Could the Blackhawks Help Solve Toronto’s Blue Line Problem?

On Tuesday morning, the Toronto Maple Leafs announced another potentially catastrophic injury to their defensive group.

Reilly joins Jake Muzzin on LTIR, and Toronto also has TJ Brodie on IR. Right now, their highest paid, healthy defenseman is Justin Holl, who was drafted by the Blackhawks in 2010. His cap hit is $2 million this season.

This is a huge problem for a Leafs team that is supposed to win right now. This is supposed to be their championship window, and they’re playing well enough to be in second place in their division behind the ridiculous Boston Bruins. But that could change with Reilly missing the reported 4-6 weeks. Their defensive group wasn’t that strong to begin with, and now they’re missing their two best (and most expensive) defensemen.

Which begs the question: could the Blackhawks help them fix their blue line situation?

I wrote last week that the Blackhawks have a logjam on the blue line in both Chicago and Rockford, and yesterday’s call-up in Rockford adds more intrigue to the roster(s) in the NHL and AHL. The Blackhawks have seven healthy defensemen (not including Seth Jones) and the IceHogs now have eight defensemen on their roster.

But there are two significant issues we need to consider.

First, the Leafs have zero cap space. They’re already dipping into LTIR money for more than $5 million, trying desperately to stay in the playoff picture long enough for some of their injured players to get healthy. Their roster is also incredibly top-heavy financially, with three players — Auston Matthews, John Tavares and Mitchell Marner — hitting the cap for more than $10 million this year.

So if the Blackhawks were to make a deal with Toronto, they would likely need to bring back a contract and retain salary if one of Jake McCabe or Connor Murphy was the player involved. Toronto would need to determine which player (likely a forward because their defense doesn’t exist) would need to leave and how that would impact their chemistry moving forward, and then still need to make the money work.

The Leafs would also need to be willing to accept the term left on either of those contracts if they were involved. McCabe has two more years at $4 million after this, while Murphy has three more at $4.4 million.

Chicago’s front office would probably need to eat salary on either of those deals to make it work financially for Toronto, which is another headache. NHL teams can only retain salary on three deals per season, and if/when the Blackhawks ever get to the point that one/both of Patrick Kane and Jonathan Toews are on the market, the likelihood is that Chicago will need to eat salary on both of those players as well.

More than that, Kyle Davidson would need to be willing to have dead money on the books for the remainder of the term on either deal if he retained on them, which complicates the deal further from Chicago’s perspective. Kane and Toews are UFAs after this season.

Which brings us back to the right defenseman for Chicago to consider moving if they were to engage Toronto in negotiations. It might not be McCabe or Murphy, though they are better fits for what Toronto is trying to accomplish. Caleb Jones isn’t playing well right now, so it doesn’t seem likely the Leafs would want to add him to a blue line that is garnering its share of complaints (especially Holl, if you’re on Twitter during Leafs games).

Would Toronto have interest in Jack Johnson? And would he be open to a move to a contender on a one-year deal? His cap his is much more attractive ($950,000) and he’s been playing heavy enough minutes (20:11 per night) in Chicago that he could prove a valuable option with limited financial exposure to the Leafs. And he wouldn’t cost the Leafs much in a trade, though the returning asset would impact that issue.

And that’s the second significant question that needs to be answered if Chicago engaged Toronto in a trade discussion. The Leafs don’t have a second- or fourth-round pick in the 2023 draft. They do have their own and Ottawa’s pick in the third round this year, however.

Would those picks be enough for Davidson to bring back salary in a deal? And how would the player coming back work on the Blackhawks’ current roster? Davidson has said all along that he’s willing to bring in a contract so long as it doesn’t hurt the Blackhawks’ system; the player needs to fit what Luke Richardson is doing. And, remember, the Blackhawks also have too many forwards on their NHL roster at the moment as well.

Add to all of that the returns of Tyler Johnson (soon, hopefully) and Seth Jones at some point, and the Blackhawks have enough bodies that they could stand to move one or two out… but at least one would likely be coming back in a trade with the Leafs.

So the question becomes: would a package of Jack Johnson and an inexpensive forward (Boris Katchouk?) for a player like Pierre Engvall ($2.25M cap hit, UFA in 2023) and a couple third-round picks in the 2023 draft make sense for the two sides?

If that makes sense, I’m sure we’ll find out soon.

written by

Tab Bamford has been writing about the Chicago Blackhawks for almost two decades. He joined Bleacher Nation as the lead Blackhawks writer in May 2022. Tab is a member of the Professional Hockey Writers Association and is the author of two books about the Blackhawks: "100 Things Blackhawks Fans Should Know & Do Before They Die" (Triumph Books) and "Chicago Blackhawks: An Illustrated Timeline" (Reedy Press, 2021). Find him on Twitter/X/Instagram/Threads at @The1Tab

more blackhawks news

Kane Comeback Thoughts, Toews, Korchinski, B1G Freshmen, Cheli’s Custom Converse, and Other Blackhawks Bullets

How about a slow week for the Blackhawks for once in what feels like forever? After playing nine games in 18 days since the all-star break, eight of which have been at the United Center, the Hawks are off until...

I’m Still Trying to Get Over Patrick Kane’s Emotional Return

Before yesterday's marathon began, I wrote about how emotional I expected the day to be with the Blackhawks retiring Chris Chelios' jersey and then Patrick Kane returning to the United Center. The confluence of those events felt like putting a...

