If Roster Sizes Increase to 26, What Are the Side Effects?

travis-wood-curtain-callHave you been obsessively watching the ongoing, but deadline-impending CBA negotiations like we have?

To briefly catch you up to date, the previous Collective Bargaining Agreement expires on December 1, which means the players and owners have just two days to find some common ground before we get into some unnerving territory.

Among the many other interesting proposals, rumors of adding a 26th man to the regular season roster have been making their rounds. Indeed, it sure sounds like the 26th man idea is gaining steam and might actually be something new in 2017. It would help with roster management, and also could allow for small roster expansion in September.

Given our proximity to the season (pitchers and catchers report in 75 days!), it might be worth examining the implications of an extra man on the average roster. Tom Verducci (Sports Illustrated) and Dave Cameron (FanGraphs) already got us started.

[adinserter block=”1″]

And it’s Verducci who expresses the biggest concern over the potential roster change: “Baseball’s owners and players have talked about expanding rosters to 26 men as part of the collective bargaining agreement negotiations. If they do so without limitations on pitcher usage, it will be the worst thing to happen to the sport since Astroturf and threaten to end the game’s period of record growth.”

Of course, the issue Verducci raises is the idea that every team will jump to add another reliever to their bullpen, which can be a serious problem for the sport. More available pitchers, in today’s game, necessarily means more pitching changes and match-up improvements. And that is a two-fold problem: more pitching changes means more downtime in the action and depressed offense.

I’m fairly confident that if you asked the commissioner about the two biggest long-term existential threats facing baseball today, he’d tell you about pace-of-play and a depressed offensive environment. So, yeah, maybe a 26th man without any additional pitching restrictions might not be the best idea.

[adinserter block=”2″]

JJ Cooper explains why this is the case:

Essentially, teams and their managers utilize strategies to win. Full stop. They do not (and should not) have to worry about whether their calls make for a compelling and enjoyable game. Instead, they are worried solely about getting the W at the end of the day. Baseball, as an entity, has to think bigger than that, even if it means cutting off some useful strategies. Baseball needs to produce drama with its rules, and the managers can adjust their strategies to meet those rules.

The alternative, I fear, is a far less compelling game.

One way to combat this problem, according to Verducci, is to limit the total number of pitchers on the roster to 13 (effectively forcing teams to add a bench bat, which could actually help alleviate match-up problems later in the game), and/or forcing every pitcher that enters the game to face a minimum of two batters. You’d surely think twice about bringing in your LOOGY to face Kyle Schwarber if Kris Bryant was on deck behind him.

[adinserter block=”3″]

Check out Sports Illustrated for much more on the subject (including data on how relievers are being used now far more than they have ever been before).

Dave Cameron illustrates a similar work-around, suggesting that MLB can simply differentiate between hitters and pitchers, while allowing a fixed number of each on the roster. Or, similarly, differentiating between relievers and starters, while allowing a fixed number of each. A useful idea, though both could present a similar challenge.

That being, some relievers are swing starters, sixth starters, etc., and are/have been used in multiple roles. Forcing them to remain in the bullpen doesn’t really solve the “too many pitching changes” problem, and it does present a number of potential issues and eventually loopholes. To be fair, Cameron acknowledges this with respect to starters and relievers. However, he does believe that differentiating between hitters and pitchers is an easy enough fix, should MLB decide to go this route.

HOWEVA, I believe that presents issues, as well.

[adinserter block=”4″]

In 2016, we saw Travis Wood (for one example) take at bats, and play left field. Rare I know, but it happened (and he did this! and this!). We also saw Miguel Montero toss 1.1 innings off the mound. In 2015, we saw each of David Ross and Chris Denorfia pitch 2.1 innings of baseball. Again, I know it’s rare, but it does happen. So what’s the call when a team runs out of pitchers or bench players? Is the game over, or is that an exception to the rule limiting certain types of players on the roster? What if a team hasn’t run out of pitchers, but the only “pitcher” they have left is a reliever who’s already thrown three days in a row? Can a position player pitch at that point? You see the issue.

Then, of course, there’s the impending craziness of a guy like Shohei Otani playing both ways, and who knows what that’ll mean for the rule. Point being: MLB would have to figure out how to deal with managers/teams that use players on both sides of the ball.

The previous CBA expires in two days, hopefully we’ll get answers to many of these questions soon.

written by

Michael Cerami began covering the Chicago Cubs for Bleacher Nation as a part-time contributor in 2015. One year later, he joined Bleacher Nation full-time, covering the Chicago Cubs and Major League Baseball. Today, Michael runs Bleacher Nation, contributing as a writer (Cubs, MLB) and an editor for all sections of the site, including the Chicago Bears, Bulls, and Blackhawks, as well as MLB, NBA, NHL, and NFL. In 2019, Michael was the co-host of NBC Sports Chicago's Cubs Post-Game Show Outside the Ivy. You can find him on Twitter/X @Michael_Cerami

more cubs news

Wrigley Field is Gonna Be Lit This Year (As in New Colored Lights!)

Last year, the Cubs started using their new LED outfield lights to do a little dancing display during 'Go Cubs Go,' lighting along with the song and throwing in a W. It was very fun and I liked it. This...

The 2024 Chicago Cubs for Dummies

Boom. We made it. The offseason is over, and the Cubs regular season - and those elevated expectations - begins tomorrow. But in case you slept through the winter, I'm here to catch you up on everything you need to...

