If the Cubs Want to Go Shorter-Term on Carlos Correa, the Average Annual Value is Gonna Have to Be Nuts

On the back of the big Cubs-Carlos Correa rumor last night (“mutual interest,” Cubs are “serious,” Cubs don’t want to go 10 years), I have been mulling what a shorter-term deal for Correa could even plausibly look like. I want to say up front that I still tend to think Correa is going to be able to get a very long deal – with opt out(s) – but it’s at least worth thinking about just HOW big the annual value would have to be, and what the contract structure would have to look like, for the Cubs to land Correa on a shorter deal.

Up first, a thought on what it means to be a “short” deal. In no universe is Carlos Correa, age 27, going to take a one or two or three-year deal. That might be “short”-term for some players, but for a guy like Correa, short-term is more like five years. And, moreover, there’s no chance he’ll sign a short-term deal like that for his last remaining prime-age seasons unless he’s getting an opt out. So you have to factor that in there, too.

Note that five years isn’t entirely coming out of thin air – that was reportedly the final offer from the Houston Astros before Correa hit free agency: 5/$160 million. No one expected him to take that deal, and thus it probably puts a hard floor of $32 million in average annual value (AAV) on any short-term deal Correa would even consider.

But if Correa were actually going to take a shorter-term deal, then the AAV is going to have to be truly wild. Much higher than $32 million. Probably a record-breaker.

The current record for AAV is the one just set by Max Scherzer at $43.3 million, though you could argue that’s a reaaaaally unique situation that isn’t comparable to a player like Correa. So, fine, maybe you throw that one out. The next highest AAV deal is Gerrit Cole’s ($36 million), but obviously that’s another imperfect fit. Next up is Mike Trout at $35.5 million, which is another really tough comp because Trout is the best player in baseball and also that was an extension. Anthony Rendon is next up at $35 million, and now we’re getting into more interesting comp territory (Rendon’s deal was seven years). As for shortstops, Francisco Lindor is at $34 million, and Corey Seager is (now) at $32.5 million. But those two guys got ten years.

You take all that together and just do some mental math, and you come to the conclusion that a shorter-term deal on Correa – even at five years – is gonna have to have an AAV up in that Cole range, at a minimum. You could argue it would have to approach $40 million, all things considered. Heck, maybe it would have to top Scherzer if it was only five years.

None of that is to say that a shorter-term deal is impossible or unwise for the Cubs. Indeed, there are arguments that, even for Correa, a hypothetical five-year, $200 million deal is a better bet than a ten-year, $300 million deal. Aging curves are a brutal reality. I’m only saying that, if you want to start thinking about a shorter-term deal on Correa – and it sounds like the Cubs do – then you have to think about going absolutely bonkers with the AAV.

By the way: if the luxury tax level gets a meaningful bump in the next Collective Bargaining Agreement, you can bet that a lot of large market teams are going to be even more interested in a shorter-term, higher-AAV deal for guys like Correa.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Dansby Swanson with Two Incredible Defensive Plays Tonight (And Justin Steele is Loving It)

Justin Steele is pitching really well tonight against the San Francisco Giants. But things would've have gone quite as smoothly so far if it weren't for Dansby Swanson. Not once, but TWICE tonight, Swanson has made a Gold Glove caliber...

Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Giants (8:45 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — The Cubs are starting a four-game, west-coast road trip tonight at Oracle Park. Justin Steele is on the mound for the Cubs, who are running out of time to turn this ship around before the trade deadline...

A West Coast Trip? Sure, Why Not … Cubs vs Giants Series Preview

Cubs vs Giants — In case you missed our earlier conversation, the Cubs upcoming stretch looks like their toughest of the year. And unfortunately, unless they start playing a lot better — immediately — this could be it for the...

An Incredible Week for Matt Shaw Means It’s Award Time

If you have seen Matt Shaw's name a lot this past week, it's because he's been lighting up the Southern League, even more than he already was. Thus, he gets some weekly award honors: https://twitter.com/smokiesbaseball/status/1805326329404870946 Shaw, 22, was the Cubs'...

The Second All-Star Ballot Update is Still Light on Chicago Cubs

Not that you'd expect otherwise at this point, but the Chicago Cubs are not running away with the fan voting for the 2024 position player All-Star starters. You have to go deep to find any Cubs names at all: https://twitter.com/MLB/status/1805286499128328237...

MLBits: Must Read on the Pitching Revolution, Mets, Cards, Kwan, More

MLB NOTES—Once in a while, you come across a story that's an absolute must-read. The Athletic's Andy McCullough delivered that for us this morning with his feature, which helps us understand the school of logic behind the pitching revolution in...

