Mike Matheny Takes Issue with Jason Heyward’s Reasons for Choosing the Cubs

mike matheny cardinalsEver since Jason Heyward offered some very candid thoughts on why he chose the Chicago Cubs in free agency over the St. Louis Cardinals, I’ve been waiting for a response out of St. Louis. I wasn’t sure we’d actually get one, because it’s always touchy when talking about a former player who opted to depart for another club – if you say almost anything, you’ll be dubbed salty or whiny or something worse.

Thankfully, Cardinals manager Mike Matheny obliged in this St. Louis Post-Dispatch article, taking on Heyward’s commentary on the aging core in St. Louis (in short, Heyward saw himself fitting better long-term with the younger Cubs core). To his credit, I think Matheny was pretty reasonable in his response.

“I don’t think we have anything to apologize for in having a group like a [Matt] Holliday, a [Yadier] Molina, a[n Adam] Wainwright. Those are the kinds of guys everybody wants on a club,” Matheny told the Post-Dispatch. “I see where [Heyward’s] coming from. I mean, look at what Chicago’s done. It’s very unique in this game — to have that many impact players at that young age. And he’s a young player. But I can’t say I’m in any kind of agreement with that [Chicago] core being better than any kind of core that we have.”

[adinserter block=”1″]There are many more thoughts from Matheny on the issue in the Post-Dispatch article, as well as a deep take on the Cardinals’ odd offseason, and it’s worth a read.

Matheny shifted the discussion rather deftly there, making it about the quality of the core, rather than the youthfulness, though in doing so, I’m not so sure he didn’t highlight the very issue the Cardinals will face in the coming years.

When you think of the Cardinals’ “core”, of whom do you think? Probably those three named players, each of whom is over 30 and dealt with serious injury issues in 2015. Matt Carpenter, too, I’d think, though even he just turned 30.

The Cardinals have many other quality players, but Lance Lynn just had Tommy John surgery, Jhonny Peralta is 33 and was one of the worst hitters in baseball in the second half last year, Matt Adams was hurt last year, and the bullpen is good, but it’s a bullpen.

On the young side, the Cardinals absolutely have some nice pieces – Kolten Wong, Stephen Piscotty, Tommy Pham, Randal Grichuk, Carlos Martinez, and Michael Wacha are all guys any team would like to have – but all come with questions.

If you were comparing the young side of the Cardinals’ “core” – if you’d even include all of those guys – I think it’s pretty easy to see that the Cubs are very far ahead, especially now that Heyward, himself, can be included in their core.

[adinserter block=”2″]The big question for the Cubs, of course, is going to be whether they can continue to have successful starting pitching without getting much of any contribution from the farm system there; or, will the farm system break through in time to pick up the slack after 2017 if Jake Arrieta departs and/or if Jon Lester declines and/or when John Lackey departs and/or when Jason Hammel departs and/or if Kyle Hendricks regresses?

For the long term, I’m not sure the Cardinals are in that much better shape on the pitching side than the Cubs, but I think that’s where you’d make the case if you wanted to argue that Heyward is wrong about what he sees in the future for each club.

In the end, though, I don’t think you can get too excited about an imminent decline of the Cardinals. Yes, much of their most core-iest core players are aging, injured, and/or in decline. But the Cardinals develop young players extraordinarily well, and they also have a ton of financial resources available at their disposal, both because of continued revenue increases and also because that aging core will roll off the books soon.

I do know that the Cubs are better for having signed Heyward, though, and the Cardinals are not better for having lost him.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Dansby Swanson with a First Inning Three-Run Homer

For the second straight night, the Cubs are jumping all over the Astros in the first inning. After a couple hits from Nico Hoerner and Ian Happ to get things going, Michael Busch hit a sac fly, Christopher Morel walked,...

Welcome Back to Iowa, Brennen Davis: Rocket Homer in His First Game Post-Rehab

What a road it's been - continues to be - for Cubs outfield prospect Brennen Davis. The former top prospect was on a rocket ship to Triple-A in 2021, and then mostly lost the last two years to various injuries....

CRAAAAAP: Cody Bellinger to the Injured List (UPDATES)

So much for all those words of optimism and negative X-rays. After colliding with the outfield wall last night, Cody Bellinger fractured his rib (Update: It's actually TWO fractured right ribs) and will hit the injured list today. Chicago Cubs...

Chicago Cubs Lineup: What is it, June 2023?

CUBS LINEUP — The Chicago Cubs took Game 1 against the Houston Astros in convincing fashion last night. So tonight, they'll go for the quick series win against Spencer Arrighetti at Wrigley Field (it'd be a good idea to win...

Bellinger Optimistic Post-Injury, Busch’s Defense, Almonte Stock Rising, Tauchman Slugging, and Other Cubs Bullets

Ed. Note: Since this article was published, a CT scan revealed a rib fracture for Cody Bellinger, who is now on the Injured List. You can find all the details of that news in our most recent article right here....

