Lukewarm Stove: How About Brantley for the Cubs? Pollock’s Market, Braves, Philles, Corbin, Diaz, More

Although the Cubs, themselves, are well-positioned to contend in both their division and league next season, it’s not fun to see them outside the broader conversation.

Perhaps it’s my own unrealistic expectations begot by so many huge transactions over the past few years, but it sure feels like nobody is talking about the Cubs right now. And why would they be? Chicago petered out at the end of the 2018 season and have signaled an intention not to spend aggressively this offseason (and, of course, that was *after* the front office said they wouldn’t settle for talent over production). They can do a lot to change the narrative, but it might take some extreme creativity.

Here’s some rumors – Happy Wednesday!

  • At Cubs.com, Jordan Bastian mentions that the bullpen (Andrew Miller, Cody Allen) and middle infield (Daniel Murphy, DJ LeMahieu, Jed Lowrie) will be the Cubs’ focus this winter, which, yeah that sounds about right if you were breaking it down positionally (bullpen and impact bat would perhaps be even better). We’ve discussed most of these names already – and we’ll hit on LeMahieu later today – so for now the bigger takeaway is the continued belief that, based on Bastian’s suggestions, the Cubs will hang out in the second tier of free agency, at best, this offseason.
  • Bastian also discusses Michael Brantley as a potential target in response to a question about him, but concedes that while his bat would fit well in the lineup (124 wRC+, .364 OBP, 9.5% strikeout rate last season), his glove is best suited for left field, where Kyle Schwarber is already stationed most of the time. But with Joe Maddon still on board as skipper, I just wouldn’t worry about exact positioning of any individual. If the front office brought Brantley in and his bat still played, Maddon would find a place for him.
  • For what it’s worth, Brantley strikes me as a great addition for the Cubs, in the same way Andrew McCutchen would. These guys shouldn’t break the bank, could squeeze into the outfield, are veteran leaders, and add another 15-20% above-average bat to the Cubs lineup. If the Cubs are truly out on Harper/Machado and with Josh Donaldson already off the board, the Cubs should *really* consider someone like Brantley (all of this, of course, relies upon the assumption that the Cubs are willing to spend some money this winter, but I’m just not sure they are anymore). The Cubs don’t necessarily need an “outfielder,” but they must consider offense where they can find it.
  • One big caveat with Brantley: although the 31-year-old was healthy in 2018, he played just 101 games between 2016 and 2017 because of multiple shoulder surgeries.
  • (Photo by Jason Miller/Getty Images)

  • These are not the only outfield free agents, of course, but given the early rumors, I think they might be more worth the money:
  • Pollock is younger, a better defender, and had an elite(ish) season back in 2015, but I’m guessing Brantley and McCutchen outplay him at the plate next year *and* cost a lot less – then again, I doubt Pollock winds up with 5 years or $80M, so who knows. Pollock probably comes with more upside, but also – given his injury history – more downside relative to the cost.
  • According to GM Alex Anthopoulos, the Braves are still looking to add a “front of the rotation starting pitcher, a late inning reliever (but probably not someone expensive like Craig Kimbrel), and one more outfielder,” this winter. Wow. It wasn’t clear if any or all of those would come from free agency, but the Braves are clearly ready to take hold of the NL East and run with their core as soon as possible.
  • And yet, they aren’t really the team everyone is talking about in the East. At the New York Post, Joel Sherman details how everyone will be watching the Phillies this offseason: “I can never remember a winter in which one team is the linchpin more than Philly is now,” a veteran GM said. “Maybe the Yankees in some free-spending period, but maybe not even them.” We discussed this in the stove yesterday with respect to the Cubs, but it remains true now. The Phillies, if they really are what they claim to be, are in driver’s seat and everyone else will be forced to wait to see what they do. It wouldn’t be this way if the Dodgers and Cubs weren’t under seeming self-imposed timeouts – but here we are.
  • At The Athletic, Ken Rosenthal writes that the Phillies might not decide between a massive deal for Bryce Harper/Manny Machado and a bunch of other moves. They might do both. Specifically, he believes they might want to sign a top reliever, trade for a starting pitcher, trade Carlos Santana and Cesar Hernandez, sign an infielder like Mike Moustakas, plus a defensive-minded shortstop, and revamp their outfield … all IN ADDITION to Harper or Machado. My word.
  • But still, it’s not like they don’t need to make so many moves, because even without the Braves’ rise, they clearly have needs:
  • And to close this loop for now: here’s even more indication that the Phillies are serious about Patrick Corbin, who was spotted at the ballpark yesterday. I won’t be surprised to see them end up with one of Harper/Machado, Patrick Corbin, and one of the big-name relievers – at a minimum – this winter. For what it’s worth, though, they’ll likely have to battle the Yankees for Corbin, and the Yankees rarely lose fights when it comes to big-money free agents, even if the Phillies are talking a big game.
  • The Mets, Yankees, Braves, Phillies, and Red Sox have all expressed strong interest in Mariners closer Edwin Diaz and the Mariners are willing to move him, but they’re trying to attach him to Robinson Cano so as to get out of that expensive contract ($120M over the next five years). I still think they’d be silly to parlay Diaz’s value into mere money savings, but that’s just me. I am positive we have not heard the last of the Mariners this winter, as Jean Segura, Dee Gordon, Edwin Diaz, Robinson Cano, and several others all constitute attractive, available talent (depending on contracts and returns).
  • Rosenthal has more on the Diaz/Cano talks:
  • For once, the Mets are right. If you attach Cano to Diaz, the return is going to be FAR lighter, unless the Mariners kick in some serious cash, at which point, why are they doing it in the first place? Again, I’m perfectly willing to believe both guys get traded this winter, but separate deals seem more likely than a monster, complicated, money-driven deal.
  • Eyes are still on the Padres and Mets on a potential Noah Syndergaard deal:
  • Given the Padres’ extreme prospect glut and desires to contend soon, you can presume they will make some kinds of trades this offseason, Syndergaard or not.
  • Brett Taylor contributed to this post.

