The New York Mets Blew It and Then Blew It – So What Happens Next? What’s the Broader Market Impact?

I don’t have any kind of specific level of distain for how much Steve Cohen and the New York Mets spent on payroll this year. We would love it if the Ricketts Family made a $300+ million payroll available to the Chicago Cubs, after all.

Where my antipathy grew and grew and grew was that the Mets had this clear opportunity to make a deep run in the postseason, with a boatload of older stars and impending free agents and two older true aces, and they turned coward at the Trade Deadline. It was their final chance to add impactful pieces to the team – for the other players and for the fans – and it wound up potentially hurting the Cubs in the process, as you know by now.

So, yes, I was absolutely pulling hard for the Mets to lose the NL East late in the year, and for the San Diego Padres to take them out in the Wild Card round this weekend, as they did last night with a 6-0 shutout win.

Insult to injury in the loss last night: Mets manager Buck Showalter decided to have the umpires investigate Joe Musgrove for foreign substances in the sixth inning and nothing turned up. It’s going to be a joke for years and years and years.

It was a final humiliation in a season that could’ve been a championship march. I’m not saying the Mets definitely win the East or make a deep run if they’d had Willson Contreras and David Robertson, but it’s not hard to imagine them winning just one more game in September. If they had, they’re in the division series against the Phillies tomorrow. Hope it was worth hanging onto your fifth or sixth best prospect or whatever so that you could have a fractionally better chance of reaching, and losing, more Wild Card series over the next few years …

Now for the broader impactful part: how does Mets owner Steve Cohen respond to this humiliation?

It’s not hard to see him going any number of ways. He could go scorched earth and clear out a number of players and personnel, while turning over as much of the roster as possible. They have the money and the impending free agents to do that. He could decide they just need to run it back, and re-sign all of Jacob deGrom, Edwin Diaz, Brandon Nimmo, Chris Bassitt, Taijuan Walker, Seth Lugo, and Trevor May, among others, and push that payroll up to $350 million+. He could decide he needs to do whatever it takes to bring in a top-tier baseball president first, and who knows what ripples that creates. Or he could decide money doesn’t win championships and retrench.

That is all to say, because of the Mets’ group of free agents and Cohen’s largess, they have the ability to completely shift the dynamics of the offseason for every team that is looking to spend, including the Cubs.

So it’s not all just about schadenfreude with the Mets. Sure, I’ve enjoyed this weekend and the jokes a whole lot, but now we have to see what messaging comes out of New York. The Cubs figure to be aggressive at the top of the market, but it’s not like they’re going to get into a WHATEVER-IT-TAKES bidding war with the Mets on Jacob deGrom if Cohen is absolutely insistent on deGrom returning no matter what. That’s just one hyper-specific example, but hopefully the broader point is clear.

The New York Mets are among the few teams that can fundamentally alter the course of the offseason for multiple other teams, and now maybe they have a reason to be even more disruptive.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Cubs Farm Report | July 15, 2024: Everybody But Iowa Rolls on Sunday

CUBS PROSPECTS — Everyone on the Cubs farm rolled on Sunday except for the I-Cubs, who fell to the Nashville Sounds again. Cubs Prospects Report | July 15, 2024 Triple-A Iowa Cubs Prospects The Iowa Cubs lost 3-2 to the...

The 2024 MLB Draft, Day Two – Rounds 3-10

The 2024 MLB Draft continues this afternoon at 1pm CT with Rounds 3 through 10, which you can watch on MLB.com. There will be one minute between picks, and I'll be updating the Cubs' selections at the bottom of this...

MLBits: Guardians Take “Perfect Match” at No. 1 Overall, Myers Fractures Ankle After Ejection, More

[BN_drinks] The Guardians took their "perfect match" at No. 1 overall—that and more MLB Draft reaction in today's MLB Notes. Guardians Take Aussie Second Baseman Travis Bazzana No. 1 Overall Travis Bazzana is heading to Cleveland after the Guardians made...

Bleacher Nation & Ankin Law Happy Hour

We are excited to announce our first Happy Hour event thanks to our partners at Ankin Law! Come hang out with Brett, Michael, and others from the teams at Bleacher Nation and Ankin Law! We will be giving away swag,...

More on the Cubs’ Top Two Draft Picks, Cam Smith and Cole Mathis

In advance of today's Day Two of the MLB Draft (Rounds 3 through 10, starting at 1pm CT), I wanted to share a few more bits on the guys the Cubs took in Rounds 1 and 2, Florida State third...

