To Start or Not to Start? And When to Start? And Why to Start? And, Yes, This Conversation Is Killing Me, But It’s Still Important

Everyone is trying to figure out when Bears rookie QB Justin Fields will make his first start. Naturally, the guesses are all over the map.

•   Kevin Fishbain, Adam Jahns, Dan Pompei, and Jon Greenberg all have their predictions in The Athletic’s latest NFL roundtable.
•   Alyssa Barbieri examines which weeks Fields could take over the starting role at Bears Wire .
•   Adam Hoge takes an educated guess at NBC Sports Chicago .
•   And we found ourselves exploring the most sensible options for starting Fields, ourselves.

Oh, and then there’s this:

 

Ultimately, it might make the most sense for Fields to start the season as QB2 — and finish that way. I know, I know.

But at The Athletic, Ted Nguyen (The Athletic) uses All-22 images and situational breakdowns to explain why sitting Fields might be best for the QB’s long-term development and he makes some solid points. I encourage you to check it out and remember that Nguyen isn’t being a contrarian take for the sake of it. There are arguments that make sense in either direction, and ideally, this all plays out in a way that allows Fields to cash in on his obvious upside.

But either way, the only person who truly knows what’s next is Matt Nagy. And this seems to be one of those things where you’ll know it’s time when you see it based on how it plays out when Andy Dalton plays games:

So, in other words, your guess is as good as anyone’s. But I feel as if this is one of those situations you’ll know when it’s time based on what you see on the Field. It’s less of a matter of if and more of a “when” thing. So stay tuned.

Michael Cerami contributed to this post. 

written by

Luis C. Medina, who you can find on Twitter at lcm1986, has been covering the Chicago Bears at Bleacher Nation since 2017. Since then, he has written about 3 head coaches, 5 play-callers, and 11 starting quarterbacks. Previously, Luis wrote about the Cubs and MLB at BN (2015-16) and worked in the Chicago Tribune sports department (2011-16). He also co-hosted a Cubs postgame show, Outside the Ivy, in 2019.

more bears news

Texans 19, Bears 13: Caleb Williams Takes a Beating

We waited all day for Sunday night. Unfortunately, the Chicago Bears did not make it worth the wait as the Houston Texans came away with a victory defending their home turf. FINAL: Houston Texans 19, Chicago Bears 13 (ESPN Box...

Instant Bears Player Grades: Houston, We Have a Problem

Lots of work to do for the Chicago Bears. Let's hand out some instant grades. Offense QB Caleb Williams | C+ I'm not even mad about Williams' interceptions. What was he supposed to do? He has zero help. The line...

Azeez Al-Shaair Punched Roschon Johnson (But Didn’t Get Booted)

Things are getting chippy in the Bears-Texans game on Sunday Night Football. Bears quarterback Caleb Williams took a late-ish hit on a play in the middle of the third quarter. Usually, things calm down after that ... but didn't this...

WATCH: Khalil Herbert Scores the Bears’ First Offensive TD of 2024

Khalil Herbert is a trivia answer that will stump your friends in the future. The question will be "who scored the first offensive touchdown of the Caleb Williams era?" And just in case someone calls you out on it, the...

WATCH: The Bears Scored on a Lucky Doink

A post with “doink” in the title should come with a trigger warning for Chicago Bears fans. But what if I told you this doink was a good thing? Well, it was — no, seriously. This is how the Bears...

Week 2 on Sunday Night Football: Bears vs Texans — Lineups, Inactives, How to Watch, More

The Chicago Bears didn't have to wait too long to get under the primetime lights in 2024. Here we are in Week 2 and Chicago's football team gets the Sunday Night Football treatment. Sure, they had to go on the...

It’s Official: Rome Odunze is IN For Week 2 and Sunday Night Football

The Chicago Bears will be without one of their top receiver options for Week 2. Sunday Night Football's list of inactive players is OUT — and so is Keenan Allen. The veteran wide receiver is sitting tonight's Sunday Night Football matchup...

Keenan Allen’s Status is “More on the Doubtful Side” of Things

My morning started on a positive note with word on Rome Odunze's status leaning toward an increasing possibility that the Chicago Bears rookie wide receiver would give it a go on Sunday Night Football against the Houston Texans. Unfortunately, that...

Happy Sunday! Belief in Caleb, TV Maps, Waldron’s Challenge, Getsy Learning? A New Urlacher, and Other Bears Bullets

I have a love-hate relationship with the Chicago Bears playing on Sunday Night Football. On the one hand, playing in prime time means I can spend my Sunday afternoon however I please. But on the other hand, waiting all day...

