A Reminder of All That the Cubs *DIDN’T* Do This Offseason

Although there’s likely a little bit more to come (a top-shelf lefty reliever? and/or just some relief depth?), I’m generally pleased with the offseason the Chicago Cubs have had so far. They’ve signed the second most free agents in MLB (8), have committed the fifth most dollars overall ($305.5M), and are already getting credit for a “sneaky” good offseason.

Whether or not it’s enough is a different question entirely. I’m just saying what they have done has been pretty solid.

THAT SAID, I don’t want us to forget what the Cubs haven’t done. That still stands out to me as part of the offseason discussion, and I just want to lay it out there for posterity. Hopefully, this isn’t something we have to return to three months into 2023 MLB season, but I want it written down somewhere just in case the choices they made – the things they didn’t do – wind up looking like mistakes, and we do have to come back for some further thought.

The Shortstops

The Chicago Cubs signed free agent shortstop Dansby Swanson to a seven-year, $177 million deal. That was the cheapest of the four free agent shortstop deals signed this offseason, largely because Swanson was considered number four in the group of the four big free agent shortstops. The Cubs never seemed like a true threat to sign Trea Turner (11-years, $300M), so I’m not losing too much sleep over that one. And the Carlos Correa saga (six-years, $200M) was complicated enough that I can kinda brush it off, as well. So really this comes down to Xander Bogaerts (11-years, $280M).

The Cubs were seriously in on Bogaerts this offseason, including a recruiting attempt from Jon Lester, and were even considering signing both him *and* Swanson. So their decision that $280M was too rich for their blood was a legitimate inflection point. The Cubs seem serious about prioritizing defense this offseason, and Swanson certainly helps more on that front, but their offense is lacking thump and Bogaerts is a better bet for much more impact with the bat.

We won’t know right away whether this was the right or wrong choice, but this is something I’ll be watching (and potentially judging the front office on) throughout this and the next few seasons.

The Starting Pitchers

The Chicago Cubs signed two starting pitchers this offseason. Their big addition was Jameson Taillon (four-years, $68M). Taillon got the fifth biggest overall commitment among all free agent starters this offseason. And his three biggest/most realistic alternatives were Chris Bassitt (three-years, $63M), Taijuan Walker (four-years, $72M), and Kodai Senga (five-years, $75M).

Each of Walker, Bassitt, and Senga were reportedly on the Cubs’ radar at various points, with Senga the one who stands out the most. It’s possible Senga always wanted only a sure-fire contender, and he definitely comes with risk, but $75 million isn’t a terribly expensive deal. If he winds up being an absolute stud, the Cubs should probably be kicking themselves for not offering more. Playing for a contender is great and all, but an extra $10-15M might tilt the scales. Ultimately, at this level, it feels like the Cubs had their target and they specifically wanted Taillon. In other words, it doesn’t feel like they cheaped out. I think they got the guy they wanted most.

The Cubs also re-signed Drew Smyly (two-years, $19M). There were a number of free agent alternatives in this range, but some came with risk (Noah Syndergaard), others were never really an option (Clayton Kershaw), and others were never ever going to happen (Jose Quintana). By contrast, I do think Sean Manaea (two-years, $25M), Andrew Heaney (two-years, $25M), and Nathan Eovaldi (two-years, $34M) offered some legitimate upside for slightly more expensive price tags. So we’ll have to watch out on they may have whiffed at this level.

With that said, I think the familiarity and potential upside with Smyly was a little too obvious to overlook. The Cubs may have even gotten a slight discount if this was where he wanted to be.

The Catchers

Catcher is arguably the biggest potentially missed opportunity of the offseason for the Cubs. They could have re-signed Willson Contreras, who left for the Cardinals (five-years, $85M), they could have tried harder to trade for A’s catcher Sean Murphy, who was dealt to the Braves for … barely anything and immediately signed a team-friendly extension. And they made an identical offer to the one Christian Vázquez ultimately signed with the Twins (3-years, $30M).

I don’t think they ever wanted to re-sign Contreras for differences in catching philosophy. So whatever. But their unwillingness to up the offer over what the Twins gave Vázquez feels eerily like those oft-repeated concerns about identical offers being generated from homogenous player-value systems.

Instead, they signed Tucker Barnhart (two-years, $6.5M), who can offer the defense and the soft factors (together with Yan Gomes), but mostly signals an abandoning of hope for any offensive contributions from the catcher spot. This one bugs me, because they clearly wanted Vázquez but did not do what they needed to do to get it done.

First Base/DH

The Cubs signed both Eric Hosmer (one-year, MLB minimum) and Trey Mancini (two-years, $14M) to extremely affordable deals this offseason. And both make sense given what was left on the market and the presence of Matt Mervis. However, the Cubs did reportedly make a significant offer to Jose Abreu, who eventually signed with the Astros (three-years, $60M).

