Yo, How About Eddie Butler’s Fantastic Cubs Debut, Eh? And Other Bullets

Friends of ours just had a baby at the same place we had The Littlest Girl, so we got to take a stroll down near-term memory lane this morning going to visit them. It’s wild how much of that process feels like a blur already, but being in the same place where we first met our third kiddo definitely put me into a happy mood.

Cubs win last night helped, too. Although it’s been a frustrating start to the season for a pre-season-heralded, World-Series-champion-defending Cubs team, I do at least take some tiny bit of extra joy from the fact that a win like last night – even in early May – can still get me really jacked up when it comes in St. Louis against a first place Cardinals team. That was a good win, folks.

  • Like I said last night in the EBS, what an interesting Cubs debut for Eddie Butler. The 26-year-old former top prospect held the Cardinals scoreless through six innings, allowing just two hits (one of which was a bunt), striking out five and walking three. He gave up almost exclusively weak contact, and kept Cardinals batters off balance with a combination of two-seamers, four-seamers, cutters, curveballs, and changeups. He has the diverse mix that you’d want in a starter, and the ability (it seemed) to go more to the pitches that were working for him as the night went on. I was definitely not expecting to see such an effective four-seamer up in the zone from him, and I also didn’t expect him to be hitting 97(!)mph. Some of that was assuredly his own level of excitement and a desire to make the most of his debut opportunity with the Cubs, and it did look like he had a lot of effort in his delivery (which, combined with the crossfire style (albeit from the first base side, unlike Jake Arrieta, who goes from the third base side), yielded some clear wildness). All in all, though, it was just impossible to watch and not see the bones of a very good starting pitcher there. The results he got last night were not a fluke, predicated on great defense. The Cardinals simply did not see or anticipate the ball well.
  • In sum: don’t get too high or too low with any one start (especially a first start, when the other team has little on which to scout the guy), but it is totally fair to say that what we saw last night was legit.
  • Even Willson Contreras said he didn’t know Butler could sit at 95/96mph with his fastball, and when he saw how much juice Butler was getting, he decided to ride that pitch even more (Cubs.com).
  • (Photo by Dilip Vishwanat/Getty Images)

  • Not-so-fun note in this ESPN write-up on Butler’s desire to hold onto the rotation spot: the Cubs were officially the last team in baseball to have a starting pitcher hit 95mph. Butler will get at least one more start, by the way. Which, well, obviously at this point.
  • If you missed it earlier, Kris Bryant won’t play again today (illness), and the Cubs are kind of a mess on the health front.
  • Matt Szczur led off for the Padres last night, his second start in as many games since the Cubs traded him – hey, we always said there were teams out there that would give him a shot – and he immediately took to the role:
  • Padres Chairman Ron Fowler also said in an interview that they tried to get Szczur from the Cubs in the spring but were rebuffed. While I have no doubts that it’s true talks occurred, I can only assume not much was being offered at the time, because you’ll recall, the Cubs were pretty clearly open to moving Szczur at that time (out of options, roster crunch, outfield depth, etc.). In other words, I’m guessing any offers on Szczur this spring were not much more (or not more at all) than the relief prospect they received in Justin Hancock (who made his debut at AA with a 2 K inning yesterday, by the way).
  • Over at Baseball is Fun, Michael throws back to a classic Jim Leyland umpire argument … interrupted by ‘God Bless America.’
  • A very high-capacity portable charger for your electronics is on a 58% off sale at Amazon, and also ‘Reader’s Digest’ is on a ridiculous sale for just $9 if you want to check that out (yes, we do get ‘Reader’s Digest’ – we read at a 70th grade level).
  • written by

    Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

    more cubs news

    REPORT: Cincinnati Reds Hiring Terry Francona as Manager

    I gotta say, I'm a little bit stunned. I didn't think the Cincinnati Reds quite had it in them to do what it would take to lure a top-tier manager this offseason, but apparently it's happening. Terry Francona is coming...

    The Brewers Blew a 9th Inning Lead to Get Bounced from the Playoffs by the Mets

    The Milwaukee Brewers were a better team than the Chicago Cubs this season. Much, much better, actually. But the outcome for the Brewers, in the end, winds up pretty similar to the one for the Cubs: home by October 4....

    Sammy Sosa Talks About a Cubs Reunion, Past Mistakes

    Sammy Sosa was back in Chicago this past weekend for, among other things, a Club 400 fundraiser in support of Cubs fans in need. It was just Sosa's second visit to Chicago since 2007, but encouragingly, both of those visits...

    Chicago Cubs 2025 Draft Position and Lottery Odds

    With the regular season in the rearview, the 2025 MLB Draft Lottery Odds are now fully set, as well as the spot where the Chicago Cubs will be picking after the first round. The Cubs this year finished with the...

    Good Regular Season Teams Losing in the Playoffs, Sustainability, Spin, Diamond Bankruptcy, and Other Cubs Bullets

    The sweeps yesterday almost left us without a playoff game today. But the Mets did some Metsing and the Brewers evened up that series. Now they play a decisive game three tonight at 6:08pm CT on ESPN. Going back a...

