Oh … So the Owners Who Opposed MLB’s Last Offer Are Definitely Not the Ones I Would Have Guessed

For all the reasons I dug into last night, I think it is important to discuss the report that four MLB owners voted no on the league’s “best” offer this past week, believing it was too generous for the players. But, as I said then, it’s also important not to go too far with information that (1) is very convenient for one side to have out there, and (2) could be more flexible than it initially sounds.

One thing I didn’t get into, at least not explicitly, was the identities of the four teams/owners that had voted no. They weren’t named in the original SNY report, and I didn’t see much point in trying to name names. I figured we all knew they were among the smaller-market teams that stand to benefit most from holding down the bigger-market teams and artificially depressing salaries across the board. That was enough for me.

Well. I was kinda wrong. Because these are definitely not the precise teams I would have guessed:

What an odd mix that is. If you search for a harmonizing principle, you’re going to come up short, because you’ve got only one historically always tight franchise (Reds), one periodically very tight franchise (Diamondbacks), one franchise that goes through cycles of spending very aggressively (Tigers), and one franchise that pretty much always spends aggressively (Angels). You could characterize Cincinnati and Detroit in the smaller-market bucket, but they have not historically been among the smaller-market clubs that get beefed about.

So what the heck is bringing these particular four owners together? Just a desire to keeps salaries down? (Maybe.) Divisional concerns about big spending opponents? (That would seem to apply only to the Diamondbacks and maybe the Reds.) Just big boss problems with paying employees too much money? (Who knows.)

I mean, it’s not like it’s just “teams that don’t like to go over the luxury tax,” because that’s most teams! Heck, the Pirates and Rays and A’s and Marlins apparently voted yes on this thing, but the Angels did not? What the what? (Also, if those teams can get on board with a proposal but you cannot, then you should probably feel some additional shame, if possible.)

One other thing that’s really interesting here: what if some of our assumptions about who is driving the CBA talks from the owner side have been … wrong? What if it isn’t a coalition of smaller-market clubs? Or ones that don’t do particularly well in April and May? Could it be that, while many of the owners are on board with the overall strategy (either get a ridiculous win, or cancel a big chunk of games), the divisions among them on the finer points are much more idiosyncratic and broad-based? What if we can’t predict the positions of the owners in relation to the CBT as well as we would have thought?

I gotta mull this a bit, because these are just not the four teams I would’ve come up. Sure, two of them would’ve been frequently among my attempts, but let’s just say, if it were a Wordle, I would absolutely lose my streak. Also? Evan Drellich is not exactly known as an MLB shill or owner-friendly reporter. I have actually found him to be very fair throughout this cycle, so him dropping this information makes me wonder all the more about where the incentives lie (could this actually be coming from some owners that WANT to out the Reds/Diamondbacks/Angels/Tigers, and want public pressure applied?).

Like I said last night, I still think when the rubber meets the road and the negotiations get serious again (in a few weeks, probably), some owners might change their votes when they know they are the deciding vote, and/or where they are incentivized to do so by their fellow owners with some kind of internal give. Leverage, even on one side of a negotiation within its own body, is still a thing. More on that here.

(Also, the meal money thing … come on. My very quick math has it that teams provide about $500,000 in meal money throughout the year, give or take. Is that really worth pissing players off to get included in the CBT calculation? Other benefits are included, yes, so it’s not like this is an OUTLANDISH request. But it does effectively shave half a million off the final numbers.)

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Hey, Maybe Roki Sasaki Will Actually Consider Teams Other Than the Dodgers?

I won't belabor my feelings on the extent to which Roki Sasaki to the Dodgers is probably already a done deal - you can read more on that stuff here and here - but will instead focus on at least...

Will Angels Now Make Catcher Matt Thaiss Available in Trade? If So, Is He an Option for the Cubs? (UPDATE)

I had some additional thoughts from the Angels signing free agent catcher Travis d'Arnaud yesterday, which Michael discussed here. As Michael said, yes, it might make Logan O'Hoppe a TINY bit more stomach-able for the Angels to trade (and we...

The Rays Have a Temporary Stadium Solution for Next Season

A little over a month ago, Tropicana Field, home of the Tampa Bay Rays, was destroyed by Hurricane Milton. And while we did learn yesterday that the field can be fixed (... for the small price of $55 million), it...

Is Nate Pearson a Good Starting Rotation Conversion Project for the Chicago Cubs?

Tentatively, I loved what we saw from Nate Pearson after the Cubs picked him up at midseason from the Blue Jays. The former top prospect, who'd struggled to find his footing (and health) in the big leagues, sometimes starting, sometimes...

Things Really Moving on the Diamond-FanDuel TV Stuff, More Long, Catchers, and Other Cubs Bullets

Gotta be on the road for several hours today for a kiddo appointment, so you can assume something major will happen at the absolute most inconvenient time for me. It would figure, because it's been quiet so far (it often...

