Would You Rather: Five Cubs Choices for the Coming Season

A friend in a text thread sent me this (thanks, Adam!), based on conversations he was having with another friend. And it looked sufficiently debatable to me that I thought it made for a fun discussion tonight.

Of the following five things, you can choose one to happen this season … and the other four are guaranteed NOT to happen:

1.) All five Cubs starting pitchers make at least 27 starts.

2.) Kris Bryant and Anthony Rizzo play a combined 290 games.

3.) Kyle Schwarber hits 45 home runs.

4.) Jason Heyward posts a wRC+ of 125 over a full season.

5.) Addison Russell and Javier Baez have an average wRC+ of 115 between the two of them over a full season.

When I first saw the question, I leapt on number one, thinking that if this killer rotation is generally healthy all year, the Cubs are a lock for the postseason.

But then I remembered that picking number one means that the other four things are guaranteed not to happen. Bryant and Rizzo play under 290 games. Schwarber doesn’t hit 45 homers. Heyward is definitely under 125 wRC+. And Russell/Baez are combined under 115 wRC+. Do I still take number one?

I think I do, though it’s the Rizzo/Bryant one that gives me pause. Schwarber can still have a great season without hitting 45 bombs. Heyward can still have a very nice bounceback season without going over 125 wRC+. And if Russell and Baez are at 100 wRC+ with their gloves, then that’s perfectly fine. But Bryant and Rizzo combining for under 290 games means there was at least a medium-term injury for one of those guys (or worse). Risking that feels a little scary. Debatably more scary than risking one of the starting pitchers going under 27 starts.

… of course, by not locking in those 27 starts for each starter, I’m risking several or – GASP – all of them being seriously injured. By taking number one, whatever else happens, I at least guarantee health for an excellent rotation.

As nice as it would be to see Schwarber or Heyward go off – and they’d be worth a ton of value at those levels – I don’t think they’d be my pick even if the question were which one do you want to happen, and then you don’t know what will happen with the other four (let alone if it guaranteed the other four won’t happen). The Russell/Baez one is very tempting, because that’s huge value at two positions. If picking them didn’t guarantee the other four wouldn’t happen, I might take that one.

All right. Enough from me. What about you? Which one are you picking, and is it more because you really want that one, or because you are afraid about the other four things not happening? Slide down to the comments and get into it.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Looking at the Positives, Bellinger and Morel Streaking (in Opposite Directions), and Other Cubs Bullets

What started as a small convo for the bullets ballooned into a deeper dive on Kyle Hendricks, what's going wrong, and where the Cubs go from here. So if you're looking for the Hendricks discussion, that was earlier today. Despite...

Latest 2024 MLB Mock Draft Lands the Cubs a Top Prospect Out of Wake Forest

Baseball America today released its updated (version 2.0) 2024 MLB mock draft. With more of the amateur season taking place, we are starting to see more of the top tier become firmly crystalized with eight names, none of whom are...

What’s Going on with Kyle Hendricks and Where Do We Go From Here?

That was a bummer of a series. The Cubs wound up splitting their weekend series at Wrigley Field, which isn't an awful outcome. But playing home against those Marlins, you definitely hope for at least three of four. Unfortunately, after...

Cubs Injury Updates: Seiya Suzuki, Ian Happ, Justin Steele (UPDATE)

If you're looking for some good news following a pretty frustrating weekend of baseball at Wrigley Field, I do have some for you. Just before the game, a trio of updates were reported for the Cubs injured players, and it...

Enhanced Box Score: Marlins 6, Cubs 3 – April 21, 2024

Well, this is what happens when you don't close out winnable games earlier in the weekend when you have the chance - it's a four-game series split with the lowly Miami Marlins at Wrigley Field. I watched most of this...

Pre-Gamin’: Marlins at Cubs (1:20) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — The Cubs were just a couple outs away from sweeping the double-header, but they came up short after another blown save by Adbert Alzolay in Game 1. But because they won on Friday, they still have a...