    MLB Playoffs Highlights: Three Sweeps and a Whoopsie

    The 2024 MLB playoffs opened up yesterday with four Wild Card series games, the outcomes of which were generally pleasing to me … Tigers 5, Astros 2 – Detroit Wins Series 2-0 For the first time in EIGHT YEARS, the...

    Cam Smith’s Kinda Outrageous First Year and His Visit to Wrigley Field

    Although more established Chicago Cubs prospects are going to get the bulk of the after-season attention for the big years they had, I still think about how incredible Cam Smith's pro debut was. The 21-year-old Florida State third baseman, who...

    Blue Jays President Won’t Call Vlad Guerrero Jr. a “Generational Player,” and I Declare That Vladito Must Demand a Trade

    I do not care about details or nuance. I am choosing to believe this means Vlad Guerrero Jr. is on the trade block and DESPERATELY wants to get out of Toronto. TAKE OFFENSE: https://twitter.com/CBSSportsMLB/status/1841529053834105164 https://twitter.com/bnicholsonsmith/status/1841497396989120963 HOW DARE YOU?! Vladito, you...

    The Initial 2025 Cubs Arbitration Projections Are Out

    Although the MLB offseason doesn't officially begin until five days after the World Series comes to an end, we did hit a couple of key offseason landmarks this week. Yesterday, Jed Hoyer delivered the annual end-of-season press conference. And today,...

    Cody Bellinger and Jed Hoyer on the Opt-Out Decision

    One of the more consequential moments in the coming offseason for the Chicago Cubs is more or less going to be entirely out of their control. Shortly after the end of the World Series, Cody Bellinger can walk back into...

    Latest News

    Where to Watch Union Berlin vs. Borussia Dortmund: TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

    Union Berlin (ninth in the Bundesliga) and Borussia Dortmund (fifth) will face each other at An der alten Forsterei on Saturday at 9:30 AM ET.Watch Bundesliga matches on Fubo! Use our link to start a free trial now.Union Berlin vs....

    Where to Watch Manchester City vs. Fulham: TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

    Erling Haaland, first in the Premier League with eight goals, and Raul Jimenez, ninth with three goals, will be on display when Manchester City hosts Fulham on October 5, 2024.Watch Premier League matches on Fubo! Use our link to start...

    Where to Watch Leicester City vs. AFC Bournemouth: TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

    Two teams in the bottom half of the Premier League table, Leicester City (17th) and AFC Bournemouth (11th), square off on Saturday at 10:00 AM ET.Watch Premier League matches on Fubo! Use our link to start a free trial now.Leicester...

    Where to Watch Espanyol vs. RCD Mallorca: TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

    The sixth-place team in LaLiga, RCD Mallorca, visits 17th-place Espanyol on Saturday at 8:00 AM ET.Watch LaLiga matches on Fubo! Use our link to start a free trial now.Espanyol vs. Mallorca TV & Live Stream InfoWhen: Saturday, October 5, 2024...

    Where to Watch Arsenal FC vs. Southampton FC: TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

    The No. 2 defensive team in the Premier League meets one of the worst offensive squads in the league when Arsenal FC (five goals allowed) hosts Southampton FC (three goals scored, No. 20 in league) at 10:00 AM ET on...

    Where to Watch Brentford FC vs. Wolverhampton Wanderers: TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

    Bryan Mbeumo (No. 3 in the Premier League, five goals), leads Brentford FC at home against Wolverhampton Wanderers, which has conceded 16 goals (20th in the league). The match is on Saturday at 10:00 AM ET.Watch Premier League matches on...

    Where to Watch Udinese vs. US Lecce: TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

    The eighth-place club in Serie A, Udinese, hosts 18th-place US Lecce on Saturday at 9:00 AM ET.Watch Serie A matches on Fubo! Use our link to start a free trial now.Udinese vs. US Lecce TV & Live Stream InfoWhen: Saturday,...

    Where to Watch Crystal Palace vs. Liverpool FC: TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

    Two clubs at opposite ends of the standings in the Premier League, Liverpool FC (first) and Crystal Palace (18th), play at 7:30 AM ET on Saturday.Watch Premier League matches on Fubo! Use our link to start a free trial now.Crystal...

    Where to Watch VfL Bochum vs. VfL Wolfsburg: TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

    The Bundesliga's 17th-place club, VfL Bochum, hosts 13th-place VfL Wolfsburg on Saturday at 9:30 AM ET.Watch Bundesliga matches on Fubo! Use our link to start a free trial now.VfL Bochum vs. VfL Wolfsburg TV & Live Stream InfoWhen: Saturday, October...

    Where to Watch Bayer Leverkusen vs. Holstein Kiel: TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

    A pair of the top scorers in the Bundesliga will will be on display when Florian Wirtz's Bayer Leverkusen hosts Shuto Machino's Holstein Kiel on Saturday at 9:30 AM ET. Wirtz has four goals on the season, and Machino has...

    more cubs news