Scott Boras on the Huge Connection Between Draft Changes and Tanking, and Also a Great Bonus Idea

Made out for years by owners and fans as the central villain of all things financial, super agent Scott Boras has taken an even more visible place over the last two years of tumult. Sure, I find many of his analogies and puns eye-rolling, and I am cautious about anything that centers the top-tier earners at the expense of the lower-earning guys and/or amateurs (not to say he does that, exclusively! I’m just cautious about when it happens). But, generally speaking, Boras is just a very visible, very involved, very successful agent, who does right by his clients. I think he gets more grief than is deserved.

Not that this post is designed to be an apologia for Boras, who has been made out to be the prime bad guy by some in the CBA negotiations. Instead, it’s to introduce an interview he gave to The Athletic, the timing of which is obviously very interesting. I am always very interested to hear what he has to say, and right now that’s more true than ever. Recall, it’s not just that Boras’s agency represents dozens and dozens of players, he also counts several players on the MLBPA executive council among his clients. His opinion matters a great deal.

First, here’s the full interview, worth your time to explore (either written or in audio):

The conversation was obviously wide ranging, but I wanted to touch on two points made by Boras – one because it’s central to what the players are fighting for in these CBA negotiations, and the other because it’s simply a great idea.

First, Boras hammers the idea of non-competition in the sport – it is clearly a problem that the players want to combat, both because it sucks for guys on tanking teams and because it means money isn’t being spent on salaries. What Boras highlights, though, is the impact that the changes to the draft two CBAs ago had on this issue (and we know it well, because it happened just as Theo Epstein and Jed Hoyer were arriving, setting up a specific plan for reorienting the organization):

I don’t think a lot of people really understood what the draft means to these major league teams. In 2011 when they allowed (MLB) to put a cap on the draft, I heard general managers say things two weeks before (about) what they were going to do, and then completely alter their program once they got the rules and understood what was available to them. And that was, sell off your free agents, it’s a race to the bottom so I can get all these valued draft picks and get as many as I can. And it gave the fan base a method of illustrating that losing was OK; it was actually beneficial. And I think when you introduce that cancer, that non-competitive cancer, into the sport … the local fan does not go to the ballpark with the intent of having his team win every day. And I think we have to reintroduce that into our game.

The combined impact of (relatively) hard bonus pools, dramatic changes to draft pick compensation, and draft-related luxury tax penalties created a situation where teams realized how hard it was going to be to build through the draft in the new world. Although tanking was always at least a peripheral issue, it did not become absolutely pervasive until teams could no longer “overspend” in the draft. You more or less had to have a high pick if you wanted a great draft class, not so much because picking higher is better (although it is!), but because the differences in the size of your bonus pool were so dramatic depending on where you were picking. The differences between a 20th pick draft and a 3rd pick draft just got SO magnified.

Also? If you know you won’t be making the playoffs anyway, and you know it’s going to hurt you significantly to finish with the 10th worst record instead of the 2nd worst record, why would you spend on free agents?

So, as Boras said, teams coupled a race to the bottom with plans to sell off at the deadline, and it became all about building up the prospect base. Again: we’ve seen it up close and personal here with the Cubs! There are reasons not to like it, obviously, but it was also the system the Cubs had to operate under. Back in 2012-14, I’m sorry, but it simply made too much sense not to do it. (In 2021, the sell-off at the deadline certainly made sense, though a multi-year tank job would not and should not, in my view.)

Interesting, then, that I’ve heard no talk about reshaping the hard bonus pools or lessening the overspending penalties to make the bonus pools much softer. Some teams might cry “competitive balance!,” but the reality is that small-market clubs were always financially able to spend more in the draft. An extra $10 million above your pool, for example, would be an absolute BLOWOUT MONSTER spending draft … you really gonna tell me the Pirates couldn’t afford that?

