So, What Should The Cubs Do With Free-Agent-To-Be Justin Wilson?

Although the Cubs bullpen was a strength this season – their collective 3.35 ERA led the National League (2nd in MLB) – there are plenty of concerns heading into 2019.

To hit on some of those concerns quickly … Brandon Morrow finished the season injured, as did Pedro Strop. Carl Edwards Jr. developed severe control problems, and the same could probably be said of Brian Duensing. Steve Cishek was used a TON, and his production may have suffered for it. You can never know if guys like Jorge De La Rosa or Jesse Chavez will (1) come back and (2) be half as effective as they were this year. You cannot count on the Cubs’ 2019 Minor League fill-in types having as much immediate success as that group did in 2018. Concerns aplenty.

And then there’s something that could be an additional concern, or could be an answer to those concerns: what to do about Justin Wilson?

The 31-year-old reliever came to the Cubs half-way through the 2017 season and had absolutely awful results (5.09 ERA, 20.9% BB rate). Indeed, despite his history as a closer with plenty of success, Wilson didn’t even generate enough confidence to get himself onto the NLDS roster last year.

Wilson bounced back in a big way this season (3.46 ERA, 3.64 FIP), though still had some relatively significant command problems (14.0%). But everything else he provided – from a strong 29.2% strikeout rate, to a 28.4% hard-hit rate, to his 11.3% infield fly ball rate – made him a perfectly useable, even in big situations, late-inning reliever.

But the question remains: now that he’s a free agent, do the Cubs try to re-sign him?

I think, in general, the Cubs plan to add to their bullpen this winter. Maybe even significantly. Besides the fact that every competitive team needs to address this very fickle positional group annually, the Cubs have some obvious issues to consider (as described above). But this decision won’t be made in a vacuum, either. Wilson was good frequently, but struggled mightily often. And with a huge free agent relief class like the incoming group, it’ll be hard to justify too big of a deal.

Here are just some of the notable, available relievers this winter, ranked by WAR in 2018 and including their age next season:

Adam Ottavino (33 years old, 2.0 WAR)
Jeurys Familia (29, 1.8)
David Robertson (34, 1.5)
Craig Kimbrel (31, 1.5)
Jesse Chavez (35, 1.2)
Oliver Perez (37, 1.1)
Tony Sipp (35, 0.9)
Zach Duke (36, 0.9)
Brad Brach (33, 0.7)
Joe Kelly (31, 0.7)
Sergio Romo (36, 0.5)
Jake Diekman (32, 0.5)
Justin Wilson (31, 0.5)
Tyler Clippard (34, 0.5)
Shawn Kelley (35, 0.5)
Andrew Miller (34, 0.4)
Kelvin Herrera (29,0.4)
Mark Melancon (34, 0.3) – (opt out)
Greg Holland (33, 0.3)
Tony Barnette (35, 0.3)
Aaron Loup (31, 0.3)
Jonny Venters (34, 0.3)
Adam Warren (31, 0.3)
John Axford (36, 0.2)
Bud Norris (34, 0.2)
Ryan Madson (38, 0.2)
Jeanmar Gomez (31, 0.2)
Zach Britton (31, 0.1)
Santiago Casilla (38, 0.1)
Cody Allen (30, 0.0)
Jorge De La Rosa (38, 0.0)
Fernando Salas (34, 0.0)

Some names are more attractive than others, but there are some legitimate stars in there (Craig Kimbrel, David Robertson, Adam Ottavino) including some other talented guys, whom the Cubs have had their eyes on in the past (De La Rosa, Zach Britton, Adam Warren, Greg Holland, Andrew Miller, Wilson, Chavez, etc.). Needless to say, it’s not as though Wilson is the only option.

(Photo by Stacy Revere/Getty Images)

And even though he had a disastrous second-half of 2017, relievers with his pedigree (big K-stuff, plenty of weak contact, previous experience as a closer) tend to get at least two to three-year deals in the $6-$8M per year range, right? Do you want him back at that level, knowing his upside, but also his risk?

