Cubs Still Considering Going with an Extra Position Player? Should They?

When Brett deconstructed the roster back in February, he laid out the 24 players who appear (very) likely to make the team out of Spring Training.

The conversation was much deeper than what you’ll see below – and you can go back and check it out, regardless – but it essentially amounted to this:

  • 5 starting pitchers (Jon Lester, Kyle Hendricks, Yu Darvish, Jose Quintana, Tyler Chatwood)
  • 7 relievers (Brandon Morrow, Pedro Strop, Carl Edwards, Steve Cishek, Mike Montgomery, Brian Duensing, Justin Wilson)
  • 12 position players (Willson Contreras, Anthony Rizzo, Javy Baez, Ben Zobrist, Addison Rusell, Kris Bryant, Kyle Schwarber, Albert Almora, Jason Heyward, Ian Happ, Tommy La Stella, Chris Gimenez).
  • Obviously, there’s some leeway baked in there (for example, Victor Caratini could wrestle the backup catcher job away from Gimenez, even if it’s unlikely), but that’s sort of beside the point.

    The more salient matter is that, the way we see it, the Cubs currently have 12 pitchers and 12 position players who appear, more or less, to be locks for Opening Day.

    And that leaves one roster spot remaining (assuming Pedro Strop will be healthy and ready for Miami, that is). We are operating on the assumption that the final spot will go to another reliever, as has become custom in a bullpen-heavy world (as well as most of Joe Maddon’s recent rosters).

    But perhaps that’s not necessarily the case.

    The Chicago Sun-Times, MLB.com, and The Athletic all raise the possibility of the Cubs carrying an extra bench player, in lieu of a pitcher. It is unlikely at this point, but with utility men like Ryan Court and Mike Freeman having huge springs, and with Peter Bourjos the kind of defensively-inclined reserve outfielder teams like to have available, you can see why it’s at least discussed.

    Joe Maddon would not dismiss the possibility of going with an extra bench guy instead of an 8th reliever, and he had significant praise for Bourjos, in particular.

    “Love him – absolutely love him,” Maddon told Cubs.com. “I’ve had a lot of good conversations with him, and I’ve admired his work from a distance for a while …. I spent a lot of time talking with him in this camp about things I’ve noticed. The conversation is easy, he’s a pro. I see him coming out of his shell – meaning he’s getting more comfortable here. The dialogue is real easy, and I enjoy the way he’s playing.”

    It’s not necessarily Bourjos or a reliever or bust, either. Maddon has been impressed with a number of Cubs position players this Spring including Court and Freeman. And there’s always the idea of going with three catchers again, something Maddon has enjoyed at various times over the past 2-3 seasons.

    With Victor Caratini’s switch-hitting and positional versatility, he’d actually be a really easy guy to shove on the bench – though, given his status as a developing prospect, you’d probably rather not limit him too much right now. Sure, Caratini might be able to help the Cubs today, but his value to the team tomorrow in other ways might be just as (if not more) important. And that lesson extends beyond just a third catcher.

    “For me, it’s always about the eight versus the extra guy on the bench,” Maddon told the Sun-Times. “Who’s going to help you win more? But then, again, it’s also about maybe, possibly losing somebody you don’t want to lose.”

    Eddie Butler is an example of a guy who the Cubs would risk losing if he doesn’t make the Opening Day roster (he’s out of options). And if, for example, Strop did have to start the season on the disabled list, I wouldn’t be surprised to see Butler get one of the two remaining roster spots – in fact, I’d actually prefer it, given his remaining upside and ability to start. But if it’s down to the last spot, and you’re still deciding between him and a position player (let alone another reliever), the conversation isn’t as easy.

    Plus, Butler’s ability to start is neutered a bit by pitching out of the pen. If someone in the rotation were to break down, neither he nor Montgomery would be immediately stretched out. There’s a chance Butler could be converted into a full-time reliever – and with guys like Alec Mills and Jen-Ho Tseng available as one-off starting depth at Triple-A, you don’t hate that – but now we’re really getting into the weeds on his fit with this team.

    Clearly, this decision isn’t going to be easy.

