Lukewarm Stove: Free Agent Freeze, Red Sox Big Decisions, Trading Big Cubs, More

Well, it’s certainly not as rewarding as the playoffs, but I do love me some rumors. And given the known roster turnover, expected payroll space (more on that soon), and ongoing managerial search, we should be in store for plenty of them over the next few months.

Here’s a collection of the latest.

  • Ken Rosenthal assembled the apparent offseason intentions of a handful of teams (Rockies, Astros, Red Sox, Marlins, Blue Jays) and it doesn’t look good in terms of free agent spending. Naturally, Players Union Chief Tony Clark isn’t thrilled: “After another year of declining attendance, it seems odd that several clubs rushed to announce that they plan to sit out the free-agent market before the first pitch of the postseason had even been thrown.” He continued: “The Hot Stove season has traditionally been about ticket sales and fan engagement. Yet several clubs are laying the groundwork for more of the same, even as franchise values skyrocket and central revenues continue to increase.”
  • Clark isn’t wrong and this could be a league-wide issue for the third-straight offseason, but that doesn’t necessarily mean bad news for the Cubs.
  • Let’s actually consider the last two offseason in which the free-agent freeze-out was an issue …

  • (1) Heading into the 2018 MLB season: Although this was roughly the beginning of the free agent nightmare, the Cubs weren’t really the problem. They may have spent late and they may have spent poorly, but they certainly spent plenty – Yu Darvish ($126M), Tyler Chatwood ($38M), Brandon Morrow ($21M), and Steve Cishek ($13M).
  • (2) Heading into the 2019 MLB season: This was the second straight frustrating winter for free agents, but this time the Cubs can not claim to be uninvolved. They hardly spent any money at all, despite several clear holes on the roster, and went into the season with largely the same team as what they had the year before. Moreover, the Cubs were the team that wound up signing one of the frozen free agents in Craig Kimbrel, after the draft pick deadline passed. HOWEVER, you could point out that the Cubs didn’t spend because they were already carrying a payroll that was among the very highest in baseball. I said then and I’ll say it again now: they made a HUGE mistake by not increasing that level given the circumstances, but they were well above the luxury tax, so in a group of 30 teams, they’re hardly shouldering the bulk of the blame.
  • Point being: If the Cubs carry a payroll around where it was lastyear, then they should be positioned to spend again – just like they did two years ago. Don’t let the broader (but fair) MLB narrative and an idiosyncratic payroll decision of 2019 cloud your expectations. The Cubs should have money to spend and they clearly have PLENTY of reasons to spend it. If they don’t, I’ll be the first one to call it out.
  • For what it’s worth, Rosenthal points out that the Reds, Rangers, and Nationals have each signaled their intentions to spend more this offseason in their own ways.
  • Speaking of spending plans: the Red Sox stated their desire to get the payroll below the lowest luxury tax threshold, and MLB.com discusses their many difficult upcoming decisions. For example, they already have several outgoing free agents (and a possible Jackie Bradley Jr. non-tender), but there’s also a potential opt-out situation in the making (J.D. Martinez) that could impact their decisions elsewhere (like trading superstar Mookie Betts (WANT?)).
  • And of particularly random note from that article, there’s this: “One thing to keep an eye on: If the Sox can trade a couple of players who are on big salaries, could they make a blockbuster with the Mets for Noah Syndergaard?” That’s an awfully specific rumor to toss in at the very end of the post, so you should probably keep it in mind. Of course, the Mets have appeared to be both willing and unwilling to trade Noah Syndergaard for … 2-3 years now. So I really don’t know if he’ll ever actually be on the move, and the Mets have said he won’t be. (But whatever.)
  • After Theo Epstein’s end-of-season press conference, one discussion point seems to be taking the greatest hold of Cubs fans (and for obvious reasons): Trading Kris Bryant and/or Javy Baez. Although I think everyone on the roster will theoretically be on the table (at least not unavailable), there seems to be a particularly greater focus on those two, as Brett discussed recently. For more, Mark Gonzales weighed the pros and cons of keeping or trading either of them.
  • You can check out his article for the actual pros and cons, but I will highlight a few key/stray notes: (1) Gonzales seems to expect the Cubs to take another shot at signing Kris Bryant long-term, (2) re-signing Nicholas Castellanos could make it easier to trade Bryant from an offensive standpoint, and (3) trading Javy Baez would basically leave Nico Hoerner as the starting shortstop from Day 1 (which isn’t necessarily a good idea for a number of reasons).
  • The Cubs catcher situation is one of the most fascinating and enigmatic topics to me right now. On the one hand, they have a star in Willson Contreras, who’s probably got one of the two best bats (and possibly athleticism) at the position in all of baseball. He struggles significantly with framing, but he may be improving there, and very few teams wouldn’t love to have him. Behind Contreras, you have Victor Caratini who emerged as a slightly better framer and worse (but still solidly above average) offensive contributor, who can play first base and switch-hit. If the Cubs wanted to, they could go back into 2020 with these two behind the plate and be just fine. However … (1) the Cubs have been teasing big changes, which doesn’t exclude their catchers (2) Contreras missed big chunks of the season in 2017 and 2019 due to injury, (3) Caratini has just one year of high-level success under his belt, and (4) … Yasmani Grandal is available in free agency.
  • If the Cubs were so inclined, it’s not impossible to imagine a scenario where trading Contreras and/or Caratini and using their financial capital to sign Grandal wouldn’t leave them better off in the long-run (return from the trade) and possibly close to neutral – or even better – next season, as well. Grandal has AVERAGED 5.0 WAR per year over the last five seasons and has been a solidly above-average bat in 3 of the last 4 seasons. The Cubs do not have to make a move at catcher, quite obviously. But it wouldn’t be an offseason of change if they didn’t seriously consider how a coordination of moves might leave them much better off for 2020 and beyond.
  • written by