A Wild Night in Chicago, Chelios, Seabrook, Stars Scouting Again, and Other Blackhawks Bullets

Yesterday was a lot, folks. Just a lot. I knew going in that the day was going to be an emotional rollercoaster for Blackhawks fans of my age, and the day did not come up short. Wow! From chatting with...

Blackhawks 2, Red Wings 3 (OT) — Three Stars, Key Takeaways

After a fantastic ceremony celebrating Chris Chelios' career... oh crap! We've gotta play a game still. The star of the first period was Patrick Kane, but not necessarily for anything he did on the ice on Sunday. He got three...

WATCH: Blackhawks Celebrate Patrick Kane With Tribute Video, Fans Give Him Three-Minute Standing Ovation

Yes, the Blackhawks retired No. 7 for Chris Chelios before the game on Sunday. But a big part of the fan base was waiting for the organization to welcome home Patrick Kane for the first time. During the first television...

BN Blackhawks Prospect Watch: College Three Stars (Feb. 26)

For the first time in a while, this week's three stars among the Blackhawks' college prospects was a struggle to pick -- in a bad way. Minnesota didn't play and there weren't any big-time, stand-out performances. In fact, only two...

Blackhawks vs Red Wings – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

Y'all already know. Today's one of the big days. Drink water, bring tissues, get ready to cheer and cry and let Detroit know that they still suck and all the goods. Blackhawks vs. Red Wings hasn't meant this much since,...

Blackhawks Celebrate Chris Chelios: Sights and Sounds From Before the Ceremony

Blackhawks fans absolutely got the memo that the Chris Chelios jersey retirement ceremony was starting early on Sunday. From a BLACK Blackhawks jersey on the Jordan Statue in the atrium to Connor Bedard arriving in a BLACK Blackhawks jersey... the...

Patrick Kane, Chris Chelios, Detroit Sucks, and Other Blackhawks Bullets

Sunday, Feb. 25, 2024 will stack up as one of the most memorable days for Blackhawks fans since Gary Bettman handed the Stanley Cup to Jonathan Toews at center ice at the United Center in 2015. Between the ceremonies celebrating...

Why Tonight’s Blackhawks Game Means So Much To Me

I had a conversation this week that made something overwhelmingly clear: Tonight's Blackhawks game is going to be an emotional rollercoaster for me, bringing my life as a fan full circle. I was born in 1980, the year the Blackhawks...

Latest News

Top 25 College Basketball Picks and Best Bets: February 28

The Wednesday college basketball slate includes 10 games featuring a ranked team on the court. Among those games is the Auburn Tigers taking on the Tennessee Volunteers.How to Bet on Top 25 Games[lasso ref="draftkings-promo-1" id="299003" link_id="1433766"]Top 25 Games for February...

Cavaliers vs. Bulls Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets – Wednesday, February 28, 2024

Central Division foes meet when the Cleveland Cavaliers (38-19) visit the Chicago Bulls (27-31) at United Center, beginning at 8:00 PM ET on Wednesday, February 28, 2024. The Bulls are 4.5-point underdogs in the game, the fourth matchup between the...

Timberwolves vs. Grizzlies Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets – Wednesday, February 28, 2024

The Memphis Grizzlies (20-38) visit the Minnesota Timberwolves (41-17) after losing four road games in a row. The Timberwolves are heavy favorites by 12.5 points in the contest, which begins at 8:00 PM ET on Wednesday, February 28, 2024. The...

Mavericks vs. Raptors Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets – Wednesday, February 28, 2024

The Toronto Raptors (22-36) will attempt to build on a three-game win streak when they host the Dallas Mavericks (33-25) on Wednesday, February 28, 2024 at Scotiabank Arena as only 3-point underdogs. The matchup airs at 7:30 PM ET on...

Pacers vs. Pelicans Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets – Wednesday, February 28, 2024

The New Orleans Pelicans (35-24) visit the Indiana Pacers (33-26) after winning three road games in a row. The Pacers are favored by 5.5 points in the contest, which begins at 7:30 PM ET on Wednesday, February 28, 2024. The...

Western Illinois vs. Eastern Illinois: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Eastern Illinois Panthers (14-16, 8-9 OVC) aim to end a three-game road losing streak when they visit the Western Illinois Leathernecks (18-11, 11-5 OVC) on February 29, 2024.In its most recent game, Western Illinois beat Southern Indiana on Saturday,...

Georgia Tech vs. Florida State: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets (12-16, 5-12 ACC) host the Florida State Seminoles (15-13, 9-8 ACC) in ACC play at McCamish Pavilion, tipping off at 12:00 PM ET on Saturday, March 2, 2024.On Saturday, in its most recent game, Georgia...

Eastern Michigan vs. Miami (OH): Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

MAC action features the Eastern Michigan Eagles (12-16, 5-10 MAC) at home against the Miami (OH) RedHawks (14-14, 8-7 MAC) on Saturday, March 2, 2024 at 1:00 PM ET.In its previous game, Eastern Michigan topped Western Michigan on Tuesday, 70-67....

Loyola Chicago vs. Dayton: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Loyola Chicago Ramblers (20-8, 12-3 A-10) will host the Dayton Flyers (22-5, 12-3 A-10) after winning five straight home games.Loyola Chicago dropped its most recent game to Saint Bonaventure, 79-64, on Tuesday. Philip Alston was its leading scorer with...

Kentucky vs. Arkansas: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

SEC action features the No. 16 Kentucky Wildcats (20-8, 10-5 SEC) at home against the Arkansas Razorbacks (14-14, 5-10 SEC) on Saturday, March 2, 2024 at 1:30 PM ET.Kentucky was victorious in its most recent game against Mississippi State, 91-89,...

more blackhawks news