Instead, the focus has been on a draft lottery, which, if implemented correctly, could have the desired effect. I’m just not sure it would be nearly as effective as it would be if you paired the lottery with changes to the way bonus pools work. (Am I being a little bit of a homer because I know the Cubs would spend aggressively in the draft every year, which is all the more important in the years they’re drafting low? A little, I guess. But the same paths would be available to all teams.)

That is all to say, I think Boras is right to target this issue as a major, major factor in the competitive cultural shift over the past decade.

The other bit I want to share – again, it’s a super long interview with a lot to get into – is simply an idea for getting a little more compensation into the minor leagues. On first glance, it strikes me as a great idea, especially if paired with the continued push to improve wages in the minor leagues. It’s something like a uniform bonus system, but very smartly is not coming from the teams that might otherwise game it to the players’ detriment:

We also have to have an incentive program, where when you play over three years in the minor leagues, you get a $50,000 bonus. Not paid by the team, but paid by a contributory pool that we put player fines and penalties in over time. If you actually do make it to the major leagues, and you didn’t get a bonus that exceeded a couple of million dollars, you would then be able to get an extra $500,000 for making it to the big leagues. So these men who’ve contributed their lives, and they’re going to have very short major league careers, they’re getting a benefit from their minor league service, which, as we all know, is very important to the preparation of the great major leaguers who we enjoy.

You can play with the numbers however is necessary to actually make it financially feasible, but wouldn’t it be great if the guys who were career minor leaguers – or journeymen who just barely make the big leagues – would have a chance to earn significant dollars? They are creating value by their mere presence in the minor leagues, after all (you can’t properly develop the next superstar if he doesn’t have teammates and opponents to play with and against).

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Mike Tauchman Has to Leave the Game in the Third Inning with a Groin Issue

[ankin_law] After legging out an infield single in the bottom of the third tonight, Mike Tauchman immediately - and aggressively - signaled for the athletic trainer to join him on the field. Tauchman tried to stretch out a bit, but...

Oof: Anthony Rizzo Reportedly Fractured His Arm on That Scary Collision at First Base

The Yankees are getting Gerrit Cole back this week, but they'll lose Anthony Rizzo for a while. According to The Athletic's Ken Rosenthal, Rizzo has an arm fracture. While the club doesn't expect Rizzo to need surgery to repair the...

Pre-Gamin’: Cubs vs Giants (7:05 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — Please, Cubs. Win a game. Score some early runs. Just be better. Chicago Cubs Lineup: Mike Tauchman, DH Christopher Morel, 3B Cody Bellinger, CF Seiya Suzuki, RF Ian Happ, LF Nico Hoerner, 2B Michael Busch, 1B Dansby...

MLBits: Major Injuries, Cole is Back, Witt Incredible, Ranking City Connects, More

MLB Notes — It was a tough weekend for the Los Angeles Dodgers. I know there's not much sympathy for a team that spent over a billion dollars on future contracts, one of which brought them the game's brightest star...

Cubs Farm Report | June 17, 2024: Owen Caissie’s Three-Run Blast Caps Big Day for Iowa

CUBS PROSPECTS — Owen Caissie's three-run homer caps a strong day for Iowa at the dish on Sunday. Cubs Prospects Report | June 17, 2024 Triple-A Iowa Cubs Prospects The Iowa Cubs defeated the Columbus Clippers 11-6. Starter Riley Thompson...

Latest MLB Mock Drafts: A New Name for the Cubs?

The 2024 MLB Draft is just one month away, and the Draft Combine begins this week. A good time, then, for a couple new mock drafts to drop ... The latest MLB Pipeline mock draft has the Chicago Cubs taking...

The First All-Star Ballot Update is Very Light on Chicago Cubs

Like an empty-nest bear home, the top of the first round of MLB All-Star Game balloting results features no Cubs. https://twitter.com/MLB/status/1802752018726998254 You do see some Cubs names show up waaaay down the ballot, with Nico Hoerner, Dansby Swanson, and Christopher...