I think, yeah, you probably do, especially if you can get him for just two years and $12-14M. In fact, I think that’s probably a no-brainer, such that he’ll likely get more. It’s a risky deal given what he could be, sure, but he made a lot of improvements this season. And perhaps more importantly, he has experience closing, which I think we all know could come in handy if Morrow is the 9th inning man again next summer (hopefully Pedro Strop and *at least* one other big-time relief addition mitigate against that, but we saw how things turned out this year).

One other consideration is that Wilson has been an extremely healthy pitcher throughout his career. Check out his inning totals season-by-season:

2013: 73.2 IP
2014: 60.0 IP
2015: 61.0 IP
2016: 58.2 IP
2017:  58.0 IP
2018: 54.2 IP

That sort of durability has inherent value, as well.

Wilson is going to have suitors out there, however much you think his second half of 2017 will pollute the well. For the most part in his career, he’s been consistently good and durable. He has value. He’s relatively young. There’s familiarity there. If the numbers make sense for the Cubs, re-upping would be just fine.

However, if his value in the market trends up into that three to four-year deal range? Like the (now-disastrous) four-year, $30.5 million deal lefty Brett Cecil signed with the Cardinals a couple years ago? Then I think it would be more prudent to look to the rest of the deep reliever market.

written by

Michael Cerami began covering the Chicago Cubs for Bleacher Nation as a part-time contributor in 2015. One year later, he joined Bleacher Nation full-time, covering the Chicago Cubs and Major League Baseball. Today, Michael runs Bleacher Nation, contributing as a writer (Cubs, MLB) and an editor for all sections of the site, including the Chicago Bears, Bulls, and Blackhawks, as well as MLB, NBA, NHL, and NFL. In 2019, Michael was the co-host of NBC Sports Chicago's Cubs Post-Game Show Outside the Ivy. You can find him on Twitter/X @Michael_Cerami

more cubs news

Now We Know Why Ian Happ Was Removed Mid-game

In the top of the seventh inning of today's 8-3 win over the Miami Marlins, Alexander Canario trotted out to left field in place of Ian Happ. At first, we thought (or maybe just hoped) that Craig Counsell was giving...

Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 8, Marlins 3 – April 19, 2024

And just like that the Chicago Cubs are the first team in the NL Central to reach 12 wins! They're not technically in first place yet because the Brewers (11-6) have played fewer games, but we're talking about a matter...

Nico Hoerner and Dansby Swanson with Back-to-Back Slick Defensive Plays

With a lefty Marlins starter on the mound this afternoon, Nico Hoerner lead off today's game for the Chicago Cubs. And he did it in style, ripping a leadoff double to the left-center field wall, before coming into score a...

Pre-Gamin’: Marlins at Cubs – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

*The Cubs were rained out yesterday, but today? Today, we've got a Friday 1:20 start at Wrigley Field, and that means all is right in the world. Before you take a look at the Cubs lineup against Miami, check out...

MLBits: The White Sox Might be the Worst Team Ever, What Games I’m Watching this Weekend, More

Happy Friday! Well, for everyone except for the pilots who were supposed to be manning the Colorado Rockies flight last week but instead allowed a member of the Rockies coaching staff to hop in the pilot's seat for a fun...

Can I Interest You in a Positive Injury-Update on Justin Steele?

Justin Steele, arguably the single most irreplaceable player on the Chicago Cubs 2024 roster, went down with a hamstring injury just 4.2 innings into his Opening Day start against the Rangers on March 28. In his place, the Cubs sixth...

FAA Reportedly Investigating How a Passenger on Colorado Rockies Team Flight Was Seen Accessing the Cockpit

If you do this job long enough, it's really wild to see the range of topics that can somehow become attached to sports. That is to say, I did not envision myself at some point writing about flight safety, cockpit...

Cubs Farm Report | April 19, 2024: Kevin Alcántara is Heating Up!

