The Cubs Deployed a Solid Strategy on Day One of the Draft, and What It Means for Day Two

The Draft, Day One

We expected upside, and the Cubs definitely took some risks to go for impact bats. Two of their picks (24th overall and 78th overall) were both fairly high floor types. The other two (62nd overall and 77th overall) were both pure upside plays, and with both the Cubs were swinging for the fences. These may not have been the high ceiling players you thought the Cubs would take, but they are high ceiling players nonetheless.

First off, Nico Hoerner is a contender for the top overall prospect in the system. I think his tools compare fairly well across the board with current top hitter Aramis Ademan; just how well we’ll have to see once he gets into playing professionally. As a college hitter, he should be able to move quickly. The Cubs will likely let him get acclimated in Mesa and Eugene, but I wouldn’t be surprised to see him in South Bend this year or Myrtle Beach to start next year.

The thing to watch with Hoerner will be his power. He should be able to hit for average, so if he can produce at least average power while sticking at shortstop, he’s going to be a valuable guy to have around.

Paul Richan, the last pick and only pitcher for the Cubs on the day, is a little hard to grade. It sounds like he wore out later in the season, so people who saw him late weren’t impressed with his velocity. Those who saw him early saw a 92+ MPH fastball backed by a good change and a slider. Both groups agree he could consistly stay in the strikezone.

Given the fatigue concerns, I wouldn’t be surprised if the Cubs pitch him sparingly out of the bullpen in Mesa and Eugene to open his professional career, but don’t rule out a move to the rotation next season. As a guy with a three pitch mix and possibly good control, he could move relatively quickly. It is too early to say anything for sure, but so far the Cubs’ appear to have done fairly well in their recent efforts to build up their ranks of pitching prospects by drafting college guys. I don’t see Richan changing that trend.

And then we get to the high school outfielders. Both were relatively unknown by Cubs fans where they were taken, but both have significant potential. Brennen Davis pretty consistently has 60s dropped on both his speed and his power, and grades in the 50s on his defense and arm. That translates to a guy who can hit long balls, steal bases, and play in center field. The catch, other than that he’s been injured and is very raw, is that his hit tool only grades out as 40 at best. If that stays the case, that will be a problem.

But remember, this guy is a two sport athlete who has been slowed by injuries. The bat is going to be behind everything else right now. The Cubs may have to spend some effort working on his swing, but so long as they believe he’ll be able to recognize and react to pitches well enough, that effort could pay off substantially. I think one of the biggest weaknesses in the farm system right now is a lack of high upside bats, particularly power bats, and Brennen helps fill that void pretty effectively.

As does Cole Roederer. He also missed time with an injury this year, and he showed more power than he had in the past before that injury. Given that other terms Baseball America used in his description include ‘bat speed’, ‘well rounded toolset’, and ‘above average runner’, I see Roederer as another high ceiling project who could turn into a good hitter who hits for plenty of power and has good speed.

One final thing to note on both Davis and Roederer – both are committed to very good baseball schools (Miami and UCLA respectively). Those college commits would have been made before their injuries. That two good baseball schools liked them enough, when healthy, to sign them bodes well for their abilities when healthy. I suspect in both cases not many professional scouts saw them healthy, and that in turn depressed their stocks.

In short, I think the Cubs had a good day. I really like the first round pick, and I like the philosophy behind the next three picks, and particularly the high school outfielders. Those are exactly the sorts of players the Cubs need to draft, and to hit on, if they are going to rebuild this farm system as efficiently as possible while remaining competitive at the big league level.

Something else to keep in mind about the secretive nature of the draft:

Looking Ahead To Day Two

So what does that tell us about today? I think we need to think draft philosophy over particular players.

The Cubs have shown that they subscribe to a ‘buy in bulk’ philosophy of player development. When they really needed pitching in the farm system, they drafted a ton of pitchers in both 2016 and 2017. At that same time, although it recieved less notice, they drafted and signed a ton of middle infielders.

