Let’s Break Down a Suggested Cubs-Braves Trade Involving Shelby Miller and Prospects

shelby miller bravesIf you’re not into football today, here’s a proposed trade for you to discuss, via Jim Duquette:

  • Cubs get Shelby Miller
  • Braves get Willson Contreras and Billy McKinney
  • On its face, this proposal – not a rumor, mind you – makes sense for each team. The Cubs are looking for controlled, impact starters like Miller (and, indeed, are rumored to have checked in on him). The Braves are rebuilding and are looking for young talent.

    But is the value proposition fair for each side?

    Miller, 25, looked might good last year in the times I saw him pitch, and he posted a 3.02/3.45/4.07 ERA/FIP/xFIP over 205.1 innings, and was worth 3.4 WAR. Miller saw a sharp uptick in his groundball rate from when he was with the Cardinals (47.7% last year was nearly top 30 in baseball), and his strikeout rate bounced back up a little bit from 2014 (16.6% to 19.9%). The only bit of results that you could probably chalk up to good fortune was the 6.4% HR/FB ratio, which could regress.

    Given the increased groundball rate, it should be no surprise to see that Miller relied much more heavily on his two-seamer with the Braves than he had with the Cardinals. He also saw his velocity climb a bit. In terms of projecting future performance, I like Miller to be a very solid three-type starter – with the upside to more – over the next few years.

    I mention those years, because those are the three for which he remains under team control. He’s arbitration-eligible for the first time this season, and MLBTR projects him at $4.9 million. Even if you don’t buy Miller’s breakout, and instead think he’s a league-average, two-win-type starter, those guys get about $10 to $15 million in free agency these days, depending on the length of the contract (and other particularities). If Miller’s arb figures go something like $4.9 million, $7.5 million, $10 million, there’s something in the $7.5 to $22.5 million range of surplus value available even if you project Miller to be merely a league average starter. If you believe Miller’s re-emergence last year was legit and sustainable, then the value is considerably higher. (With a younger, less-consistently-established guy like Miller, it’s a little harder to perform a typical surplus value calculation, which is why I’m being more general here.)

    So, then, what’s a guy like that worth?

    [adinserter block=”1″]Well, it seems like it’s been a little while since a guy in Miller’s position (in terms of performance and arbitration position) has been traded for prospects. The one that came to mind for me was back in 2011 when the A’s traded Gio Gonzalez to the Nationals for a package of youngsters, including three of the Nationals’ top ten prospects, all of whom were generally in the top 100 overall at the time. Gonzalez, who was also 25 at the time, was probably seen as a little surer bet, having posted back-to-back three-win seasons. Then again, Miller’s been worth a total 6.9 WAR in his career to date, whereas Gonzalez was at 6.5 WAR.

    Your long story short? Miller’s probably worth multiple top 100 prospect types, at least one of which is going to have to be arguably a near-term “impact” guy.

    Would Contreras and McKinney fit the bill? Well, each will be a top 100 guy when the lists start coming out, and my guess is that you see Contreras uniformly in the top 50 (if not much higher), and McKinney in the 75ish range. It would be painful to part with both in a single deal, but it’s hard to argue that – in terms of value – they aren’t the range you’d be looking at in a deal for Miller.

    Contreras could be a future stud, and McKinney could emerge as fantastic with the bat in the big leagues very soon, but being able to add an arm like Miller for multiple, cost-controlled years without trading away from the big league talent pool would be an impressive feat.

    To be quite clear, none of that is to say that the Cubs would, or even should, do this particular deal. It’s possible that the organization believes so strongly in Contreras’s upside and future behind the plate that they simply wouldn’t deal him at this point absent an even more impressive return. It’s possible the Cubs don’t value Miller all that highly. And so on and so forth.

    I’m saying only that, as I examine this particular proposal, there’s nothing that jumps out to me as absurd on either side.

    Would I pull the trigger on this particular deal? Eh. Maybe. I probably wouldn’t as of today, though. Why? Because free agency is only just getting started. I’d want to get just a little more of a feel on what the Cubs might be able to accomplish with cash before saying yes to giving up this much young impact talent for a starting pitcher. If I knew, for example, that the Cubs were going to be able to get a free agent starter on a reasonable deal AND an outfielder? Then, yeah, maybe I more seriously consider this trade.

    Of course, you don’t always have the luxury of being able to structure your decisions in such a linear fashion.

    Man, this offseason is complicated.

    written by

    Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

    more cubs news

    Justin Steele Injury Update: New Classification, MRI Tomorrow, IL Stint Coming? Steele and Counsell Speak

    A significant update on Justin Steele came from Craig Counsell tonight after the Cubs extra innings loss in Texas. In short: Yes, a stint on the Injured List is likely for Justin Steele. But we still don't know how severe...

    Enhanced Box Score: Rangers 4, Cubs 3 – March 28, 2024

    It took exactly one day for the Cubs' ace to sustain what may be a significant injury, for their closer to blow a save, for the umpires to significantly impact the outcome of a critical play (this time in the...

    OMG: Michael Busch Scored the 9th Inning, GO-AHEAD Run, Because He Just Never Stopped Running

    That was absolutely incredible. To all the little kids out there, when your coach tells you to never stop running, this is why. Rookie Cubs 1B Michael Busch (the guy the Cubs got from the Dodgers this offseason to be...

    Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Rangers – Lineups, Pitching Matchup, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

    *SHORT COURTS: It's Time To Bring The Home Court, Home! Looking for a unique way to celebrate your athlete or team before you peruse the FIRST CHICAGO CUBS LINEUP of the Year? Don't miss out! For just one more week...

    The Cubs Are Among the Most Returning-y Teams

    I am still mostly incapacitated at the moment, so apologies for the short shrift on such an otherwise blessed day. In between pokes and prods, I wanted to share a chart I saw that was pretty interesting, even if unsurprising:...

    Maybe the Cubs Are the Favorites in the NL Central, After All?

    ESPN was the first to throw some love the Cubs way this week, with an overwhelming majority of their writers, analysts, and editors picking the Chicago Cubs to win the NL Central in 2024. But the love doesn't end there....

    The Season Begins, Love for Morel, Counsell’s Value, and Other Cubs Bullets

    You know where you want to spend your Opening Day morning? The hospital! Suffice to say, this is not how I imagined getting HYPED for the Cubs' opener. I guess I'll just have to think about all the possible lineup...

    Cubs vs Rangers: The First Series of the Year!

    Cubs vs Rangers — THE REGULAR SEASON IS HERE! Wake up and rejoice. Later tonight, the Cubs will begin their march toward October Baseball against the (reigning World Series champion) Texas Rangers in Arlington. Justin Steele is getting the nod...

    The 2024 Chicago Cubs for Dummies

    Boom. We made it. The offseason is over, and the Cubs regular season - and those elevated expectations - begins tomorrow. But in case you slept through the winter, I'm here to catch you up on everything you need to...

    I’m Expecting More This Year, Cubs — It’s Time to Start Winning

    There's no way around it: The Chicago Cubs did *not* have the offseason we hoped they might after making Craig Counsell the highest paid manager in MLB history. Not that they did poorly, mind you. Cody Bellinger, Shota Imanaga, and...

    Latest News

    Big Ten Basketball Predictions, Computer Picks and Best Bets | March 29

    There is one game on the postseason college basketball schedule on Friday that feature Big Ten squads, and we have best bets recomendations. That matchup is the Gonzaga Bulldogs versus the Purdue Boilermakers.How to Bet on Big Ten Games[lasso ref="draftkings-promo-1"...

    SEC Basketball Predictions, Computer Picks and Best Bets | March 30

    The Friday postseason college basketball slate includes two games featuring an SEC team in action. Among those games is the Creighton Bluejays playing the Tennessee Volunteers. Here are our recomendations for the best bets on action throughout the conference.How to...

    Big 12 Basketball Predictions, Computer Picks and Best Bets | March 30

    There is one game on the postseason college basketball schedule on Friday that feature Big 12 squads, and we have best bets recomendations. That matchup is the Duke Blue Devils versus the Houston Cougars.How to Bet on Big 12 Games[lasso...

    ACC Basketball Predictions, Computer Picks and Best Bets | March 29

    There are two games on the postseason college basketball schedule on Friday that feature ACC squads, and we have best bets recomendations. That includes the Duke Blue Devils versus the Houston Cougars.How to Bet on ACC Games[lasso rel="draftkings-promo-1" id="299003"]Best ACC...

    Big East Basketball Predictions, Computer Picks and Best Bets | March 29

    There are three games on the postseason college basketball schedule on Friday that feature Big East squads, and we have best bets recomendations. That includes the Creighton Bluejays versus the Tennessee Volunteers.How to Bet on Big East Games[lasso ref="draftkings-promo-1" id="299003"...

    Braves vs. Phillies Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Friday, March 29, 2024

    The Atlanta Braves open their season as -125 favorites in a road matchup with the Philadelphia Phillies on Friday at 3:05 PM ET, live on BSSO.Spencer Strider takes the mound for Atlanta while Zack Wheeler is Philadelphia's starter for the...

    Washington State vs. Illinois Women’s Basketball: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

    Two hot teams meet when the Washington State Cougars (21-14) host the Illinois Fighting Illini (17-15) on April 1, 2024. The Cougars will put their three-game win streak on the line against the Fighting Illini, who have won three straight.On...

    Villanova vs. Penn State Women’s Basketball: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

    The Villanova Wildcats (21-12) will try to extend a three-game winning streak when they host the Penn State Lady Lions (22-12) on April 1, 2024. The Lady Lions have also won three games in a row.In its previous game, Villanova...

    Brewers vs. Mets Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Friday, March 29, 2024

    The Milwaukee Brewers look to start their season with a win as road favorites (-110) in a season-opening matchup with the New York Mets. First pitch is on Friday at 1:40 PM ET on SNY, live from Citi Field.Freddy Peralta...

    Braves vs. Phillies Probable Starting Pitchers – March 29

    The Atlanta Braves (0-0) and the Philadelphia Phillies (0-0) match up on Friday at Citizens Bank Park for Opening Day. First pitch is at 3:05 PM ET.The Braves will look to Spencer Strider versus the Phillies and Zack Wheeler.Braves vs....

    more cubs news