Abreu is a MUCH better shot at delivering the sort of power and overall offensive production the Cubs lineup is still lacking even after signing Hosmer and Mancini. Though I do understand that he got a lot more than people were expecting.

Then again, the Cubs reportedly offered $20M AAV over two years and Abreu wound up getting $19.5M AAV over three years, so it’s not like there was THAT much more to go. Given his connection to Chicago, you’d like to think they had a shot, even as a not-so-obvious contender. But this one just feels like a darn more than a massive mistake.

Center Field

Unless you were willing to spend a BOATLOAD of money for Brandon Nimmo (8-years, $162M), there’s not too much regret in the center field market for the Cubs. I’m not sure that deal was particularly wise, even though I do like Nimmo in general.

Instead, Chicago signed Cody Bellinger (one-year, $17.5M) to a pretty expensive deal, albeit over just one year. Given his speed, quality center field defense, left-handed bat, and ability to play first base, I think the Cubs actually made the right call here. If he bounces way back (unlikely), great! The Cubs hit a grand slam. If not, his floor will still be valuable and he’ll be gone in time for some of the Cubs prospects (Brennen Davis, Alexander Canario, Pete Crow-Armstrong) to emerge.

Other options include Kevin Kiermaier (one-year, $9M) or Kevin Pillar (1-year, $3M minor league deal). It was an exceptionally thin market. I like the route the Cubs took.

The Bullpen

Like I said, I don’t think the Cubs are done here yet. But so far, the big addition to the Cubs bullpen is right-hander Brad Boxberger (one-year, $2.8M). There are/were a DOZEN potential alternatives, but I actually trust the Cubs’ judgement on bullpen building. If they liked Boxberger, I believe there was a good reason. And the guys they’ve signed to minor league deals could wind up contributors, too. Still more work to be done, but I don’t think I’ll sweat this one quite so much.

Conclusion

Signed: Dansby Swanson, Jameson Taillon, Drew Smyly, Tucker Barnhart, Eric Hosmer, Trey Mancini, Cody Bellinger, Brad Boxberger

Passed Over/Missed Out: Xander Bogaerts, Kodai Senga, Chris Bassitt, Andrew Heaney, Sean Manaea, Nathan Eovaldi, Christian Vázquez, Jose Abreu, Kevin Kiermaier, Kevin Pillar, and a dozen potential relievers.

Including the price tags, I think I’m happy where the Cubs landed with Swanson, Smyly, Bellinger, and Boxberger. But I think they might have some regret skipping over Kodai Senga, and especially Christian Vázquez. Jury is out on Abreu, Heaney, and Bogaerts. It’s possible those look like massive whiffs, but there’s plenty of risk there, as well.

While we always remember to judge the moves the Cubs have made in a particular offseason, it’s just as important to remember everything they didn’t do. And this offseason, the Cubs made a lot of moves, but there were also a lot of potential moves they didn’t make.

written by

Michael Cerami began covering the Chicago Cubs for Bleacher Nation as a part-time contributor in 2015. One year later, he joined Bleacher Nation full-time, covering the Chicago Cubs and Major League Baseball. Today, Michael runs Bleacher Nation, contributing as a writer (Cubs, MLB) and an editor for all sections of the site, including the Chicago Bears, Bulls, and Blackhawks, as well as MLB, NBA, NHL, and NFL. In 2019, Michael was the co-host of NBC Sports Chicago's Cubs Post-Game Show Outside the Ivy. You can find him on Twitter/X @Michael_Cerami

more cubs news

Cubs Injury Updates: Seiya Suzuki, Ian Happ, Justin Steele (UPDATE)

If you're looking for some good news following a pretty frustrating weekend of baseball at Wrigley Field, I do have some for you. Just before the game, a trio of updates were reported for the Cubs injured players, and it...

Enhanced Box Score: Marlins 6, Cubs 3 – April 21, 2024

Well, this is what happens when you don't close out winnable games earlier in the weekend when you have the chance - it's a four-game series split with the lowly Miami Marlins at Wrigley Field. I watched most of this...

Pre-Gamin’: Marlins at Cubs (1:20) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — The Cubs were just a couple outs away from sweeping the double-header, but they came up short after another blown save by Adbert Alzolay in Game 1. But because they won on Friday, they still have a...

Words are Great, Actions are Better, and Other Bulls Bullets

The Chicago Bulls have entered Phase 1 of the recovery process – acceptance. Arturas Karnisovas sat down with reporters after another depressing end to the regular season and – shockingly – said the right things. Not only did he take...

Here’s One Unique Reason Shota Imanaga Keeps Dominating

For all the issues in the Cubs rotation so far this season (injuries, underperformance), Shota Imanaga has been an absolute dream. And although I didn't expect his first earned runs of the year to come against the Marlins (and their...

