Valuing Kris Bryant at Different Positions and Other Bullets

kris bryant smileI had a total ‘Inception’ night last night, where I literally dreamt that I was talking to The Wife about a dream I had within another dream. As in, I had the first dream, “woke up,” started to talk to The Wife about the dream, “woke up” again, and started to talk to The Wife about the original dream. But even that conversation was in a dream! The original was a really lame dream, by the way. Some slimy dude was hitting on The Wife, and then subsequent layers of dreams within dreams made it unclear if it had actually happened, and all of the conversations were about the previous dream level and whether the incident had actually happened.

And now I’ve just put you all to sleep. Better talk about Kris Bryant …

  • Working on yesterday’s piece on the value the Cubs could lose by keeping Kris Bryant in the minors to start the 2015 season (turns out: it’s not much), I started wondering about a tangential valuation question that I think I’ll explore now. If we assume that Bryant could play league average defense at third base OR left field next year, and if we accept the projections Steamer currently has for Bryant’s offensive numbers, how much WAR would he be worth at 3B? How much would he be worth in LF? I’m just curious to see if it’s a striking difference. Using the Simple WAR Calculator

  • At .265/.344/.489 over 600 plate appearances in 150 games, with average baserunning and with average defense in left field, Bryant would be worth about 3.2 WAR.
  • At the same numbers and with the same assumptions, but playing average third base, Bryant would be worth about 4.1 WAR. That’s almost an entire extra win for exactly the same production. So, as you probably would have expected, if you can keep Bryant at third base, it’s probably worth trying.
  • One more little experiment: since some believe Bryant has Gold Glove-caliber upside in the outfield, but average-at-best upside at third base, what happens if we once again use the same offensive production, but given Bryant the best possible defensive rating in left field, and the worst possible rating at third? Well, the third base WAR drops all the way to 2.6, and the left field WAR increases to 4.7. In other words, yeah, all things equal, Bryant at third base clearly provides the most value. But … all things might not be equal. This is why the decision makers get paid the big bucks.
  • As mentioned in this morning’s Enhanced Box Score, Addison Russell had a big game in the AFL yesterday, notching his first homer of the year. You can read more from Russell on the game and on the AFL, in general, here.
  • A fun read on Cubs outfield prospect Bijan Rademacher, who is making the most of his limited opportunities in the AFL. Although his upside is mostly likely as a reserve outfielder, Rademacher’s 2014 season was quietly excellent. He’s a guy to watch for a potential breakout in 2015.
  • A little slice of Wrigleyville in South Bend for the new Cubs affiliate there?
  • Mike Petriello took on the “Big Game James” thing about James Shields at FanGraphs (before his unsuccessful World Series opener), and looked into why it hasn’t worked out for him in the playoffs in the same way it has in the regular season. I’m still very much on board with the Cubs pursuing Shields, but I should probably emphasize at some point that it’s not like I’m saying he’d be my number one target for the Cubs regardless of money. I’m just saying it would be nice for the Cubs to have as many palatable quality options as possible.
  • If you missed the latest Saber Shorts video, it was on wOBA, and you can see it below (and you can subscribe to the BNTV YouTube page so you don’t miss any others, and you can forever safely ignore reminders like this one instead of blasting me in the comments for how much you hate reminders):
  • written by

    Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

    more cubs news

    Get ‘Em While They’re Down: Cubs vs Astros – Series Preview

    Cubs vs Astros — Splitting a four-gamer against the current, badly-struggling Miami Marlins is unquestionably a bad outcome, especially when one of those two losses was a win-in-hand that slipped away into the seats. But the typical, and maddeningly correct,...

    South Side Horror Show (and Campfire Milkshakes), Alzolay and Evolving Relief Roles, and Other Cubs Bullets

    It's going to be a really good year for Horror movies. Late Night with the Devil was good (just saw it the other night). And I've got my eyes on Long Legs, Cuckoo, The First Omen, Immaculate, MaXXXine, In a...

    Two NL Central Pitchers Down: Miley and Montas

    A couple injuries to note among other NL Central contenders, as each of the Brewers and Reds have taken a hit to their rotation. The presumption for now is short-term on each, but I suppose we'll see. First, you have...

    Brewers Pitcher Jakob Junis Taken Off Field in an Ambulance After Being Struck by BP Ball

    A very scary scene in Pittsburgh, where Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Jakob Junis, currently on the IL with a shoulder impingement, took a batting practice ball off the neck and went down. Junis was apparently on the ground for a long...

    Nico Hoerner is Back to Being Nico Hoerner

    On April 9, I took an early look at Nico Hoerner's apparently evolving approach at the plate, which featured a lot more patience and a lot more big hacks. Effectively, it seemed like he was trying for a little more...