The Dodgers Have Lost BOTH Mookie Betts and Yoshinobu Yamamoto to Long-Term Injuries

[ankin_law] Nobody is going to spill any tears for the Los Angeles Dodgers (44-29), but it had to be quite a headspinner for the fans this weekend as BOTH Mookie Betts and Yoshinobu Yamamoto have gone out for what could...

Time To Start Winning – Cubs vs Giants Series Preview

Cubs vs Giants — I started typing the intro here, when it turned into that angry, bloggy, rambling post from this morning: Well ... This Sure Sucks, Doesn't It? So check that one out for the emotion. We'll just turn...

Just Keep Swimming, Another Set of Good Taillon Results, Offensive Turns, and Other Cubs Bullets

Talking about games on a day-to-day basis with this team has become almost intolerable, because there is almost never anything new or interesting to say. Some of that is on me - my job is to tease out the interesting...

Latest News

Tuesday’s MLB Computer Picks & Best Bets – June 18

The MLB's 15-game slate on Tuesday is not one to miss, and we offer best bets for each game here. The matchups include the Baltimore Orioles playing the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium.MLB picks todaySt. Louis Cardinals at Miami...

France vs. Netherlands Euros Odds, Match Time and Preview – June 21

On June 21 at 3:00 PM ET, France and the Netherlands collide at Red Bull Arena in their second match of the 2024 UEFA European Championship (Group D).France's game versus the Netherlands will be available on FOX. Sportsbooks have given...

Chile vs. Peru Copa America Odds, Match Time and Preview – June 21

Chile opens its 2024 Copa America campaign with a match against Peru at 8:00 PM ET on June 21.Chile's matchup versus Peru will be available on Fox Sports 1. Chile is +101 to win this group-stage game, Peru is +320,...

Austria vs. Poland Euros Odds, Match Time and Preview – June 21

On June 21 at 12:00 PM ET, Austria and Poland meet at Olympiastadion in their second match of the 2024 UEFA European Championship (Group D).You should head to Fox Sports 1 in order to watch this match. The three-way moneyline...

Red Sox vs. Blue Jays: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

Jarren Duran and the Boston Red Sox (37-35) visit Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and the Toronto Blue Jays (35-36) on Tuesday, with first pitch at 7:07 PM ET.Keep reading to find out how to watch the Boston-Toronto matchup in the article...

How to Watch Braves vs. Tigers: Live Stream or on TV

On Tuesday, Spencer Schwellenbach will start for the Atlanta Braves (38-31) against Casey Mize and the Detroit Tigers (34-37), with first pitch scheduled for 7:20 PM ET at Truist Park.The article below will provide you with everything you need to...

Mike Tauchman Has to Leave the Game in the Third Inning with a Groin Issue

[ankin_law] After legging out an infield single in the bottom of the third tonight, Mike Tauchman immediately - and aggressively - signaled for the athletic trainer to join him on the field. Tauchman tried to stretch out a bit, but...

How to Watch Cardinals vs. Marlins: Live Stream or on TV

The St. Louis Cardinals (35-35), led by Brendan Donovan, visit Jazz Chisholm and the Miami Marlins (23-48) at 6:10 PM ET on Tuesday in a series opener.Keep reading to find out all the details on how to watch St. Louis...

How to Watch Reds vs. Pirates: Live Stream or on TV

On Tuesday, Nick Lodolo will take the mound for the Cincinnati Reds (34-37) versus Bailey Falter and the Pittsburgh Pirates (34-37), with first pitch scheduled for 6:40 PM ET at PNC Park.The article below will give you everything you need...

Phillies vs. Padres: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

Aaron Nola takes the mound for the Philadelphia Phillies (47-24) when they host starting pitcher Michael King and the San Diego Padres (37-38) at 6:40 PM ET on Tuesday.The article below will provide you with everything you need to know...

more cubs news