So, is Trevor Story Not a Fall-Back Option for the Chicago Cubs?

Despite all the rumors connecting the sides, and the Christmas wishes from hopeful fans, it would be silly to call the Cubs “front-runners” for Carlos Correa at this point. I do think they’re legitimately in this race, the rumors are wayyyyy too specific for anything less, but at the end of the day, some very big questions remain. Also, generally speaking: lots of teams want very desirable players, so most of the interested teams wind up disappointed. That’s just the mathematical reality of an indivisible human.

So what happens in the more likely event that the Cubs do not land Carlos Correa this offseason? Well, there are some high-quality, relatively low-cost defensive options out there — and with this particular rotation, that would likely be the focus of any Cubs external addition at shortstop. But each of the names Brett investigated earlier this month would be quite a comedown from chasing the best free agent shortstop on the market, right?

The only other free agent option who is in an upper-tier – the kind whose signing, when paired with the Marcus Stroman addition, changes your thinking about the 2022 Cubs’ intentions – would be Trevor Story. No, he’s not Carlos Correa. He’s almost exactly two years older and had some arm injury/throwing concerns last season. His offensive numbers were down, too.

But he’s still one of the better shortstops in baseball and should cost a HECK of a lot less than Correa. And, hey, the Cubs were tangentially connected to Story very early in the offseason. So is he the Cubs fallback option if they whiff on Correa?

Well, no, actually, according to Bruce Levine (via his recent 670 The Score appearance):

“I really don’t [think Trevor Story is a fallback option for the Cubs]. I don’t think that people are that high on Story to give him a long-term deal. He’s had some issues, he’s had some throwing issues, he’s had some arm and shoulder issues. I don’t know what’s Story is going to get. I don’t know where he’s going to go. But I think the possibility for free agency is that he signs a shorter-term deal. If the situation is that Correa signs quickly [after the new CBA] maybe I’m wrong. Maybe he gets a six or seven-year contract. He’s a really good player, but after the year he had and some of the problems he had physically, I don’t think he’s getting a six or seven-year contract.”

I won’t brush off that response entirely, but I’d note that the certainty with which Levine reported on the Cubs-Correa stuff felt like it came with far more conviction than the more speculative-y response he had with respect to Cubs-Story. In other words, the Correa discussion last week felt like A Report; the Story stuff felt like a guess. I’m not sure Levine is planting his flag in the ground saying the Cubs absolutely would never consider Story later in the offseason.

So let’s keep this door open for a moment, shall we? Even if only to discuss the other big free agent shortstop? What are the factors here? What are the concerns?

The obvious upside is that of an above-average defensive shortstop, who runs the bases well, and comes with an above-average offensive career (.272/.340/.523; 112 wRC+ and 158 home runs). All on a potentially under-market deal because of down 2021 season (100 wRC+, defensive questions tied to the arm). There’s some quality upside there!

… the definite downside is that he will still likely command a significant contract, comes with the mentioned risks, and would cost the Cubs draft pick compensation (second-round draft pick, associated bonus pool space, and $500K in IFA money – a price they’d likely be more willing to pay for Correa and/or on a longer deal). But, of course, that’s not all.

There are some fairly massive traditional splits to consider. Correa hasn’t just been better at Coors Field (125 wRC+) than he has been on the road (98 wRC+) throughout his career, he’s also been faaar better against lefties (146 wRC+) than righties (98 wRC+), which isn’t a particularly useful split when you’re talking about an everyday player.

I’m still willing to bet he remains an above-average overall offensive contributor in the short-term (don’t forget the Coors hangover effect, which disproportionately hurts Rockies players on the road). That would make him a well-above average offensive shortstop overall. But the splits are not factors you can completely ignore. What if he’s actually trending downward, and the splits are just going to make that trend even sharper in the years ahead?

Ditto the defense. What if those arm issues that affected his throws don’t go away as he approaches 30? What if they get worse? Sure, the Cubs need offensive firepower, but they also desperately need to improve their infield defense given the skillset of the front three in their rotation. Story will probably be a plus defensive shortstop, but he’s not without his red flags.