    written by

    Michael Cerami began covering the Chicago Cubs for Bleacher Nation as a part-time contributor in 2015. One year later, he joined Bleacher Nation full-time, covering the Chicago Cubs and Major League Baseball. Today, Michael runs Bleacher Nation, contributing as a writer (Cubs, MLB) and an editor for all sections of the site, including the Chicago Bears, Bulls, and Blackhawks, as well as MLB, NBA, NHL, and NFL. In 2019, Michael was the co-host of NBC Sports Chicago's Cubs Post-Game Show Outside the Ivy. You can find him on Twitter/X @Michael_Cerami

    more cubs news

    Still Thinking About That Incredible Christopher Morel Play

    I don't want to overreact to a relatively brief stretch of success, and I certainly don't want to jinx anything. But Christopher Morel has looked pretty darn solid at third base the last couple weeks, hasn't he? Maybe some of...

    Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 5, Diamondbacks 3 – April 17, 2024

    UNCLENCH. They did it. There was 9th inning drama, because of course there was, but Drew Smyly was able to get the job done, pitching for the third consecutive day. Cubs win the game, Cubs win the series. Cubs win...

    Cody Bellinger’s Third Homer of the Year Breaks the Tie in Arizona!

    Thank god. I was starting to think Brandon Pfaadt was Cy Young in disguise or something. I can't stand (or understand, for that matter) how this guy carves up the Cubs while getting destroyed by almost everybody else. But at...

    Watch Owen Caissie Launch His First Triple-A Home Run (Off a Lefty, Too!)

    Owen Caissie is just one of several Cubs top prospects at Triple-A Iowa this season, but after a monster Spring Training performance (following an equally impressive Double-A debut last season), he's got a lot of eyes on him this summer....

    Cubs Call Up a Couple of Fresh Arms from Iowa

    In discussing the potential for a Cubs move today for a fresh arm, I wondered if they'd go down and grab someone already on the 40-man roster or if they'd shift Julian Merryweather over to the 60-day IL to make...

    Pre-Gamin’: Cubs vs Diamondbacks – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

    CUBS LINEUP — How many rubber matches can one team have? After two wild games to start the series, the Cubs are looking to win their second-consecutive series this afternoon in Arizona. Jordan Wicks is on the mound for Chicago....

    MLBits: Orioles Can’t Stop Hitting Home Runs, Learn Jac Caglianone’s Name, More

    If you have an MLB.TV subscription: I suggest you try to catch a Baltimore Orioles game soon. The Orioles lineup is chock-full of young talent, and they're absolutely mashing the baseball right now. They're fun to watch if you can...