Fun with Pete Crow-Armstrong’s Big Day

Yesterday marked not just a great day for the Chicago Cubs overall, but a particularly good day for rookie center fielder Pete Crow-Armstrong. It's no secret that the year has been a significantly challenging adjustment at the plate for the...

That Was a Good Day, Gotta Keep Exploding, Defensive Gems, Bigge Optioned, and Other Cubs Bullets

Day Two of the MLB Draft kicks off at 1pm CT today, with rounds 3 through 10 (the rest of the bonus pool rounds). If you missed last night's picks, the Cubs took Cam Smith in the first round, and...

Christopher Morel Hurt Jim Edmonds’ Tender Feelings

I like to consider myself a sensitive soul, eager to find understanding and compassion where the feelings of others are concerned. Sometimes, it's easy. Sometimes, it's difficult. But, usually, I at least like to try to know where someone is...

Wake Up and Watch the Cubs Homer All Over the Cardinals to Close Out the First Half

The Cubs closed out the nominal first half with a big win over the Cardinals in St. Louis. Big both in importance - could help turn the tide on a selling July - and in the nature of the win,...

The Chicago Cubs Draft Cole Mathis in the Second Round

When I saw that the Chicago Cubs had drafted College of Charleston first/third baseman Cole Mathis in the second round tonight (54th overall), I knew immediately he must've played in the Cape Cod summer league and hit really well with...

Latest News

The 2024 MLB Draft, Day Two – Rounds 3-10

The 2024 MLB Draft continues this afternoon at 1pm CT with Rounds 3 through 10, which you can watch on MLB.com. There will be one minute between picks, and I'll be updating the Cubs' selections at the bottom of this...

Hungarian Grand Prix Schedule Wednesday, July 17: Matchups & TV/Live Stream Info

There are two matches at the Hungarian Grand Prix on July 17, highlighted by No. 75-ranked Elina Avanesyan against No. 117 Rebeka Masarova. Looking to keep up with the action? The Tennis Channel provides live coverage and highlights of all...

Seidel vs. Uchijima Prediction at the Hungarian Grand Prix – Tuesday, July 16

In the Round of 32 at the Hungarian Grand Prix on Tuesday, Ella Seidel (ranked No. 166) takes on Moyuka Uchijima (No. 69).Compared to the underdog Seidel (+170), Uchijima is the favorite (-227) to advance.Hungarian Grand Prix InfoTournament: The Hungarian...

Lamens vs. Monnet Prediction at the Hungarian Grand Prix – Wednesday, July 17

No. 137-ranked Suzan Lamens will face No. 221 Carole Monnet in the Hungarian Grand Prix Round of 16 on Wednesday, July 17.Compared to the underdog Monnet (+333), Lamens is the favorite (-500) to advance.Hungarian Grand Prix InfoTournament: The Hungarian Grand...

Bleacher Nation & Ankin Law Happy Hour

We are excited to announce our first Happy Hour event thanks to our partners at Ankin Law! Come hang out with Brett, Michael, and others from the teams at Bleacher Nation and Ankin Law! We will be giving away swag,...

More on the Cubs’ Top Two Draft Picks, Cam Smith and Cole Mathis

In advance of today's Day Two of the MLB Draft (Rounds 3 through 10, starting at 1pm CT), I wanted to share a few more bits on the guys the Cubs took in Rounds 1 and 2, Florida State third...

MLBits: Guardians Take “Perfect Match” at No. 1 Overall, Myers Fractures Ankle After Ejection, More

[BN_drinks] The Guardians took their "perfect match" at No. 1 overall—that and more MLB Draft reaction in today's MLB Notes. Guardians Take Aussie Second Baseman Travis Bazzana No. 1 Overall Travis Bazzana is heading to Cleveland after the Guardians made...

ESPN’s Top-10 Quarterback List is OUT (And Bears Fans Should Take Note)

One of my favorite things about the build-up to each NFL season is ESPN's annual look-ahead player positional rankings that are compiled after consulting with front office executives, coaches, and scouts around the league. Naturally, the position I have most...

Cubs Farm Report | July 15, 2024: Everybody But Iowa Rolls on Sunday

CUBS PROSPECTS — Everyone on the Cubs farm rolled on Sunday except for the I-Cubs, who fell to the Nashville Sounds again. Cubs Prospects Report | July 15, 2024 Triple-A Iowa Cubs Prospects The Iowa Cubs lost 3-2 to the...

Fun with Pete Crow-Armstrong’s Big Day

Yesterday marked not just a great day for the Chicago Cubs overall, but a particularly good day for rookie center fielder Pete Crow-Armstrong. It's no secret that the year has been a significantly challenging adjustment at the plate for the...

more cubs news