The Hamels Trade That Isn’t Happening, and Why Trading Russell for Him Would Be a Mistake

cole hamelsAlthough teams claim players on waivers in August all the time, and, because word never leaks out, it doesn’t become a story, I don’t think the heavy attention that the Chicago Cubs’ claim of Phillies ace Cole Hamels was unreasonable. Sure, I think a lot of the discussion was ill-informed, being that a trade was always extraordinarily unlikely. But the process of discussing the situation was meritorious both as an object lesson in August waiver trades – how they happen, why they happen, why they don’t happen, and why waiver claims aren’t always a big deal – and as a guide for the near-term future of the Cubs.

Let’s call the Cubs/Hamels hype full of sound and fury and signifying … something.

The something, as we discussed, is the Cubs’ readiness and willingness to target and pursue top tier pitching, even if it comes at a high price (either in dollars or prospects). Not only is that reassuring with respect to the Cubs’ financial position (though, with so much money coming off the books, and revenue increases slowly coming online, we expected some spending soon), but also with respect to the Cubs’ internal belief about where they are in the rebuild. You don’t go adding 31-year-old ace-level pitchers unless you believe it’s time to go. I see it, too, for the Cubs in 2015/16/17, and I’m glad their actions are starting to align with that belief.

But, that’s all academic. Because the reality of this process is that Cole Hamels is not actually coming to the Cubs right now. With the two-day period in which to complete a trade coming to a close later today, we can safely say no deal is forthcoming. Buster Olney says it. Patrick Mooney says it. Gordon Wittenmyer says it. And, for whatever it’s worth, I’ve said it.

Wittenmyer’s piece adds, via a source, that the Phillies wanted one of the Cubs’ top young shortstops for Hamels, plus more. The shortstop in question is almost certainly Addison Russell (Javier Baez and Starlin Castro are on the 40-man roster, and thus subject to the waiver process in August if you want to trade them), a top five prospect in baseball.

Acquiring Hamels, even on a contract that will pay him $96 million over the next four years (or $110 to $114 million (because of varying options) over the next five years), has value. I am in complete agreement on that. For me, however, that value never reached the level of an Addison Russell. If the Phillies ate a bunch of the deal? Sure, then maybe. But they’ve shown no inclination to do so (which I totally understand).

I don’t think asking for Russell in a deal for Hamels is unreasonable, but I do think it would be a mistake for the Cubs to pull that trigger.

Even if you consider Russell solely as an asset – imagining that he never plays a game for the Cubs – the monetary value of his projected future performance is enormous, and in the range of tens and tens of millions of dollars. Some projections have prospects less elite than Russell worth as much as $30 to $40 million. Hamels, on the other hand, by reasonable calculations, would offer no surplus value on his current contract after this season.

That means, in order to justify trading Russell (and more!) for Hamels, the Cubs would have to believe that the value of merely having Hamels under contract (and not risking the free agent market to try, and maybe fail, to sign someone like Jon Lester or Max Scherzer (for more total money)) is on the order of tens and tens of millions of dollars. In other words, it’s like saying “winning” a free agent bidding war, itself, is worth $30 to $40 million. Is “getting the guy” at market rate really worth that much? Well, here’s the pretty easy way to know that it isn’t: you could just tack $20 million on to your offer and win the bidding war.

So, that’s a convoluted way of saying – just for example – that Russell plus Lester at $130 million over six years (when the next highest bidder was only at $110 million over five) is worth more than Hamels, alone, at $110 to $114 million over five years. Instead of using Russell’s (too much) value to acquire a pitcher who’s making market rate, the Cubs would be better off paying a comparable free agent more than he’s worth and keeping Russell.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

WAKE UP, BASEBALL IS BACK

The day has arrived. Opening Day. The most glorious day on the baseball calendar, save for the day of each Chicago Cubs World Series win, of course. See, I get to say things like that on Opening Day. Maybe the...

Wrigley Field is Gonna Be Lit This Year (As in New Colored Lights!)

Last year, the Cubs started using their new LED outfield lights to do a little dancing display during 'Go Cubs Go,' lighting along with the song and throwing in a W. It was very fun and I liked it. This...

The 2024 Chicago Cubs for Dummies

Boom. We made it. The offseason is over, and the Cubs regular season - and those elevated expectations - begins tomorrow. But in case you slept through the winter, I'm here to catch you up on everything you need to...

Why Craig Counsell Wanted Miles Mastrobuoni on the Cubs’ Bench

I don't know why Miles Mastrobuoni bugs some folks, but it's probably heavily-weighted toward his small-sample, bad-batted-ball-luck start last year, and that time he didn't dive while playing in right field. It can be hard to shake initial impressions, I...