Where Do the Way-Too-Early MLB Power Rankings See the Chicago Cubs?

While I would strongly urge folks not to put too much into 30-team-wide MLB power rankings in November - before transactions have taken place and Spring Training injuries and so on and so forth - I do think they can...

More AFL Award Love for Cubs Prospect Jonathon Long

First he was named to Baseball America's top spot on the Hot Sheet for his big week in the Arizona Fall League, and now he's getting a weekly award. Cubs prospect Jonathon Long is the Hitter of the Week in...

No Silver Slugger Seiya Suzuki, Outfield Quality and Depth, Cubs Versus Sox, and Other Cubs Bullets

I went to the gym yesterday for the first time since the hernia surgery, and although it was good to get back (doc said I was good to go!), I took things EXTREMELY easily and still kinda feel it today....

Would You Like to Start Your Day with Another Matt Shaw Highlight?

Listen. I'm sure it's the case that other Team USA players are doing things worthy of highlighting, and I'm sure those highlights are bouncing around somewhere. Having stuff come organically across your social feed is a little more challenging these...

One Cubs Free-Agent Catching Target Comes Off the Board

The Los Angeles Angels are doing all the early, tangentially-Cubs-related moves, eh? First, they traded for former Cubs outfielder/DH Jorge Soler. Then, they signed former Cubs starter Kyle Hendricks. And now, they've signed theoretical Cubs free-agent catcher target Travis d'Arnaud....

Latest News

Rams vs. Patriots Best Bets, Picks and Prediction – Nov. 17

Check out best bets for when the Los Angeles Rams (4-5) and the New England Patriots (3-7) play at Gillette Stadium on Sunday, November 17, 2024.Sign up for a Fubo free trial to watch the NFL, live sports and entertainment...

I Love Hearing Tom Thibodeau Gush About Derrick Rose

Derrick Rose is coming home on January 4, 2025. Shortly after the Chicago Bulls legend announced his retirement earlier this year, the organization chose a date to celebrate. While it's unclear exactly what the Bulls have planned for Rose and...

Oof: Jaquan Brisker Goes on IR

The hits keep coming for a Chicago Bears team that is being met with unsavory news at seemingly every turn this week. Shortly after the team released its Thursday update of the Week 11 injury report, The Athletic's Kevin Fishbain...

Hey, Maybe Roki Sasaki Will Actually Consider Teams Other Than the Dodgers?

I won't belabor my feelings on the extent to which Roki Sasaki to the Dodgers is probably already a done deal - you can read more on that stuff here and here - but will instead focus on at least...

Two Bears Players Get Upgrades on Thursday’s Injury Report

Thursday's Chicago Bears injury report comes with some good news, but not enough to get me throwing a party. As expected, Bears defensive end Montez Sweat practiced on Thursday. We discussed Sweat's return to the practice field earlier today in...

Around the NFL: Deion Sanders Says He’ll Intervene in NFL Draft Process, Rodgers Playing in 2025? More

Shedur Sanders will likely be a first-round pick in the 2025 NFL Draft, but his father will play a part in where he lands—that and more in today's NFL Notes. Deion Sanders Says He'll Intervene If the Wrong Team Drafts...

Bears Offense vs Packers Defense: How Do They Stack Up?

The Chicago Bears are home this weekend, taking on the Green Bay Packers at Soldier Field in Week 11. How does their offense stack up against the Packers' defense? Let's discuss. Chicago Bears Offense QB: Caleb Williams RB: D'Andre Swift...

Thursday Night Football: Eagles vs. Commanders – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread, More

Week 11 kicks off tonight on Thursday Night Football with a battle between the Eagles and the Commanders at Lincoln Financial Field. How to Watch Thursday Night Football: Eagles vs. Commanders TV: NONE Streaming: Prime Video Radio: Westwood One Kickoff...

Green Bay Packers Injury Report: Mostly Good (Which Is Mostly Bad for the Bears)

The Green Bay Packers added two offensive linemen, Rasheed Walker and Jordan Morgan, to their injury report on Thursday due to potential recurrences of previous injuries. Walker, the starting left tackle, was limited with a recurring knee issue, while Morgan,...

The Rays Have a Temporary Stadium Solution for Next Season

A little over a month ago, Tropicana Field, home of the Tampa Bay Rays, was destroyed by Hurricane Milton. And while we did learn yesterday that the field can be fixed (... for the small price of $55 million), it...

Josh Jacobs and the Packers Rushing Attack Presents Tough Challenge For Bears

With all the noise and distractions off the field coming out of Halas Hall this week, it's slightly being overlooked that a very good Green Bay Packers team is coming into town. That's not to say that's been lost on...

more cubs news