Jason Heyward’s Contract Ranks as Fifth Worst in Baseball … But He’s Playing So Well

Let’s get some stuff out of the way upfront.

Jason Heyward is currently slashing .277/.360/.431 (120 wRC+) this season, with identical 10.5% walk and strikeout rates. For reference, his current walk rate would represent the highest since 2013 and his strikeout rate would be the best of his career. More importantly, his overall offensive contributions would be greater than what he did at the plate during his 4.7 WAR season with the Braves in 2014.

And it’s not all smoke and mirrors, as Heyward’s peripherals strongly suggest he’s earning this production (if not more).

Consider that …

  • His .286 BABIP is below his career .300 average
  • His .154 ISO is right in line with his career .151 ISO mark (and much better than 2017 (.130 ISO) and 2016 (0.94 ISO))
  • He’s creating more hard contact (36.2%) than he has since his rookie year in 2010 (38.8 hard%)
  • His 37.9% ground ball rate is much lower than it ever has been before
  • His 48.3% fly ball rate is much higher than it’s ever been before
  • He’s pulling the ball less than he ever has before (which isn’t always a good thing, but I’d say that’s the right spray-change for him right now)
  • He’s swinging at fewer pitches out of the zone than he has since he was a rookie
  • He’s swinging at more pitches in the zone than he ever has throughout his career
  • And finally, his swinging strike rate is down quite a bit from last year
  • Don’t get me wrong, it’s definitely not all good news (his zone-contact rate is down a bit from the last two years, his first-pitch strike rate is up, his soft% is higher than it should be, etc.), but on the whole, it’s pretty hard not to love what we’re seeing – at least, relative to our expectations.

    In fact, I’d go as far as saying … Had this been his production over the first two years of his deal, that contract really wouldn’t look so bad right now. It wouldn’t be the overwhelming win the Cubs were hoping to receive once they unlocked the next level of Heyward’s power, but it wouldn’t be anywhere near the ugliness it has been and, frankly, still looks (look, I like what I’m seeing so far, but I’m not ready to proclaim Heyward is back – not by a long shot).

    To that end, we probably shouldn’t be surprised to learn that Jason Heyward’s 8-year, $184 million deal signed before the 2016 season ranks as the 5th worst active contract in baseball by the ZiPS projections.

    (Photo by Christian Petersen/Getty Images)

    In an Insider article at ESPN, Dan Szymborski ranked the worst contracts in terms of surplus wins – “that is, the difference between the number of wins the team is paying for and the number of wins it’s projected to get for the remaining years of the contract” – and Heyward’s deal comes up as the fifth worst.

    You’ll have to read the piece for the full list and attendant write-ups, but the bottom five for some context:

    1. Miguel Cabrera (-15 wins)
    2. Albert Pujols (-14.8 wins)
    3. Chris Davis (-11.9 wins)
    4. Ian Desmond (-7.9 wins)
    5. Jason Heyward (-7.5 wins)

    According to Szymborski, Cubs fans should probably stop waiting for Heyward to turn things around offensively (but my peripherals!), which means the best they can likely hope for is 1-2 wins per season, thanks to his still excellent defense in right.

    I still have hope – as always – but I can understand Szymborski’s position.

    I obviously don’t know what’s going to happen with Heyward the rest of the way (and, to my eye, the issues with his swing look more or less the same), but I’m just not ready to rule out a mini-bounce back. After all, he’s still just 28, he has five full seasons of above-average offensive production, he’s got a brand new hitting coach, and, for the first time in forever, an above-average slash in Chicago with peripherals to support it.

    Skepticism here is merited, but if Heyward can keep up his production somewhere between 110-115 wRC+, while maintaining his signature defense, he can easily be a 3-4 win player. And at that point, that pool of missing wins the Cubs paid for will start to shrink.

