David Ortiz is a First Ballot Hall of Famer, No One Else Getting In This Year

Even as there are other players I would be voting to enshrine – who have no chance of ever getting voted in, by the writers or the committees – that doesn’t take away from the fact that I think David Ortiz deserves the honor he’s receiving.

David Ortiz is a Hall of Famer:

https://twitter.com/fergieajenkins/status/1486120351679582210

The long-time Red Sox slugger, who was one of the best hitters of his era and who dominated in the postseason, received 77.9% of the vote in his first year on the ballot. At a 75% cutoff, no other players received enough support for enshrinement:

(via BBWAA)

For Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Curt Schilling, and Sammy Sosa, this is it. They are now off the ballot going forward, and their candidacy is in the hands of the various committees that MLB and the Hall of Fame have put together. I don’t expect any of the four to get in during their lifetimes.

I didn’t do a lot of mulling on the Hall of Fame this year – I’m a bit frustrated with the whole thing – but I did discuss a bit on Ortiz back in December, relative to an article on why Ortiz gets so much support but Sammy Sosa does not:

It seems likely that, for voters who are making choices based on PED suppositions, there is a meaningful difference between Sosa and Ortiz: although both “tested positive” only within that 2003 survey that was absolutely not supposed to be used in this way (and was also reportedly fraught with data collection issues), the bulk of Sosa’s big league success took place before the league actually cracked down on PEDs. Ortiz’s success, by contrast, took place almost entirely within the testing era, and he never tested positive, despite putting up monster numbers even into his late-30s. (Rosenthal acknowledges this distinction, though it’s not the reason he votes for one and not the other – mostly it’s a strategic decision that he knows Sosa won’t get enough votes, and he wants to support another player who has a better chance.)

You probably don’t *have* to get into all of that to make the case for Ortiz over Sosa, though. In a worse scoring environment, Ortiz became, by far, the better overall hitter than Sosa. And although Ortiz was mostly a DH, Sosa’s defense was pretty bad by the time he was putting up his best offensive numbers. Throw in Ortiz’s substantial postseason accomplishments, and, fair or not, I can see why he gets more support than Sosa.

For me, on Sosa, I remain of the mind that you cannot punish the pre-2003 players for their PED use when the league CLEARLY had no interest in actually enforcing these rules, and indeed made guys like Sosa the face of the sport precisely because of the things they were (possibly, probably) doing on the backs of those substances. I may not like the cheating, and I definitely feel terrible for the clean players in that era, but it just seems to entirely ignore reality to act like we can suss out who cheated, who didn’t, who would’ve been a Hall of Famer even if they hadn’t cheated, and all that crap. Just look at the performance for the era, incorporate as much knowledge as possible, and make a decision on whether the player was truly among the elite of the elite for that era. That’s why I’ve been on the fence for so long with Sosa and the Hall, some years thinking it should happen, other years thinking he was actually statistically just short in his era. If I had a vote this year, I can see beating myself up a bit whichever direction I went. Not that it would matter, because he’s not going to get enough votes in this, his final year on the ballot.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Does a Suddenly-Hot Nico Hoerner Make Sense for the Now Ozzie Albies-less Braves? Eh…

In the almost two months from April 27-June 22 (175 PAs), Nico Hoerner was ice cold. During all that time, the Cubs second baseman managed just nine extra base hits (only two homers) and slashed .200/.291/.284 (68 wRC+). But since...

The Rally Bucket Returns, Shōta’s Partial No-No, Lester HOF, Prospect Dingers, and Other Cubs Bullets

We're having a Happy Hour this Saturday in Chicago, and it'll be a fun and free time! Details here, register here! While I could focus on the long scoreless streak that preceded it, I do think it was very nice...

Let’s Go … Build That Trade Value? Brewers vs Cubs Series Preview

[BN_drinks] Cubs vs Brewers — The Cubs needed to win AT LEAST two of three against the Diamondbacks this weekend to make this coming Cubs-Brewers series "matter," but they came up short. And worse, they once again looked generally lifeless,...

Cubs Could “Theoretically” Listen to Trade Offers for Justin Steele

The Athletic trio of Ken Rosenthal, Patrick Mooney, and Will Sammon dropped a Trade Deadline article that got me sitting up in my chair and typing rapidly this morning. You drop Justin Steele's name in a rumor-type article and my...

Wake Up and Watch Shōta Imanaga Dominate, and the Cubs Literally Walk It Off

The Chicago Cubs salvaged the Sunday finale of their series against the Diamondbacks, and although the series as a whole is hardly worth celebrating, the win did feature a few very good things. For one, you had Shōta Imanaga coming...

