What Would a Chicago Cubs Trade Offer for Shohei Ohtani Look Like? A Lot!

I joked in the Bullets this morning that the Cubs had failed to trade for Shohei Ohtani 36 hours into the offseason, but my sincere thought was that I’m not so sure Ohtani will be traded. With a sale of the Angels underway, I just have a hard time seeing the front office being given the green light to trade Ohtani before new ownership gets a chance to extend him. Heck, his presence in the organization is probably a big selling point in the first place.

Then again, if Ohtani is not interested in extending no matter what (talks haven’t progressed before, and he offered some unhappy comments on the season recently), maybe everyone involved will understand that it’s better to get a massive return this offseason than wait things out and see him leave? The Nationals were willing to trade Juan Soto in similar circumstances, after all.

So, all that said, the folks at The Athletic did some speculating today on what nine teams might try to trade for Ohtani, and what it might cost them:

At the top, The Athletic’s writers (the byline is “Andy McCullough, Corey Brock, and more”) suggest that a return package for Ohtani would be “more significant” than what the Nationals got for Soto. I’d have to take issue with that, not because Ohtani isn’t more valuable than Soto, but instead because teams acquiring Soto were getting 2.5 seasons. With Ohtani, you’re getting just one season at $30 million. There’s value there. Huge value! But it’s not really apples to apples.

Though that’s not to say a realistic Ohtani trade package wouldn’t be eye-popping.

Anyway, the writeup features nine plausible suitors for Ohtani, with an accompanying trade offer from that team’s local beat writer. There appear to be widely-varying degrees of being realistic in these offers.

Yes, the Cubs are included, and here’s what Sahadev Sharma offered up for Ohtani: LHP Justin Steele, OF Brennen Davis, OF Owen Caissie, SS Cristian Hernandez, LHP Jordan Wicks, and RHP Nazier Mulé.

Yo. Wow. You certainly can’t accuse Sharma of being unrealistic …

So, I’m about as Gung ho about landing Ohtani as anyone out there, but even I would have to pause at that one, especially if it didn’t come with a guaranteed long-term extension. I’m not saying I wouldn’t do it, or that it’s not what it would cost; I’m saying only that, yes, you do have to at least think for a moment about whether you’re doing long-term damage in service of a shorter-term addition. That said, if Ohtani were willing to sign an eight-year, $400 million extension (or whatever absurd amount he requires), it would be hard for me to say no to a deal like that. Ohtani is just that special.

Sharma tends to think this wouldn’t get the deal done, though, because it’s more volume than impact:

Similarly to the offer made at The Athletic for Juan Soto in July, Cubs fans probably won’t love this, but it’s also likely not enough. However, even though only a few months have passed, the Cubs system feels a bit different now than it did in the middle of the summer. The Angels would get a starting pitcher they could put in their rotation immediately, an outfield prospect who should be ready to contribute early next season, another pitching prospect in Wicks who could be ready as early as late 2023, plus three other young, high-upside prospects.

It’s also important to remember that Soto had two and a half years left on his deal and Ohtani will be a free agent after the 2023 season. So in theory that means the offer should be significantly less, one could even use the Mookie Betts deal as a yardstick. But that ignores the two-way value of Ohtani and the fact that his presence would be a dream for the team’s marketing department.

This offer is also fluid. The Cubs system is deep enough to switch players out. Prefer James Triantos to Caissie? No problem. Rather have Jackson Ferris than Mule (both of whom have impressed onlookers thus far)? Probably not going to haggle there. The Cubs would surely love to do this without including Pete Crow-Armstrong, but there are probably iterations of this deal that could include him too. There’s maybe even a version of this deal where the Cubs take on Anthony Rendon’s contract to lessen the prospect cost, but it seems silly for the Angels to reduce their return to free up cash when you have a player like Ohtani to trade.

Ultimately, the reality is the Cubs system may not have the true impact stars (yet) that some other farms do, but it’s as deep as any in baseball and they can be creative and aggressive as Jed Hoyer looks to transition his rebuilding team into true contenders.

If the Angels prefer a deal with a couple top 30 types and more, the Cubs would have a hard time beating that. From where I sit, the offer looks maybe a touch heavy, but then again, if you’re going volume, it’s going to seem like a lot.

For now, I don’t want to get too deep in the weeds of trade analysis, because, like I said, I’m dubious that a trade happens at all. But you better believe, if there’s even the tiniest whiff of Ohtani being made available for real, I will start obsessing about how the Cubs can make it happen without COMPLETELY eviscerating their organization, and how monstrous of an extension they can offer up. Ohtani is worth more than any player in baseball.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

PCA Optioned to Triple-A, PCA Immediately Hits a Bomb

The Chicago Cubs made a handful of roster moves on Monday, which surprisingly included optioning Pete Crow-Armstrong back to Triple-A. The standout prospect was sent down alongside Miles Mastrobuoni to make room for Dansby Swanson and fellow intriguing prospect Luis Vazquez....

Pre-Gamin’: Braves at Cubs (6:40 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — It's a rematch! The Cubs won only one game during their series in Atlanta last week, and it was started (on both ends) by the guys on the mound tonight: Javier Assad and Charlie Morton. Let's hope...

