Royals Reportedly Not Considering Trading Whit Merrifield Right Now

There was a rumor earlier this offseason that the Cubs might make trading for Whit Merrifield a “priority,” but even if it’s true, the Royals would have to actually engage in those trade talks to make anything happen.

And the signal they’re putting out is that they aren’t there right now:

Translation? The Royals probably don’t have very realistic demands for Merrifield in a trade right now. That’s fine. He’s signed to a multi-year deal, he’s one of the few familiar faces on the club, and teams don’t have to trade away every valuable piece just because there are askers.

The Royals are highly unlikely to be competitive in 2020, so the advantage of hanging onto Merrifield now is a gamble that he’ll be more valuable with the pressure of the deadline (and a smaller market), versus the much larger market now (but competing with free agency). It’s also a gamble that a 31-year-old Merrifield won’t get hurt or take another sizable step back.

From our previous write-up on Merrifield and the Cubs:

Ah, Whit Merrifield. The Great Whit Whale. He’s back for another round of trade rumors.

You understand why. The now 30-year-old second baseman has put together back-to-back seasons of solid leadoff work, and he’s a career .296/.344/.445 hitter (109 wRC+) who doesn’t strike out (16.6%), and runs the bases well. Given what the Cubs have been desperate to find at the top of their order, Merrifield has *obviously* been a trade rumor target for over a year now.

There are rubs, though, even if the Cubs were making him a priority.

For one, there’s the age. Although Merrifield is nicely cost-controlled – he signed a four-year, $16.25 million deal before the 2019 season – he will play next season at age 31. For a guy with speed, you always worry about decline in athleticism after 30. Indeed, Merrifield’s baserunning and defensive metrics were down considerably in 2019 over 2018.

For another thing, there’s his offensive profile. His line and OBP look great, but they are built almost entirely only a BABIP that is in the .350s. To be sure, Merrifield is a great line drive hitter with enough pop to keep defenses honest, but if that BABIP takes a hit at any point, his whole line crumbles because he doesn’t have huge power (.149 ISO) and doesn’t walk much (6.4%). Guys who are primarily BABIP monsters – even if they’ve been consistent at it in the past – make me nervous.

Steamer projects a .282/.337/.426 line next year for Merrifield, just below league average (99 wRC). The OBP would be a decent bit above league average (.323), and he’d still do other stuff you’d be happy to have atop the order. But the point is, he’s hardly a lock to be an overall above-average hitter.

Would you still gladly take Merrifield as your leadoff hitter and Opening Day second baseman in 2020? Of course! His salary doesn’t hurt, as it might allow the Cubs to make more impactful additions in the rotation and in the bullpen, too.

But when it comes to the price tag in trade, how much are you giving up for a 31-year-old Merrifield, knowing that the upside is limited to him being what he’s been the last two years (average defender, solid hitter, good leadoff guy)? And knowing that the downside is that his BABIP slips just 20 points and he’s suddenly a merely average hitter atop your lineup? Are you giving up Nico Hoerner for that? I don’t think I am, and that’s likely where the Royals would start their ask.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Brewers Pitcher Jakob Junis Taken Off Field in an Ambulance After Being Struck by BP Ball

A very scary scene in Pittsburgh, where Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Jakob Junis, currently on the IL with a shoulder impingement, took a batting practice ball off the neck and went down. Junis was apparently on the ground for a long...

Nico Hoerner is Back to Being Nico Hoerner

On April 9, I took an early look at Nico Hoerner's apparently evolving approach at the plate, which featured a lot more patience and a lot more big hacks. Effectively, it seemed like he was trying for a little more...

MLBits: Spencer Strider Speaks (His and Other Pitcher Arm Injuries), Shohei Ohtani’s Latest Milestone, More

There's been much debate about pitcher arm injuries lately, much of it sparked by Spencer Strider's season-ending Tommy John surgery, and Strider spoke to the media for the first time since the injury on Friday. Spencer Strider on pitcher arm...

Chicago Cubs Sign Lefty Pitching Prospect Mitchell Tyranski

A new signing popped up on the Chicago Cubs' transaction log: lefty Mitchell Tyranski. Tyranski, 26, put up a 3.83 ERA over 42.1 innings at High-A last year in the Dodgers organization, striking out 47 and walking 21. Were you...

The Cubs Have TWO of the Early Front-Runners for NL Rookie of the Year

We already dove deep into Shota Imanaga's latest impressive start against the Marlins yesterday. And there's been no shortage of love for Michael Busch this season either. But I do want to take this time to illustrate just how good...

