Nick Castellanos Isn’t Pushing Advanced Analytics, And That’s Just Fine Because He’s Awesome

When I woke up this morning, I was pleasantly greeted by a text from the boss-man, who asked if I was up to do a Nicholas Castellanos post. And why wouldn’t I be?! The guy has been the heartbeat of the Cubs on and off the field since he joined the team at the deadline, and he just launched another home run (his 20th of the season/9th with Chicago) in their win over the Mets last night! Plenty to discuss.

So what am I writing about … his hot streak? An extension rumor? Did he get a face tattoo of the Bean to prove how much he really loves Chicago? 

Nope. I have to write about an unenthused player position on advanced analytics, and the contrast with elements of the clubhouse that are hard to quantify … or something along those lines. Thanks for the direction, Brett.

As something of a setup, here’s Castellanos musing on how much analytics may or may not ultimately be beneficial: “The movie Moneyball, that was the start of introducing this idea of analytics to fans,” Castellanos said, via USA Today. “Obviously, the movie was entertaining with Jonah Hill and Brad Pitt. But the way I look at it, what good did it do the A’s? They still haven’t won the World Series.”

Well first of all, Nicholas, “Moneyball” blessed the world with this gif, which makes the entire philosophy and attendant motion picture completely worth whatever systemic damage was done to the game and free agent market by the mathematical commoditization of players into numbers and assets on a screen, devoid of any fun, emotion, or general commitment to winning and tradition:

Oh, and the A’s also won 103 games plus their division that season, while winning an AL-record (at the time) 20 consecutive games. 

Castellanos continued: “They have these analytics that come out of nowhere that are supposed to predict how players are going to do and what they are going to do before they do it,” Castellanos said. “They have WAR, but when I talk to people on the MLB Network and other places, and ask how they come up with it, they have no idea.”

Well, not to pick the low-hanging fruit here, but … I’m not entirely surprised the MLB Network was incapable of explaining that to you.

Okay, so, at a first level: how do we feel about this? Honestly, it doesn’t bother me at all. While I may agree or disagree with Castellanos, I don’t really need him to care or even understand analytics – at almost any level. All he has to do is listen to his coaches, who were hand-selected by a manager, who was, himself, hired by a front office that doesn’t just believe in analytics, but is often at the forefront of the entire industry, in that respect. Castellanos is here to play ball, not do player value analysis.

(Photo by Dylan Buell/Getty Images)

As a matter of fact, there were probably some very specific, very illuminating advanced analytics that made the front office confident enough in a Castellanos breakout to surrender some nice prospects and ask Tom Ricketts to stretch the budget at the deadline to acquire him. Heck, we talked about many of them right here at Bleacher Nation.

But, again, I don’t blame Castellanos, and his thoughts on analytics don’t really bother me at all. Not only is it not his job to worry about player valuations in advanced analytics, but also I can understand where he’s coming from. He’s actually got a very compelling origin story, with plenty of truth to it: “The biggest mistake the Tigers made was not signing Torii Hunter back. Regardless what his analytical performance said,” Castellanos said, “you can’t value the centerpiece in the clubhouse. Someone with the same WAR is not going to provide the same thing.”

Castellanos’ former team, the Tigers, have not reached the playoffs since.

But the problem isn’t advanced analytics, it’s how they are employed. There absolutely needs to be a balance between numbers and feeling, and, in a lot of ways, that’s the beauty of a guy like Joe Maddon. We often pick and choose when to get upset with him, but I don’t think there’s a manager out there more open to any “analytical” suggestion, while still able to blend that with his own experience and gut.

Cubs pitching coach Tommy Hottovy said something endearingly appropriate recently, too (via Sahadev Sharma): “As Hottovy told me, these are the types of issues you ignore at the time because you can’t overwhelm a pitcher with a thousand issues just because you have the technology to notice them.”

And ultimately, I think we’re all saying the same thing here: don’t overdo it on analytics with the players. There is another half to this game that can’t be ignored – just like the numbers shouldn’t be, either. I don’t know why you’d purposefully close yourself off to any data/information.