Assad Keeps Dealing, Gaming Out the Rotation, Who Else Could Close? And Other Cubs Bullets

Let's just jump right into it. Javier Assad had a wobbly start to his game yesterday, immediately allowing a double and a walk to open things up, while dealing with some clear command issues. Miguel Amaya took notice and trotted...

Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 5, Marlins 3 – April 20, 2024

Muuuuuuuuuch better. But first, the bad stuff. For the second straight game, the Cubs couldn't get anything going against a Marlins starter; only this time, that starter was not an established big leaguer like Jesus Luzardo. Nope, for what felt...

Alexander Canario Just Demolished a Baseball

In the bottom of the ninth inning of the first half of today's double-header, Alexander Canario swung out of his shoes and came up empty. In the bottom half of the sixth inning of the second game ... he connected....

Of Course Cody Bellinger Homered Today

Cody Bellinger has been swinging a really nice bat lately, and that continued in the top of the first inning tonight at Wrigley Field (and of course he homered on 4/20...easiest call ever). Check out his fourth homer of the...

Pre-Gamin’: Marlins at Cubs (6:40 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — The only silver lining I can see right now, is we don't have to wait very long between another frustrating Cubs loss and blown save by Adbert Alzolay. The next Cubs lineup is already out, and it...

Latest News

Yankees vs. Athletics Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, April 22, 2024

Entering Monday's matchup with the New York Yankees (15-7), the Oakland Athletics (8-14) are on a three-game losing streak. The contest starts at 1:05 PM ET on NBCS-CA with the Yankees listed as -247 favorites, while the are +203 underdogs...

Yankees vs. Athletics Probable Starting Pitchers – April 22

The Oakland Athletics (8-14) kick off a four-game series against the New York Yankees (15-7) with a Monday matchup at Yankee Stadium. First pitch is at 1:05 PM ET.The probable pitchers are Carlos Rodon (1-1) for the Yankees and JP...

Mavericks vs. Clippers Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets for NBA Playoffs Game 2 – Tuesday, April 23, 2024

The Dallas Mavericks are slight 2.5-point favorites heading into Game 2 of the opening round of the NBA Playoffs against the Los Angeles Clippers at Crypto.com Arena on Tuesday, tipping off at 10:00 PM ET on TNT. The Clippers lead...

Bucks vs. Pacers Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets for NBA Playoffs Game 2 – Tuesday, April 23, 2024

The Milwaukee Bucks are slight 1.5-point favorites for Game 2 of the opening round of the NBA Playoffs against the Indiana Pacers at Fiserv Forum on Tuesday, starting at 8:30 PM ET on NBA. The Bucks hold a 1-0 lead...

Thunder vs. Pelicans Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets for NBA Playoffs Game 2 – Wednesday, April 24, 2024

The Oklahoma City Thunder are 8-point favorites in Game 2 of the opening round of the NBA Playoffs against the New Orleans Pelicans at Paycom Center on Wednesday, tipping off at 9:30 PM ET on TNT. The Thunder have a...

Nuggets vs. Lakers Predictions, Best Bets and Odds: NBA Playoffs Game 2 – Monday, April 22, 2024

The Los Angeles Lakers are 7.5-point underdogs for Game 2 of the first round of the NBA Playoffs against the Denver Nuggets at Ball Arena on Monday, tipping off at 10:00 PM ET on TNT. The Nuggets are on top...

Knicks vs. 76ers Predictions, Best Bets and Odds: NBA Playoffs Game 2 – Monday, April 22, 2024

The New York Knicks are 5.5-point favorites heading into Game 2 of the opening round of the NBA Playoffs against the Philadelphia 76ers at Madison Square Garden on Monday, beginning at 7:30 PM ET on TNT. The Knicks have a...

Giants vs. Mets: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Monday, Jung Hoo Lee and the San Francisco Giants (10-13) play Pete Alonso and the New York Mets (12-9), with first pitch scheduled for 9:45 PM ET at Oracle Park.Keep reading to see how to watch the San Francisco-New...

How to Watch Angels vs. Orioles: Live Stream or on TV

On Monday, Reid Detmers will take the mound for the Los Angeles Angels (9-13) against Albert Suarez and the Baltimore Orioles (14-7), with first pitch scheduled for 9:38 PM ET at Angel Stadium of Anaheim.Keep reading to find out all...

Minnesota Twins vs. Chicago White Sox Series April 22-25: Odds, Starting Pitchers & Predictions

The Minnesota Twins are hosting the Chicago White Sox for a four-game series, with the first matchup getting underway at 7:40 PM ET on Monday, April 22.Twins vs. White Sox Series Info White Sox @ Twins Time: Monday, April 22...

more cubs news