    If it were up to me, however, this is how I think I’d handle it:

    1. If Pedro Strop is ready for Opening Day and you want to go with a position player, you go with Victor Caratini. I love the added versatility he brings to the game, as well as to Maddon’s roster planning. Working with three catchers has been a quietly awesome advantage over the past three seasons, and I’m very excited to see more. [Brett: Not to just straight up disagree with you in the middle of your post, Michael, but if going with a position player, I think I’d let Caratini keep starting at Triple-A, and would instead carry Bourjos, who might offer just as much value for Maddon to use in spots. It’s close. I like Caratini. I don’t think I’d hate it either way … IF going with a position player.]
    2. If Pedro Strop is ready for Opening Day and you want to go with a pitcher, I think you risk losing Eddie Butler, hoping that other roster crunches around the league allow the Cubs to sneak him through waivers, and go with a hot reliever like Randy Rosario (2.45 ERA, .160 avg against in Spring Training). [Brett: If any other reliever is a guy who clearly looks more capable of contributing quality innings, of course you take him. But if Butler is close, you keep him, and the other guys go to the minors, where they can be held onto. Sorry, Michael, I did it again.]
    3. If Pedro Strop is not ready for Opening Day and you want a position player, I think you can replace Strop with Eddie Butler, and once again add Victor Caratini. [Brett: If Strop isn’t ready, I’d rather see the Cubs going with eight relievers.]
    4. If Pedro Strop is not ready for Opening Day and you want to add an extra pitcher, I’d go with Butler and Rosario once again. [Brett: Agreed! Well, on it being Butler plus-one, at least. All these notes just confirm what Michael and Maddon have been saying: the decision at the margins here is not easy.]

    Basically, despite everything a veteran like Bourjos can bring to the table, I’m not itching to add more of a glut to the outfield, which already figures to be crunched with Ian Happ, Albert Almora, Kyle Schwarber, Jason Heyward, and Ben Zobrist clawing for time.

    On top of that, the Cubs have plenty of solid outfield defense (Almora, Heyward, Happ) and plenty of veteran clubhouse/leader types (Rizzo, Zobrist, Lester, etc). Plus, the Cubs wouldn’t stand to lose Bourjos if they left in the Minors to open the season, so if a need arises or an opt-out date approaches, you can always add him later on.

    Ultimately, though, I wouldn’t be surprised to see Strop ready for the season, and the Cubs just stick with one extra reliever. When push comes to shove, that’s the game today and the Cubs have grown accustomed to easing the load on the starters early in the season, helping preserve them for the second half.

    What would you do?

    Brett Taylor contributed to this post.

    written by

    Michael Cerami began covering the Chicago Cubs for Bleacher Nation as a part-time contributor in 2015. One year later, he joined Bleacher Nation full-time, covering the Chicago Cubs and Major League Baseball. Today, Michael runs Bleacher Nation, contributing as a writer (Cubs, MLB) and an editor for all sections of the site, including the Chicago Bears, Bulls, and Blackhawks, as well as MLB, NBA, NHL, and NFL. In 2019, Michael was the co-host of NBC Sports Chicago's Cubs Post-Game Show Outside the Ivy. You can find him on Twitter/X @Michael_Cerami

    more cubs news

    REPORT: Cubs to Call Up Infield Prospect Luis Vazquez

    A surprising report tonight ahead of tomorrow's off-day for the Chicago Cubs. Another infielder is coming up, and he'd be making his big league debut in the process. It's defensive stud Luis Vazquez, a guy whom many had been calling...

    Enhanced Box Score: Pirates 3, Cubs 2 – May 19, 2024

    The brutal, brutal run for the Chicago Cubs' offense continued today. It's really hard to win that way, and even harder to watch. Jameson Taillon was a touch better than his line today, without a lot of defensive help behind...

    Pre-Gamin’: Pirates at Cubs (1:20 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

    CUBS LINEUP — Well, the good news is that the Cubs have an off-day tomorrow and Dansby Swanson is targeting a Tuesday return from the IL. So no matter what, this SHOULD be the last day the Cubs middle infield...

    Enjoying the Actual Walk-Off, Morel History, Leiter and Neris, Holy Brennen Davis, and Other Cubs Bullets

    Despite everything, the Cubs are still three games up for the second Wild Card spot at the moment (and two games back in the NL Central). That's not a going-forward projection, it's just some context. The drama around the call...

    The Pirates Can Be As Mad As They Like, But That Call Was Correct

    If I were a catcher and wanted to record an out, I would simply not drop the ball. It's a jokey line, sure, but it's also correct in relation to yesterday's controversial conclusion. I think after seeing the replays of...

    Wake Up and Watch Shota Imanaga Dominate and the Cubs Walk It Off

    The Cubs pulled out a win in the bottom of the 9th yesterday, when Christopher Morel drove in Cody Bellinger to walk it off. The Pirates were undoubtedly displeased about the controversial ending, as it looked like Bellinger had been...

    The Cubs Walk It Off on a Weird Play at the Plate!