Cubs Farm Report | June 24, 2024: Shaw Blasts Two, Scary Collision, Just Missing Out, More

CUBS PROSPECTS — Matt Shaw blasted a pair of home runs, but a scary collision stole the show in a Tennessee loss that allowed Birmingham to take the first-half division title. Cubs Prospects Report | June 24, 2024 Triple-A Iowa...

He Has Work to Do For Sure, But Making Declarations About Pete Crow-Armstrong’s Offensive Future is Silly

I got pretty annoyed this weekend when I saw a bit from Bob Nightengale's latest: "MLB scouts have insisted all season that Chicago Cubs prospect Pete Crow-Armstrong may not be the impact bat that’s been hyped, and so far they’ve...

This Next Stretch Will Define the Cubs Season – And it’s Arguably Their Toughest of the Year

The Chicago Cubs are four games under .500, eight games out of first place, and nothing seems to be going right for them. So naturally, the universe is delivering one its toughest stretches of the season. And for the Cubs,...

It Ain’t a Good Feeling, Morel’s Blast, Diaz Sticky, Martinez PED, and Other Cubs Bullets

Going outside without immediately becoming drenched in sweat. Yeah baby. Today is a win. Well, for me, I mean. I can't speak for the Cubs' prospects in San Francisco tonight ... As for last night ... another loss. Another series...

Latest News

Today’s Copa America 2024 Predictions, Picks and Odds – Tuesday, June 25

With multiple games on Tuesday's 2024 Copa America schedule, let's take a look at the betting odds for each match.We break down the betting odds for all the important games today below.Head to Fubo to watch the entire Copa America...

Where to Watch Denmark vs. Serbia: UEFA European Championship 2024 TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

On Tuesday, June 25 at 3:00 PM ET, Denmark (2 points) and Serbia (1 point) meet for each side's final match in Group C at the 2024 UEFA European Championship.This game will be airing on Fox Sports 1.Watch the entire...

Where to Watch England vs. Slovenia: UEFA European Championship 2024 TV Channel, Start Time and Live Stream

England (4 points) and Slovenia (2 points) meet on Tuesday, June 25 at 3:00 PM ET in the third game of Group C action at the 2024 UEFA European Championship.You should head to FOX in order to see this match.Watch...

Padres vs. Nationals: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The San Diego Padres (41-41), led by Jurickson Profar, host C.J. Abrams and the Washington Nationals (38-39) on Tuesday at 9:40 PM ET.Keep reading to see how to watch the San Diego-Washington matchup in the article below.When is Padres vs....

Dodgers vs. White Sox: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

In a series opener on Tuesday, Bobby Miller will start for the Los Angeles Dodgers (48-31) against Chris Flexen and the Chicago White Sox (21-58), with first pitch scheduled for 8:10 PM ET at Guaranteed Rate Field.The article below will...

Angels vs. Athletics: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

Taylor Ward and the Los Angeles Angels (30-46) host JJ Bleday and the Oakland Athletics (29-51) on Tuesday in a series opener, with first pitch at 9:38 PM ET.Keep reading to find out how to watch the Los Angeles-Oakland matchup...

Connor McDavid Wins the Conn Smythe Trophy — on the Losing Team

After producing a historic 42 points (8 goals, 34 assists) in 24 games -- breaking Wayne Gretzky's playoff assist record -- Oilers superstar Connor McDavid won the Conn Smythe Trophy as the postseason's most valuable player. https://twitter.com/PR_NHL/status/1805437656936935880 Before tonight, only...

How to Watch Royals vs. Marlins: Live Stream or on TV

The Kansas City Royals (42-37), who will give the start to Seth Lugo, host the Miami Marlins (27-50) with Yonny Chirinos on the hill, Tuesday at 8:10 PM ET.The article below will give you everything you need to know to...

How to Watch Brewers vs. Rangers: Live Stream or on TV

The Milwaukee Brewers (45-33), led by William Contreras, host Marcus Semien and the Texas Rangers (37-40) at 8:10 PM ET on Tuesday in a series opener.If you're planning on watching this game, keep reading for streaming and TV options for...

Twins vs. Diamondbacks: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

In a series opener on Tuesday, Carlos Santana and the Minnesota Twins (43-35) face Ketel Marte and the Arizona Diamondbacks (38-40), with first pitch scheduled for 9:40 PM ET at Chase Field.Keep reading to see how to watch the Minnesota-Arizona...

more cubs news