Amid all the talk surrounding Dempster and Delgado over the past few days, some fans have expressed concern or surprise that some national analysts project Randall Delgado as “only” a number three starter in the majors. For Cub fans, a number three starter means someone like Travis Wood, or maybe Paul Maholm. That’s not exactly exciting.
For scouts and baseball analysts, though, the words mean something completely different. For that crew, the designation No. 1, No. 2, No. 3, and No. 4/5 refers more to the stuff the pitcher has than his likely place in a rotation. A No. 3 starter is a pitcher with one definite plus pitch (a pitch that is significantly above major league average). He also likely has at least two secondary pitches that are no worse than league average. All of those pitches can be thrown for strikes, and he is able to maintain his composure and concentration throughout a game. That is not a bad pitcher. On most teams, a guy fitting that description would pitch second in the rotation. On some teams, that guy would be the ace.
So how high is the standard for No. 1 pitcher? Really, really high. A true No. 1 has at minimum two plus-plus pitches. That means he has two pitches that are among the best the in baseball for that pitch. He also has a third pitch that is no worse than average, and likely a fourth pitch as well. He has pinpoint control, can throw any of his pitches for strikes in any situation, and has that icy calm demeanor on the mound that we associate only with the greatest of great pitchers in baseball history. There are not many No. 1 pitchers. Not being classified as a No. 1 guy is no insult.
If the Cubs can land Randall Delgado, even though he projects as “only” a No. 3 starter, they will be doing quite well and will be acquiring a guy who has a very good chance to pitch at or near the front of the Cubs rotation for a very long time. If Zach Lee similarly projects as a No. 2 or a No. 3, although he is clearly behind Delgado. (You’ll want to keep tabs on the latest, though, as the Delgado possibility is slipping away.)
Scores From Yesterday
Iowa – With the wind blowing out to left, the final score in the Cubs’ 15-9 loss was not surprising.
Tennessee – The Smokies won the opener in Jacksonville 9-2.
Daytona – Good pitching helped Daytona hold on for a 4-3 win.
Peoria – The Peoria Chiefs were off on Tuesday.
Boise – Boise pitching allowed just two hits as they won 2-1.
Arizona – The Cubs took advantage of six Indians errors in their 9-2 win.
Performances of the Day
Other Minor League Notes
Farm System Standings
AAA – Iowa Cubs : 41 – 63.
Pacific Coast League American Northern Division – Third Place: 21.0 Games Behind.
AA – Tennessee Smokies : 14-17
Southern League North Division – Third Place : 5.0 Games Behind
High A – Daytona Cubs : 13-18
Florida State League North Division – Fifth Place : 6.0 Games Behind
Low A – Peoria Chiefs : 11-19
Midwest League Eastern Division – Fifth Place : 5.5 Game Behind
Short-Season A – Boise Hawks : 1-0
Northwest League East Division – First Place (tie) : 1.0 Games Behind
Rookie League – AZL Cubs : 20 – 7
Arizona Rookie League East – First Place : 1.5 Games Ahead