears offense had a tough day in shorts and tee shirts on May 23? Prepare yourself because it happened. The word out of Lake...

WATCH: An Inside Look at the Minnesota Vikings 2024 Draft War Room

While the Chicago Bears don't tend to participate much in these video drops, other teams — including the Minnesota Vikings do not shy away. In fact, this inside look at the team's first-round trade-ups is unlike anything I've seen before. Check...

Caleb Williams and Co. Head to the Southside, Claypool on His Time with Chicago, and Other Bears Bullets

Not many things would make me want to attend a White Sox game again this season, but this Caleb Williams-inspired promo could be one of them. The White Sox are offering $18 outfield tickets for their game against the Baltimore...

I Love This Rome Odunze Quote About Learning

The folks over at Bears Wire got an opportunity to go one-on-one with rookie wide receiver Rome Odunze. In a wide-ranging conversation that touched on everything from his draft-night experience, early impressions on Caleb Williams, and the "Call of Duty:...

Latest News

Celtics vs. Pacers: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Boston Celtics and Indiana Pacers are meeting in the Eastern Conference Finals, with a decisive Game 4 next to come.The Celtics will seek another victory over the Pacers after a 114-111 win on Saturday. Jayson Tatum led the Celtics...

Padres vs. Marlins Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, May 27, 2024

The San Diego Padres (28-28) are set to take on the Miami Marlins (19-35) Monday at 6:40 PM ET, airing on SDPA. The Padres are listed as -183 favorites by sportsbooks, while the underdog Marlins have +154 odds for the...

Bedard’s Worlds Experience, Czechia Celebrates, Dallas’ Build, and Other Blackhawks Memorial Day Bullets

It's Memorial Day, a time when we are supposed to take a step back amidst the barbeque invites and driving to/from lakes and boats to be thankful for those who have paid the ultimate price to preserve our freedom. As...

Padres vs. Marlins Probable Starting Pitchers – May 27

The San Diego Padres (28-28) host the Miami Marlins (19-35) on Monday to kick off a three-game series at PETCO Park. The matchup begins at 6:40 PM ET.The Padres will call on Michael King (4-4) versus the Marlins and Trevor...

What If We Try Winning Some Games? Cubs vs Brewers Series Preview

Cubs vs Brewers — On April 26, the Chicago Cubs were eight games over .500 and mostly cruising *despite* multiple significant absences/injuries to key players on the roster. One month later, they're mostly healed up, but are now just one...

Giants vs. Phillies Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, May 27, 2024

The San Francisco Giants (27-27) and Philadelphia Phillies (38-16) meet Monday at Oracle Park, with first pitch at 5:05 PM ET on NBCS-PH. The Giants are -111 moneyline favorites for the contest, however, the Phillies are favored against the spread...

Today’s Best NBA Player Prop Bets – Monday, May 27, 2024

In a Monday NBA playoff slate that features just one contest, the Boston Celtics versus the Indiana Pacers is the only way to catch the NBA today.There are usually plenty of NBA player prop bets available for each and every...

Dodgers vs. Mets Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, May 27, 2024

The Los Angeles Dodgers (33-22) stumble into Monday's matchup with the New York Mets (22-30) looking to break a five-game losing streak. The contest starts at 4:10 PM ET on MLB Network with the Dodgers listed as -151 favorites to...

Reds vs. Cardinals Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, May 27, 2024

The St. Louis Cardinals (25-26) will lean on Paul Goldschmidt, following a two-homer game, to lead them in a matchup with the Cincinnati Reds (23-30) on Monday at 4:10 PM ET on BSOH. The Cardinals are +115 underdogs for the...

Guardians vs. Rockies Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, May 27, 2024

The Cleveland Guardians (36-17) will vie for their 10th straight victory when they visit the Colorado Rockies (18-34) on Monday at 4:10 PM ET on COLR. The Guardians are listed as -132 favorites by sportsbooks, while the Rockies are +113...

more bears news