And even more to his point: front offices cannot and should not hide behind numbers when it comes time to open their checkbooks. “There’s a lot of uncertainty right now with the relationship between ownership and players,” Castellanos said, “just the way that we’re being evaluated. It’s something I can’t control.”

Ah, now you’re talking my language. There’s no doubt in my mind that front offices and ownership groups have used advanced analytics as a mathematical shield against signing more baseball players and trying to win as much as possible every season. That’s not good for the players (and arguably for the sport as a whole), and Castellanos is right to point it out, especially when he’s just a couple months away from free agency.

As one of the more thoughtful, interesting philosophers to join the Cubs in recent years, I really enjoy hearing his perspective on these topics that we so often consider only from the front office perspective.

Castellanos concluded all of his thoughts, which you can read here, beautifully: “But I’m not an owner. I’m not a GM. I’m just a ballplayer.” And a pretty darn good one, I’d add.

Brett Taylor contributed to this post.

written by

Michael Cerami began covering the Chicago Cubs for Bleacher Nation as a part-time contributor in 2015. One year later, he joined Bleacher Nation full-time, covering the Chicago Cubs and Major League Baseball. Today, Michael runs Bleacher Nation, contributing as a writer (Cubs, MLB) and an editor for all sections of the site, including the Chicago Bears, Bulls, and Blackhawks, as well as MLB, NBA, NHL, and NFL. In 2019, Michael was the co-host of NBC Sports Chicago's Cubs Post-Game Show Outside the Ivy. You can find him on Twitter/X @Michael_Cerami

more cubs news

Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Mariners – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — Don't shoot the messenger, but this Cubs game doesn't start until 8:40pm CT ... and it's on AppleTV+. I don't make the rules. In any case, it's been a nice long break since the frustrating series in...

REPORT: Cubs Calling Up Keegan Thompson – Recent Performance, What to Expect, More

Last night, we learned that the Chicago Cubs had optioned right-handed reliever Jose Cuas to the Triple-A Iowa Cubs after a pretty horrendous start to the year. Although he's got some arm talent and a funky delivery (which creates a...

More Late-Night Games: Cubs vs Mariners Series Preview

Cubs vs Mariners — The Cubs west coast trip continues tonight in Seattle, where they'll open up the first of three games against the Mariners at T-Mobile Park. The Cubs are coming off a pretty frustrating series loss in San...

Apparently the Cubs Traded Catcher Joe Hudson to the Mets After Signing Ali Sanchez

In another bit of news dropping on the transactions page, the Chicago Cubs have traded catcher Joe Hudson to the New York Mets. Nothing is listed on the Cubs page or the Mets page as the trade return, so I...

Cubs Farm Report | April 11, 2024: Reginald Preciado’s Big Night Not Enough for Myrtle Beach

We've got a shorter Cubs Farm Report today, with half of the affiliates being rained out. The Iowa Cubs got their game in against the St. Paul Saints but lost to the Twins' affiliate. Myrtle Beach scored nine runs with...

Random Awesome Highlight Flashback: The Time Reed Johnson Robbed Prince Fielder of a Grand Slam

Thanks to yesterday's off-day and today's game being of the late-night variety, we're having to wait a very long time between games. For that reason, I very much appreciated today's random flashback from the Daily Random Cub account, which took...

Small Change Coming for Hendricks? Dreaming on Old Keegan Thompson, Streaks Alive, and Other Cubs Bullets

Sorry for the late bullets this morning. Brett is still working his way back (no pun intended), and I still have some other "running-the-site" duties to address on any given day. To that end, we are working on some stuff...

Cubs Prospect Reginald Preciado Making Some Early Noise

When the Cubs traded Yu Darvish to the Padres, everyone understood it to be two things: (1) saving some payroll in the wake of the pandemic, and (2) getting a volume-based return to stock up the farm system. In other...

Jose Cuas is Headed to Iowa, So the Cubs Must Be Making a Bullpen Move

As spotted by a number of eagle-eyed folks out there, the Chicago Cubs transaction page was updated tonight to include this line: "Chicago Cubs optioned RHP Jose Cuas to Iowa Cubs." There is no corresponding move listed. Yet. That means...

