Kevin Kiermaier Would Ideally Like a Two-Year Deal – Would You Prefer Him or Cody Bellinger on a Pricier One-Year Deal?

In his most recent rumor round-up at The Athletic, Ken Rosenthal mentioned a desired price tag for center fielder Kevin Kiermaier, who has previously been rumored a Cubs target in center field.

This is just a desired price tag, mind you:

In Kevin Kiermaier’s perfect world, he would land a deal similar to the two-year, $24 million free-agent contract another defense-first center fielder, Jackie Bradley Jr., landed prior to the 2021 season.

Bradley, though, was entering his Age 31 season, and coming off an .814 OPS in the shortened 2020 campaign. Kiermaier is entering his Age 33 season, and played only 63 games before undergoing season-ending hip surgery in August. Because of injuries, he has averaged only 101 games over his last six full seasons.

I’d note that you probably don’t want to bring up Jackie Bradley Jr.’s deal if you don’t have to, since that thing wound up uggggly for the Brewers when he completely stopped being able to hit.

That said, I can understand the attempted comp, given that it’s a glove-first lefty bat who might have to do some platooning to be most effective. The question with Kiermaier is the age and the hip surgery. How much will his speed be impacted? His quick movements? Can you still count on the glove being top-tier, which is where he derives most of his value? It seems like that risk is going to have to be baked into the price tag (as is the upside – if he *IS* healthy and as effective as always, he really is a nice and valuable player if you limit his at bats against lefties).

But let’s say for the sake of argument that 2/$24 million is indeed the deal Kiermaier is going to land.

My question, given that the two were paired together in the Cubs’ rumored hopes for center field: would you rather the Cubs signed Kiermaier to that deal, or Cody Bellinger to a one-year deal in the $18 to $20 million range?

We can’t say for sure that Bellinger will get quite that much (or, again, that Kiermaier will get that much), but this is more of a thought experiment than a hard prediction. Where do you land?

Neither is free from significant risks of a nothingburger. With Kiermaier, again, it’s that the hip surgery and the aging combine to make him simply not close to what he was (and the bat isn’t going to float him, because the upside there is *maybe* league average). With Bellinger, it’s that the degradation of his swing is irreversible, and he’s going to be a well below-average bat overall.

On the one hand, you could argue it’s obviously Bellinger, since it’s only a one-year risk, and the upside -though very low odds – is a true impact player. A lineup-changer, who can also play great defense in center field or at first base.

On the other hand, you could argue that you’re barely paying more for a whole extra season of Kiermaier, who might offer nice value in 2024, even as a fourth outfielder.

The more I mull it over, I’m not sure there’s a WRONG answer if you HAVE to choose between only these two players and at only these two price points. If it weren’t for the injuries to Brennen Davis and Alexander Canario, I might be aggressively inclined to push for only a one-year deal. But with their futures extremely cloudy, I’m not sure the presence of Kiermaier for an extra year – if he’s healthy! – would be the worst thing in the world.

Ultimately, I’m not so sure Kiermaier actually gets 2/$24M, so that might clarify this further. In the abstract, I’d still prefer Bellinger for the Cubs because the gloves are close and I’d like to see them take that chance on upside when it’s available for only money. But, given the horrible center field market and given the potential that the Cubs can upgrade offensively elsewhere (they freaking better … ), I wouldn’t have a problem with them landing Kiermaier on a two-year deal.

Oh, and by the way: lots of other teams want these guys, too. It’s not as if the Cubs can just choose their preferred target without any competition whatsoever. They may not actually be able to land the guy they prefer.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 5, Cardinals 1 – July 12, 2024

The Cubs keep on rolling, with their fifth straight win. In theory, that was the toughest match-up of this Cardinals series, too, with Sonny Gray generally pitching very well, and Kyle Hendricks having struggled. I don't know how he does...

Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Cardinals (7:15 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — We do not do intros anymore. We also are all still wearing the same underwear, watching these games in the same seats, and eating the same meals everyday, right? Chicago Cubs Lineup: Nico Hoerner, 2B Michael Busch,...

More Mock Drafts? Why Not! The Latest Cubs Picks

Just two days to go before the 2024 MLB Draft kicks off with the first two rounds on Sunday evening. I can't wait. Which means I am consuming whatever last-minute mock drafts come out, and looking with great interest up...

MLBits: Skenes Named NL Starter, Bichette and Anderson Forgot How to Hit, Phillies Statement Sweep, More

MLB NOTES — After Paul Skenes' final start before the MLB All-Star Game on Thursday, I tweeted in jest that I would riot if he weren't named the starter for the National League team. Thankfully, I can proceed in peace....