    Whew. That game was kinda dumb, but I tell you, the ending sure was fun. And also weird! So, to set the stage, the Pirates and Cubs' offenses could do nothing all day long. The game was still 0-0 in...

    Brennen Davis FREAKING DID IT AGAIN! AND THEN HE DID IT AGAIN AFTER THAT!

    This guy. What do I even say? I was already kinda buzzy when Brennen Davis homered again - a grand slam - for the fifth time in six games, and sixth time in eight games. THAT IS RIDICULOUS. https://twitter.com/IowaCubs/status/1791967453888598441 Truly...

    Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 1, Pirates 0 – May 18, 2024

    What matters most is that the Cubs won the game. And it was a fun ending, too. So I'm happy. But I also do feel a little frustrated - or concerned might be the better word - as I'm sure...

    Pre-Gamin’: Pirates at Cubs (1:20 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

    CUBS LINEUP — Losing to the Braves (and then Jared Jones and Paul Skenes), when you have 10 people on the IL, including your entire middle infield, is not really that concerning to me. It sucks and banking losses is...

    Latest News

    Liberty vs Storm Prediction: Picks, Live Odds & Moneyline – May 20

    The New York Liberty (3-0) will try to extend a three-game winning streak when they host the Seattle Storm (1-2) on Monday, May 20, 2024 at Barclays Center. The game airs at 7:00 PM ET on ESPN3, WWOR, FOX13, and...

    Sun vs Fever Prediction: Picks, Live Odds & Moneyline – May 20

    The Indiana Fever (0-3) will try to stop a three-game losing streak when they host the Connecticut Sun (2-0) on Monday, May 20, 2024 at Gainbridge Fieldhouse. The matchup airs at 7:00 PM ET on ESPN.Sun vs. Fever Prediction &...

    Dodgers vs. Diamondbacks: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

    The Los Angeles Dodgers (32-17), led by Mookie Betts, host Ketel Marte and the Arizona Diamondbacks (22-25) on Monday at 10:10 PM ET.The article below will give you everything you need to know to watch Los Angeles take on Arizona.When...

    St. Louis Cardinals vs. Baltimore Orioles Series May 20-22: Odds, Starting Pitchers & Predictions

    On Monday, May 20 at 7:45 PM ET, a three-game series featuring the St. Louis Cardinals and the visiting Baltimore Orioles will begin.Cardinals vs. Orioles Series Info Orioles @ Cardinals Time: Monday, May 20 at 7:45 PM ET Cardinals Starting...

    Houston Astros vs. Los Angeles Angels Series May 20-22: Odds, Starting Pitchers & Predictions

    In the first of a three-game series, on Monday, May 20 at 8:10 PM ET, the Houston Astros will host the Los Angeles Angels.Astros vs. Angels Series Info Angels @ Astros Time: Monday, May 20 at 8:10 PM ET Astros...

    Kansas City Royals vs. Detroit Tigers Series May 20-22: Odds, Starting Pitchers & Predictions

    On Monday, May 20 at 7:40 PM ET, a three-game series featuring the Kansas City Royals and the visiting Detroit Tigers will begin.Royals vs. Tigers Series Info Tigers @ Royals Time: Monday, May 20 at 7:40 PM ET Royals Starting...

    Los Angeles Dodgers vs. Arizona Diamondbacks Series May 20-22: Odds, Starting Pitchers & Predictions

    On Monday, May 20 at 10:10 PM ET, a three-game series between the Los Angeles Dodgers and the visiting Arizona Diamondbacks will begin.Dodgers vs. Diamondbacks Series Info Diamondbacks @ Dodgers Time: Monday, May 20 at 10:10 PM ET Dodgers Starting...

    Royals vs. Tigers: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

    On Monday at 7:40 PM ET, Bobby Witt Jr. and the Kansas City Royals (29-19) take on Riley Greene and the Detroit Tigers (23-23) at Kauffman Stadium.The article below will give you everything you need to watch Kansas City take...

    Panthers vs. Rangers Stanley Cup Semifinals Game 1 Prediction: Picks, Live Odds and Moneyline – Wednesday, May 22, 2024

    The Florida Panthers are -115 on the moneyline against the New York Rangers (-105) on Wednesday, with this tight-looking matchup being played at Madison Square Garden in New York City.Watch the NHL on Fubo!Panthers vs. Rangers Favorite, Moneyline, TotalFavorite: Panthers...

    Astros vs. Angels: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

    Kyle Tucker and the Houston Astros (21-26) host Taylor Ward and the Los Angeles Angels (18-29) on Monday in a series opener, with first pitch at 8:10 PM ET.If you're planning on watching this game, keep reading for streaming and...

    more cubs news