    MLBits: Spencer Strider Speaks (His and Other Pitcher Arm Injuries), Shohei Ohtani’s Latest Milestone, More

    There's been much debate about pitcher arm injuries lately, much of it sparked by Spencer Strider's season-ending Tommy John surgery, and Strider spoke to the media for the first time since the injury on Friday. Spencer Strider on pitcher arm...

    Chicago Cubs Sign Lefty Pitching Prospect Mitchell Tyranski

    A new signing popped up on the Chicago Cubs' transaction log: lefty Mitchell Tyranski. Tyranski, 26, put up a 3.83 ERA over 42.1 innings at High-A last year in the Dodgers organization, striking out 47 and walking 21. Were you...

    The Cubs Have TWO of the Early Front-Runners for NL Rookie of the Year

    We already dove deep into Shota Imanaga's latest impressive start against the Marlins yesterday. And there's been no shortage of love for Michael Busch this season either. But I do want to take this time to illustrate just how good...

    My Expectations and Realistic Hope for the Cubs VERY Tough Upcoming Schedule

    Even though Sunday ended in a loss for the Chicago Cubs, we did get some good news in the form of positive injury updates. Ian Happ (hamstring) was available off the bench and could be good to go tomorrow, when...

    Aaron Boone Just Got Ejected Despite Saying Literally Nothing

    I know that sometimes there is a history between an umpire and a manager. I know that sometimes a manager can subtly get under the skin of an umpire without doing much that we can see or hear. And I...

    Latest News

    Prioritizing the Carolina Panthers NFL Draft: Top 5 Positions to Address

    The Carolina Panthers have several positions to address in the 2024 NFL Draft after a rough 2-15 with rookie quarterback Bryce Young at the helm. Let's dive into the team's biggest needs heading into the draft as the team moves...

    Seattle Seahawks 1st Round Mock Draft: Seahawks Land Exciting Defensive Lineman

    The Seattle Seahawks head into the 2024 draft with the 16th overall pick. This Seattle Seahawks 1st round mock draft addresses a major need for them. After a season with some bright spots but overall inconsistency, the Seahawks have several...

    Dodgers vs. Nationals Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Tuesday, April 23, 2024

    The Los Angeles Dodgers (13-11) visit the Washington Nationals (10-11) on Tuesday to begin a three-game series, with the first pitch at 6:45 PM ET from Nationals Park. The Dodgers are listed as -216 favorites, while the underdog Nationals have...

    Braves vs. Marlins Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Tuesday, April 23, 2024

    The Atlanta Braves (15-6) are favorites (-252) on the moneyline when they square off against the Miami Marlins (6-18) Tuesday at 7:20 PM ET, live on BSSO.Max Fried starts for Atlanta while Trevor Rogers is Miami's starter for the contest.Braves...

    Phillies vs. Reds Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Tuesday, April 23, 2024

    The Philadelphia Phillies (15-8) will put their seven-game win streak to the test when they visit the Cincinnati Reds (12-10) Tuesday at 6:40 PM ET on NBCS-PH. Sportsbooks consider the Phillies -128 favorites to extend their streak, while the Reds...

    Yankees vs. Athletics Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Tuesday, April 23, 2024

    The New York Yankees (15-8) are set to take on the Oakland Athletics (9-14) Tuesday at 7:05 PM ET, airing on NBCS-CA. The Yankees are listed as -217 favorites by sportsbooks, while the underdog Athletics have +180 odds for the...

    Brewers vs. Pirates Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Tuesday, April 23, 2024

    The Milwaukee Brewers (14-7) are favorites (-115) on the moneyline when they square off against the Pittsburgh Pirates (12-11) Tuesday at 6:40 PM ET, live on SportsNet PT.Milwaukee's Wade Miley and Pittsburgh's Bailey Falter have been named the starters for...

    Rays vs. Tigers Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Tuesday, April 23, 2024

    Amed Rosario (14 games) will look to add to his hitting streak when the Tampa Bay Rays (12-12) and Detroit Tigers (13-10) meet Tuesday at 6:50 PM ET, live on BSSUN from Tropicana Field. Rosario and the Rays are favored...

    Cardinals vs. Diamondbacks Probable Starting Pitchers – April 23

    The St. Louis Cardinals (10-13) host the Arizona Diamondbacks (11-13) for a home game at Busch Stadium on Tuesday. First pitch is at 7:45 PM ET.The probable pitchers are Steven Matz (1-1) for the Cardinals and Tommy Henry for the...

    Astros vs. Cubs Probable Starting Pitchers – April 23

    The Chicago Cubs (13-9) kick off a three-game series on Tuesday against the Houston Astros (7-16). The matchup begins at 7:40 PM ET at Wrigley Field.The probable starters are J.P. France (0-2) for the Astros and Jordan Wicks (0-2) for...

    more cubs news