The Cubs Are Reportedly Optioning Nico Hoerner in Favor of Eric Sogard to Start the Season

While I can’t say this decision will find many supporters in Chicago (and the concern about service time manipulation is at least a legitimate one given the organization’s history), I do genuinely understand why the Cubs would elect to roll with Eric Sogard over Nico Hoerner *to start the season* as reported by Jeff Passan earlier tonight.

Hoerner, 23, is already a Gold Glove caliber middle infielder and the organization’s primary backup for Javy Baez at shortstop (and was also having a really great spring), but he has struggled mightily at the plate since being forced into big league duty at the end of the 2019 season (his 73 wRC+ ranks 12th worst in MLB for any batters with at least 200 PAs since his big league debut).

But that’s not entirely his fault. As I’ve mentioned before, he still has *far* less minor league experience than many of the recent Cubs prospects, all of whom were relatively rushed to the majors, themselves!

Minor League PAs before MLB:

•   Nico Hoerner: 375 PAs
•   Kyle Schwarber: 621
•   Jorge Soler: 622
•   Kris Bryant: 773
•   Ian Happ: 978
•   Addison Russell: 1,087
•   Javier Báez: 1,350
•   Albert Almora Jr.: 1,788
•   Willson Contreras: 2,132

So, as I’ve explained many times before, I am alright with the Cubs sending Hoerner to the alternate site (for the first month) and ultimately Triple-A Iowa to start the year (where he still hasn’t taken a single at-bat). At the end of the day, he needs more time to develop his offensive approach against pitchers who will attack him *like* a big league pitcher will, but with worse stuff (velocity, movement, etc.). And, yes, I know a big spring training performance makes that easy to forget, but we can’t let ourselves learn the same lesson the hard way year after year.

And to be *crystal* clear, I only support this decision – which will likely make the Cubs worse in the short term – because I believe so strongly in Hoerner’s future. If I didn’t, I’d say his value to a team that absolutely *needs* his quality of defense in the infield is more important than his development. And, frankly, this could hurt the Cubs chances in the first half, which could make decisions even tougher at the deadline.

But, again, I think the long-term value – plus reasonable bridge options in Eric Sogard (whom the Cubs front office obviously loves) plus the lively bat of David Bote (who, himself, deserves a good look) – may make it all worth it in the end.

I am sure we will see Nico Hoerner up with the Cubs before the end of the season, and likely for a long time after that.

As for the service time manipulation stuff brought up in the Passan tweet, I don’t know. I don’t want to comment on it too directly without knowing all the facts. But I do know a few things: (1) Hoerner does have stuff to work on in the minors, (2) The Cubs have dealt with serious service time manipulation grievances before (Kris Bryant), and (3) teams hold prospects/young players down for all sorts of reasons, some with malintent, others not.

written by

Michael Cerami began covering the Chicago Cubs for Bleacher Nation as a part-time contributor in 2015. One year later, he joined Bleacher Nation full-time, covering the Chicago Cubs and Major League Baseball. Today, Michael runs Bleacher Nation, contributing as a writer (Cubs, MLB) and an editor for all sections of the site, including the Chicago Bears, Bulls, and Blackhawks, as well as MLB, NBA, NHL, and NFL. In 2019, Michael was the co-host of NBC Sports Chicago's Cubs Post-Game Show Outside the Ivy. You can find him on Twitter/X @Michael_Cerami

more cubs news

Enhanced Box Score: Rays 3, Cubs 2 – June 13, 2024

If I knew the Cubs were playing a re-run tonight, I wouldn't have tuned in. For the hundredth time this season, the Cubs got a really nice outing from their starter, Justin Steele (The Ankin Law “Making It Personal” Player...

LOL: The Cubs Just Bunted *THREE TIMES IN A ROW* … And It Worked!

The Cubs offense has been struggling to score runs lately. So naturally, the allure of small ball has reached the dugout. Last night, that meant stealing SIX bases. But tonight? Tonight, Craig Counsell had something sillier up his sleeve. In...

How to Win FREE Rooftop Tickets to a Cubs Game with the Bleacher Nation Team and Howard Ankin!

Back in 2021, when I was still living in the city up on the North Side of Chicago, I had a bike. And I liked to ride that bike south-east down Clybourn towards this little rock climbing gym in Lincoln...

Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Rays (5:50 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — The only thing more consistent than the Cubs' issues closing games or getting hits with runners in scoring position? Rubber matches. Including this series, ELEVEN of the Cubs 15 three-game series this season have resulted in a...

Cubs Announce Upcoming Rotation (Including Ben Brown’s Replacement)

There are no surprises here, but it is good to get the confirmation. According to Maddie Lee (Chicago Sun Times), the Cubs probables for this weekend's series against the Cardinals include Jordan Wicks (Friday), Shota Imanaga (Saturday), and Jameson Taillon...