Here’s One Unique Reason Shota Imanaga Keeps Dominating

For all the issues in the Cubs rotation so far this season (injuries, underperformance), Shota Imanaga has been an absolute dream. And although I didn't expect his first earned runs of the year to come against the Marlins (and their...

Assad Keeps Dealing, Gaming Out the Rotation, Who Else Could Close? And Other Cubs Bullets

Let's just jump right into it. Javier Assad had a wobbly start to his game yesterday, immediately allowing a double and a walk to open things up, while dealing with some clear command issues. Miguel Amaya took notice and trotted...

Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 5, Marlins 3 – April 20, 2024

Muuuuuuuuuch better. But first, the bad stuff. For the second straight game, the Cubs couldn't get anything going against a Marlins starter; only this time, that starter was not an established big leaguer like Jesus Luzardo. Nope, for what felt...

Alexander Canario Just Demolished a Baseball

In the bottom of the ninth inning of the first half of today's double-header, Alexander Canario swung out of his shoes and came up empty. In the bottom half of the sixth inning of the second game ... he connected....

Latest News

Knicks vs. 76ers: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

In Game 2 of the opening round of the NBA Playoffs, the New York Knicks will go up against the Philadelphia 76ers.The Knicks will seek another victory over the 76ers after a 111-104 win on Saturday. Jalen Brunson led the...

Washington Commanders Draft Picks: Full List of NFL Draft Selections

The Washington Commanders have the number 2 overall picks in the 2024 NFL Draft and will likely select a quarterback. What other picks does Washington have? Check out the complete list of Commanders draft picks for 2024. More: Get awesome...

Pirates vs. Brewers Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, April 22, 2024

The Milwaukee Brewers (14-6) will put their four-game win streak to the test when they visit the Pittsburgh Pirates (11-11) Monday at 6:40 PM ET on BSWI. Oddsmakers consider the Pirates to be -145 favorites, while the Brewers are +123...

Braves vs. Marlins Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, April 22, 2024

A pair of division rivals take the field Monday when the first-place Atlanta Braves (14-6) host the fifth-place Miami Marlins (6-17). Sportsbooks favor the Braves (-209) for the contest, which starts at 7:20 PM ET on BSSO.Bryce Elder gets the...

Phillies vs. Reds Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, April 22, 2024

The Philadelphia Phillies (14-8) are -123 favorites to extend their six-game win streak when they face the Cincinnati Reds (12-9), winners of three in a row. The game begins Monday at 6:40 PM ET on BSOH, live from Great American...

Tigers vs. Rays Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, April 22, 2024

Amed Rosario (13 games) will look to add to his hitting streak when the Tampa Bay Rays (12-11) and Detroit Tigers (12-10) meet Monday at 6:50 PM ET, live on BSSUN from Tropicana Field. Amed Rosario and the Rays are...

Blue Jays vs. Royals Probable Starting Pitchers – April 22

The Kansas City Royals (13-9) begin a four-game series against the Toronto Blue Jays (12-10) with a Monday matchup at Kauffman Stadium. First pitch is at 7:40 PM ET.The probable starters are Yusei Kikuchi (1-1) for the Blue Jays and...

Cardinals vs. Diamondbacks Probable Starting Pitchers – April 22

The Arizona Diamondbacks (11-12) kick off a three-game series against the St. Louis Cardinals (9-13) with a Monday meeting at Busch Stadium. First pitch is at 7:45 PM ET.This contest's pitching matchup is set, as the Cardinals will send Lance...

Twins vs. White Sox Probable Starting Pitchers – April 22

The Chicago White Sox (3-18) carry a three-game losing streak into a road contest against the Minnesota Twins (7-13) at 7:40 PM ET on Monday.The probable starters are Chris Paddack (0-1) for the Twins and Jonathan Cannon for the White...

Looking at the Positives, Bellinger and Morel Streaking (in Opposite Directions), and Other Cubs Bullets

What started as a small convo for the bullets ballooned into a deeper dive on Kyle Hendricks, what's going wrong, and where the Cubs go from here. So if you're looking for the Hendricks discussion, that was earlier today. Despite...

more cubs news