Cubs Outfield Prospect Pete Crow-Armstrong Coming Up

With Cody Bellinger headed to the Injured List with a rib fracture, the Cubs are in need of another outfielder: center field prospect Pete Crow-Armstrong is coming back up to the big leagues for the second time. https://twitter.com/670TheScore/status/1783217891195625709 Crow-Armstrong, 22,...

Is Mike Tauchman the Best Player in Baseball? An Exploration

Hey, we're just having some early-season fun. So allow me to present the 'Mike Tauchman Is Clearly Better Than' list. As of this moment, Mike Tauchman has ... ... a higher wRC+ (151) than Pete Alonso, Fernando Tatis Jr., and...

Cubs Farm Report | April 24, 2024: Kevin Alcántara Cannot Miss Right Now

Name a player hotter than Kevin Alcántara right now. Go ahead, I'll wait. (He's already raking again today. Literally as I type this.) More on Alcántara's big day and the Smokies home run parade last night in today's Cubs Farm...

Oof: Blake Snell to the Injured List Just Three Horrible Starts into His Giants Career

Just three starts into his San Francisco Giants career, Blake Snell is heading to the injured list with a left-adductor strain. Oof. You hate to even say it — and who really knows if this was related — but early...

It’s Gotten Impossible to Not Comment on the White Sox Making Futility History

In 1997, I was a miserable Chicago Cubs fan. I mean, that was true a lot of the time, but I mean it in a very specific way that year: the Cubs had started the season 0-14. They had literally...

Latest News

Brewers vs. Pirates Probable Starting Pitchers – April 25

The Milwaukee Brewers (15-8) and the Pittsburgh Pirates (13-12) square off in Pittsburgh on Thursday. First pitch is at 12:35 PM ET at PNC Park.The Brewers will call on Freddy Peralta (2-0) against the Pirates and Mitch Keller (2-2).Brewers vs....

Golden Knights vs. Stars NHL Playoffs First Round Game 3 Prediction: Odds, Picks, Best Bets – Saturday, April 27, 2024

The oddsmakers have the Vegas Golden Knights at -120 on the moneyline, and the Dallas Stars at +100, for their matchup on Saturday, April 27 at 10:30 PM ET.Golden Knights vs. Stars Favorite, Moneyline, TotalFavorite: Golden Knights (-120)Underdog: Stars (+100)Total:...

How to Watch Guardians vs. Red Sox: Live Stream or on TV

The Cleveland Guardians (17-7), led by Josh Naylor, host Tyler O'Neill and the Boston Red Sox (14-11) at 1:10 PM ET on Thursday in the rubber match of the series.The article below will give you everything you need to know...

Maple Leafs vs. Bruins NHL Playoffs First Round Game 4 Prediction: Live Odds, Stats, History and Picks – Saturday, April 27, 2024

The oddsmakers have the Toronto Maple Leafs at -112 on the moneyline, and the Boston Bruins at -108, for their matchup on Saturday, April 27 at 8:00 PM ET.Maple Leafs vs. Bruins Favorite, Moneyline, TotalFavorite: Maple Leafs (-112)Underdog: Bruins (-108)Total:...

How to Watch Mariners vs. Rangers: Live Stream or on TV

On Thursday at 2:35 PM ET, Caleb Raleigh and the Seattle Mariners (12-12) take on Adolis Garcia and the Texas Rangers (13-12) at Globe Life Field.See how to watch the Seattle-Texas matchup below.When is Mariners vs. Rangers and when does...

Padres vs. Rockies: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The San Diego Padres (14-13), led by Fernando Tatis Jr., visit Ryan McMahon and the Colorado Rockies (6-19) at 3:10 PM ET on Thursday.See how to watch the San Diego-Colorado matchup below.When is Padres vs. Rockies and when does it...

2024 Las Vegas Raiders Big Board: Potential First-Round Fits Including Tackle & Cornerback

The desert heat is rising in Las Vegas, and so are the expectations for the Raiders. The 2024 NFL Draft is rapidly approaching, and the Silver and Black hold the 13th overall pick. Will they prioritize shoring up the offensive...

Twins vs. White Sox: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Minnesota Twins (10-13), led by Ryan Jeffers and aiming for a series sweep, host Gavin Sheets and the Chicago White Sox (3-21) at 1:10 PM ET on Thursday.See how to watch the Minnesota-Chicago matchup below.When is Twins vs. White...

Astros vs. Cubs: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Thursday, trying to prevent a series sweep, Justin Verlander takes the mound for the Houston Astros (7-18) against Javier Assad and the Chicago Cubs (15-9), with first pitch scheduled for 2:20 PM ET.Find out how to watch the Houston-Chicago...

Royals vs. Blue Jays: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Kansas City Royals (15-10), led by Salvador Perez, host Daulton Varsho and the Toronto Blue Jays (13-12) on Thursday at 2:10 PM ET.The article below will provide you with everything you need to watch Kansas City play Toronto.When is...

more cubs news