The bulk approach helps insure against the uncertainties of prospect development. The Cubs could hit on a relatively low percentage of those prospects and still produce multiple players for the future major league roster. If one or two of them break out in a big way, and that sort of thing does happen in every draft class and International Free Agent group, the Cubs will look like geniuses for finding that player. What no one will remember is that the also had nineteen other players who were very similar in many ways who didn’t break out.

I think they are taking that same buy-in-bulk approach to high ceiling power hitters. Already in the system they have Jonathan Sierra and Nelson Velazquez, and we could probably toss Miguel Amaya into that group. Already this draft they have added Davis and Roederer.

I think we should look for more of the same. The Cubs will probably take some shots on the pitching front today, they usually draft at least one high upside high school pitcher each draft, but I think today and tomorrow we will see plenty of toolsy hitters with projectable power. We may also see them continue to hone in on players who may be undervalued due to their missing time with injuries.

Keep in mind that the Cubs now have an extremely large scouting operation, so it is very possible that they are getting more eyes on these players than many other teams. That could explain the differences in the Cubs’ valuations in the injury cases.

I’m not sure they have much financial wiggle room left – anything they saved on their first and fourth pick they may need to sign the middle two – so I don’t expect more than maybe one highish dollar sign today. Then they’ll kick over to senior signs probably around round eight.

But even then, don’t dismiss those guys. The Cubs have done a fantastic job finding quality prospects in that range (Zack Godley and James Farris both became trade chips after being senior signs). Value in that window seems to come from relievers and smaller college hitters, so I think we’ll see some of each late today.

All in all, I’m encouraged by where the Cubs are so far. They didn’t draft some players I thought they would, and there were some they didn’t draft I’d like to have in the system, but I can’t argue with the philosophy I think I am seeing unfold. This is a team with a plan, and I like the thinking behind that plan. I think the 2018 draft is off to a pretty good start.

written by

Luke Blaize is the Minor League Editor at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @ltblaize.

more cubs news

Cubs Outfielders Snagging Extra Outs All Over the Place

We all know that Seiya Suzuki has made some high-profile mistakes in right field the last couple years, but he does still occasionally make the odd great play, too. For example, throwing out Matt Carpenter at home on this play:...

Royals Jump the Reliever Trade Market, Acquire Hunter Harvey from the Nationals

This is a pretty significant trade for the pre-Draft period, with the Royals acquiring Hunter Harvey from the Nationals for a Competitive Balance A pick (after the first round) and infield prospect Cayden Wallace. Wallace, 22, is a top-ten...

Miguel Amaya Homers As Part of a Four-Run, Two-Out Rally

Tonight's game might be a barnburner at this rate, so it's a good thing the Cubs really turned it on in the second inning with two outs. Miguel Amaya got things started with a two-run homer: And Nico Hoerner...

Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Cardinals (7:15 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — The Cubs dropped the first game of this double-header to snap their five-game winning streak and end their last-ditch bid to finish the "first half" at an even .500. The best they can do now is one...

Enhanced Box Score (Game 1): Cardinals 11, Cubs 3 – July 13, 2024

Well, this game was pretty much over before it started. The Cubs got the early lead on a Seiya Suzuki first inning home run (I guess we'll call him the Ankin Law "Making It Personal" Player of the Game), but...

Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Cardinals (1:15 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — Nobody move, nobody breathe. This isn't even an intro. It's just text on a page. (Turns out I am superstitious). Chicago Cubs Lineup: Nico Hoerner, 2B Michael Busch, 1B Seiya Suzuki, RF Ian Happ, LF Chris Morel,...

Cubs Roster Moves: Little to the IL, Roberts and Assad Return

In advance of today's double-header, the Cubs made a couple roster moves (with the possibility of making another in-between games if necessary). As anticipated, Luke Little is immediately going on the IL after leaving last night's game with a shoulder...

