The Chicago Cubs Could Get a “Ton” in a Craig Kimbrel Trade

I haven’t been particularly subtle in pointing out how much trade value I think a resurgent Craig Kimbrel has, even in an era of prospect hoarding and financial uncertainty and what-have-you. Dominant closers are the bee’s knees in the postseason, and Kimbrel is poised to be the best closer on the trade market since the Cubs paid out the nose for Aroldis Chapman in 2016. And Kimbrel comes with a team option for 2022.

So, when Buster Olney is saying Kimbrel will be the “most coveted player” on the market, you shouldn’t be surprised. And when Jon Heyman says this, you should nod in agreement:

“Kimbrel is the big one to me,” Heyman said on the Mully & Haugh Show on 670 The Score. “I mean, that’s the one that people are going to want the most. He’s been one of the two or three best closers in the game this year, an All-Star, regained his form. They should be able to get a ton for him. It’s a real seller’s market. We have many anxious buyers and almost all of them are looking for pitching. So while (Kris) Bryant has been the bigger Cubs player, the bigger Cubs star, Kimbrel particularly with that extra option (team option for 2022). Kimbrel is the one they can get the most for.”

Like I said yesterday, we’ll see what else happens on the market over the next few weeks, but it wouldn’t at all surprise me if we look back and see that Kimbrel netted the most in trade of any player who changes teams (barring some controllable starting pitcher or position player getting moved, which is obviously a different animal).

But how much is “a ton” in trade for Kimbrel in this environment? One where the game keeps getting younger, prospects keep getting more valuable, and an unsettled CBA looms?

Well, let’s start with the comp that’s close to all of our hearts. In late July 26, the Cubs traded Gleyber Torres, Billy McKinney, Rashad Crawford, and Adam Warren to the Yankees for Aroldis Chapman, then a pure rental. Although the deal became almost immediately reframed by Torres’s breakout later that year, it’s worth keeping the as-of-the-trade context in mind – he was considered a consensus top 50 prospect at the time, and was top 30 to most. He wasn’t quite a top 10 guy, which is what he became soon thereafter. McKinney was a back-end top 100 prospect entering that season, but had taken a step back in the eyes of most by the time of the trade. Crawford was a lottery ticket prospect, with upside, but outside the Cubs’ top 30 at the time. And Warren is a tough one to value as part of the trade, because he’d been so brilliant with the Yankees and had 2.5 years of control, but was BRUTALLY bad with the Cubs and was not going to be sticking around anyway.

So … the Cubs can get a top 30 prospect and a top 150 prospect and another lottery ticket and a throw-in big league piece for Kimbrel is what you’re saying?!?!

… well, no. I wouldn’t quite go that far. The return to the Yankees at the time was roundly considered an “overpay” by the Cubs, even if a completely understandable one given the context. In the current environment, it would be very, very hard to get a top 30 prospect as part of a package (if at all) in a deal for anyone. An elite closer with an extra year of control? Yeah, well, that might be as close as the discussion gets. So I wouldn’t rule it out. But I think multiple really solid prospects – maybe even a 50-100 guy and another near-100 guy? – is absolutely feasible. Maybe more.

To that end, I was trying to come up with a more recent comp that could give us an idea, and it’s really hard, both because no one like Kimbrel has been traded since Chapman, and also because you have to throw 2020 out entirely. So let me try to offer context this way, though it’s only marginally useful: in 2019, the Braves sent the 11th best prospect in their extremely loaded system (lefty Joey Wentz, probably top eight in an average system?) and a lottery ticket type (outfielder Travis Demeritte, a former first rounder) for rental closer Shane Greene, who had been getting great results with thoroughly mediocre peripherals. How much more valuable now is Kimbrel than Greene was then? So, so, so much more valuable. So extrapolate some value much larger than a, say, top eight system prospect and another back-end top 30 prospect.

That is all to say, yeah, Kimbrel should net the Cubs “a ton” if he’s traded this month. Maybe not quite a Chapman-level return, but definitely much more than we’ve seen for a reliever trade since the Chapman trade.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Mariners – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — Don't shoot the messenger, but this Cubs game doesn't start until 8:40pm CT ... and it's on AppleTV+. I don't make the rules. In any case, it's been a nice long break since the frustrating series in...

REPORT: Cubs Calling Up Keegan Thompson – Recent Performance, What to Expect, More

Last night, we learned that the Chicago Cubs had optioned right-handed reliever Jose Cuas to the Triple-A Iowa Cubs after a pretty horrendous start to the year. Although he's got some arm talent and a funky delivery (which creates a...

More Late-Night Games: Cubs vs Mariners Series Preview

Cubs vs Mariners — The Cubs west coast trip continues tonight in Seattle, where they'll open up the first of three games against the Mariners at T-Mobile Park. The Cubs are coming off a pretty frustrating series loss in San...

Apparently the Cubs Traded Catcher Joe Hudson to the Mets After Signing Ali Sanchez

In another bit of news dropping on the transactions page, the Chicago Cubs have traded catcher Joe Hudson to the New York Mets. Nothing is listed on the Cubs page or the Mets page as the trade return, so I...

Cubs Farm Report | April 11, 2024: Reginald Preciado’s Big Night Not Enough for Myrtle Beach

We've got a shorter Cubs Farm Report today, with half of the affiliates being rained out. The Iowa Cubs got their game in against the St. Paul Saints but lost to the Twins' affiliate. Myrtle Beach scored nine runs with...

