Lukewarm Stove: Kemp Trade, Lucroy, Bruce, Davis, Rays Starters, Moore, More

old stove featureThe BN Blogathon starts bright and early tomorrow morning at 5am CT, and I am READY.

I’ll be writing, tweeting, live-streaming, snapping, and everything else about the Cubs and activity around the league – constantly – for 39 hours straight, leading up to and past Monday’s MLB Trade Deadline. That’s because you all were so very generous in your donations to Make-A-Wish (it’s not too late to give, by the way!).

I’ll also be doing portions of the Blogathon from spots around Wrigleyville, which hopefully adds a little fun. That’ll include tomorrow night’s game against the Mariners (which is going to be challenging, to say the least – the reception there, when the place is packed, is not always great).

So, if you want maximum coverage during the Blogathon, make sure you’re not only checking the site, but also following on Twitter, liking on Facebook, and adding me on Snapchat.

All right, a set of rumors and news as you wind down your evening, and I get ready to hopefully sleep very soundly …[adinserter block=”1″]

  • The big news of the afternoon, of course, was the Pirates trading closer Mark Melancon to the Nationals, which we discussed earlier. That doesn’t mean they’re selling off or waving a white flag, though, and Ken Rosenthal says they’ve talked to the Rays, among other teams, about picking up a starting pitcher.
  • And that wasn’t the only big trade of the day, with the Padres sending Matt Kemp (wait, wuh?) to the Braves (HUH?) for Hector Olivera (WHAT IN THE WORLD IS HAPPENING?!?!?!). Although certainly strange for the players and teams involved, the deal actually makes plenty of sense when you dig in: the Padres are sending some cash along with Kemp, but they’re still saving money even when accounting for adding Olivera’s contract (he’s expected to be dropped). So then, the Padres save money while they rebuild, and the Braves get Kemp for the next three years for around $15 million total. Kemp is nothing like he was five years ago, but $5 million per year on a chance he can still be useful? Why not?
  • Brewers catcher Jonathan Lucroy has been in rumors for over a year, but it now finally seems like he will be traded. The 30-year-old catcher (who is under control through 2017 on a cheap team option) has rebounded in a big way in 2016 after a down 2015, and he’s going to be a huge upgrade for some playoff hopeful team. Which one? No one seems to know for sure right now, but the Brewers have admitted that they’re holding Lucroy out of the lineup tonight (and presumably tomorrow as well, if necessary) because talks have progressed. Right now, the best guess on the teams:
  • A lot of folks have asked me if I think the Cubs could be involved, and I really don’t. So much of Lucroy’s value is that 2017 club option, and because of it, the price tag in trade is going to be enormous. Would the Cubs pay that much in trade, knowing that they’ve got Willson Contreras ready to go for next year, Miguel Montero already under contract for $14 million, and Kyle Schwarber returning from injury (and theoretically plausible for a start a week)? The 2016 Cubs would unquestionably be better with Lucroy – almost every team would be – but he’s not a rental. And the Cubs have three catchers on the roster as is. No, it hasn’t been a bright spot overall, but it hasn’t been the disaster some would have you believe.
  • [adinserter block=”2″]

  • The other big NL Central name being bandied about on the rumor mill is Reds outfielder Jay Bruce, who is also controlled through 2017 via a team option. Briefly connected to the Cubs, Bruce is another guy who I don’t see the Cubs making a major push for, mostly for the same reasons I just laid out with respect to Lucroy (just change the catcher stuff to outfield stuff). Also, Bruce’s defense is frighteningly bad. In any event, it does sound like lots of serious trade talks are going on around the league involving Bruce, and something is likely to happen.
  • Oof for the Royals, as trade chip (and closer, if they don’t sell) Wade Davis is having an MRI on his forearm. Remember those rumors that the Royals were demanding more for Davis than the Yankees were for Andrew Miller? About that …
  • Similarly, Rich Hill is now on the DL with his blister issue, which is going to make it very difficult for the A’s to maximize his trade value. The timing could not have been worse for them, especially given how thin the starting pitching trade market is.
  • That market gets a lot better if the White Sox seriously entertain offers for ace Chris Sale. Sounds like they are kinda considering offers, but only huge ones:
  • [adinserter block=”3″]