Hendricks Owns the Cardinals, Complicated Bullpen Talk, Rumble, Alcántara, Suriel, and Other Cubs Bullets

[BN_drinks] The thinking coming into these seven games against the Orioles and Cardinals was that the Cubs had to win AT LEAST five games for the front office to be justified in punting the buy-sell decision for another week or...

Wake Up and Watch the Cubs Take the First Game of the Cardinals Series

This weekend could wind up wildly important to the Cubs' Trade Deadline plans, particularly after sweeping the Orioles in Baltimore and keeping hopes alive. So far so good, as the Cubs bumped their winning streak to five by beating the...

Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 5, Cardinals 1 – July 12, 2024

The Cubs keep on rolling, with their fifth straight win. In theory, that was the toughest match-up of this Cardinals series, too, with Sonny Gray generally pitching very well, and Kyle Hendricks having struggled. I don't know how he does...

Latest News

Seattle Storm vs. Atlanta Dream: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Atlanta Dream (7-15) will attempt to break a six-game losing streak when they visit the Seattle Storm (15-8) on Sunday, July 14, 2024 at Climate Pledge Arena. The matchup airs at 6:00 PM ET on FOX13+, Prime Video, and...

Where to Watch Argentina vs. Colombia: Copa America 2024 TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

The 2024 Copa America final is set for 8:00 PM ET on July 14, with Argentina going head to head against Colombia at Hard Rock Stadium. Argentina eliminated Canada in its semifinal game, while Colombia grabbed the win against Uruguay.You'll...

Dodgers vs. Tigers: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Los Angeles Dodgers (56-40), led by Shohei Ohtani, visit Riley Greene and the Detroit Tigers (46-50) at 1:40 PM ET on Sunday.The article below will provide you with everything you need to watch Los Angeles take on Detroit.When is...

Storm vs Dream: Best Bets, Player Props & Computer Picks – July 14

The Atlanta Dream (7-15) will hope to break a four-game road slide when taking on the Seattle Storm (15-8) on Sunday, July 14, 2024 at Climate Pledge Arena, airing at 6:00 PM ET.If you are trying to gain an edge...

Giants vs. Twins: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – July 14

On Sunday, the Minnesota Twins (54-41) are visiting the San Francisco Giants (46-50), at 4:05 PM ET, in the final game of a three-game set.Curious about who's playing for the Giants and the Twins? Keep scrolling to get full injury...

Braves vs. Padres: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – July 14

In the final game of a three-game set at PETCO Park, the Atlanta Braves (52-42) play the San Diego Padres (50-48), Sunday at 4:10 PM ET.Looking to see who's available to play for the Braves and the Padres? Keep reading...

Orioles vs. Yankees Probable Starting Pitchers – July 14

The Baltimore Orioles (57-38) look to end to a five-game skid as they host the New York Yankees (58-39) on Sunday at 11:35 AM ET.The Orioles will give the nod to Dean Kremer (4-5) against the Yankees and Carlos Rodon...

Storm vs Dream Prediction: Picks, Live Odds & Moneyline – July 14

The Atlanta Dream (7-15) will look to turn around a six-game losing streak when they visit the Seattle Storm (15-8) on Sunday, July 14, 2024 at Climate Pledge Arena. The game airs at 6:00 PM ET on FOX13+, Prime Video,...

Diamondbacks vs. Blue Jays: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

Ketel Marte and the Arizona Diamondbacks (48-47) host Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and the Toronto Blue Jays (43-51) on Sunday, with first pitch at 4:10 PM ET.See how to watch the Arizona-Toronto matchup below.When is Diamondbacks vs. Blue Jays and when...

How to Watch Hall of Fame Open 2024: TV Schedule, Live Stream Links – Monday, July 15

The menu at the Hall of Fame Open on July 15 includes eight matches in the round of 32, including Mackenzie McDonald (ranked No. 96) against Rinky Hijikata (No. 77). How to watch, you ask? Go to ESPN for the...

more cubs news