Random Awesome Highlight Flashback: The Time Reed Johnson Robbed Prince Fielder of a Grand Slam

Thanks to yesterday's off-day and today's game being of the late-night variety, we're having to wait a very long time between games. For that reason, I very much appreciated today's random flashback from the Daily Random Cub account, which took...

Small Change Coming for Hendricks? Dreaming on Old Keegan Thompson, Streaks Alive, and Other Cubs Bullets

Sorry for the late bullets this morning. Brett is still working his way back (no pun intended), and I still have some other "running-the-site" duties to address on any given day. To that end, we are working on some stuff...

Cubs Prospect Reginald Preciado Making Some Early Noise

When the Cubs traded Yu Darvish to the Padres, everyone understood it to be two things: (1) saving some payroll in the wake of the pandemic, and (2) getting a volume-based return to stock up the farm system. In other...

Jose Cuas is Headed to Iowa, So the Cubs Must Be Making a Bullpen Move

As spotted by a number of eagle-eyed folks out there, the Chicago Cubs transaction page was updated tonight to include this line: "Chicago Cubs optioned RHP Jose Cuas to Iowa Cubs." There is no corresponding move listed. Yet. That means...

The Chicago Cubs’ Bonus Pool for the 2024 MLB Draft is Smaller Than You Probably Hoped

The full bonus pools for the upcoming 2024 MLB Draft are out, and the Chicago Cubs, despite picking 14th in the first round, will have only the 19th largest bonus pool, at $9,802,300. Thanks to compensatory draft picks and -...

Latest News

Wild vs. Sharks Prediction: Picks, Live Odds and Moneyline – Saturday, April 13, 2024

The bookmakers really fancy the Minnesota Wild to top the San Jose Sharks in their meeting on Saturday, April 13, with the visiting Wild given moneyline odds of -245, and the Sharks at +200.Wild vs. Sharks Favorite, Moneyline, TotalFavorite: Wild...

Kings vs. Ducks Prediction: Picks, Live Odds and Moneyline – Saturday, April 13, 2024

The Los Angeles Kings are big favorites (-340) at home versus the Anaheim Ducks (+270) on Saturday at 10:30 PM ET.Kings vs. Ducks Favorite, Moneyline, TotalFavorite: Kings (-340)Underdog: Ducks (+270)Total: 5.5Best Kings vs. Ducks Promo Codes[lasso type="table" id="1" link_id="1565208"]How to...

Oilers vs. Canucks Prediction: Picks, Live Odds and Moneyline – Saturday, April 13, 2024

The Edmonton Oilers are -142 on the moneyline against the Vancouver Canucks (+120) on Saturday, with this matchup taking place at Rogers Place in Edmonton.Oilers vs. Canucks Favorite, Moneyline, TotalFavorite: Oilers (-142)Underdog: Canucks (+120)Total: 6.5Best Oilers vs. Canucks Promo Codes[lasso...

How to Watch Dodgers vs. Padres: Live Stream or on TV

On Saturday, Mookie Betts and the Los Angeles Dodgers (10-5) face Fernando Tatis Jr. and the San Diego Padres (7-8), with first pitch scheduled for 9:10 PM ET at Dodger Stadium.Keep reading to find out how to watch the Los...

Predators vs. Blue Jackets Prediction: Live Odds, Stats, History and Picks – Saturday, April 13, 2024

The Nashville Predators are big favorites (-305) at home against the Columbus Blue Jackets (+245) at Bridgestone Arena on Saturday.Predators vs. Blue Jackets Favorite, Moneyline, TotalFavorite: Predators (-305)Underdog: Blue Jackets (+245)Total: 6.5Best Predators vs. Blue Jackets Promo Codes[lasso type="table" id="1"]How...

Cardinals vs. Diamondbacks: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The St. Louis Cardinals (6-7), who will give the start to Kyle Gibson, visit the Arizona Diamondbacks (6-7) with Ryne Nelson on the hill, Saturday at 8:10 PM ET.Keep reading to find out how to watch the St. Louis-Arizona matchup...

Astros vs. Rangers: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Houston Astros (4-11), who will give the ball to Ronel Blanco, host the Texas Rangers (8-6) with Andrew Heaney on the mound, Saturday at 4:05 PM ET.The article below will give you everything you need to know to watch...

Nationals vs. Athletics: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

MacKenzie Gore will take the ball for the Washington Nationals (5-7) when they visit starter Joseph Boyle and the Oakland Athletics (5-8) in a series opener on Saturday, with first pitch at 4:07 PM ET.The article below will provide you...

Cubs vs. Mariners: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Chicago Cubs (7-5), with Shota Imanaga on the hill, visit the Seattle Mariners (5-8) who will counter with Emerson Hancock, at 9:40 PM ET on Saturday in a series opener.Keep reading to find out all the details on how...

Stephen Curry Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Pelicans – Friday, April 12, 2024

To beat his 3-point prop, Stephen Curry needs to make five from beyond the arc on Friday, when his Golden State Warriors play the New Orleans Pelicans, tipping off at 10:00 PM ET.Stephen Curry's Three-Pointer Prop Odds vs. the PelicansStephen...

more cubs news