  • Jon Heyman dropped a column today with a ton of bits on every team, including speculation that, despite all the rumors, the Rays won’t ultimately end up trading anyone. Speaking of which:
  • Moore, 27, is controlled via team options the next three years ($7.5 million, $9 million, and $10 million), which would make him exceedingly attractive … if you knew what you were going to get. It’s clear that Moore isn’t the guy he was before Tommy John surgery, and his numbers overall this year are pretty middling. Getting Moore would be a bet on continued improvement – it’s a bet I’d be interested in seeing the Cubs take, since they’ll need arms with upside in the coming years, but I don’t think they should give up a significant haul to get Moore. It all depends a bit on what scouts are seeing, and what they think Moore can be next year when he’s even further removed from surgery.
  • Wade Miley may have gotten himself traded with his great performance today against the Cubs. That’s a bit of an exaggeration, but I’m serious: the guy looked ridiculously good. I don’t know what’s gone wrong for him the rest of the year, but the guy I saw today would make any team better.
  • By the way, I think it’s safe to believe that the Yankees really, truly were not going to trade Andrew Miller for anything less than Kyle Schwarber:
  • I’m about as Miller-happy as anyone, but the best pitching prospect in baseball for a guy signed to a regular-ole free agent contract? Yes please.
  • written by

    Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

    more cubs news

    Chicago Cubs 2025 Draft Position and Lottery Odds

    With the regular season in the rearview, the 2025 MLB Draft Lottery Odds are now fully set, as well as the spot where the Chicago Cubs will be picking after the first round. The Cubs this year finished with the...

    Good Regular Season Teams Losing in the Playoffs, Sustainability, Spin, Diamond Bankruptcy, and Other Cubs Bullets

    The sweeps yesterday almost left us without a playoff game today. But the Mets did some Metsing and the Brewers evened up that series. Now they play a decisive game three tonight at 6:08pm CT on ESPN. Going back a...

    MLB Playoffs Highlights: Three Sweeps and a Whoopsie

    The 2024 MLB playoffs opened up yesterday with four Wild Card series games, the outcomes of which were generally pleasing to me … Tigers 5, Astros 2 – Detroit Wins Series 2-0 For the first time in EIGHT YEARS, the...

    Cam Smith’s Kinda Outrageous First Year and His Visit to Wrigley Field

    Although more established Chicago Cubs prospects are going to get the bulk of the after-season attention for the big years they had, I still think about how incredible Cam Smith's pro debut was. The 21-year-old Florida State third baseman, who...

    Blue Jays President Won’t Call Vlad Guerrero Jr. a “Generational Player,” and I Declare That Vladito Must Demand a Trade

    I do not care about details or nuance. I am choosing to believe this means Vlad Guerrero Jr. is on the trade block and DESPERATELY wants to get out of Toronto. TAKE OFFENSE: https://twitter.com/CBSSportsMLB/status/1841529053834105164 https://twitter.com/bnicholsonsmith/status/1841497396989120963 HOW DARE YOU?! Vladito, you...

    The Initial 2025 Cubs Arbitration Projections Are Out

    Although the MLB offseason doesn't officially begin until five days after the World Series comes to an end, we did hit a couple of key offseason landmarks this week. Yesterday, Jed Hoyer delivered the annual end-of-season press conference. And today,...

    Cody Bellinger and Jed Hoyer on the Opt-Out Decision

    One of the more consequential moments in the coming offseason for the Chicago Cubs is more or less going to be entirely out of their control. Shortly after the end of the World Series, Cody Bellinger can walk back into...

    Quiet on Injuries, Brown’s Timeline, Heyward, Posey, Brewers Set Mark, and Other Cubs Bullets

    The nice thing about the playoffs is just having meaningful baseball games perpetually on in the background in the family room. We can kinda look in, look out, watch when free, focus on other things when not. I don't have...