Cubs Injury Update: Alzolay’s Second Opinion, Wicks Takes a Big Step, Smyly, Palencia, More

[ankin_law] She's obviously not the only one out there on the beat, but Meghan Montemurro (Chicago Tribune) has been all over the Cubs (many) injury updates this season. And for that, we thank her greatly! Among her latest updates is...

Kyle Hendricks is Officially OUT of the Cubs Rotation (For Now)

Before today's series opener against the Atlanta Braves, the Cubs released their pitching probables for the week. And where Kyle Hendricks' name was supposed to be penciled in this Thursday was a big fat TBD. There was a chance the...

Even Cardinals Players Don’t Like Their City Connect Jerseys

I joked about the new St. Louis Cardinals City Connects this morning in the Bullets, but if you missed it, here's how they look: https://twitter.com/Cardinals/status/1792563447000891514 https://twitter.com/BleacherNation/status/1792590082970419552 It's just ridiculous. You've got the main, same-as-ever logo, set atop a name no...

MLBits: Devers Chasing History, Mariners Wild Comeback, Sale’s Resurgence, More

Rafael Devers has a chance to chase history tonight, Chris Sale is having a career resurgence in Atlanta, and the Mariners topped the Yankees in a wild one last night. That and more in today's MLB Notes. Rafael Devers Homers...

Cubs Farm Report | May 21, 2024: Top 25 Prospect Stock Report

The Chicago Cubs minor league affiliates were off on Monday, so it's time to take stock of some recent hot (and not-so-hot) performers inside the Cubs Top 25 prospects down on the farm in today's Cubs Farm Report. Cubs Farm...

Triple-A Promotion for Relief Prospect Zac Leigh and the Near-Term Future of Impact Relievers

Zac Leigh has been a helium Cubs pitching prospect since about 10 days after the team drafted him in the 16th round in 2021 out of Texas State. The Cubs converted him to relief out of the gate, and he...

I Actually Like Their Chances This Week: Cubs vs Braves – Series Preview

Cubs vs Braves — Well here's the good news: Chris Sale and Reynaldo Lopez BOTH pitched yesterday in the Braves-Padres double-header, which means the Cubs will most both of them this series. Seeing as they combined to throw 12 shutout...

The Cubs Are Coming Home to Face the Pirates

Cubs vs Pirates — There's going to be a little deja vu here for the next week, as the Cubs play seven straight games against the Pirates and Braves after just wrapping up six games against ... the Pirates and...

Latest News

The Charles Schwab Challenge Betting Odds, Streaming Live, TV Channel – Round 1

Colonial Country Club in Fort Worth, TX is the site of the 2024 Charles Schwab Challenge from May 23-26 ($9.1M purse), with Scottie Scheffler the favorite (+280) and Emiliano Grillo the most recent winner.Xander Schauffele shot -21 at Valhalla Golf...

PCA Optioned to Triple-A, PCA Immediately Hits a Bomb

The Chicago Cubs made a handful of roster moves on Monday, which surprisingly included optioning Pete Crow-Armstrong back to Triple-A. The standout prospect was sent down alongside Miles Mastrobuoni to make room for Dansby Swanson and fellow intriguing prospect Luis Vazquez....

Braves vs. Cubs: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

In a series opener on Wednesday, Max Fried will start for the Atlanta Braves (27-17) against Justin Steele and the Chicago Cubs (26-22), with first pitch scheduled for 7:40 PM ET at Wrigley Field.The article below will provide you with...

Padres vs. Reds: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Wednesday at 6:40 PM ET, Jurickson Profar and the San Diego Padres (25-25) face Elly De La Cruz and the Cincinnati Reds (19-28) at Great American Ball Park.The article below will give you everything you need to know to...

Pirates vs. Giants: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Wednesday, in a series opener at PNC Park, Jared Jones takes the mound for the Pittsburgh Pirates (22-26) versus Blake Snell and the San Francisco Giants (23-25), with first pitch scheduled for 6:40 PM ET.See how to watch the...

Brewers vs. Marlins: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

Freddy Peralta will take the ball for the Milwaukee Brewers (27-20) when they visit starting pitcher Jesus Luzardo and the Miami Marlins (16-33) on Wednesday, with first pitch at 6:40 PM ET and the Marlins going for a series sweep.The...

Blue Jays vs. White Sox: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Wednesday, looking for a series sweep, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and the Toronto Blue Jays (21-25) take on the Chicago White Sox (14-34), with first pitch scheduled for 7:07 PM ET at Rogers Centre.Keep scrolling to find out all the...

Yankees vs. Mariners: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Wednesday, Nestor Cortes Jr. will take the mound for the New York Yankees (33-16) against Bryce Miller and the Seattle Mariners (26-22), with first pitch scheduled for 7:05 PM ET at Yankee Stadium.Keep reading to find out all the...

Vic Fangio Got Sniped By One of His Ex-Players

Vic Fangio is one of the most revered assistant coaches in football. Chicago Bears fans hold Fangio in high regards because of his time with the team from 2015-18. Fangio was the Bears' defensive coordinator under two different head coaches...

How to Watch Twins vs. Nationals: Live Stream or on TV

The Minnesota Twins (24-23), led by Ryan Jeffers, visit C.J. Abrams and the Washington Nationals (21-25) on Wednesday at 1:05 PM ET.If you're trying to watch this game, keep reading for streaming and TV options for the Minnesota-Washington matchup.When is...

more cubs news