Why Craig Counsell Wanted Miles Mastrobuoni on the Cubs’ Bench

I don't know why Miles Mastrobuoni bugs some folks, but it's probably heavily-weighted toward his small-sample, bad-batted-ball-luck start last year, and that time he didn't dive while playing in right field. It can be hard to shake initial impressions, I...

Kinda Sounds Like Craig Counsell May Have a Set Top Three in the Batting Order

New Chicago Cubs manager Craig Counsell has said, generally, his batting order philosophy is the very simplistic (and very correct): just get your best hitters the most at bats. Sure, there's some play in that to set up good match-ups,...

Los Angeles Dodgers Signing Will Smith to a TEN-YEAR Extension

The Los Angeles Dodgers have done it again. And by it, I mean they have signed a funkily-structured contract that is going to leave some folks annoyed. The Dodgers are extending catcher Will Smith on a DECADE-long deal with a...

The Stretch: 2024 MLB Season Preview

On Monday, during a team-building conversation with some of the Bleacher Nation and Betsperts Media Group folks, we discussed sports—shocking, I know—and Brian Twining asked the group what their favorite sport was. For me, it's baseball. There's no debate. I...

We Have to Talk About Some of the “Deals” the Cubs Sat Out in Free Agency

This week, in a conversation with Jon Greenberg at The Athletic, Cubs President Jed Hoyer made an honest and sober (but also moderately disappointing) admission about the 2024 Chicago Cubs: "We need to perform probably at or a little bit...

The Chicago Cubs Are Reportedly Now Worth Over $5 Billion

Given all the tumult in the baseball broadcasting world, and the uncertain future for that portion of revenues, you'd be forgiven for expecting that MLB franchise valuations would slow their recent surge. But, according to Sportico at least, you'd be...

Reds Second Baseman Matt McLain Had Shoulder Surgery

The injury to Matt McLain's shoulder issue obviously wound up being worse than he and the Cincinnati Reds had been hoping. The damage to his left (non-throwing) labrum ultimately required surgery: https://twitter.com/m_sheldon/status/1772993402604339478 When the hope is that a guy can...

Cubs Actually Getting a Whole Lot of Votes to Win the NL Central

ESPN dropped its big season preview, and included were a set of divisional predictions by way of their writers, editors, and analysts voting. There's nothing in the way of proof or certainty there, but with 26 voters, I do like...

Latest News

Celtics vs. Hawks Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Atlanta Hawks (33-39) are big, 17.5-point underdogs as they attempt to build on a three-game winning streak when they host the Boston Celtics (57-15) on Thursday, March 28, 2024 at State Farm Arena. The matchup airs at 7:30 PM...

Celtics vs. Hawks Predictions, Best Bets and Odds – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The Atlanta Hawks (33-39) are big, 17.5-point underdogs as they attempt to build on a three-game winning streak when they host the Boston Celtics (57-15) on Thursday, March 28, 2024 at State Farm Arena. The contest airs at 7:30 PM...

Bucks vs. Pelicans Predictions, Best Bets and Odds – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The New Orleans Pelicans (44-28) are only 2-point underdogs against the Milwaukee Bucks (46-26) at Smoothie King Center on Thursday, March 28, 2024. The game begins at 8:00 PM ET on NBA. The matchup's point total is 223.If you are...

How to Watch Indiana State Sycamores vs. Utah Utes: Live Stream or on TV

The Indiana State Sycamores (31-6) will attempt to build on a three-game winning streak when they host the Utah Utes (22-14) on April 2, 2024. The Utes have also won three games in a row.Indiana State won its most recent...

How to Watch Seton Hall Pirates vs. Georgia Bulldogs: Live Stream or on TV

The Seton Hall Pirates (23-12) will attempt to extend a three-game win streak when they host the Georgia Bulldogs (20-16) on April 2, 2024. The Bulldogs have also won three games in a row.In its previous game, Seton Hall beat...

Diamondbacks vs. Rockies: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Arizona Diamondbacks, led by Corbin Carroll, take on Nolan Jones and the Colorado Rockies in their first game of the season, at 10:10 PM ET on Thursday.If you're trying to watch this game, keep reading for streaming and TV...

Mariners vs. Red Sox: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Seattle Mariners, led by Julio Rodriguez, square off against Rafael Devers and the Boston Red Sox in their opening game of the season, at 10:10 PM ET on Thursday.If you're trying to watch this game, keep reading for streaming...

Guardians vs. Athletics: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

In their season opener on Thursday, Jose Ramirez and the Cleveland Guardians face Brent Rooker and the Oakland Athletics, with first pitch scheduled for 10:07 PM ET at Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum.The article below will give you everything you need to...

Senators vs. Blackhawks Prediction: Picks, Live Odds and Moneyline – Thursday, March 28, 2024

The bookmakers give the edge to the Ottawa Senators on home ice (-198) over the Chicago Blackhawks (+164) when they face off on Thursday, March 28 at 7:00 PM ET.Senators vs. Blackhawks Favorite, Moneyline, TotalFavorite: Senators (-198)Underdog: Blackhawks (+164)Total: 6.5Best...

Wrigley Field is Gonna Be Lit This Year (As in New Colored Lights!)

Last year, the Cubs started using their new LED outfield lights to do a little dancing display during 'Go Cubs Go,' lighting along with the song and throwing in a W. It was very fun and I liked it. This...

more cubs news