New Cardinals Home Run Celebration Raises Questions

Although I'm sure Jim Edmonds would be UTTERLY APPALLED to see that his St. Louis Cardinals are celebrating home runs, the team has recently gotten together with a distinct home run celebration. Because the celebration visually evokes images from the...

Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 2, Diamondbacks 1 – July 21, 2024

BEGGERS CAN'T BE CHOOSERS! The Cubs did nothing offensively for almost nine full innings, but Nico Hoerner scored the tying run in the bottom of the 9th, and then "drove in" the winning run on a walk-off walk: https://twitter.com/Cubs/status/1815127531047309382 We...

Cubs May Be Opening to the Idea of Trading Jameson Taillon, Reportedly Have Had Talks

In the last two days, Jameson Taillon's name has popped up twice in relation to the upcoming MLB Trade Deadline. This happens against the backdrop of the Chicago Cubs probably very eager NOT to sell, but the reality of their...

Pre-Gamin’: Cubs vs Diamondbacks (1:20 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — The Cubs season isn't hanging on by a thread anymore. At this point, after two lifeless losses to the Diamondbacks to open the second half, they'd have to undergo a miracle resuscitation —something for the history books....

“Two Tough Ones,” No Offense, Injury News, Promotions, Serious Draft Success, and Other Cubs Bullets

[ankin_law] Well, sir. If you believed the Cubs needed to go 7-3 over these final pre-deadline games to push the front office to really buy, they are now down to having to go 7-1 after losing the first two games...

Latest News

Red Sox vs. Rockies Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, July 22, 2024

Ezequiel Tovar leads the Colorado Rockies (36-64) into Monday's matchup with the Boston Red Sox (53-45) on a three-game homer streak. His Rockies are underdogs for the contest, however, with sportsbooks naming the Red Sox as -169 moneyline favorites. The...

Phillies vs. Twins Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, July 22, 2024

The Minnesota Twins (54-44) will lean on Byron Buxton, following a two-homer game, to lead them in a matchup with the Philadelphia Phillies (63-36) on Monday at 7:40 PM ET on NBCS-PH. The Twins are -104 underdogs for the contest,...

Red Sox vs. Rockies Probable Starting Pitchers – July 22

The Boston Red Sox (53-45) look to end to a three-game skid as they visit the Colorado Rockies (36-64) on Monday at 8:40 PM ET.The Red Sox will call on Tanner Houck (8-6) against the Rockies and Austin Gomber (2-6).Red...

Legal DraftKings Sportsbook States: Where the Sportsbook is Available in the US

DraftKings, a powerhouse in the daily fantasy sports (DFS) and sports betting industry, has taken the US by storm. But with constantly evolving legalization landscapes, navigating where you can legally place a wager can be tricky. Fear not, sports fans!...

Royals vs. Diamondbacks Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, July 22, 2024

The Kansas City Royals (55-45) will vie for their fourth straight victory when they host the Arizona Diamondbacks (51-49) on Monday at 8:10 PM ET on BSKC. The Royals are listed as -157 favorites by oddsmakers, while the Diamondbacks are...

Rangers vs. White Sox Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, July 22, 2024

The Chicago White Sox (27-74) hope to avoid their eighth straight defeat when they visit the Texas Rangers (47-52) Monday at 8:05 PM ET on BSSW. The Rangers are listed as -171 favorites, while the White Sox are +145 underdogs...

Brewers vs. Cubs Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, July 22, 2024

Following a two-homer game in a win over the Twins, Eric Haase leads the Milwaukee Brewers (57-42) into action as -122 favorites against the Chicago Cubs (48-53). First pitch from Wrigley Field at 8:05 PM ET on Monday, live on...

Braves vs. Reds Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, July 22, 2024

A losing streak will come to an end Monday when the Atlanta Braves (54-44), losers of two straight, take on the Cincinnati Reds (47-53). The Reds are hoping to avoid their fourth loss in a row. The Braves are -150...

Tigers vs. Guardians Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, July 22, 2024

The Cleveland Guardians (59-39) enter Monday's matchup with the Detroit Tigers (49-51) following their 1-2 series defeat to the Padres. The Tigers, coming off of a series win against the Blue Jays, are listed as -130 favorites for Game 1....

Pirates vs. Cardinals Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, July 22, 2024

The Pittsburgh Pirates (50-49) are set to take on the St. Louis Cardinals (52-47) Monday at 6:40 PM ET, airing on BSMW. The Pirates are listed as -126 favorites by bookmakers, while the underdog Cardinals have +107 odds for the...

more cubs news