The Iowa Cubs were rained out, but the rest of the farm was in action, and so was Kevin Alcántara, who picked up four hits and now has seven in his last three games as he breaks out of an...

It’s Not Kyle Hendricks Last Chance (But…), Ben Brown, Jameson Taillon, and Other Cubs Bullets

Well, the rain stole one from us yesterday, which is a blessing and a curse. On the bright side, the bullpen gets an extra day of rest (on top of the day Hayden Wesneski bought them). But on the flip...

The Chicago Cubs Are Not Stealing Bases So Far This Year

The Chicago Cubs are against theft. Of bases: https://twitter.com/codifybaseball/status/1781046629103231339 The Chicago Cubs this year have stolen just three bases, the fewest in all of baseball. Dansby Swanson has stolen two bases, Nick Madrigal has stolen one. That's it. I don't...

Latest News

Padres vs. Blue Jays: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The San Diego Padres (11-11), led by Fernando Tatis Jr., host Justin Turner and the Toronto Blue Jays (11-9) at 8:40 PM ET on Saturday.Find out how to watch the San Diego-Toronto matchup below.When is Padres vs. Blue Jays and...

Nuggets vs. Lakers Predictions, Best Bets and Odds: NBA Playoffs Game 1 – Saturday, April 20, 2024

The Denver Nuggets and the Los Angeles Lakers square off to tip off the opening round of the NBA Playoffs. The Nuggets are favored by 7 points in the matchup, which will be broadcast on ABC at 8:30 PM ET....

Best NBA Prop Bets Today – Saturday, April 20, 2024

Today's NBA playoff schedule has four quality competitions on the docket. Among those contests is the Phoenix Suns playing the Minnesota Timberwolves.One of the most fun ways to wager on the NBA is via NBA player prop bets. There are...

Diamondbacks vs. Giants: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Arizona Diamondbacks (10-11), led by Ketel Marte, visit Michael Conforto and the San Francisco Giants (9-12) on Saturday at 4:05 PM ET.See how to watch the Arizona-San Francisco matchup below.When is Diamondbacks vs. Giants and when does it start?This...

How to Watch Dodgers vs. Mets: Live Stream or on TV

Mookie Betts and the Los Angeles Dodgers (12-10) host Pete Alonso and the New York Mets (11-8) at 4:05 PM ET on Saturday.See how to watch the Los Angeles-New York matchup below.When is Dodgers vs. Mets and when does it...

How to Watch Cardinals vs. Brewers: Live Stream or on TV

The St. Louis Cardinals (9-11), led by Brendan Donovan, host William Contreras and the Milwaukee Brewers (12-6) on Saturday at 2:15 PM ET.The article below will give you everything you need to know to watch St. Louis take on Milwaukee.When...

How to Watch Cubs vs. Marlins: Live Stream or on TV

Javier Assad will take the mound for the Chicago Cubs (12-7) when they host starter Jesus Luzardo and the Miami Marlins (4-16) on Saturday, with first pitch at 2:20 PM ET.If you're intending to watch this game, keep reading for...

How to Watch Twins vs. Tigers: Live Stream or on TV

The Minnesota Twins (6-12), with Bailey Ober on the mound, host the Detroit Tigers (11-9) who will start Reese Olson, at 2:10 PM ET on Saturday.The article below will provide you with everything you need to watch Minnesota play Detroit.When...

Yankees vs. Rays: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The New York Yankees (14-6), with Nestor Cortes Jr. on the hill, host the Tampa Bay Rays (11-10) who will start Zach Eflin, at 1:05 PM ET on Saturday.Find out how to watch the New York-Tampa Bay matchup below.When is...

Reds vs. Angels: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

Elly De La Cruz and the Cincinnati Reds (10-9) host Mike Trout and the Los Angeles Angels (9-11) at 6:40 PM ET on Saturday.See how to watch the Cincinnati-Los Angeles matchup below.When is Reds vs. Angels and when does it...

more cubs news