Still, at the end of the day, Story is likely going to cost FAR less than Carlos Correa. And if the Cubs can get creative to minimize the cost of signing a qualified free agent, Story might not be a terrible short-term, high-upside play, if he goes for a deal like that. In fact, if it’s a short-term deal, he kind of matches the bigger picture idea of adding Marcus Stroman, Wade Miley, Yan Gomes, etc., and seeing how things go in the first half of 2022 before re-evaluating.

Ultimately, I think I wind up somewhere like this: If the Cubs are serious about adding Carlos Correa, who comes with his own red flags (injury) and risks (extreme cost), and we believe they are, then I don’t see why they wouldn’t consider Trevor Story as a lower-cost, lower-upside Plan B? That’s not entirely rhetorical, mind you, because the Cubs may have some internal calculation that has simply ruled Story out completely. But absent something like that, you’d presume – after Correa signs – there is some price tag at which the Cubs would deem Story too good of a deal to pass up. In the end, isn’t that actually what is guiding a lot of their maneuverings in the current moment?

Brett Taylor contributed to this post.

written by

Michael Cerami began covering the Chicago Cubs for Bleacher Nation as a part-time contributor in 2015. One year later, he joined Bleacher Nation full-time, covering the Chicago Cubs and Major League Baseball. Today, Michael runs Bleacher Nation, contributing as a writer (Cubs, MLB) and an editor for all sections of the site, including the Chicago Bears, Bulls, and Blackhawks, as well as MLB, NBA, NHL, and NFL. In 2019, Michael was the co-host of NBC Sports Chicago's Cubs Post-Game Show Outside the Ivy. You can find him on Twitter/X @Michael_Cerami

more cubs news

Jose Cuas is Headed to Iowa, So the Cubs Must Be Making a Bullpen Move

As spotted by a number of eagle-eyed folks out there, the Chicago Cubs transaction page was updated tonight to include this line: "Chicago Cubs optioned RHP Jose Cuas to Iowa Cubs." There is no corresponding move listed. Yet. That means...

The Chicago Cubs’ Bonus Pool for the 2024 MLB Draft is Smaller Than You Probably Hoped

The full bonus pools for the upcoming 2024 MLB Draft are out, and the Chicago Cubs, despite picking 14th in the first round, will have only the 19th largest bonus pool, at $9,802,300. Thanks to compensatory draft picks and -...

Kyle Hendricks’ Brutal Start, the Cubs’ Limited Options, Some Reason for Optimism

There's really no way to sugar-coat this: The first three starts of Kyle Hendricks' season could not have gone worse. Like, almost literally. According to ESPN Stats and Info, the 17 earned runs Kyle Hendricks has allowed through three games...

I Bet Christopher Morel Has Been Even Better Than You Realize

When I was looking into Michael Busch's excellent plate discipline numbers to start the season for the bullets this morning, I was happy to see Christopher Morel's name even higher up the leaderboards. Generally speaking, Morel is known for his...

Federal Charges Reportedly Filed Against Ippei Mizuhara, Claiming Theft of Over $16 Million from Shohei Ohtani

Per multiple reports, federal authorities today announced that Ippei Mizuhara, formerly the translator for Shohei Ohtani, is facing formal charges related to the scandal that rocked baseball's opening week. According to the reports, the federal criminal complaint alleges that Mizuhara...

Cubs Farm Report | April 10, 2024: Wisdom, Mervis Lead Iowa, Rojas’ Big Day, More

Wednesday was a successful day for the Cubs affiliates, with three wins in four tries. Patrick Wisdom and Alexander Canario each hit home runs for the Iowa Cubs in a victory over the St. Paul Saints. Moises Ballesteros, Nick Dean,...

Wake Up and Watch the Cubs Beat the Padres, Craig Counsell’s Comments

West Coast highlights hit different. By which I mean, many of us can't actually be awake after midnight thanks to life, and thus the Cubs highlights from a game out west might be all the more important. It's the first...

