Would Cubs Fans Actually WANT to See Dansby Swanson Sign with the Cardinals?

Thanks to an MLB Network question to Jon Morosi about Dansby Swanson and the Chicago Cubs, the outgoing(?) Atlanta Braves shortstop has been the topic of the day in a lot of Cubs internet corners.

I thought Morosi’s comment that he’d be very surprised if the Cubs didn’t land ONE of the top four shortstops was a little more noteworthy than his answer on Swanson (sure, there could be a fit there for a couple thin reasons). But I understand that, in this climate, if anyone starts attaching Swanson to the Cubs BEFORE the other three (who are preferable) actually sign, people will recoil.

Me? Yeah, I prefer the other three to Swanson, but if Swanson is what ended up happening, I can see reasons to be happy about that, depending on what else the Cubs do. I don’t see why I should be yelling negative things about Swanson at the moment, just because he’s fourth out of the current four shortstops on the market. In another year, he might’ve been the top shortstop on the market. In any case, he would be a clear upgrade for the Cubs, who could pair him up the middle with Nico Hoerner. I could see that being a very good fit! (Even if, again, I’d much rather see the Cubs land one of Carlos Correa, Trea Turner, or Xander Bogaerts.)

Anyway, Swanson was on folks’ minds today, and that wasn’t limited to the Cubs’ space. You also had Atlanta beat writer David O’Brien openly speculating – speculating! – about Swanson and the St. Louis Cardinals:

The Cardinals have been mentioned at the periphery of the shortstop market, which I think is where they belong. They are in a win-now moment, and they could stand to have a big upgrade at shortstop. But they also do have some huge contracts on the books, and Masyn Winn at Double-A. I can see the arguments for and against the Cardinals being aggressive on any of these shortstops.

But what about Swanson, specifically, who figures to land the smallest contract of the bunch?

Well, back to MLB Network, where they see the fit:

Yes, the fit makes sense, but Jayson Stark there offers up the same question I had about having $80+ million annually locked up in your infield. I’m not saying that’s good or bad; I’m just not sure if it’s the way the Cardinals would go.

So there’s the question for Cubs fans: would you WANT to see the Cardinals give Dansby Swanson a, say, six-year, $150 million deal? That’s roughly the high-end of the range that’s been guesstimated. I can see him being a reasonably productive value over the course of that contract (ages 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, and 34 seasons), but I could also see that the offensive spike last year was as anomalous as the massive uptick in defensive metrics.

Of course, Swanson would go to the Cardinals and then totally settle into actually BEING the guy he was last year, posting a 5-6 WAR season for each of the next six years. Cardinals voodoo magic …

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Umpire Angel Hernandez Cannot Help Himself

With Joe West retired, Angel Hernandez has become the symbol of umpire incompetence. Sure, there are others in the conversation with him — C.B. Bucknor immediately comes to mind (also Laz Diaz, Andy Fletcher, and Chad Fairchild) — but Angel...

As Feared, Spencer Strider Had to Have Elbow Surgery and His Season is Over

It felt like this is where the ominous news was trending, and now it has indeed happened: Atlanta Braves ace Spencer Strider had to have what amounts to Tommy John-like surgery. The team made the announcement this morning: https://twitter.com/Braves/status/1779140182756769897 For...

Enhanced Box Score: Mariners 4, Cubs 2 – April 12, 2024

Jordan Wicks once again flashed really good stuff, racking up a ton of whiffs, but he didn't quite have the control he needed to stay efficient and keep traffic off the bases. So he twice got himself into trouble with...

Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Mariners – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — Don't shoot the messenger, but this Cubs game doesn't start until 8:40pm CT ... and it's on AppleTV+. I don't make the rules. In any case, it's been a nice long break since the frustrating series in...

REPORT: Cubs Calling Up Keegan Thompson – Recent Performance, What to Expect, More

Last night, we learned that the Chicago Cubs had optioned right-handed reliever Jose Cuas to the Triple-A Iowa Cubs after a pretty horrendous start to the year. Although he's got some arm talent and a funky delivery (which creates a...

More Late-Night Games: Cubs vs Mariners Series Preview

Cubs vs Mariners — The Cubs west coast trip continues tonight in Seattle, where they'll open up the first of three games against the Mariners at T-Mobile Park. The Cubs are coming off a pretty frustrating series loss in San...