Kinda Sounds Like Craig Counsell May Have a Set Top Three in the Batting Order

New Chicago Cubs manager Craig Counsell has said, generally, his batting order philosophy is the very simplistic (and very correct): just get your best hitters the most at bats. Sure, there's some play in that to set up good match-ups,...

Los Angeles Dodgers Signing Will Smith to a TEN-YEAR Extension

The Los Angeles Dodgers have done it again. And by it, I mean they have signed a funkily-structured contract that is going to leave some folks annoyed. The Dodgers are extending catcher Will Smith on a DECADE-long deal with a...

The Stretch: 2024 MLB Season Preview

On Monday, during a team-building conversation with some of the Bleacher Nation and Betsperts Media Group folks, we discussed sports—shocking, I know—and Brian Twining asked the group what their favorite sport was. For me, it's baseball. There's no debate. I...

We Have to Talk About Some of the “Deals” the Cubs Sat Out in Free Agency

This week, in a conversation with Jon Greenberg at The Athletic, Cubs President Jed Hoyer made an honest and sober (but also moderately disappointing) admission about the 2024 Chicago Cubs: "We need to perform probably at or a little bit...

The Chicago Cubs Are Reportedly Now Worth Over $5 Billion

Given all the tumult in the baseball broadcasting world, and the uncertain future for that portion of revenues, you'd be forgiven for expecting that MLB franchise valuations would slow their recent surge. But, according to Sportico at least, you'd be...

Reds Second Baseman Matt McLain Had Shoulder Surgery

The injury to Matt McLain's shoulder issue obviously wound up being worse than he and the Cincinnati Reds had been hoping. The damage to his left (non-throwing) labrum ultimately required surgery: https://twitter.com/m_sheldon/status/1772993402604339478 When the hope is that a guy can...

Latest News

2024 MLB Mock Draft: Opening Day Mock Draft Projections

Happy Opening Day! As the new baseball season begins, and hope is present among most fanbases, why not take a look at a new 2024 MLB Mock Draft? Various mock drafts meticulously analyze potential picks, emphasizing the abundance of talent...

WAKE UP, BASEBALL IS BACK

The day has arrived. Opening Day. The most glorious day on the baseball calendar, save for the day of each Chicago Cubs World Series win, of course. See, I get to say things like that on Opening Day. Maybe the...

Pac-12 Basketball Predictions, Computer Picks and Best Bets | March 28

There is one game featuring a Pac-12 teams on the Thursday postseason college basketball schedule, the Clemson Tigers versus the Arizona Wildcats. Make sure you check out below for today's best bets!How to Bet on Pac-12 Games[lasso rel="draftkings-promo-1" id="299003"]Best Pac-12...

Rays vs. Blue Jays Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Tampa Bay Rays are moneyline favorites (-135) to begin their season with a home win over the Toronto Blue Jays on Thursday at 4:10 PM ET, live on MLB Network.Tampa Bay's Zach Eflin gets the start, and he'll go...

Astros vs. Yankees Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Houston Astros start their season as home favorites (-156) in a matchup with the New York Yankees on Thursday at 4:10 PM ET, live on YES from Minute Maid Park.Framber Valdez will get the ball for Houston while New...

Tigers vs. White Sox Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Detroit Tigers begin their season as -178 favorites in a road tilt against the Chicago White Sox on Thursday at 4:10 PM ET, live on BSDET.Detroit's Tarik Skubal gets the start, and he'll go against Chicago's Garrett Crochet.Tigers vs....

Reds vs. Nationals Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Cincinnati Reds open their season as -153 favorites in a home matchup with the Washington Nationals on Thursday at 4:10 PM ET, live on MASN2.Frankie Montas will get the ball for Cincinnati while Washington will counter with Josiah Gray.Reds...

Dodgers vs. Cardinals Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Los Angeles Dodgers (1-1) will look to Will Smith, red hot after a four-hit game, to lead them in a matchup with the St. Louis Cardinals (0-0) on Thursday at 4:10 PM ET on BSMW. The Dodgers are -235...

Marlins vs. Pirates Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Miami Marlins are moneyline favorites (-132) to begin their season with a home win over the Pittsburgh Pirates on Thursday at 4:10 PM ET, live on Sportsnet PT.Jesus Luzardo will get the ball for Miami while Pittsburgh will counter...

Padres vs. Giants Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The San Diego Padres (1-1) are favored on the moneyline (-114) in Thursday's contest versus the San Francisco Giants (0-0). First pitch is at 4:10 PM ET on NBCS-BA. The Giants, with +159 odds, are favored against the spread (1.5).San...

more cubs news