    [Brett: This is all good stuff and well put, but I know immediately where folks will go next – yeah, but if he has that kind of season in 2018, will he opt out of his deal? Will the Cubs be able to trade him (he has a limited no-trade clause after this season)? To those questions, I would say (1) the kind of Trout-ian season he would need to have in 2018 in order to justify opting out of the final five years of his well-compensating deal is not possible, and (2) if there were an obvious trade fit out there and the Cubs ate a bunch of salary, yes, it’s possible that a very good (i.e., typical for Heyward before 2016) season in 2018 could make him a tradable piece. For now, though, I think all of that just gets way too far ahead of ourselves. It hasn’t even been a month yet. The early results and performance are great. No question. But let’s see if he can keep doing this for multiple months before we start thinking about the contract as anything other than an uncomfortable reality. For now, I’m just happy to see Heyward helping the Cubs win games. He’s been great.]

    written by

    Michael Cerami began covering the Chicago Cubs for Bleacher Nation as a part-time contributor in 2015. One year later, he joined Bleacher Nation full-time, covering the Chicago Cubs and Major League Baseball. Today, Michael runs Bleacher Nation, contributing as a writer (Cubs, MLB) and an editor for all sections of the site, including the Chicago Bears, Bulls, and Blackhawks, as well as MLB, NBA, NHL, and NFL. In 2019, Michael was the co-host of NBC Sports Chicago's Cubs Post-Game Show Outside the Ivy. You can find him on Twitter/X @Michael_Cerami

    more cubs news

    REPORT: Cubs to DFA Garrett Cooper

    Garrett Cooper DFA — Earlier today, Tommy Birch caught word of Matt Mervis and Hayden Wesneski making their way up to Chicago, though no one has had the corresponding moves just yet. What we do know is that Wesneski would...

    Cubs Farm Report | April 23, 2024: Studs and Duds of the Week

    As I typed this, news broke that the Cubs were promoting Matt Mervis from Iowa to Chicago. So, we'll start this week's Studs and Duds on the Cubs farm with Mervis, who has been impressive this season. Plus, Kevin Alcántara...

    What Happened to Bears’ Arlington Move? Watch Out For Cards, New and Texans Unis, and Other Bears Bullets

    This afternoon's forecast in Chicago calls for afternoon rainstorms, which means I need to tweak my schedule to get my regularly scheduled walk in without getting soaked. Wish me luck! The Chicago Bears are reportedly set to announce lakefront stadium...

    Get ‘Em While They’re Down: Cubs vs Astros – Series Preview

    Cubs vs Astros — Splitting a four-gamer against the current, badly-struggling Miami Marlins is unquestionably a bad outcome, especially when one of those two losses was a win-in-hand that slipped away into the seats. But the typical, and maddeningly correct,...

    REPORT: Cubs Are Calling Up Matt Mervis and Hayden Wesneski

    I was literally in the middle of an article asking "What Are the Cubs Going to Do with Matt Mervis," when this news came across the wire. The Cubs first base picture is fully settled with the left-handed Michael Busch...

    South Side Horror Show (and Campfire Milkshakes), Alzolay and Evolving Relief Roles, and Other Cubs Bullets

    It's going to be a really good year for Horror movies. Late Night with the Devil was good (just saw it the other night). And I've got my eyes on Long Legs, Cuckoo, The First Omen, Immaculate, MaXXXine, In a...

    Two NL Central Pitchers Down: Miley and Montas

    A couple injuries to note among other NL Central contenders, as each of the Brewers and Reds have taken a hit to their rotation. The presumption for now is short-term on each, but I suppose we'll see. First, you have...

    Brewers Pitcher Jakob Junis Taken Off Field in an Ambulance After Being Struck by BP Ball

    A very scary scene in Pittsburgh, where Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Jakob Junis, currently on the IL with a shoulder impingement, took a batting practice ball off the neck and went down. Junis was apparently on the ground for a long...

    Nico Hoerner is Back to Being Nico Hoerner

    On April 9, I took an early look at Nico Hoerner's apparently evolving approach at the plate, which featured a lot more patience and a lot more big hacks. Effectively, it seemed like he was trying for a little more...