    Michael Cerami began covering the Chicago Cubs for Bleacher Nation as a part-time contributor in 2015. One year later, he joined Bleacher Nation full-time, covering the Chicago Cubs and Major League Baseball. Today, Michael runs Bleacher Nation, contributing as a writer (Cubs, MLB) and an editor for all sections of the site, including the Chicago Bears, Bulls, and Blackhawks, as well as MLB, NBA, NHL, and NFL. In 2019, Michael was the co-host of NBC Sports Chicago's Cubs Post-Game Show Outside the Ivy. You can find him on Twitter/X @Michael_Cerami

    more cubs news

    Cubs Roster Moves: Wisdom and Taillon Are Back, Wesneski and Mastrobuoni Are Out

    Even with tonight's rainout, the Chicago Cubs are still making some roster moves. When Patrick Wisdom was removed (perfectly healthy) from the I-Cubs game in the 4th inning on Wednesday, we had an idea of what was coming next. When...

    Tonight’s Cubs-Marlins Game Has Been Postponed

    The weather wasn't going to cooperate for Jameson Taillon's season debut, and tonight's Cubs-Marlins tilt has been postponed. The game will instead be part of a split-doubleheader this Saturday, with the first game at 1:20pm CT and the second at...

    MLBits: Paul Skenes Could Make His MLB Debut Any Day (But Probably Won’t), Red-Hot Orioles, Houck’s Maddux, More

    If you're into tracking young pitchers with star potential like I am—as I watch Jack Leiter's debut while typing this column—then you're probably itching to see Pirates top prospect Paul Skenes make his way to Pittsburgh sooner than later. While...

    Back to Wrigley: Cubs vs Marlins – Series Preview

    Cubs vs Marlins — Whew! The Cubs got through their first West Coast road trip of the year, and did so with a winning record (5-4) against the Padres, Mariners, and Diamondbacks. They definitely let a couple games slip out...

    Taillon Coming Back, Busch’s Integrity and Success, Bad News for the White Sox, Wicks, Hendricks, and Other Cubs Bullets

    As the father of a toddler who was sick for an entire week — the same week Brett was out from his back surgery and the Cubs were playing almost exclusively late-night ballgames on the West Coast — I was...

    Cubs Farm Report | April 18, 2024: Caissie, Alcántara Go Yard, South Bend and Myrtle Beach Smoked, More

    Kevin Alcántara hit his first home run of the season for the Tennessee Smokies last night, and Owen Caissie hit his first Triple-A home run for the Iowa Cubs as Iowa and Tennessee secured victories. The same can't be said...