    MLB Playoffs Highlights: Mets, Tigers, Royals, and Padres Open With Wins

    The 2024 MLB playoffs opened up yesterday with four Wild Card series games, the outcomes of which were generally pleasing to me ... Tigers 3, Astros 1 - Detroit Leads Series 1-0 American League Triple Crown-winning pitcher (that's a thing,...

    Two Cubs Prospects Land on the All-MiLB Prospects Second Team

    Some post-season plaudits for a couple top Chicago Cubs prospects, as third baseman Matt Shaw and catcher/DH Moises Ballesteros made the All-MiLB Prospects Second Team. https://twitter.com/smokiesbaseball/status/1841195310804070504 From the MLB Pipeline write-up on each: "3B: Matt Shaw, Cubs (No. 1/MLB No....

    Latest News

    Blackhawks College Pipeline Well Represented on ‘Players to Watch’ List

    There are college preseason games this weekend, which is fabulous for those of us who are keeping track of the Blackhawks' pipeline beyond Rockford. Ryan Kennedy at The Hockey News dropped his list of the top 100 collegiate players to...

    Ayo Dosunmu Has High Praise for Matas Buzelis, Jalen Smith Knows It’s a Rebuild, and Other Bulls Bullets

    Only hours after posting a welcome photo of Marcus Domask on their social media, the Chicago Bulls gave the training camp invite the boot. Ouch. https://www.bleachernation.com/bulls/2024/10/02/chicago-bulls-tc-move Kenny Lofton Jr, EJ Liddell, and Talen Horton-Tucker remain on the battlefield. All three...

    Brewers vs. Mets Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – NL Wild Card Game 3

    The Milwaukee Brewers will host the New York Mets in the decisive game of the NL Wild Card Series on Thursday at 7:08 p.m. ET, live on ESPN from American Family Field. The teams split the first two games of...

    Swift’s Resurgence, What Happened to Herbert? Davante’s Trade Preferences, and Other Bears Bullets

    Oh, hey! Happy Thursday. I can't believe you just snuck up on me like that (even though I know that Thursday always comes after Wednesday). How did that happen? Kevin Fishbain (The Athletic) goes to the All-22 to explore how...

    Brewers vs. Mets Probable Starting Pitchers – NL Wild Card Game 3

    The New York Mets (89-73) and the Milwaukee Brewers (93-69) square off at American Family Field on Thursday at 7:08 p.m. ET.The probable starters are Tobias Myers (9-6, 3.00 ERA) for the Brewers and Jose Quintana (10-10, 3.75 ERA) for...

    Fantasy Football Start ‘Em Sit ‘Em: Week 5 Players to Upgrade & Tough Matchups

    Fantasy football start 'em sit 'em strategy is a pivotal part of the game. It revolves around the weekly challenge of deciding which players from your fantasy team should be in action and who should take a backseat. These decisions are...

    China Open Schedule Friday, October 4: Matchups & TV/Live Stream Info

    There are two matches at the China Open on October 4, highlighted by No. 22-ranked Mirra Andreeva versus No. 7 Qinwen Zheng. Looking to keep up with the action? The Tennis Channel provides live coverage and highlights of all the...

    Week 5 Fantasy Football Sleepers & Starts: Geno Smith, Xavier Worthy

    Fantasy football sleepers are players who are expected to outperform their preseason expectations and provide excellent value for fantasy team owners. Week 5 of the NFL season is always full of surprises, and it's important to move with the tide of...

    Good Regular Season Teams Losing in the Playoffs, Sustainability, Spin, Diamond Bankruptcy, and Other Cubs Bullets

    The sweeps yesterday almost left us without a playoff game today. But the Mets did some Metsing and the Brewers evened up that series. Now they play a decisive game three tonight at 6:08pm CT on ESPN. Going back a...

    MLB Playoffs Highlights: Three Sweeps and a Whoopsie

    The 2024 MLB playoffs opened up yesterday with four Wild Card series games, the outcomes of which were generally pleasing to me … Tigers 5, Astros 2 – Detroit Wins Series 2-0 For the first time in EIGHT YEARS, the...

    more cubs news