Obsessive Top Shortstop Watch: Cubs in on Both, More Likely for Swanson, But How Do You Project Contracts?

Yesterday was all about reminding myself that, in addition to the possibility that the Cubs can still have a successful offseason without signing one of the shortstops (really hard to see, but possible, I suppose), that the Cubs aren’t out on the two remaining shortstops. It is still possible that they could land Carlos Correa or Dansby Swanson. So I will keep obsessing until that is decided. I can’t help it.

The latest from Jon Heyman reiterates a lot of what we’ve been hearing the last two days, which, on the one hand means it’s just the same stuff. On the other hand, it means he is also hearing the things increasingly suggested by every other source lately. You add it to the pile if you are obsessing about these things …

Specifically, focuses on the Twins and Giants for Carlos Correa, indicating that of course the Twins really do want to keep him and will stretch as much as they can to make it happen, but the market is so strong right now that it might not happen. And the Giants, by contrast, have tons of money available and a sense of urgency to DO SOMETHING. (I could make an argument that, with all that the Padres have done, and given where things are with the Dodgers, now might not be the best offseason for the Giants to just DO SOMETHING to supplement what is otherwise a mediocre roster, but I’m not about to be a Cubs fan throwing stones at a team that is trying to add a star …. )

Here is what Heyman said about the Cubs, which, again, tracks with everything else the last couple days:

However, at least five teams still seek a shortstop — and the top of the market is now down to only Correa and Dansby Swanson, who’s terrific but doesn’t match Correa for persona and pizzazz. The Cubs are looking at both Correa and Swanson, though Swanson seems like the more obvious fit for them since his fiancée, Mallory Pugh, is a star of the Chicago Red Stars soccer club, and he’ll be cheaper than Correa.

The Cubs are in on both, but Swanson is more likely than Correa. That’s been the mantra of everyone one of the last few reports. I think some of that is just reporters being logical – Correa is way more expensive, has two desperate other teams in the mix, and the Cubs haven’t shown any kind of appetite recently to do a 10+ year deal. I also wonder if some of it is there being a sense that the Cubs really do want Swanson, specifically. Maybe not MORE than Correa, but maybe more than we’d been thinking? More than just a “ah, well, I guess if we HAVE to accept that guy …”?

I’m not saying that’s right or wrong – the pros and cons of Swanson are well-documented at this point, and I stand by my main conclusion (would love to have him on the Cubs, but it would make the desire to add an impact bat all the more strong and urgent). But I guess I’m trying to pay more attention when there is seeming consensus like this about how into Swanson the Cubs might be.

Good luck projecting the contracts for either of these guys at this point, by the way. The guarantee Turner got from the Phillies was on the high end of what you might have projected going into the offseason, but no one saw the 11-year structure coming back in October. And then the guarantee Bogaerts got from the Phillies BLEW AWAY anyone’s reasonable estimate, and the fact that he also got 11 years sure felt tied to the Turner deal. So, then, it would not be at all hard to imagine Correa’s demand is for longer than 11 years and for waaay more than $300 million. And Swanson suddenly has a market-based argument for $200 million (at, what, like eight years?!), which is jarring. And, yes, it becomes fair to ask whether that’s the right move at all.

I gotta stop myself on that side of things, because I think we just have no idea where these contracts are actually going. I’m sure that’s part of why this process slowed down a bit.

Oh, and to be sure, Heyman does not suggest it is ONLY the Giants, Twins, and Cubs for Correa, and ONLY the Cubs and Braves for Swanson. Those teams get more of the focus, but he also name checks the Red Sox and Dodgers for obvious reasons, and then the Cardinals and Mariners as long-shots.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Major 2024 MLB Award Finalists Announced

Tonight, MLB unveiled the three finalists for each of the major BBWAA awards. Although you could make an argument for at least one Chicago Cubs player to show up - Shōta Imanaga among the NL Rookie of the Year options...

The Upcoming Roki Sasaki Road Show, Comments From His Team, and the Shifting International Landscape

Over the weekend, word broke that Japanese ace Roki Sasaki, two years shy of the 25-year-old age cut-off for getting outside the International Free Agency rules, would be posted for MLB teams to sign this offseason. Because he's only 23,...

Baseball America Releases Its New Top Ten Chicago Cubs Prospects List

Baseball America is releasing its new, post-2024 organizational top ten prospect lists, and they just arrived at the Chicago Cubs. https://twitter.com/BaseballAmerica/status/1855973643211170282 Ultimately, we've come to know who the Cubs' top eight prospects are at this point, and I suspect they...

REPORT: Wander Franco Arrested Again in the Dominican Republic

Former(?) Tampa Bay Rays star shortstop Wander Franco was reportedly arrested again in the Dominican Republic, this time while out on bail awaiting trial on sexual abuse charges, the allegations for which originated all the way back in August of...

Brandon Lowe Probably Isn’t the Utility Guy the Cubs Would Target, But He Might Be Available

Last week we discussed the Chicago Cubs' reported desire to add a lefty-hitting utility infielder to pair with their group of righty bats at 2B/SS/3B. The desire to have a guy like that is pretty easy to describe, but the...

