The Many (Positive) Reactions to the Anthony Rizzo Extension

anthony rizzo happy celebrationYesterday, the Chicago Cubs announced that they’d reached a seven-year extension agreement with first baseman Anthony Rizzo, and then presented him a core piece of “the future” in a press conference at Wrigley Field. There were a lot of interesting reactions to the signing, all of which were positive …

  • Dave Cameron at FanGraphs offered the most effusive praise of the signing, calling it the second time in a little over a year that the Cubs have scored big in a deal involving Rizzo. In a long piece well worth your time, Cameron compares Rizzo’s deal to the pre-arb extensions recently signed by Paul Goldschmidt and Allen Craig, and concludes not only that Rizzo is the superior player, but also that the Cubs got the best deal of the three. The piece is chock-full of quotable quotes, but I’ll go with this one as my favorite: “Rizzo’s power is carrying him at the moment, making up for the fact that he’s a bit too aggressive at the plate, but discipline develops with experience, and Rizzo should be able to add more walks to his profile before his power begins to decline. In his prime, Rizzo should develop into a +4 to +5 win first baseman. In terms of overall value, he projects to be not that different from what Prince Fielder is right now, with his better defense making up for the lower walk rate.”
  • Keith Law, who pointed out some issues in Rizzo’s swing earlier this year before he exploded, said the signing was a “strong move” for the Cubs.
  • Rob Neyer also applauds the deal for the Cubs, comparing Rizzo to another NL Central first baseman, Joey Votto – whose seasons in his 30s are going to cost the Reds three times as much as Rizzo’s seasons in his 20s. (It’s fun to think of it that way, but, let’s be honest, that’s mostly just a product of contract dynamics in MLB. Votto was going to be a free agent, and the Reds bought him out of that. The vast majority of Rizzo’s deal comes during years he was under (cheap) control already. That said, I think the more important point here is how valuable young, cost-controlled talent is.)
  • At the press conference yesterday, neither Rizzo nor GM Jed Hoyer really said much that you wouldn’t expect. It was nice hearing Hoyer say this, though: “We’ve known Anthony for a long time. Theo, Jason and I have spent a lot of time with this guy and feel like we know him really well. Ultimately you want to build your team around people you trust, people you believe in, and I think today is a really good example that we believe in Anthony.” Talent and baseball ability matter, probably more than anything else. But when you’re able to find a core group of players who have talent, but are also good, trustworthy people? There’s an impact there, even if you can’t measure it with a statistic.
  • Dale Sveum took the praise to the next level, saying that the deal is good for the City of Chicago. “In my position, it’s nice to have a guy projected for 30 [homers] and 100 RBIs in your lineup for the next seven-to-whatever years, especially with his makeup and defensive ability,” Sveum said, per Cubs.com. “It’s pretty important to all of us – the city and the organization – to have somebody like that locked up for that long. It’s a pretty special day for all of us.”
  • Even Jon Greenberg, who will snark the crap out of you if you give him an inch, had nothing but good things to say about Rizzo and the Cubs for locking him up.
  • James Russell had the best reaction to the extension, per Bruce Levine: “I am happy it happened to one of my friends so he can buy me dinners and lunches all the time. He can also take me and the guys out and pick up the bar tab.”
  • written by

    Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

    more cubs news

    Cubs Haven’t Had a First Base Season Like This in a While, Hendricks and Miller, How Chapman Got His Deal, and Other Cubs Bullets

    A very happy birthday to our Littlest Girl, who has to work harder than most of us, but who does it while generating more sunshine than any of us. Michael Busch erupted out in Colorado, which happens for a lot...

    The Final Two Weeks (Mercifully) – Cubs vs Athletics Series Preview

    [BN_drinks] CUBS VS ATHLETICS — Although I know that the day the season ends, I'll instantly miss baseball ... I am otherwise ready for this to all be over. This has been such a weird and disappointing year, filled with...

    Iowa Cubs Offense Goes Off in Home Finale

    The Triple-A Iowa Cubs have one more week left in their season, and they played their final home game yesterday. I'll dispense quickly with the part where they gave up 17 runs and did not win (eep), and will instead...

    Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 6, Rockies 2 – September 15, 2024

    The Cubs really didn't want to let this one slip away, adding a flurry of runs late to insure the lead, including homers from Michael Busch and Pete Crow-Armstrong in the 9th. Good thing, as Keegan Thompson loaded the bases...

    Kevin Alcántara and Matt Shaw Both Just Hit Homers Onto the Roof at Iowa

    Whatever happens today with the big league Cubs and their series in Colorado, at least the Iowa Cubs are having a mighty fun day at home already. Through two innings, the I-Cubs have already scored six runs. You have outfield...

    Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Rockies (2:10 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

    CUBS LINEUP — If the Cubs had simply won more games this season, they'd have a better record. It's as easy as that. Here's a look at the Cubs lineup for the finale against the Rockies at Coors Field. Chicago...

    The Late-Inning Difference for the Cubs, Check Swing, Bellinger Streak, and Other Cubs Bullets

    The Bear is a "comedy" in the same way that the 2024 Chicago Cubs are a comedy. The humor is there, but it is incidental to the haunting, and occasionally beautiful, mix of drama and horror. Which is to say,...

    Matt Shaw Becomes the Cubs’ First 20-20 Player of the Year

    A nice milestone reached for top Chicago Cubs prospect Matt Shaw, who clubbed his 20th home run of the 2024 season. That, combined with his 28 stolen bases, makes Shaw the first 20-20 player in the system: https://twitter.com/MLBPipeline/status/1835117475844751721 Shaw is...

    Enhanced Box Score: Rockies 6, Cubs 5 – September 14, 2024

    Welp. Welp. Yeah. With a two-run lead, Porter Hodge struck out the first two batters in the 9th, and came within an eyelash of striking out the third. Hunter Goodman did a two-strike check swing that was one of those...

    Pete Crow-Armstrong Sends One Out to Deeeep Center at Coors Field

    The ball flies well in the thin air of Denver, but the ballpark's dimensions there account for it. So if you hit one well over the wall in center at Coors Field, you must have hit it a very long...

    Latest News

    Pressure Problems, O-Line Concerns, Eberflus’ Poor Process, Stroud Chimes In, and Other Bears Bullets

    Last night’s Bears-Texans game doesn’t deserve an intro with a build-up. Let’s just get into it. From the top: A thought I can’t get out of my head after watching last night’s loss to the Texans: Caleb Williams is a...

    Royals vs. Tigers Probable Starting Pitchers – Sept. 16

    The Kansas City Royals (82-68) and the Detroit Tigers (77-73) face off at Kauffman Stadium on Monday at 7:40 p.m. ET, beginning a three-game series.The Royals will call on Seth Lugo (16-8) against the Tigers and Casey Mize (2-6).Royals vs....

    Pirates vs. Cardinals Probable Starting Pitchers – Sept. 16

    The St. Louis Cardinals (74-75) begin a four-game series against the Pittsburgh Pirates (71-78) on Monday at Busch Stadium. First pitch is at 7:45 p.m. ET.The Pirates will call on Paul Skenes (10-2) against the Cardinals and Andre Pallante (6-8).Pirates...

    Phillies vs. Brewers Probable Starting Pitchers – Sept. 16

    The Philadelphia Phillies (90-59) and the Milwaukee Brewers (86-63) face off at American Family Field on Monday at 7:40 p.m. ET, starting a three-game series.The Phillies will give the nod to Ranger Suarez (12-6, 3.05 ERA), who is eyeing win...

    Cubs vs. Athletics Probable Starting Pitchers – Sept. 16

    The Chicago Cubs (76-73) and the Oakland Athletics (65-85) face off at Wrigley Field on Monday at 7:40 p.m. ET, beginning a three-game series.The Cubs will call on Shota Imanaga (13-3) against the Athletics and Joey Estes (7-7).Cubs vs. Athletics...

    Mets vs. Nationals Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, September 16, 2024

    The Washington Nationals (68-81) and James Wood (2 HR in his last game) are underdogs (+160) on the moneyline for their matchup with the New York Mets (81-68) on Monday at 7:10 p.m. ET on MLB Network.New York's Sean Manaea...

    Twins vs. Guardians Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, September 16, 2024

    An AL Central matchup Monday features the third-place Minnesota Twins (79-70) visiting the first-place Cleveland Guardians (86-64). The Twins (-113) are listed as favorites for the game, which gets underway at 6:40 p.m. ET from Progressive Field.Minnesota's Pablo Lopez and...

    Dodgers vs. Braves Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, September 16, 2024

    The Los Angeles Dodgers (88-61) visit the Atlanta Braves (81-68) at 7:20 p.m. ET Monday for a sluggers' duel between two of the best power hitters in MLB. For the favored Dodgers (-114), Shohei Ohtani has racked up 47 homers...

    Chicago Sports Network Updates: Over-the-air Option Announced, Preseason Questions, More

    Our continued wait to see how and where (and, frankly, when) we'll be able to watch Chicago Sports Network, the new home of the Blackhawks, Bulls and White Sox, is slowly starting to get some clarification. On Monday morning, Chicago...

    Training Camp Week is Here! Prospect Buzz, Bedard, Commesso, TV News, and Other Blackhawks Bullets

    Welcome to Training Camp Starts This Week... week, Blackhawks fans! Thursday morning, there will be Blackhawks skaters -- NHL guys and prospects -- on the ice at Fifth Third Arena. We'll also talk to Kyle Davidson for the first time...

    more cubs news