Two Cubs Thumpers Are Getting Hot at the Same Time

Although their overall ability to score hasn't quite evened out yet — the numbers w/ RISP are still dreadful — the Cubs offense has started to wake up lately. Cody Bellinger has remained steady. Ian Happ has been solid since...

Let’s Take a Trip Together on the Attempted Steal of Third Base With Two Outs

There was a moment in last night's game when I spouted off some "traditional wisdom" about the game of baseball. I was pretty sure I was right, but it kinda caught me for a minute. I wanted to make sure...

MLBits: Correa and Lewis Power Twins Offensive Onslaught, Pages Rookie Mistake, Merrill’s Walk-Off Blast, More

MLB Notes — Carlos Correa had collected four hits in a game on 12 previous occasions entering last night's game with the Colorado Rockies. He picked up No. 13 last night before the seventh inning when the game went into...

Cubs Farm Report | June 13, 2024: Smokies Power Surge, Caissie Homers, More

Cubs Prospects — The Smokies were long ball happy on Wednesday, and Owen Caissie went yard for the I-Cubs in a losing effort. Cubs Farm Report | June 13, 2024 Triple-A Iowa Cubs Prospects The Iowa Cubs lost 6-3 in...

Big Night for the Tennessee Smokies: Triantos, Ballesteros, Franklin, McGeary, Pinango, Verdugo

The Chicago Cubs' Double-A squad at Tennessee deserved a special shout this morning. It's not just that they won their game over the Milwaukee Brewers' Double-A affiliate, and it's not just that they beat up on the organization's best pitching...

Latest News

Sky vs Mystics Prediction: Picks, Live Odds & Moneyline – June 14

The Washington Mystics (1-12) hope to break a five-game home losing streak when they host the Chicago Sky (4-7) on Friday, June 14, 2024 at 7:30 PM ET.Sky vs. Mystics Prediction & OddsFavorite: Sky (-2)Total: 157Sky Moneyline: -135Mystics Moneyline: +114Spread...

Lynx vs Sparks Prediction: Picks, Live Odds & Moneyline – June 14

Dearica Hamby and the Los Angeles Sparks (4-8) are up against Napheesa Collier and the Minnesota Lynx (9-3) on Friday, June 14, 2024 at Target Center. The matchup starts at 7:30 PM ET on ION.Lynx vs. Sparks Prediction & OddsFavorite:...

Nationals vs. Marlins: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Friday at 6:45 PM ET, C.J. Abrams and the Washington Nationals (32-36) face Jazz Chisholm and the Miami Marlins (23-45) at Nationals Park.The article below will give you everything you need to know to watch Washington take on Miami.When...

Giants vs. Angels: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

Matt Chapman and the San Francisco Giants (34-35) host Taylor Ward and the Los Angeles Angels (26-42) at 10:15 PM ET on Friday.Keep reading to see how to watch the San Francisco-Los Angeles matchup in the article below.When is Giants...

Rockies vs. Pirates: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

Ryan McMahon and the Colorado Rockies (24-44) host Bryan Reynolds and the Pittsburgh Pirates (32-36) at 8:40 PM ET on Friday.If you're intending to watch this game, keep reading for streaming and TV options for the Colorado-Pittsburgh matchup.When is Rockies...

Mavericks vs. Celtics Predictions, Best Bets and Odds: NBA Finals Game 4 – Friday, June 14, 2024

The Boston Celtics take a 0-3 series lead into a decisive Game 4 of the NBA Finals. The Mavericks are favored by 1 point in the matchup, which airs on ABC at 8:30 PM ET. The matchup has an over/under...

Lynx vs Sparks: Best Bets, Player Props & Computer Picks – June 14

Dearica Hamby and the Los Angeles Sparks (4-8) play Napheesa Collier and the Minnesota Lynx (9-3) on Friday, June 14, 2024 at Target Center, at 7:30 PM ET.If you are aiming to make an informed wager on Friday's game, find...

Sky vs Mystics: Best Bets, Player Props & Computer Picks – June 14

The Washington Mystics (1-12) will look to snap a five-game home losing streak when hosting the Chicago Sky (4-7) on Friday, June 14, 2024 at St. Elizabeths East Entertainment and Sports Arena, airing at 7:30 PM ET.Our computer predictions for...

Yankees vs. Red Sox: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – June 14

The Boston Red Sox (35-34) will host the New York Yankees (49-22), Friday at 6:30 PM ET, in a matchup of AL East rivals.Curious about who's playing for the Yankees and the Red Sox? Read on to see full injury...

Orioles vs. Phillies: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – June 14

The Baltimore Orioles (45-23) will host the Philadelphia Phillies (46-22), Friday at 7:05 PM ET, in the opener of a three-game series.Want to see who's in and who's out for the Orioles and the Phillies? Keep scrolling to get full...

more cubs news