    MLBits: Spencer Strider Speaks (His and Other Pitcher Arm Injuries), Shohei Ohtani’s Latest Milestone, More

    There's been much debate about pitcher arm injuries lately, much of it sparked by Spencer Strider's season-ending Tommy John surgery, and Strider spoke to the media for the first time since the injury on Friday. Spencer Strider on pitcher arm...

    Latest News

    Paul George Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Mavericks – NBA Playoffs Game 2, Tuesday, April 23, 2024

    At 10:00 PM ET on Tuesday, in Game 2 of the opening round of the NBA playoffs, it'll be the Los Angeles Clippers versus the Dallas Mavericks, with Paul George needing four trifectas to beat his 3-pointer over/under.Paul George's Three-Pointer...

    James Harden Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Mavericks – NBA Playoffs Game 2, Tuesday, April 23, 2024

    On Tuesday at 10:00 PM ET, the Los Angeles Clippers play the Dallas Mavericks in Game 2 of the opening round of the NBA playoffs, and James Harden's 3-pointer prop for this clash requires three trifectas.James Harden's Three-Pointer Prop Odds...

    Kyrie Irving Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Clippers – NBA Playoffs Game 2, Tuesday, April 23, 2024

    At 10:00 PM ET on Tuesday, in Game 2 of the opening round of the NBA playoffs, it'll be the Dallas Mavericks against the Los Angeles Clippers, with Kyrie Irving needing four treys to beat his 3-pointer prop.Kyrie Irving's Three-Pointer...

    Luka Doncic Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Clippers – NBA Playoffs Game 2, Tuesday, April 23, 2024

    Luka Doncic needs to make five 3-pointers to beat his prop when the Dallas Mavericks play the Los Angeles Clippers on Tuesday at 10:00 PM ET, in Game 2 of the opening round of the NBA playoffs.Luka Doncic's Three-Pointer Prop...

    When is the 2024 NFL Draft? Dates, Location, Mock Drafts, Pick Order

    It's finally here, folks! The event every football franchise and fan alike circles on their calendar. The 2024 NFL Draft! The air crackles with anticipation as franchises across the league gear up to reshape their destinies. Quarterback-hungry teams sit on...

    REPORT: Cubs to DFA Garrett Cooper

    Garrett Cooper DFA — Earlier today, Tommy Birch caught word of Matt Mervis and Hayden Wesneski making their way up to Chicago, though no one has had the corresponding moves just yet. What we do know is that Wesneski would...

    Giants vs. Mets Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Tuesday, April 23, 2024

    The San Francisco Giants will take the field against the New York Mets (12-10) on Tuesday. The game begins at 9:45 PM ET on NBCS-BA, with the Giants listed as -136 favorites on the moneyline.Logan Webb will get the ball...

    Orioles vs. Angels Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Tuesday, April 23, 2024

    The Los Angeles Angels (9-14) will try to end their five-game losing streak when they host the Baltimore Orioles (15-7) on Tuesday at 9:38 PM ET on BSW. Bookmakers consider the Orioles to be -162 favorites for the contest, while...

    Myles Turner Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Bucks – NBA Playoffs Game 2, Tuesday, April 23, 2024

    Myles Turner needs to make two 3-pointers to beat his prop when the Indiana Pacers face the Milwaukee Bucks on Tuesday at 8:30 PM ET, in Game 2 of the opening round of the NBA playoffs.Myles Turner's Three-Pointer Prop Odds...

    Pascal Siakam Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Bucks – NBA Playoffs Game 2, Tuesday, April 23, 2024

    On Tuesday at 8:30 PM ET, the Indiana Pacers meet the Milwaukee Bucks in Game 2 of the opening round of the NBA playoffs, and Pascal Siakam's 3-pointer prop for this clash requires only one trifecta.Pascal Siakam's Three-Pointer Prop Odds...

    more cubs news

    Latest News