Whoa! It Sounds Like Rome Odunze Will Play Tonight

What a difference a few days can make. Bears fans began Week 2 worried about the playing status of Rome Odunze. The rookie wide receiver's availability for the team's Sunday Night Football game against the Houston Texans was up in...

Latest News

Lazio vs. Hellas Verona Prediction, Picks, Live Odds – September 16

Coming off a draw with AC Milan, Lazio will face Hellas Verona, who just defeated Genoa CFC, on Monday. For our prediction on this matchup, continue reading.Lazio vs. Hellas Verona Prediction & OddsLazio Moneyline: -169Hellas Verona Moneyline: +465Draw Moneyline: +285Predicted...

Rayo Vallecano vs. CA Osasuna Prediction, Picks, Live Odds – September 16

Rayo Vallecano (15th) is below CA Osasuna (10th) in the table, and they square off in LaLiga on Monday. For our prediction on this matchup, continue reading.Rayo Vallecano vs. CA Osasuna Prediction & OddsRayo Vallecano Moneyline: +113CA Osasuna Moneyline: +291Draw...

Steelers vs. Chargers Week 3 Odds, Bets, Over/Under & Lines

The Pittsburgh Steelers (2-0) are listed as small favorites (-2.5) against the Los Angeles Chargers (2-0) on Sunday, September 22, 2024.Steelers vs. Chargers Game InfoWhen: Sunday, September 22, 2024 at 1:00 p.m. ETWhere: Acrisure Stadium in Pittsburgh, PennsylvaniaTV Info: CBSSteelers...

Buccaneers vs. Broncos Week 3 Odds, Bets, Over/Under & Lines

The Denver Broncos (0-2) will work to prove oddsmakers wrong when they square off against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers (2-0) on Sunday, September 22, 2024 as a 7-point underdog.Buccaneers vs. Broncos Game InfoWhen: Sunday, September 22, 2024 at 1:00 p.m....

Bengals vs. Commanders Week 3 Odds, Bets, Over/Under & Lines

According to oddsmakers, the Washington Commanders (1-1) are 7.5-point underdogs heading into their matchup on Monday, September 23, 2024 against the Cincinnati Bengals (0-2).Bengals vs. Commanders Game InfoWhen: Monday, September 23, 2024 at 8:15 p.m. ETWhere: Paycor Stadium in Cincinnati,...

Hana Bank Korea Open Schedule Tuesday, September 17: Matchups & TV/Live Stream Info

There are two matches at the Hana Bank Korea Open on September 17, highlighted by No. 44-ranked Veronika Kudermetova versus No. 15 Liudmila Samsonova. The Tennis Channel provides live coverage and highlights of all the major moments across tournaments during...

Kudermetova vs. Hon Prediction at the Hana Bank Korea Open – Monday, September 16

In the Round of 32 at the Hana Bank Korea Open on Monday, Polina Kudermetova (ranked No. 163) takes on Priscilla Hon (No. 197).Compared to the underdog Kudermetova (+180), Hon is favored (-250) to advance.Hana Bank Korea Open InfoTournament: The...

49ers vs. Rams Week 3 Odds, Bets, Over/Under & Lines

The San Francisco 49ers (1-1) visit the Los Angeles Rams (0-2) on Sunday, September 22, 2024 in matchup between NFC West opponents at SoFi Stadium. The Rams are listed as touchdown underdogs.49ers vs. Rams Game InfoWhen: Sunday, September 22, 2024...

Lions vs. Cardinals Week 3 Odds, Bets, Over/Under & Lines

The Detroit Lions (1-1) are considered 3-point favorites heading into their matchup on Sunday, September 22, 2024 versus the Arizona Cardinals (1-1).Lions vs. Cardinals Game InfoWhen: Sunday, September 22, 2024 at 4:25 p.m. ETWhere: State Farm Stadium in Glendale, ArizonaTV...

Parma vs. Udinese Prediction, Picks, Live Odds – September 16

Coming off a loss to SSC Napoli, Parma will play against Udinese, who just beat Como 1907, on Monday. For our prediction on this matchup, continue reading.Parma vs. Udinese Prediction & OddsParma Moneyline: +134Udinese Moneyline: +201Draw Moneyline: +230Predicted Score: Udinese...

more bears news