    Cody Bellinger Sticking With Scott Boras

    Given the way the offseason played out for super agent Scott Boras's top available clients - Cody Bellinger, Matt Chapman, Blake Snell, and Jordan Montgomery - you wouldn't be shocked to see some unhappiness behind the scenes. Did Boras overplay...

    You’ll Be Even More Impressed with Hayden Wesneski, When You Hear What it Took to Get Him to Arizona

    Hayden Wesneski was the hero of yesterday's finale and series-win over the Arizona Diamondbacks, coming in to clean up Jordan Wicks' (little) mess in the 5th ... and then tossing 4 shutout innings to save an over-used bullpen and help...

    Offseason Cubs Target Robert Stephenson Now Out for the Year

    Hand up, I really wanted the Cubs to sign reliever Robert Stephenson this offseason. I felt like they could use one more impact arm (accurate), and I felt like Stephenson was one of the best available (about that ... )....

    Rays Closer Pete Fairbanks With a Wonderful and Brutally Honest Line About His Performance

    Rays closer Pete Fairbanks has been an extremely effective reliever the last four years, posting a 2.66 ERA from 2020 through 2023, with a 34.8% K rate and worth 4.1 WAR. But things have started out much more rough for...

    Latest News

    Twins vs. Tigers: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

    The Minnesota Twins (6-11), with Joe Ryan on the mound, host the Detroit Tigers (10-9) who will start Jack Flaherty, at 8:10 PM ET on Friday in a series opener.Keep scrolling to find out all the details on how to...

    Orioles vs. Royals: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

    On Friday, in a series opener at Kauffman Stadium, Dean Kremer starts for the Baltimore Orioles (12-6) against Alec Marsh and the Kansas City Royals (12-7), with first pitch scheduled for 7:40 PM ET.Keep reading to see how to watch...

    Brewers vs. Cardinals: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

    William Contreras and the Milwaukee Brewers (11-6) visit Brendan Donovan and the St. Louis Cardinals (9-10) at 8:15 PM ET on Friday.Keep reading to see how to watch the Milwaukee-St. Louis matchup below.When is Brewers vs. Cardinals and when does...

    Pacers vs. Bucks Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets for NBA Playoffs Game 1 – Sunday, April 21, 2024

    The Indiana Pacers are slight 1-point favorites heading into Game 1 of the opening round of the NBA Playoffs against the Milwaukee Bucks at Fiserv Forum on Sunday, starting at 7:00 PM ET on TNT. The matchup's over/under is set...

    Mavericks vs. Clippers Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets for NBA Playoffs Game 1 – Sunday, April 21, 2024

    The Dallas Mavericks and the Los Angeles Clippers meet to start the first round of the NBA Playoffs. The Mavericks are favored by 1.5 points in the contest, which will be broadcast on ABC at 3:30 PM ET. The matchup...

    Knicks vs. 76ers Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets for NBA Playoffs Game 1 – Saturday, April 20, 2024

    The New York Knicks and the Philadelphia 76ers take the court to start the opening round of the NBA Playoffs. The Knicks are favored by 3 points in the matchup, which will be broadcast on ESPN at 6:00 PM ET....

    Heat vs. Bulls Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets for NBA Playoffs Game 1 – Friday, April 19, 2024

    The Chicago Bulls are slight 1.5-point underdogs heading into Game 1 of the opening round of the NBA Playoffs against the Miami Heat at FTX Arena on Friday, tipping off at 7:00 PM ET on ESPN. The matchup's over/under is...

    How to Watch Phillies vs. White Sox: Live Stream or on TV

    The Philadelphia Phillies (11-8), led by Trea Turner, host Gavin Sheets and the Chicago White Sox (3-15) on Friday at 6:40 PM ET.Keep reading to find out how to watch the Philadelphia-Chicago matchup in the article below.When is Phillies vs....

    Braves vs. Rangers: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

    The Atlanta Braves (12-5), who will give the start to Chris Sale, host the Texas Rangers (11-9) with Andrew Heaney on the mound, Friday at 7:20 PM ET.If you're trying to watch this game, keep reading for streaming and TV...

    How to Watch Guardians vs. Athletics: Live Stream or on TV

    In a series opener on Friday, Triston McKenzie will take the mound for the Cleveland Guardians (13-6) versus Joseph Boyle and the Oakland Athletics (8-11), with first pitch scheduled for 7:10 PM ET at Progressive Field.The article below will provide...

    more cubs news