Telephone: Ian Stewart Says that Theo Epstein Says that Josh Vitters is the Future at Third Base

ian stewart and josh vittersIan Stewart shared additional thoughts on his demotion from the Cubs with Carrie Muskat, who was in Des Moines recently to take in the Iowa Cubs. The article offers more insight into Stewart’s “time off,” and into his decision to stick with the Cubs even as they demoted him (as we suspected, it was mostly about keeping his $2 million contract (which, I mean, I’d do the same thing)). It’s worth reading if you’re into this story.

The piece I’d like to highlight, however, is one small quote from Stewart, about when he was informed that he was going to be optioned to Iowa.

“I talked to Theo, and he was basically telling me that Vitters is the future at third for them,” Stewart told Muskat. “I understand that …. Josh is young and he’s a good player and has a lot of talent. That part did not surprise me at all.

“It was basically if I wanted to stay with the Cubs and accept my assignment here, they were letting me know I wasn’t going to play a lot here,” Stewart continued. “I don’t know if that was a way to get me to take my free agency, because there’s money involved in all of that.”

There are two pieces there worth discussing, the first of which I’ll dispense with quickly: in that second line, Stewart is implying that the demotion, and the subsequent benching at Iowa, were effectively designed to push Stewart out of the organization (and save the Cubs some money). It’s certainly possible, and it does seem strange that, even with Josh Vitters out with a quad injury, Brent Lillibridge is picking up starts at third, not Stewart. Given everything that’s happened, it’s plausible that the Cubs have simply had enough with Stewart at this point, and even Stewart doesn’t think he’ll play for the Cubs again.

But that Vitters piece of Stewart’s quote is far more interesting.

Now, then. It’s necessary to note up front that we don’t know exactly what Epstein said to Stewart, or what Epstein’s intent was in so saying. We don’t know what motivations are animating Stewart’s comments, and how he decided to frame them.

That is all to say that we don’t know that Epstein actually said, word for word, that the organization expects Vitters to be the future at third base. Indeed, were it so, that statement would fly in the face of various rumblings we’ve heard for the better part of two years, which have all suggested that the higher ups don’t believe Vitters can stick at third long-term.

It’s been easy to lose sight of Vitters. He bombed out in his debut last year with the Cubs, and he missed all of Spring Training with a bum wheel. It was essentially a foregone conclusion that he was going to be moved off of third to a variety of positions, or he was going to be moved out of the organization.

But … is he actually going to get a shot to be the third baseman of the future? I wouldn’t have thought it possible until this statement from Stewart. Not only did Vitters struggle in the bigs, and not only is his defense at third questioned by some, but there are some interesting third base options potentially arriving in short order, including Christian Villanueva, Arismendy Alcantara, Junior Lake … or maybe even Javier Baez or Jeimer Candelario further down the road.

But let’s not forget: Vitters had a great year at Iowa in 2012, all while he was young for the league. There is still plenty of offensive potential there, and maybe there’s a belief that he can do just well enough to handle third base. Many players have struggled in their first appearance in the big leagues, and last year was as much about giving Vitters a taste of what the bigs are like as it was about “testing” him to see if he could take the position and run with it. Vitters is still just 23, after all. Maybe there really is a future for Vitters at third base with the Cubs.

Or maybe the message got changed just enough in the game of telephone, and maybe Epstein was simply trying to impress upon Stewart that, for now, getting Vitters starts at third base at AAA was the priority over getting starts for Stewart. That doesn’t necessarily mean that Vitters is the guy at third base long-term. It just means that he’s slightly more likely to be the guy than Stewart.

And I’d say that sounds about right at this point.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

2024 MLB Draft, Day Three – Rounds 11 Through 20 (UPDATES)

The final day of the 2024 MLB Draft is here, with Rounds 11 through 20 going off. If you missed any of the coverage of the first two days of Cubs picks, catch yourself up here and here. Day Three...

MLB All-Star Game Pre-Gamin’: Broadcast Info, Lineups, Pitching Matchups, More

The 2024 MLB All-Star Game is set to captivate fans tomorrow with a star-studded lineup and thrilling matchups. Corbin Burnes of the Baltimore Orioles will start for the American League, while Paul Skenes will take the mound for the National...

Cubs Farm Report | July 16, 2024: Top 25 Prospect Stock Report

Cubs Prospects — The Chicago Cubs minor league affiliates were off on Monday, so it's time to take stock of some recent hot (and not-so-hot) performers inside the Cubs Top 25 prospects down on the farm in today's Cubs Farm...

MLBits: Home Run Derby Thoughts, NL Hitters Advice to AL Hitters Facing Paul Skenes, More

Teoscar Hernández edged hometown hero Bobby Witt Jr. in last night's Home Run Derby at Globe Life Field in Arlington. We're discussing the derby and more in today's MLB Notes. Home Run Derby Stuff I'm glad that I decided not...

MLB All-Star Game Starting Lineups Announced

The MLB All-Star Game is set for tomorrow, and the starting lineups have just been revealed. On the mound for the American League is Corbin Burnes, who has had a stellar season with the Baltimore Orioles. The National League will...