My Expectations and Realistic Hope for the Cubs VERY Tough Upcoming Schedule

Even though Sunday ended in a loss for the Chicago Cubs, we did get some good news in the form of positive injury updates. Ian Happ (hamstring) was available off the bench and could be good to go tomorrow, when...

Aaron Boone Just Got Ejected Despite Saying Literally Nothing

I know that sometimes there is a history between an umpire and a manager. I know that sometimes a manager can subtly get under the skin of an umpire without doing much that we can see or hear. And I...

Cubs Farm Report | April 22, 2024: Weekend Wrap

Let's get caught up on all of the action down on the farm in today's Cubs Farm Report. Cubs Farm Report | April 22, 2024 Triple-A Iowa Cubs (13-8) The Cubs were swept in a doubleheader by the Louisville Bats...

Looking at the Positives, Bellinger and Morel Streaking (in Opposite Directions), and Other Cubs Bullets

What started as a small convo for the bullets ballooned into a deeper dive on Kyle Hendricks, what's going wrong, and where the Cubs go from here. So if you're looking for the Hendricks discussion, that was earlier today. Despite...

Latest 2024 MLB Mock Draft Lands the Cubs a Top Prospect Out of Wake Forest

Baseball America today released its updated (version 2.0) 2024 MLB mock draft. With more of the amateur season taking place, we are starting to see more of the top tier become firmly crystalized with eight names, none of whom are...

Latest News

Yankees vs. Athletics: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

Marcus Stroman will take the ball for the New York Yankees (15-8) when they host starter Paul Blackburn and the Oakland Athletics (9-14) on Tuesday, with first pitch at 7:05 PM ET.The article below will give you everything you need...

Phillies vs. Reds: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

In a series opener on Tuesday, Trea Turner and the Philadelphia Phillies (14-8) take on Elly De La Cruz and the Cincinnati Reds (12-9), with first pitch scheduled for 6:40 PM ET at Great American Ball Park.The article below will...

How to Watch Brewers vs. Pirates: Live Stream or on TV

Wade Miley will take the mound for the Milwaukee Brewers (14-6) when they visit starter Bailey Falter and the Pittsburgh Pirates (11-11) on Tuesday, with first pitch at 6:40 PM ET.Keep reading to find out all the details on how...

Dodgers vs. Nationals: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Los Angeles Dodgers (13-11), with James Paxton on the mound, visit the Washington Nationals (10-11) who will start Patrick Corbin, at 6:45 PM ET on Tuesday.Keep scrolling to find out all the details on how to watch Los Angeles...

How to Watch Rays vs. Tigers: Live Stream or on TV

The Tampa Bay Rays (12-11), led by Amed Rosario, host Riley Greene and the Detroit Tigers (12-10) at 6:50 PM ET on Tuesday in a series opener.Keep reading to find out all the details on how to watch Tampa Bay...

Cleveland Guardians vs. Boston Red Sox Series April 23-25: Odds, Starting Pitchers & Predictions

The Cleveland Guardians will be hosting the Boston Red Sox for a three-game series, with the first matchup getting underway at 6:10 PM ET on Tuesday, April 23.Guardians vs. Red Sox Series Info Red Sox @ Guardians Time: Tuesday, April...

Washington Nationals vs. Los Angeles Dodgers Series April 23-25: Odds, Starting Pitchers & Predictions

The Washington Nationals are hosting the Los Angeles Dodgers for a three-game series, with the first matchup getting underway at 6:45 PM ET on Tuesday, April 23.Nationals vs. Dodgers Series Info Dodgers @ Nationals Time: Tuesday, April 23 at 6:45...

Red Sox vs. Guardians: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Tuesday, in a series opener at Progressive Field, Tanner Houck starts for the Boston Red Sox (13-10) versus Ben Lively and the Cleveland Guardians (16-6), with first pitch scheduled for 6:10 PM ET.Keep reading to find out how to...

Buffalo Sabres Hire Lindy Ruff as Head Coach… Again

Did somebody throw a couple bucks in the juke box and hit the theme song from "Welcome Back, Kotter"? Because Lindy Ruff is the head coach of the Buffalo Sabres -- again. https://twitter.com/BuffaloSabres/status/1782517265956573577 Ruff, 64, was the head coach of...

Understanding Foursomes vs Fourball in Team Golf

If you're running into this article, it must be the Zurich Classic or, even better, the Ryder Cup. You've undoubtedly Googled "fourball vs foursomes" for the 6th straight year to try and remember what the difference is. In the realm...

more cubs news