Scott Boras Just Lost One of His Biggest Clients, After Fumbling the Bag This Offseason

Well this is new! We've seen plenty of players leave their agents/agency for Scott Boras in the past. But rarely does it go the other way. Of course, rarely does Scott Boras miss as badly (or overplay his hand as...

Two of the Most-Prospect-Loaded Minor League Rosters Belong to the Cubs

Although we think often about Chicago Cubs minor league teams in a variety of ways, including how prospect dense they may or may not be, I don't know how often we think about how prospect dense they are relative to...

Checking All the Boxes, Busch’s Good Decisions, Hope’s Helium (for L.A.), Lucky Brewers, and Other Cubs Bullets

I, for one, am incredibly thankful for the wonderful day of performances from top prospects in the Cubs minor league system yesterday. It's a perfect palette cleanser on this off-day following a series we all want to forget. But, hey,...

Latest News

Rays vs. Giants: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Friday, in a series opener at Tropicana Field, Tyler Alexander starts for the Tampa Bay Rays (7-6) against Keaton Winn and the San Francisco Giants (5-8), with first pitch scheduled for 6:50 PM ET.If you're planning on watching this...

Knicks vs. Nets Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets – Friday, April 12, 2024

The New York Knicks (48-32) are big, 10-point favorites as they try to continue a three-game winning streak when they host the Brooklyn Nets (32-48) on Friday, April 12, 2024 at Madison Square Garden. The contest airs at 7:30 PM...

Suns vs. Kings Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets – Friday, April 12, 2024

The Sacramento Kings (45-35) will look to De'Aaron Fox (eighth in the league scoring 26.7 points per game) when they try to overcome Kevin Durant (fifth in the NBA with 27.2 PPG) and the Phoenix Suns (47-33) on Friday, April...

Thunder vs. Bucks Predictions, Best Bets and Odds – Friday, April 12, 2024

The Oklahoma City Thunder (55-25) are big, 14.5-point favorites as they attempt to extend a three-game win streak when they host the Milwaukee Bucks (49-31) on Friday, April 12, 2024 at Paycom Center. The matchup airs at 8:00 PM ET...

Cavaliers vs. Pacers Predictions, Best Bets and Odds – Friday, April 12, 2024

The Indiana Pacers (46-34) are underdogs (+3) as they try to build on a three-game win streak when they visit the Cleveland Cavaliers (47-33) at 7:30 PM ET on Friday, April 12, 2024 at Rocket Mortgage FieldHouse. The contest airs...

Knicks vs. Nets Predictions, Best Bets and Odds – Friday, April 12, 2024

The New York Knicks (48-32) are heavily favored (-10.5) to build on a three-game winning streak when they host the Brooklyn Nets (32-48) at 7:30 PM ET on Friday, April 12, 2024 at Madison Square Garden. The contest airs on...

Flames vs. Ducks Prediction: Picks, Live Odds and Moneyline – Friday, April 12, 2024

The Calgary Flames are at the Anaheim Ducks on April 12 at 10:00 PM ET, and are -155 favorites, with the home team at +130.Flames vs. Ducks Favorite, Moneyline, TotalFavorite: Flames (-155)Underdog: Ducks (+130)Total: 6Best Flames vs. Ducks Promo Codes[lasso...

Phillies vs. Pirates: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

Cristopher Sanchez will take the mound for the Philadelphia Phillies (7-6) when they host starter Bailey Falter and the Pittsburgh Pirates (9-4) on Friday, with first pitch at 6:40 PM ET.Keep scrolling to find out all the details on how...

Diamondbacks vs. Cardinals: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Arizona Diamondbacks (6-7), who will give the ball to Brandon Pfaadt, host the St. Louis Cardinals (6-7) with Steven Matz on the mound, Friday at 9:40 PM ET.If you're intending to watch this game, keep reading for TV and...

Mariners vs. Cubs: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Seattle Mariners (5-8), who will give the ball to Bryce Miller, host the Chicago Cubs (7-5) with Jordan Wicks on the hill, Friday at 9:40 PM ET.The article below will provide you with everything you need to know to...

more cubs news