The Matt Shaw Game, Another TV Deal Made, Marlins Get Their Manager, and Other Cubs Bullets

What am I even supposed to say about the Bears? I find myself having the same conversation in my head EVERY THREE YEARS with this team. The names and faces change (well, except ownership ... ), but the story plays...

Matt Shaw Just Walked It Off For Team USA!

Matt Shaw is playing OUT OF HIS MIND to open up the Premier12 tournament for Team USA. After going 3-3 with a HBP in the first game, Shaw topped that tonight. The Cubs' top prospect went 4-5 with two singles,...

Being Good Enough to Overcome Unlucky, Hoerner, Shaw, Cards, and Other Cubs Bullets

I hate that it even crosses my mind that maybe it would be for the best for the Bears to get further humiliated today, and then pray that's the tipping point ... Nico Hoerner will be rehabbing from his forearm...

Hendricks Moves On, Phillies Front Office, Ballesteros Home Run Derby, More TV News, and Other Cubs Bullets

Got a family reunion today with The Wife's family, so that should be a fun time. No big news drops mid-day today, please and thanks ... The Phillies dropped a major news reveal about their front office: https://twitter.com/Phillies/status/1854981208452759924 Although Dave...

BREAKING: Roki Sasaki Will Be Posted

Enormous news for the offseason ahead, as 23-year-old Japanese ace Roki Sasaki will be posted by his NPB team this offseason. Jeff Passan with the wee hours scoop: https://twitter.com/JeffPassan/status/1855148106226061377 Roki Sasaki has been one of the best pitchers in the...

Latest News

NHL Anytime Goalscorer Bets and Odds Today – November 11

We have six games on the NHL card Monday, and anytime goal-scorer odds for players from around the league are available here.Watch the NHL on Fubo!Today's Top Anytime Goal OddsNathan MacKinnon (Avalanche) +105 to scoreAvalanche vs. PredatorsGame Time: 9 p.m....

WATCH: Julian Phillips Has Beautiful Block on Evan Mobley

The Chicago Bulls played like had nothing to lose in the first half against the 11-0 Cleveland Cavaliers. The energy was high right out of the gate, so much so that Chicago shot upwards of 60.0 percent in the first...

Ian Rapoport Believes Firing Shane Waldron Isn’t Off the Table

We are more than 24 hours removed from Chicago Bears Head Coach Matt Eberflus telling reporters that everything was on the table in terms of making changes to fix a slumping offense. And yet, there has been no announcement or...

Major 2024 MLB Award Finalists Announced

Tonight, MLB unveiled the three finalists for each of the major BBWAA awards. Although you could make an argument for at least one Chicago Cubs player to show up - Shōta Imanaga among the NL Rookie of the Year options...

Pre-Gamin’: Cleveland Cavaliers at Chicago Bulls (7:00 CT), Projected Lineups, How to Watch, More

The undefeated Cleveland Cavaliers come to town to take on the Bulls. Certainly, tonight should go smoothly! https://twitter.com/chicagobulls/status/1855957133172384073 Game Info Cleveland Cavaliers (11-0) at Chicago Bulls (4-6) – 6:30 p.m. CT on Chicago Sports Network (TV) and 670 The Score (Radio) Projected...

BN Fantasy DFS Contests with Kyren Williams, De’Von Achane, and More for Monday Night Football 

Are you ready to make your Monday Night Football experience even more fun? Join BN Fantasy today and use the promo code SWEATFREE to receive a sweat-free first entry of up to $250. This exclusive offer allows new users to...

BetMGM Promo Code Secures $1500 Offer for Rams vs Dolphins and More Tonight

The second half of the season kicks off with an exciting Thursday Night Football matchup between the Cincinnati Bengals and Baltimore Ravens. To make this matchup even more exciting, we are thrilled to offer an exclusive BetMGM promo code that...

PrizePicks Promo BNBONUS Unlocks $50 for Plays on MNF Rams vs Dolphins

The NFL’s 10th week of action closes with a Rams vs Dolphins showdown in Hollywood. Making this primetime battle even more exciting, would be receiving an instant $50 just by using our PrizePicks promo code BNBONUS when signing up and...

Tank Race: Are the Chicago Bulls Too Good for Their Own Good?

As of now, the Chicago Bulls have more than 72 games left on the calendar. And that's a problem. The Bulls sit 4-6 through their first ten games of the season. While that record isn't anything to call home about,...

24-Hour Rule: The Bears Are Bad and They’re Harming Caleb Williams

What more is there really to say 24 hours after the fact? Yesterday's game was pathetic. The offense was lifeless. The offensive line put in one of the worst performances I can remember from a Bears unit, and that's saying...

No, Caleb Williams Isn’t Getting Benched

Chicago Bears Head Coach Matt Eberflus says changes are coming to the Chicago Bears offense — but those changes will NOT be at quarterback: "Caleb (Williams) is our starter," Eberflus said directly in his press conference (which you can watch here)....

more cubs news