Cubs Farm Report | July 12, 2024: Wiggins Dazzles, Nearly Helps Myrtle Beach Throw a Combined No-No

CUBS PROSPECTS — On Thursday, Jaxon Wiggins and Tyler Schlaffer teamed up for a near-no hitter for the Myrtle Beach Pelicans. Cubs Prospects Report | July 12, 2024 Triple-A Iowa Cubs Prospects The Iowa Cubs lost 10-4 to the Nashville...

Cubs Injury Notes: Tauchman, Brown, Wicks, Bellinger

[ankin_law] I guess I'll just get the Cody Bellinger part out the door first, because you all already know he's got a fractured left middle finger (throwing hand), and went on the Injured List yesterday. That means you're wanting to...

One Week In, and We’re Nearly a Third of the Way to the FULL Make-A-Wish Blogathon Experience!

We are just one week into raising funds for Make-A-Wish, and you've already pushed us to nearly half of our goal! A reminder that I'm offering to blog for 40 straight hours - NO SLEEP -  at the 2024 MLB...

The First Half Ends with Four Games Against the Cardinals in Three Days … Let’s GO

[BN_drinks] Cubs vs Cardinals — Well that was a surprise. The Cubs just swept the Orioles in Baltimore, which brought them "up" to just four games under .500. And that means, the Cubs can technically get back to .500 if...

The Boys Are Rolling, What Lies Ahead, Stellar Steele, and Other Cubs Bullets

I am hopelessly and completely sucked back into "make a freaking miracle run" mode. I think that says as much about how desperate we've been for a good stretch of baseball as it says about my belief that the Cubs...

Turns Out We Haven’t Seen a Game Like Seiya Suzuki’s in a Long Time

This is one of those factoids that is not necessarily important, but struck me as pretty darn fun. We knew that Seiya Suzuki had a big night at the plate last night, with two doubles, a triple, and three runs...

Latest News

Mets vs. Rockies Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, July 13, 2024

The New York Mets (48-45) and Harrison Bader (2 HR in his last game) are favored (-228) on the moneyline for their matchup with the Colorado Rockies (33-62) on Saturday at 4:10 PM ET on SNY.Christian Scott will get the...

Phillies vs. Athletics Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, July 13, 2024

The Philadelphia Phillies will take the field against the Oakland Athletics (36-60) on Saturday. The game begins at 4:05 PM ET on NBCS-PH, with the Phillies listed as -192 favorites on the moneyline.Philadelphia's Tyler Phillips and Oakland's Mitch Spence have...

Red Sox vs. Royals Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, July 13, 2024

MJ Melendez leads the Kansas City Royals (52-43) into Saturday's matchup with the Boston Red Sox (51-42) on a two-game homer streak. His Royals are underdogs for the contest, however, with sportsbooks naming the Red Sox as -131 moneyline favorites....

Reds vs. Marlins Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, July 13, 2024

The Cincinnati Reds (46-49) are -161 favorites for their Saturday matchup with the Miami Marlins (32-62). Andrew Abbott gets the ball for the Reds and will look to earn his 10th win of the campaign.Cincinnati's Abbott gets the start, and...

Astros vs. Rangers Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, July 13, 2024

The Houston Astros (50-44) will put their four-game win streak to the test when they host the Texas Rangers (44-50) Saturday at 4:10 PM ET on BSSW. Oddsmakers consider the Astros -145 favorites to extend their streak, while the Rangers...

Orioles vs. Yankees Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, July 13, 2024

The Baltimore Orioles (57-37) host the New York Yankees (57-39) at 4:05 PM ET Saturday for a sluggers' duel between two of the best power hitters in MLB. For the favored Orioles (-135), Gunnar Henderson has racked up 27 homers...

Brewers vs. Nationals Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, July 13, 2024

The Milwaukee Brewers (54-41) are set to take on the Washington Nationals (43-52) Saturday at 4:10 PM ET, airing on BSWI. The Brewers are listed as -276 favorites by sportsbooks, while the underdog Nationals have +228 odds for the contest.Milwaukee's...

Guardians vs. Rays Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, July 13, 2024

The Cleveland Guardians (57-36) hope to avoid their fourth straight defeat when they visit the Tampa Bay Rays (47-47) Saturday at 4:10 PM ET on BSSUN. The Guardians are listed as -113 favorites to snap their losing skid, while the...

Today’s Copa America 2024 Predictions, Picks and Odds – Saturday, July 13

There is one match on Saturday's 2024 Copa America schedule, so let's look at the betting odds for this match.All of today's Copa America play provides betting opportunities, so here's an in-depth look at the odds.Head to Fubo to watch...

Guardians vs. Rays Probable Starting Pitchers – July 13

The Cleveland Guardians (57-36) visit the Tampa Bay Rays (47-47) on Saturday after a streak of three losses. First pitch is at 4:10 PM ET.The Guardians will look to Gavin Williams (0-1) versus the Rays and Zack Littell (3-6).Guardians vs....

more cubs news