Apparently the Cubs Traded Catcher Joe Hudson to the Mets After Signing Ali Sanchez

In another bit of news dropping on the transactions page, the Chicago Cubs have traded catcher Joe Hudson to the New York Mets. Nothing is listed on the Cubs page or the Mets page as the trade return, so I...

Cubs Farm Report | April 11, 2024: Reginald Preciado’s Big Night Not Enough for Myrtle Beach

We've got a shorter Cubs Farm Report today, with half of the affiliates being rained out. The Iowa Cubs got their game in against the St. Paul Saints but lost to the Twins' affiliate. Myrtle Beach scored nine runs with...

Random Awesome Highlight Flashback: The Time Reed Johnson Robbed Prince Fielder of a Grand Slam

Thanks to yesterday's off-day and today's game being of the late-night variety, we're having to wait a very long time between games. For that reason, I very much appreciated today's random flashback from the Daily Random Cub account, which took...

Small Change Coming for Hendricks? Dreaming on Old Keegan Thompson, Streaks Alive, and Other Cubs Bullets

Sorry for the late bullets this morning. Brett is still working his way back (no pun intended), and I still have some other "running-the-site" duties to address on any given day. To that end, we are working on some stuff...

Latest News

Diamondbacks vs. Cardinals Probable Starting Pitchers – April 13

The St. Louis Cardinals (7-7) go on the road at Chase Field against the Arizona Diamondbacks (6-8) at 8:10 PM ET on Saturday.The Diamondbacks will look to Ryne Nelson (0-2) against the Cardinals and Kyle Gibson (1-1).Diamondbacks vs. Cardinals Pitcher...

Umpire Angel Hernandez Cannot Help Himself

With Joe West retired, Angel Hernandez has become the symbol of umpire incompetence. Sure, there are others in the conversation with him — C.B. Bucknor immediately comes to mind (also Laz Diaz, Andy Fletcher, and Chad Fairchild) — but Angel...

DraftKings Promo Code: Bet $5, Get $150 as a New User Today for Masters, NBA, and More

The Masters carries on today along with tons MLB action! Check out the details to score a DraftKings promo code below. You can use this DraftKings promo on any event or sport to secure your bonus! DraftKings Promo Code with...

As Feared, Spencer Strider Had to Have Elbow Surgery and His Season is Over

It felt like this is where the ominous news was trending, and now it has indeed happened: Atlanta Braves ace Spencer Strider had to have what amounts to Tommy John-like surgery. The team made the announcement this morning: https://twitter.com/Braves/status/1779140182756769897 For...

Best MLB Prop Bets Today, April 13, 2024

The Milwaukee Brewers versus the Baltimore Orioles is one of 17 compelling options on today's MLB slate.MLB prop bets for today's games are available, so if you're interested in placing a bet or building a parlay, you'll find those MLB...

Fanatics North Carolina Promo Code Scores New Users Up to $1000 in Bonus Bets

Fanatics North Carolina Sportsbook has arrived, offering a thrilling welcome package for new users. This limited-time promotion allows you to snag up to $1,000 in bonus bets, propelling your sports betting experience to new heights. Unveiling the Fanatics North Carolina...

Phillies vs. Pirates Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, April 13, 2024

The Philadelphia Phillies (7-7) are favorites (-154) on the moneyline when they take on the Pittsburgh Pirates (10-4) Saturday at 4:05 PM ET, live on SportsNet PT.Spencer Turnbull will get the ball for Philadelphia while Pittsburgh will counter with Marco...

Nationals vs. Athletics Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, April 13, 2024

After a four-hit game last time out, Jesse Winker leads the Washington Nationals (5-8) as -132 favorites against the Oakland Athletics (6-8). Action gets underway from Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum at 4:07 PM ET on Saturday, live on MASN2.Washington's MacKenzie Gore...

Braves vs. Marlins Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, April 13, 2024

The Atlanta Braves (8-4), led by Marcell Ozuna on an 11-game hitting streak, will meet the Miami Marlins (2-12) Saturday at LoanDepot park. The Braves are -203 favorites for the matchup, which starts at 4:10 PM ET on BSSE.Atlanta's Chris...

Orioles vs. Brewers Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, April 13, 2024

Led by Colton Cowser (two-game homer streak), the Baltimore Orioles (8-5) are favorites versus the Milwaukee Brewers (9-3) Saturday at 4:05 PM ET. Sportsbooks have named the Orioles as -147 favorites for the game, which airs on BSWI.Dean Kremer gets...

more cubs news