    Cubs Farm Report | April 17, 2024: PCA Goes Yard, Cade Horton Dominates, More

    Pete Crow-Armstrong showed some life on Tuesday with a solo home run for the Iowa Cubs, but it was Luis Vázquez who played hero for Iowa in the end. Plus, Cade Horton dominated for the Smokies once again. That and...

    Baseball America Has Added Another Chicago Cubs Prospect to Their Top-100 List

    If you have been paying attention at all, I think it's going to be very easy for you to fill in these blanks: https://twitter.com/BaseballAmerica/status/1780601113198383137 Yes, that'd be Jefferson Rojas, the still-18-year-old shortstop for the High-A South Bend Cubs, currently hitting...

    Cade Horton Dominated Once Again at Double-A, So What’s the Plan There?

    As he's done nine times before, Cade Horton dominated in his latest outing for the Tennessee Smokies. It took him just 47 pitches to cruise through 4.0 innings of work and carve up the Rays' Double-A squad. https://twitter.com/MLBPipeline/status/1780387010039210247 Horton has...

    Latest News

    Nuggets vs. Lakers Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets for NBA Playoffs Game 1 – Saturday, April 20, 2024

    The Denver Nuggets and the Los Angeles Lakers square off to start the first round of the NBA Playoffs. The Nuggets are favored by 7 points in the contest, which airs on ABC at 8:30 PM ET. The matchup has...

    Red Sox vs. Guardians: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

    The Boston Red Sox (10-9), led by Tyler O'Neill, host Josh Naylor and the Cleveland Guardians (12-6) on Thursday at 1:35 PM ET.Find out how to watch the Boston-Cleveland matchup below.When is Red Sox vs. Guardians and when does it...

    UGH: Alex Caruso’s Availability Already in Doubt for Next Play-In Game

    The Chicago Bulls can't seem to swat the injury bug. Despite Andre Drummond and Ayo Dosunmu returning from their multi-game absences on Wednesday, the Bulls have likely lost their defense ace. Alex Caruso suffered a foot injury in the first...

    You Have to See Coby White’s Epic Sequence Against the Hawks

    Whether or not he gets the hardware, Coby White is the NBA's Most Improved Player. The Chicago Bulls guard has fully embraced his bigger workload this season, showing improvements in almost every aspect of his game. This was on full...

    Oh, Uh: Jimmy Butler “Feared” to Have MCL Injury, Will Undergo MRI

    The Miami Heat have some serious concerns after their Play-In Tournament loss to the Philadelphia 76ers on Wednesday night. According to The Athletic's Shams Charania, Jimmy Butler is "feared" to have suffered an MCL injury in his knee. An MRI...

    How to Watch Giants vs. Diamondbacks: Live Stream or on TV

    On Thursday, Logan Webb will start for the San Francisco Giants (8-11) versus Ryne Nelson and the Arizona Diamondbacks (9-10), with first pitch scheduled for 9:45 PM ET at Oracle Park.Keep reading to find out all the details on how...

    San Francisco Giants vs. Arizona Diamondbacks Series April 18-21: Odds, Starting Pitchers & Predictions

    The San Francisco Giants are hosting the Arizona Diamondbacks for a four-game series, with the first matchup getting underway at 9:45 PM ET on Thursday, April 18.Giants vs. Diamondbacks Series Info Diamondbacks @ Giants Time: Thursday, April 18 at 9:45...

    Chicago Cubs vs. Miami Marlins Series April 18-21: Odds, Starting Pitchers & Predictions

    A four-game series between the Chicago Cubs and the visiting Miami Marlins will start on Thursday, April 18 at 7:40 PM ET.Cubs vs. Marlins Series Info Marlins @ Cubs Time: Thursday, April 18 at 7:40 PM ET Cubs Starting Pitcher:...

    WATCH: DeMar DeRozan WOWS with Huge Slam Against the Hawks

    DeMar DeRozan is almost 35 years old and led the NBA in minutes this season. I want you to remember that as you watch what you're about to see. The Chicago Bulls' veteran forward was tearing apart the Atlanta Hawks...

    Enhanced Box Score: Bulls 131, Hawks 116– April 17, 2024

    The Chicago Bulls understood the assignment. Unlike what we saw against Toronto in the first Play-In Tournament game last season, the Bulls were the ones to get out to an early lead. DeMar DeRozan was completely in his bag from...

    more cubs news