Cubs VP of Scouting Dan Kantrovitz on the Organization’s Day Two Draft Picks

The Chicago Cubs made eight selections on Day Two of the 2024 MLB Draft, in Rounds 3 through 10. We talked about all the picks right here, if you missed it, and about the top two rounds here. The short...

Imanaga the All-Star, Lack of Cubs, Blown Calls, and Other Cubs Bullets

A heads up that today is Prime Day at Amazon, with tons and tons of pretty significant deals. I jumped on a new Eero mesh wi-fi upgrade for my house, and I'll be perusing the other deals today just in...

Teoscar Hernández Juuust Barely Tops Bobby Witt Jr. to Win the 2024 Home Run Derby

Teoscar Hernández brought home the 2024 Home Run Derby title to win the $1 million prize, which is approximately 200 times what the Dodgers are paying him in present-day dollars on his deal. That's my understanding of how their contracts...

The 2024 MLB Draft, Day Two – Rounds 3-10 (UPDATES: Day Complete!)

The 2024 MLB Draft continues this afternoon at 1pm CT with Rounds 3 through 10, which you can watch on MLB.com. There will be one minute between picks, and I'll be updating the Cubs' selections at the bottom of this...

Cubs Have Reportedly “Expressed Interest” in Danny Jansen, But Does That Even Still Make Sense?

Swinging a trade for Blue Jays rental catcher Danny Jansen first came onto our radar nearly two full months ago, when two things became clear: (1) the Cubs catching tandem at the time (Yan Gomes, Miguel Amaya) wasn't getting it...

Latest News

Lynx vs Dream: Best Bets, Player Props & Computer Picks – July 17

The Atlanta Dream (7-16) will look to stop a seven-game losing stretch when visiting the Minnesota Lynx (16-8) on Wednesday, July 17, 2024 at Target Center. This contest is at 1:00 PM ET.Dig into the best bets available (according to...

Fever vs Wings: Best Bets, Player Props & Computer Picks – July 17

Arike Ogunbowale and the Dallas Wings (5-19) play the Indiana Fever (11-14) on Wednesday, July 17, 2024 at College Park Center. The contest will start at 7:30 PM ET.Check out below to find the best bets you can place on...

Zheng vs. Martic Prediction at the 32nd Palermo Ladies Open – Thursday, July 18

In the Round of 16 at the 32nd Palermo Ladies Open on Thursday, Petra Martic (ranked No. 99) faces Qinwen Zheng (No. 7).Zheng is favored (-375) in this matchup, compared to the underdog Martic, who is +275.32nd Palermo Ladies Open...

Vukic vs. Spizzirri Prediction at the Hall of Fame Open – Wednesday, July 17

Aleksandar Vukic (No. 65 ranking) will take on Eliot Spizzirri (No. 393) in the Round of 16 of the Hall of Fame Open on Wednesday, July 17.Vukic is the favorite against Spizzirri, with -303 odds compared to the underdog's +220.Hall...

Fever vs Wings Prediction: Picks, Live Odds & Moneyline – July 17

The Dallas Wings (5-19) hope to stop a three-game losing streak when they host the Indiana Fever (11-14) at 7:30 PM ET on Wednesday, July 17, 2024 at College Park Center. The game airs on ESPN.Fever vs. Wings Prediction &...

Where to Watch LA Galaxy vs. Colorado Rapids: TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

A game featuring two of MLS' top scorers is coming up when Dejan Joveljic (ninth) and LA Galaxy take on Colorado Rapids and Rafael Navarro (ninth) on Wednesday, July 17, 2024.Watch every MLS match, Leagues Cup and the MLS Cup...

Where to Watch Seattle Sounders FC vs. Saint Louis City SC: TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

Seattle Sounders FC (13th in MLS) and Saint Louis City SC (27th) meet at Lumen Field on Wednesday at 10:30 PM ET.Watch every MLS match, Leagues Cup and the MLS Cup Playoffs on Apple TV+! Use our link to start...

Indiana Fever vs. Dallas Wings: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Dallas Wings (5-19) will look to end a three-game losing streak when they host the Indiana Fever (11-14) on Wednesday, July 17, 2024 at College Park Center. The matchup airs at 7:30 PM ET on ESPN.Watch the WNBA all...

Where to Watch San Jose Earthquakes vs. Houston Dynamo: TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

San Jose Earthquakes (29th in MLS) and Houston Dynamo (14th) meet at PayPal Park on Wednesday at 10:30 PM.Watch every MLS match, Leagues Cup and the MLS Cup Playoffs on Apple TV+! Use our link to start a free trial...

Where to Watch Vancouver Whitecaps FC vs. Sporting Kansas City: TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

Brian White (No. 4 in MLS, 12 goals), leads Vancouver Whitecaps FC at home against Sporting Kansas City, which has conceded 49 goals (28th in the league). The game is on Wednesday at 10:30 PM ET.Watch every MLS match, Leagues...

more cubs news