The Chicago Cubs’ Bonus Pool for the 2024 MLB Draft is Smaller Than You Probably Hoped

The full bonus pools for the upcoming 2024 MLB Draft are out, and the Chicago Cubs, despite picking 14th in the first round, will have only the 19th largest bonus pool, at $9,802,300. Thanks to compensatory draft picks and -...

Latest News

Wild vs. Sharks Prediction: Picks, Live Odds and Moneyline – Saturday, April 13, 2024

The bookmakers really fancy the Minnesota Wild to top the San Jose Sharks in their meeting on Saturday, April 13, with the visiting Wild given moneyline odds of -245, and the Sharks at +200.Wild vs. Sharks Favorite, Moneyline, TotalFavorite: Wild...

Kings vs. Ducks Prediction: Picks, Live Odds and Moneyline – Saturday, April 13, 2024

The Los Angeles Kings are big favorites (-340) at home versus the Anaheim Ducks (+270) on Saturday at 10:30 PM ET.Kings vs. Ducks Favorite, Moneyline, TotalFavorite: Kings (-340)Underdog: Ducks (+270)Total: 5.5Best Kings vs. Ducks Promo Codes[lasso type="table" id="1" link_id="1565208"]How to...

Oilers vs. Canucks Prediction: Picks, Live Odds and Moneyline – Saturday, April 13, 2024

The Edmonton Oilers are -142 on the moneyline against the Vancouver Canucks (+120) on Saturday, with this matchup taking place at Rogers Place in Edmonton.Oilers vs. Canucks Favorite, Moneyline, TotalFavorite: Oilers (-142)Underdog: Canucks (+120)Total: 6.5Best Oilers vs. Canucks Promo Codes[lasso...

How to Watch Dodgers vs. Padres: Live Stream or on TV

On Saturday, Mookie Betts and the Los Angeles Dodgers (10-5) face Fernando Tatis Jr. and the San Diego Padres (7-8), with first pitch scheduled for 9:10 PM ET at Dodger Stadium.Keep reading to find out how to watch the Los...

Predators vs. Blue Jackets Prediction: Live Odds, Stats, History and Picks – Saturday, April 13, 2024

The Nashville Predators are big favorites (-305) at home against the Columbus Blue Jackets (+245) at Bridgestone Arena on Saturday.Predators vs. Blue Jackets Favorite, Moneyline, TotalFavorite: Predators (-305)Underdog: Blue Jackets (+245)Total: 6.5Best Predators vs. Blue Jackets Promo Codes[lasso type="table" id="1"]How...

Cardinals vs. Diamondbacks: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The St. Louis Cardinals (6-7), who will give the start to Kyle Gibson, visit the Arizona Diamondbacks (6-7) with Ryne Nelson on the hill, Saturday at 8:10 PM ET.Keep reading to find out how to watch the St. Louis-Arizona matchup...

Astros vs. Rangers: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Houston Astros (4-11), who will give the ball to Ronel Blanco, host the Texas Rangers (8-6) with Andrew Heaney on the mound, Saturday at 4:05 PM ET.The article below will give you everything you need to know to watch...

Nationals vs. Athletics: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

MacKenzie Gore will take the ball for the Washington Nationals (5-7) when they visit starter Joseph Boyle and the Oakland Athletics (5-8) in a series opener on Saturday, with first pitch at 4:07 PM ET.The article below will provide you...

Cubs vs. Mariners: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Chicago Cubs (7-5), with Shota Imanaga on the hill, visit the Seattle Mariners (5-8) who will counter with Emerson Hancock, at 9:40 PM ET on Saturday in a series opener.Keep reading to find out all the details on how...

Stephen Curry Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Pelicans – Friday, April 12, 2024

To beat his 3-point prop, Stephen Curry needs to make five from beyond the arc on Friday, when his Golden State Warriors play the New Orleans Pelicans, tipping off at 10:00 PM ET.Stephen Curry's Three-Pointer Prop Odds vs. the PelicansStephen...

more cubs news